Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Link Solutions Pty Limited (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Link Solutions Pty Ltd (No 3) [2012] FCA 348

Citation: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission
v Link Solutions Pty Limited (No 3) [2012] FCA 348
Parties: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION and MARK PEARSON
v LINK SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 126 049 214, SERVICE LS PTY LTD ACN 103 836 326,
AXIS TELECOMS PTY LTD ACN 126 049 205, SERVICE AT PTY LTD ACN 076 804 718,
SONOFON PTY LTD ACN 126 249 625,
SERVICE SO PTY LTD ACN 103 970 627,
TELECOM ONE PTY LTD ACN 126 049 394, SERVICE TO PTY LTD ACN 116 646 916,
GEORGE TAWAF, MARK NESBITT, JOHN MASIA, BARRY KENNEDY, WORLDTEL (AUST) PTY LTD ACN 105 597 091, WORLDTEL CORPORATION (VICTORIA) PTY LTD ACN 109 699 425, SKYLINK COMMUNICATIONS PTY LTD ACN 112 018 809, ROMEO WEHBE, MANOEL WEHBE, FAKHR FAKHR, JOSEPH AYOUB, AUSTRALIAN INTEGRATED FINANCE PTY LTD ACN 078 700 044, ENTERPRISE FINANCE SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ACN 101 737 204, CIT GROUP (AUSTRALIA) LIMITED ACN 065 745 735 , QUEENSLAND COMMUNICATION COMPANY PTY LTD ACN 126 049 385, SERVICE QCC PTY LTD ACN 113 079 600, CLEAR COMMUNICATIONS (EURAUST) AB, CLEAR TELECOMS (AUST) PTY LTD ACN 129 296 573, ANTHONY HAKIM and NATIONAL TELECOMS GROUP PTY LTD ACN 094 312 704
File number: NSD 1473 of 2008
Judge: BENNETT J
Date of judgment: 5 April 2012
Catchwords:

TRADE PRACTICES – Exclusive Dealing – Third line forcing – Telecommunication companies offered call credits to customers conditional upon them leasing equipment from one of a panel of finance companies – declarations and injunctions by consent – Power to grant declaratory relief by consent – Presence of a proper contradictor – Relief granted

TRADE PRACTICES – Misleading and deceptive conduct and false representations in relation to ‘free’ equipment when the customer had signed an equipment lease – declarations by consent

Legislation: Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) s 12DA
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 471B and 601AD
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 31A
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 47
Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Chen (2003) 132 FCR 309 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dimmeys Stores Pty Ltd (2011) FCA 372 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Goldy Motors (2001) ATPR 41-801 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Harvey Norman Holdings Ltd [2011] FCA 1407 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Link Solutions Pty Ltd (2008) FCA 1790 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Link Solutions Pty Limited (No 2) (2010) 188 FCR 463 discussed
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v MSY Technology Pty Limited (No 2) (2011) 279 ALR 609 not followed
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pacific Dunlop (2001) ATPR 41-823 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Sampson [2011] FCA 1165 followed
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Sontax Australia (1988) Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 1202 cited
Australian Competition…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Link Soluti... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 348
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Link Solutions Pty Limited (No 3), the court was tasked with addressing allegations of exclusive dealing and misleading conduct by various telecommunications companies. The case involved numerous respondents, including Link Solutions Pty Limited and several other companies, which were accused of offering call credits to customers on the condition that they lease equipment from specific finance companies. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission sought declarations and injunctions by consent, focusing on the legality of these arrangements under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). The court had to determine whether the telecommunications companies had engaged in conduct that contravened the Act by tying the provision of credits to equipment leases from unrelated companies.

The legal issues before the court included whether the arrangements constituted exclusive dealing and whether the representations about the 'free' equipment were misleading. The court examined the nature of the relationships between the telecommunications companies and the finance companies, and whether the credit offers were genuinely independent or tied to the lease conditions. Additionally, the court considered the requirement for a 'proper contradictor' in proceedings by consent and whether the absence of opposition affected the court's ability to grant declaratory relief.

