Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Metcash Trading Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Metcash Trading Ltd [2011] FCA 1079

Citation: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Metcash Trading Ltd [2011] FCA 1079
Parties: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v
METCASH TRADING LIMITED ACN 000 031 569 and PICK N PAY RETAILERS (PTY) LTD
File number(s): NSD 1533 of 2011
Judge: JACOBSON J
Date of judgment: 20 September 2011
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – interlocutory injunction sought pending determination of appeal – consideration of serious question and balance of convenience – jurisdiction of Court to grant interim injunction relating to possible contravention of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) pending appeal – discussion of significance of failure to give undertaking as to damages
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), ss 50, 80
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 23

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, Merger Review Process Guidelines (2006)

Cases cited: APM Investments Pty Ltd v Trade Practices Commission (1983) 49 ALR 475
Attorney-General (Cth) v Davids Holdings Pty Ltd (No 1) (1993) ATPR 41-210
Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O'Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Metcash Trading Limited [2011] FCA 967
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1478
Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd (2001) 117 FCR 424
Stirling Harbour Services Pty Ltd v Bunbury Port Authority (No 2) [2000] FCA 87
Trade Practices Commission v Santos Ltd (1992) 38 FCR 382
Date of hearing: 15 September 2011
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 103
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr A J Myers QC with Mr J Halley SC and Mr C E Arnott
Solicitor for the Appellant: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr P Brereton SC with Mr D Roche
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Freehills
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Dr J Griffiths SC with Mr C Moore and Mr R Yezerski
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Blake Dawson

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1533 of 2011

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Appellant

AND:

METCASH TRADING LIMITED
ACN 000 031 569
First Respondent

PICK N PAY RETAILERS (PTY) LTD
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

JACOBSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 SEPTEMBER 2011

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Interlocutory Application brought by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission be dismissed.

2.The hearing of the appeal be expedited.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.22 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1533 of 2011

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Appellant

AND:

METCASH TRADING LIMITED
ACN 000 031 569
First Respondent

PICK N PAY RETAILERS (PTY) LTD
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

JACOBSON J

DATE:

20 SEPTEMBER 2011

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. On 25 August 2011, Emmett J dismissed an application brought by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Metcash Tra... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 1079
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) sought an interlocutory injunction against Metcash Trading Ltd to prevent the completion of a share sale agreement between Metcash and Pick n Pay for the acquisition of Franklins, a supermarket chain. The ACCC argued that the acquisition would substantially lessen competition in the independent wholesale grocery market, contravening the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). The Federal Court was required to consider whether to grant an interim injunction pending the determination of the appeal against the primary judge's decision dismissing the ACCC's application for declaratory and injunctive relief.

The court examined whether a serious question was being tried and considered the balance of convenience. The primary judge had found that the acquisition was pro-competitive and dismissed the ACCC's application. The ACCC argued that if the acquisition proceeded, Metcash would have the ability and incentive to make changes to Franklins that would harm competition and be difficult to remedy. The court noted that the primary judge considered it unlikely that the proposed consortium of retailers would purchase Franklins, thereby removing a potential competitive constraint on Metcash.

The court held that the ACCC had not established a serious question to be tried, as the primary judge's findings were not clearly wrong. The balance of convenience also did not favour granting the injunction, given the uncertain future of Franklins' business operations and the primary judge's pro-competitive view of the acquisition. The court dismissed the interlocutory application and ordered that the hearing of the appeal be expedited.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Interlocutory Application brought by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission be dismissed.