In its reasoning, the court found that the telecommunications companies had indeed engaged in exclusive dealing by conditioning credits on equipment leases from unrelated finance companies. The court also found that the representations about 'free' equipment were misleading because they failed to disclose that the equipment was provided under a lease agreement. The court acknowledged the broad discretion to grant declaratory relief but concluded that it should not be exercised where there was no opposition to the claims. The court decided to make the proposed declarations by consent, noting that the absence of a contradictor did not preclude the granting of relief where it was justified by the circumstances. The court also imposed restraints on certain individuals to prevent future similar conduct and ordered costs to be paid by one of the respondents.

The final orders included declarations against specific respondents regarding their involvement in exclusive dealing and misleading conduct, along with injunctions to prevent future occurrences. Certain respondents were deregistered or had proceedings against them dismissed due to their companies ceasing to exist or being in liquidation. The court vacated previous costs orders and set a contribution towards costs for one respondent, while dismissing the proceedings against others.

Orders

Orders of the court

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1. The proceedings as against:

(a) the First Respondent;

(b) the Second Respondent;

(c) the Third Respondent;

(d) the Fourth Respondent;

(e) the Fifth Respondent;

(f) the Sixth Respondent;

(g) the Seventh Respondent;

(h) the Eighth Respondent;

(i) the Thirteenth Respondent;

(j) the Fourteenth Respondent,

(k) the Fifteenth Respondent;

(l) the Twenty-Third Respondent; and

(m) the Twenty-Fourth Respondent

be discontinued.

By consent of the Applicants and the Ninth Respondent (George Tawaf), Tenth Respondent (Mark Nesbitt), Eleventh Respondent (John Masia), Sixteenth Respondent (Romeo Wehbe), Seventeenth Respondent (Manoel Wehbe), Eighteenth Respondent (Fakhr Fakhr), Nineteenth Respondent (Joseph Ayoub), Twenty-Fifth, Twenty-Sixth, Twenty-Seventh and Twenty-Eighth Respondents (Clear Respondents):

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

Ninth Respondent

2. George Tawaf was knowingly concerned in contraventions of s 47(1) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (now the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) by causing the Fourth Respondent, Service AT Pty Ltd (Axis Telecoms #1) to offer to give to the following individuals/organisations (customer) credits on the cost of telecommunications services each customer acquired from Axis Telecoms #1 when those credits were on the condition that the customer lease equipment from a company that provided equipment leasing services and that was specified by Axis Telecoms #1 or one of its related bodies corporate, when that company was not related to Axis Telecoms #1 or its related bodies corporate:

(a) Certified Diamond Network Pty Ltd;

(b) Asie Bassit;

(c) Bakhos Development Pty Ltd;

(d) Cammac Pty Ltd;

(e) Capital Access Holdings Ltd;

(f) Chadmore Pty Ltd;

(g) Daryl Jackson Robin Dyke Pty Ltd;

(h) E Productions Pty Ltd;

(i) Galaxios Greek Radio (Aust) Pty Ltd;

(j) Just Transmissions Pty Ltd;

(k) Manton Auctioneers Pty Ltd;

(l) Neil’s Liverpool Mechanical Repairs Pty Ltd;

(m) REM Electrical Services Pty Ltd;

(n) Sui Jin Huang;

(o) Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of Australia;

(p) Australian Chemical Research Pty Ltd;

(q) C& L Building Systems Pty Ltd;

(r) Hunt Holdings (NSW) Pty Ltd;

(s) John Charles Joseph Vella;

(t) Rapid Constructions Group Pty Limited;

(u) Totally Floored Australia Pty Ltd;

(v) Vanafu Pty Ltd;

(w) Apollo Fruit Supply Pty Ltd;

(x) A Dec Trading Company Incorporated;

(y) CTS Transport Pty Ltd;

(z) Health Pride Pty Ltd;

(aa) Margaret Ann Smith;

(bb) Nationwide Mortgage Specialists Pty Ltd;

(cc) Nissan Brothers Pty Ltd;

(dd) Riverwall Constructions Pty Ltd;

(ee) T and M Holdings Group Pty Ltd;

(ff) Charter One Pty Ltd;

(gg) Moores Corporations Australia Pty Ltd;

(hh) Sione Aonga;

(ii) R L Elias Pty Ltd;

(jj) Belcon Group Pty Limited;

(kk) Darryl R. Young;

(ll) Furntek Marketing Pty Ltd;

(mm) Maria Ria Adermann; and

(nn) Karen Joy Fenwick and Kevin Justice

and when George Tawaf knew that that company providing equipment leasing services was not related to Axis Telecoms #1.