2. The hearing of the appeal be expedited.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.22 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Much of the content of Mr Perlov’s affidavit is confidential and I am therefore unable to refer to some of the salient portions. However, I think it is fair to say that the picture painted by Mr Perlov of the business operations of Franklins, both now and in the immediate future, is not a bright one. Accordingly, I cannot assume that Franklins’ current business operations will continue in their present form for the duration of the relevant appeal period even if I were disposed to grant an injunction. That is a matter which bears strongly on the issue of where the balance of convenience lies.The Background Facts The share sale agreement between Metcash and Pick n Pay was executed on 1 July 2010. The consideration was $215 million, subject to certain adjustments. The completion date stated in the agreement was 30 September 2010. On 29 July 2010 Metcash and Pick n Pay sought review of the proposed acquisition by the ACCC pursuant to the ACCC’s Merger Review Process Guidelines (2006). The ACCC’s review process lasted for almost four months and it was not until 17 November 2010 that the ACCC announced that it had decided to oppose the acquisition on the ground that it would, or would be likely to, have the effect of substantially lessening competition in one or more relevant markets in contravention of s 50 of the Trade Practices Act as then in force. On or about 24 November 2010, the ACCC indicated to Pick n Pay that it intended to commence proceedings in the Federal Court seeking declaratory and injunctive relief. At about the same time, on 23 November 2010, Metcash and Pick n Pay agreed to extend the completion date of the share sale agreement to 30 June 2011. Also at around the same time, on 26 November 2010, Metcash and Pick n Pay agreed with the ACCC that certain steps would be taken as a means of securing an urgent final hearing of the proceeding. These steps included an undertaking to be given by Metcash to the ACCC that it would not waive any condition precedent to the proposed acquisition without giving five clear business days’ notice. It was this undertaking which had the effect of preventing completion of the share sale agreement because one of the conditions precedent was that the ACCC give the necessary approval to the acquisition agreement. The ACCC commenced its proceeding for declaratory and injunctive relief on 8 December 2010. The final hearing occupied 21 sitting days. Twenty witnesses, including two experts, gave evidence. The hearing concluded on 16 May 2011. On 10 June 2011, Metcash announced that it had reached agreement with Pick n Pay to further extend the completion date of the share sale agreement to 31 July 2011. On 31 July 2011, the parties to the share sale agreement again extended the completion date to 30 September 2011. The judgment of the primary judge was handed down on 25 August 2011 and his Honour made orders dismissing the ACCC’s application on that date. His Honour’s reasons run to 140 pages containing 461 paragraphs.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Finally, it is pertinent to note that the primary judge considered that it is quite likely that the acquisition of Franklins by Metcash will strengthen the capacity of independent retailers operating under the IGA banner to compete more vigorously with Coles and Woolworths. That is to say, his Honour’s view was that the proposed acquisition by Metcash of Franklins, is pro-competitive, rather than anti-competitive: see at [460].The ACCC’s evidence in support of the injunction The ACCC relied on an affidavit affirmed by Mr David Gwilyn Jones, who is a Director in the ACCC’s Merger Investigations Branch. He is one of two Directors charged with the carriage of the ACCC’s assessment of the proposed acquisition. Mr Jones’ evidence is that if Metcash and Pick n Pay complete the acquisition pending resolution of the appeal, Metcash will have the ability and incentive to make changes to the Franklins business which would be likely to harm competition and which are not likely to be remedied by disposal orders. Mr Jones sets out his reasons for this in some detail at paras 25 to 35 of his affidavit. In particular, Mr Jones states that upon completion of the agreement, Metcash will control Franklins, thereby giving Metcash control, inter alia, of Franklins’ wholesale assets, as identified in the affidavit. Mr Jones goes on to state that if at the time of determination of the appeal, Metcash has closed or taken steps to close the wholesale assets, any subsequent purchase of Franklins (following a divestiture order) would acquire a business with a diminished capacity to wholesale packaged groceries to independent retailers. Mr Jones goes on to set out the large number of hurdles that an alternative purchaser of Franklins would need to overcome before it could begin to wholesale packaged groceries to independent retailers. He also points to the possibility of an alternative purchaser having to deal with an “uncooperative” Metcash during the start up phase after acquisition. Mr Jones points out that upon completion by Metcash prior to the determination of the appeal, Metcash will be in a position to enter into sale contracts for the 80 Franklins stores. He refers to Metcash’s stated intention to follow that course. He goes on to state that depending upon the time taken to hear and determine the appeal, Metcash may reach a stage in its dealings with third party acquirers where those persons have entered into financial and other undertakings, or taken other steps in the establishment of the business which may make it impossible to reverse “some or all of these arrangements”. Moreover, Mr Jones states that if Metcash proceeds with the acquisition, it will have access to commercially sensitive information about Franklins’ assets which could prejudice the ability of a subsequent purchaser to compete against Metcash in the independent wholesale grocery market if the ACCC succeeds in the appeal. Mr Jones also asserts that Metcash will have an incentive to ensure that the Franklins business is not able to be used by a commercial acquirer to compete vigorously against Metcash in the independent wholesale grocery market. He asserts that this may involve poaching key staff and using information about the business to the disadvantage of any alternative purchaser.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Thus, the ACCC’s case was that if the acquisition of Franklins by Metcash does not proceed, competition in the alleged independent wholesale grocery market would not be likely to be lessened. The primary judge’s judgment The primary judge did not consider that the delineation of the market should be limited by reference to packaged groceries: see at [203]. Thus, the ACCC’s contention that there is a separate market for the wholesale supply of a particular class of product, namely packaged groceries, was rejected. His Honour went on to say at [342] that he was not persuaded that there is a separate market for the wholesale supply to independent supermarket retailers of packaged groceries, as the ACCC defined those terms in its claim. Accordingly, he found that the ACCC’s pleaded case as to the defined market was not made out. The primary judge then turned to the counterfactual analysis, that is to say, the likely state of market competition both with and without the proposed acquisition. His Honour pointed out at [344] that ordinarily this involves an analysis which includes the continuation of the status quo. However, he observed that in the present case the circumstances are out of the ordinary because it was common ground that if the acquisition by Metcash does not proceed, Pick n Pay will sell the Franklins’ business and assets to the acquirer which makes the best offer and has the capacity to complete. The ACCC’s case was that if Metcash does not acquire Franklins, there is “a real chance” that a consortium of retailers operated by the Koundouris, Karellas, Krnc and Lionis families (described in argument by the ACCC as the KKK consortium) will purchase the business and will use the assets as a continuing competitive constraint on Metcash. However, his Honour found at [396] that there were a number of reasons why the consortium could not succeed. He said that it was difficult to conclude that the proposed consortium was a credible alternative purchaser. He gave seven detailed reasons, commencing at [397] for reaching that conclusion. His final reason, at [419], was that the proposed consortium’s interest was, at best, speculative. His Honour went on to find at [425] that on the basis of the evidence before the Court, he was not persuaded that “it is more likely than not” that the consortium propounded by the ACCC would make an offer for Franklins. The primary judge therefore applied a balance of probabilities test to the counterfactual but he went on to refer to the ACCC’s proposed “real chance” test. He said at [426] that even if the ACCC’s contention is correct:I am not persuaded that there is a real chance that the counterfactual contended for by the Commission would come to pass. Finally, it is pertinent to note that the primary judge considered that it is quite likely that the acquisition of Franklins by Metcash will strengthen the capacity of independent retailers operating under the IGA banner to compete more vigorously with Coles and Woolworths. That is to say, his Honour’s view was that the proposed acquisition by Metcash of Franklins, is pro-competitive, rather than anti-competitive: see at [460].The ACCC’s evidence in support of the injunction

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established