3. George Tawaf was knowingly concerned in contraventions of s 47(1) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (now the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) by causing the Fourth Respondent, Service AT Pty Ltd (Axis Telecoms #1), to offer to give to the following individuals/organisations (customer) credits on the cost of telecommunications services each customer acquired from Axis Telecoms #1 when those credits were on the condition that the customer lease equipment from one of the companies of which Australian Equipment Rentals Pty Ltd was an agent (Finance Companies), when the Finance Companies were not related to Axis Telecoms #1 or its related bodies corporate:

(a) BBM Office National Pty Ltd;

(b) Jewish Centre on the Ageing Inc; and

(c) Advanced Towing Pty Ltd

and when George Tawaf knew that the Finance Companies were not related to Axis Telecoms #1.

Tenth Respondent

4. Mark Nesbitt was knowingly concerned in contraventions of s 47(1) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (now the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) by causing the Fourth Respondent, Service AT Pty Ltd (Axis Telecoms #1), to offer to give to the following individuals/organisations (customer) credits on the cost of telecommunications services each customer acquired from Axis Telecoms #1 when those credits were on the condition that the customer lease equipment from a company that provided equipment leasing services and that was specified by Axis Telecoms #1 or one of its related bodies corporate, when that company was not related to Axis Telecoms #1 or its related bodies corporate:

(a) Certified Diamond Network Pty Ltd;

(b) Asie Bassit;

(c) Bakhos Development Pty Ltd;

(d) Cammac Pty Ltd;

(e) Capital Access Holdings Ltd;

(f) Chadmore Pty Ltd;

(g) Daryl Jackson Robin Dyke Pty Ltd;

(h) E Productions Pty Ltd;

(i) Galaxios Greek Radio (Aust) Pty Ltd;

(j) Just Transmissions Pty Ltd;

(k) Manton Auctioneers Pty Ltd;

(l) Neil’s Liverpool Mechanical Repairs Pty Ltd;

(m) REM Electrical Services Pty Ltd;

(n) Sui Jin Huang;

(o) Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of Australia;

(p) Australian Chemical Research Pty Ltd;

(q) C& L Building Systems Pty Ltd;

(r) Hunt Holdings (NSW) Pty Ltd;

(s) John Charles Joseph Vella;

(t) Rapid Constructions Group Pty Limited;

(u) Totally Floored Australia Pty Ltd;

(v) Vanafu Pty Ltd;

(w) Apollo Fruit Supply Pty Ltd;

(x) A Dec Trading Company Incorporated;

(y) CTS Transport Pty Ltd;

(z) Health Pride Pty Ltd;

(aa) Margaret Ann Smith;

(bb) Nationwide Mortgage Specialists Pty Ltd;

(cc) Nissan Brothers Pty Ltd;

(dd) Riverwall Constructions Pty Ltd;

(ee) T and M Holdings Group Pty Ltd;

(ff) Charter One Pty Ltd;

(gg) Moores Corporations Australia Pty Ltd;

(hh) Sione Aonga;

(ii) R L Elias Pty Ltd;

(jj) Belcon Group Pty Limited;

(kk) Darryl R. Young;

(ll) Furntek Marketing Pty Ltd;

(mm) Maria Ria Adermann; and

(nn) Karen Joy Fenwick and Kevin Justice

and when Mark Nesbitt knew that the credits so offered were on that condition and that that company providing equipment leasing services was not related to Axis Telecoms #1.

5. Mark Nesbitt was knowingly concerned in contraventions of s 47(1) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (now the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) by causing the Fourth Respondent, Service AT Pty Ltd (Axis Telecoms #1), to offer to give to the following individuals/organisations (customer) credits on the cost of telecommunications services each customer acquired from Axis Telecoms #1 when those credits were on the condition that the customer lease equipment from one of the finance companies of which Australian Equipment Rentals Pty Ltd was an agent (Finance Companies), when the Finance Companies were not related to Axis Telecoms #1 or its related bodies corporate:

(a) BBM Office National Pty Ltd;

(b) Jewish Centre on the Ageing Inc; and

(c) Advanced Towing Pty Ltd

and when Mark Nesbitt knew that the credits so offered were on that condition and that the Panel Finance Companies were not related to Axis Telecoms #1.

6. Mark Nesbitt was knowingly concerned in contraventions of s 47(1) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (now the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) by causing the Third Respondent, Axis Telecoms Pty Ltd (Axis Telecoms #2), to offer to give to Debbie Hanna credits on the cost of telecommunications services she acquired from Axis Telecoms #2 when those credits were on the condition that Ms Hanna lease equipment from one of the companies of which Australian Equipment Rentals Pty Ltd was an agent (Finance Companies), when the Finance Companies were not related to Axis Telecoms #2 or its related bodies corporate, and when Mark Nesbitt knew that those credits were on that condition and that the Finance Companies were not related to Axis Telecoms #2.

Sixteenth, Seventeenth and Eighteenth Respondents

7. Romeo Wehbe, Manoel Wehbe and Fakhr Fakhr were each knowingly concerned in contraventions of s 47(1) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (now the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) by causing the Thirteenth Respondent (WorldTel) to offer to give to the following individuals/organisations (customer) credits on the cost of telecommunications services each customer acquired from WorldTel when those credits were on the condition that the customer lease equipment from a company that provided equipment leasing services and that was specified by WorldTel or one of its related bodies corporate, when that company was not related to WorldTel or its related bodies corporate:

(a) PrintOnline Pty Ltd;

(b) Gazmel Pty Ltd;

(c) Proper Painting and Decorating Pty Ltd;

(d) Aussie Power Pty Ltd;

(e) Bo Hua Guo;

(f) Fitco International Pty Ltd;

(g) G M Mitrovski Pty Ltd;

(h) Kathnic Pty Ltd;

(i) Illara J Dixon;

(j) MJ and DA Brown Pty Ltd;

(k) Motionmen Pty Ltd;

(l) Peter James Snow;

(m) Kenrick Australia Pty Ltd;

(n) Aristocrat Developments Pty Ltd;

(o) Sandhurst Manor Pty Ltd;

(p) Combined Resources Holdings Pty Ltd;

(q) Dean Kenway Services Pty Ltd;

(r) Gino Stivala;

(s) Jan Borys and Peter Borys;

(t) Funding Direct Australia Pty Ltd;

(u) Top Value International Pty Ltd;

(v) Chi Hung Peter Tsang and Oi Lan Karen Lee;

(w) Melissa Tora Veidreyaki;

(x) Pacific Mortgage Centre Pty Ltd; and

(y) ALF Property Service Pty Ltd

and when Romeo Wehbe, Manoel Wehbe and Fakhr Fakhr each knew that the credits so offered were on that condition and that that company providing equipment leasing services was not related to WorldTel.

Nineteenth Respondent

8. Joseph Ayoub was knowingly concerned in contraventions of s 47(1) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (now the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) by causing the Thirteenth Respondent (WorldTel) to offer to give to the following individuals/organisations (customer) credits on the cost of telecommunications services each customer acquired from WorldTel when those credits were on the condition that the customer lease equipment from a company that provided equipment leasing services and that was specified by WorldTel or one of its related bodies corporate, when that company was not related to WorldTel or its related bodies corporate:

(a) Aussie Power Pty Ltd;

(b) Bo Hua Guo;

(c) Fitco International Pty Ltd;

(d) G M Mitrovski Pty Ltd;

(e) MJ and DA Brown Pty Ltd;

(f) Combined Resources Holdings Pty Ltd;

(g) Funding Direct Australia Pty Ltd; and

(h) Top Value International Pty Ltd

and when Joseph Ayoub knew that the credits so offered were on that condition and that that company providing equipment leasing services was not related to WorldTel.

Twentieth Respondent

9. Australian Integrated Finance Pty Ltd (AIF), was knowingly concerned in contraventions of s 47(1) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (now the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) by Axis Telecoms, by AIF in respect of each of the customers referred to in paragraphs (g) and (h) below (the Customers):

(a) implementing arrangements which had been discussed and agreed between AIF and the Fourth Respondent (Axis Telecoms) for Axis Telecoms to provide to AIF, and AIF to receive, consider and process, forms upon which customers of Axis Telecoms applied for approval of an equipment lease; and

(b) receiving, considering and processing equipment lease application forms from each of the Customers on or about the dates referred to in those paragraphs,

while AIF knew that:

(c) when Axis Telecoms obtained from a Customer a completed application for approval of an equipment lease it did so for the purpose of the Customer applying for approval of equipment lease finance as part of a single transaction in which Axis Telecoms also offered credit on charges to be incurred for telecommunications services that would offset the lease costs to be incurred by the Customer under a lease which would come into force when that application was approved; and

(d) Axis Telecoms offered credit on charges to be incurred for telecommunications services only as part of a single transaction in which the Customer also applied to enter into an equipment lease;

(e) in each case in which such an application was received by AIF, the choice of AIF as financier was not made by the Customer; and

(f) it was not related to Axis Telecoms,

and by Axis Telecoms:

(g) on 9 August 2005, offering to give to Certified Diamond Network Pty Ltd $355 in credits per month on the cost of telecommunications services it acquired from Axis Telecoms on the condition that Certified Diamond Network Pty Ltd lease a colour laser printer from AIF, or another company that provided equipment leasing services chosen by Axis Telecoms or one of its related bodies corporate, when AIF was not related to Axis Telecoms; and

(h) on 9 June 2006, offering to give to Apollo Fruit Supply Pty Ltd $810 in credits per month on the cost of telecommunications services it acquired from Axis Telecoms on the condition that Apollo Fruit Supply Pty Ltd lease a television, surveillance system and three cameras from AIF, or another company that provided equipment leasing services chosen by Axis Telecoms or one of its related bodies corporate, when AIF was not related to Axis Telecoms.

Twenty-Sixth Respondent

10. The Twenty-Sixth Respondent contravened s 47(1) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (Act) (now the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)), by reason of s 47(6) of the Act, by:

(a) on 15 May 2008, offering to give to Rogmont Pty Ltd $300 in credits per month on the cost of telecommunications services it acquired from the Twenty-Sixth Respondent on the condition that Rogmont Pty Ltd lease a television from Enterprise Finance Solutions Pty Ltd, when Enterprise Finance Solutions Pty Ltd was not related to the Twenty-Sixth Respondent; and

(b) on 23 June 2008, offering to give to Eileen Valerie Nicholson $300 in credits per month on the cost of telecommunications services she acquired from the Twenty-Sixth Respondent on the condition that she lease a photocopier from Enterprise Finance Solutions Pty Ltd, when Enterprise Finance Solutions Pty Ltd was not related to the Twenty-Sixth Respondent; and

engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct in trade or commerce in contravention of s 12DA of the Australian Securities and lnvestments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) by:

(c) on 15 May 2008, representing to Rogmont Pty Ltd that the telecommunications equipment and television to be provided to it were free, when the telecommunications equipment and television were provided pursuant to an equipment lease with a rental of $300 per month (excluding GST); and

(d) on 23 June 2008, representing to Eileen Nicholson that the photocopier to be provided to her was free, when the photocopier was provided pursuant to an equipment lease with a rental of $300 per month (excluding GST).

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Ninth Respondent

11. George Tawaf is restrained for a period of five years from being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in promotion or conduct by a corporation of any business which offers to give credits on charges to be incurred by any person (customer) on the proposed supply of telecommunication services when those credits are on the condition that the customer will acquire equipment by leasing or hiring that equipment from a person / organisation which is:

(a) not a body corporate related to the corporation; and

(b) specified, including as one of a panel, by:

(i) the corporation;

(ii) its related bodies corporate; or

(iii) someone on behalf of the corporation or its related body corporate,

as a person or organisation from which such equipment is to be leased or hired,

unless:

(c) the corporation has provided notice of such conduct to the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (the Commission) pursuant to s 93(1) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (Act); and

(d) the ACCC has not given the corporation a notice pursuant to s 93(3A) of the Act with respect to the conduct the subject of the corporation’s notice referred to in (c) above.

Tenth Respondent

12. Mark Nesbitt is restrained for a period of five years from being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in promotion or conduct by a corporation of any business which offers to give credits on charges to be incurred by any person (customer) on the proposed supply of telecommunication services when those credits are on the condition that the customer will acquire equipment by leasing or hiring that equipment from a person / organisation which is:

(a) not a body corporate related to the corporation; and

(b) specified, including as one of a panel, by:

(i) the corporation;

(ii) its related bodies corporate; or

(iii) someone on behalf of the corporation or its related body corporate,

as a person or organisation from which such equipment is to be leased or hired,

unless:

(c) the corporation has provided notice of such conduct to the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (the Commission) pursuant to s 93(1) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (Act); and

(d) the Commission has not given the corporation a notice pursuant to s 93(3A) of the Act with respect to the conduct the subject of the corporation’s notice referred to in (c) above.

Eleventh Respondent

13. John Masia is restrained for a period of five years from being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in promotion or conduct by a corporation of any business which offers to give credits on charges to be incurred by any person (customer) on the proposed supply of telecommunication services when those credits are on the condition that the customer will acquire equipment by leasing or hiring that equipment from a person / organisation which is:

(a) not a body corporate related to the corporation; and

(b) specified, including as one of a panel, by:

(i) the corporation;

(ii) its related body corporate; or

(iii) someone on behalf of the corporation or its related body corporate,

as a person or organisation from which such equipment is to be leased or hired,

unless:

(c) the corporation has provided notice of such conduct to the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (the Commission) pursuant to s 93(1) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (Act); and

(d) the Commission has not given the corporation a notice pursuant to s 93(3A) of the Act with respect to the conduct the subject of the corporation’s notice referred to in (c) above.

Sixteenth, Seventeenth and Eighteenth Respondents

14. Each of Romeo Wehbe, Manoel Wehbe and Fakhr Fakhr is restrained for a period of five years from being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in promotion or conduct by a corporation of any business which offers to give credits on charges to be incurred by any person (customer) on the proposed supply of telecommunication services when those credits are on the condition that the customer will acquire equipment by leasing or hiring that equipment from a person/organisation which is:

(a) not a body corporate related to the corporation; and

(b) specified, including as one of a panel by:

(i) the corporation;

(ii) its related body corporate; or

(iii) someone on behalf of the corporation or its related body corporate,

as a person or organisation from which such equipment is to be leased or hired,

unless:

(c) the corporation has provided notice of such conduct to the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (the Commission) pursuant to s 93(1) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (Act); and

(d) the Commission has not given the corporation a notice pursuant to s 93(3A) of the Act with respect to the conduct the subject of the corporation’s notice referred to in (c) above.

Nineteenth Respondent

15. Joseph Ayoub is restrained for a period of five years from being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in promotion or conduct by a corporation of any business which offers to give credits on charges to be incurred by any person (customer) on the proposed supply of telecommunication services when those credits are on the condition that the customer will acquire equipment by leasing or hiring that equipment from a person / organisation which is:

(a) not a body corporate related to the corporation; and

(b) specified, including as one of a panel by:

(i) the corporation;

(ii) its related body corporate; or

(iii) someone on behalf of the corporation or its related body corporate,

as a person or organisation from which such equipment is to be leased or hired,

unless:

(c) the corporation has provided notice of such conduct to the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (the Commission) pursuant to s 93(1) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (Act); and

(d) the Commission has not given the corporation a notice pursuant to s 93(3A) of the Act with respect to the conduct the subject of the corporation’s notice referred to in (c) above.

Costs

16. The Twenty-Sixth Respondent pay the Applicants, within 14 days of the date this order is made, a contribution toward their costs of and incidental to these proceedings in the fixed sum of $50,000.

17. All previous costs orders as between the Applicants and George Tawaf, Mark Nesbitt, John Masia, Romeo Wehbe, Manoel Wehbe, Fakhr Fakhr and Joseph Ayoub be vacated, and there be no other order as to costs as between the Applicants and those parties.

18. Except for order 3 of the orders made on 10 September 2010, and subject to order 16 above, all interlocutory costs orders between the Applicants and the Clear Respondents be vacated.

19. Subject to order 16 above, there be no other order as to costs as between the Applicants and the Clear Respondents.

Disposition of proceedings

20. The proceedings as against George Tawaf, Mark Nesbitt, John Masia, Romeo Wehbe, Manoel Wehbe, Fakhr Fakhr and Joseph Ayoub otherwise be dismissed.

21. The proceedings as against the Twenty-Fifth Respondent, the Twenty-Seventh and the Twenty-Eighth Respondent be dismissed.

22. The proceedings as against the Twenty-Sixth Respondent otherwise be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Order 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On each occasion, the agent for Clear Telecoms made representations that were false and misleading. Clear Telecoms has engaged in conduct in contravention of s 12DA(1) of the ASIC Act.Conclusion I am satisfied that it is appropriate to make the proposed declarations concerning Clear Telecoms. I note that it is agreed as between the Clear Respondents that:(a)an order be made requiring Clear Telecoms to make a contribution towards the Applicants’ costs, fixed in the sum of $50,000(b)except for Order 3 of the orders made on 10 September 2010, and subject to the order referred to in (a) above, all interlocutory costs orders between the Applicants and the Clear Respondents will be vacated; and(c)subject to the order referred to in (a) above, there be no further orders as to costs between the Applicants and the Clear Respondents. It is further agreed that the proceedings as against Clear Communications, Mr Hakim and NTG be dismissed and that the proceedings as against Clear Telecoms otherwise be dismissed. Orders will be made accordingly.THE REMAINING RESPONDENTS The following respondents have been deregistered:(a)Link Solutions Pty Ltd;(b)Service LS Pty Ltd;(c)Axis Telecoms #2;(d)Sonofon;(e)The Sixth Respondent, Service SO Pty Ltd;(f)The Seventh Respondent, Telecom One Pty Ltd;(g)The Eighth Respondent, Service TO Pty Ltd; (h)The Fourteenth Respondent, WorldTel Corporation (Victoria) Pty Ltd; (i)The Fifteenth Respondent, Skylink Communications Pty Ltd;(j)QCC; and(k)The Twenty-Fourth Respondent, Service QCC Pty Ltd. Pursuant to s 601AD of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act), each of these respondent companies has ceased to exist. It is appropriate that orders be made discontinuing the proceedings against each of these respondents. Axis Telecoms #1 and WorldTel are in liquidation. Pursuant to s 471B of the Corporations Act, the proceedings in respect of these respondents have been stayed. It is appropriate that orders be made discontinuing the proceedings against Axis Telecoms #1 and WorldTel.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Justice Perram accepted that, following the reasoning of French J and his own analysis of other cases, a contradictor does not connote a party who is in fact arguing to the contrary, but rather connotes all parties whose interests are opposed and who can be bound by the outcome (at [40]). However, his Honour concluded (at [32]) that he was bound to give effect to the reasoning in BMI that the need for “a proper contradictor” required there to be ‘a party arguing against the granting of the relief and that this could not be satisfied where the matter proceeded by consent’ and that consenting defendants did not constitute proper contradictors.Consideration In Forster at 437–438, Gibbs J referred to the broad discretion to be exercised in making a declaration. It was in that context that his Honour cited Lord Dunedin. Justice Gibbs added a citation from Lord Radcliffe in Ibeneweka v Egbuna [1964] 1 WLR 219 (at 225), to the effect that the power to grant a declaration should be exercised ‘with a proper sense of responsibility’ and where justified by the circumstances. Lord Radcliffe then added ‘beyond that there is no legal restriction on the award of a declaration’. It is the case that in BMI, Keely and Beaumont JJ declined to make the declaration sought. Their Honours noted (at 152) that:·there was no opposition to the claim made by the applicants;·the declaration sought was for the invalidity of a State award and the Attorney-General for the State did not appear; and·the applicant presented a full argument in support of the claim made and no argument was advanced to the contrary. Their Honours stated that there was no criticism of this approach, it being ‘natural enough that such a course should be adopted’. Keely and Beaumont JJ:·said (at 152) that ‘we are by no means persuaded that, in the circumstances, it is appropriate that a declaration as sought should be made’.·cited Scarman J in Wallersteiner v Moir where (at 1030) his Lordship referred to the fact that the power of the Court to give declaratory relief in default of a pleading by a defendant ‘of course, exists’, although the power to grant declaratory relief should only be exercised in such circumstances where to deny it would be to impose injustice upon the claimant.·confirmed their view (at 153) that it is ‘generally undesirable that the court should grant relief by way of declaratory orders under s 108 in the absence of any contest on the question’.·observed that in the circumstances of that case, the practical operation of the declaration may extend beyond the activities of the parties and observed (at 154) that they could see no useful purpose in the making of the declarations sought except to bind other parties in other situations in the future.·in the absence of a contradictor and where the question was academic, as a matter of discretion, determined that the Court should not grant the declaratory relief, even though it had the statutory jurisdiction to do so.