Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Hughes

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Hughes
[2004] FCA 519

CONTEMPT – breaches of court orders prohibiting advertising on internet by Australian resident – advertising involved offers from Australia of sale of medical products illegally to persons resident in United States of America – advertising additionally involved offers of sale to persons resident in Australia – offers so made without disclosing illegality of supply of those products in Australia without doctors’ prescriptions and without disclosing significant health risks in the absence of obtaining medical advice – also without disclosing availability to Australian citizens of free medical assistance – citizens less expense to obtain oral contraceptives upon prescription from a pharmacy than to buy from respondent – previously disobeyed restraint orders as to sales in Australia resulted in prior imprisonment for two weeks for contempt – contraventions subject of present proceedings ultimately conceded – hardship circumstances of applicant relevant to mitigation of penalty – respondent already remanded in custody for State offences – custodial sentence imposed to operate forthwith – partially suspended

Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth)
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 78B
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 86C
Federal Court Rules Order 17 Rule 3 and Order 37 Rule 3

ACCC v Hughes (2002) ATPR 41-863 (Allsop J)
Hughes v ACCC (2000) FCA 915 (Sackville J)
ACCC v Hughes (2001) ATPR 41-807 (Tamberlin J)
ACCC v Australian Taxation Information Services Pty Ltd and Ivanoff (BC 9907613)
ACCC v Goldstar Corporation Pty Ltd and Hudson (BC 9902357)
ACCC v White (BC 9803302)
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Zhu (BC 9604214)
ACCC v Info4pc.Com Pty Ltd & Anor (2002) 121 FCR 24
Yang (2002) 132 A Crim R 438
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Matthews (1999) 32 ACSR 404
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Hickey (1999) FCA 529

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v RICHARD DAVID HUGHES T/AS CROWDED PLANET ALSO KNOWN AS DAVID HUGHES DAVID R HUGHES DAVID ‘ZERO’ HUGHES RICHARD D HUGHES DAVID Z HUGHES DAVID ZPG HUGHES DAVID Z MR ZERO POPULATION GROWTH AND DAVID ZERO POPULATION GROWTH HUGHES

N 941 OF 2000

CONTI J
29 APRIL 2004
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 941 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
APPLICANT

AND:

RICHARD DAVID HUGHES T/AS CROWDED PLANET
ALSO KNOWN AS DAVID HUGHES
DAVID R HUGHES
DAVID ‘ZERO’ HUGHES
RICHARD D HUGHES
DAVID Z HUGHES
DAVID ZPG HUGHES
DAVID Z
MR ZERO POPULATION GROWTH AND DAVID ZERO
POPULATION GROWTH HUGHES
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

CONTI J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 APRIL 2004

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.The respondent is guilty of contempt of this Court in that in breach of Order 6 made by Justice Allsop on 18 March 2002, the respondent Richard David Hughes:

(a)From on or about 28 February 2003 offered for sale the following oral contraceptives to persons in the United States of America:

(i)Microgynon 50 ED, Levlen 30ED, Loette, Logynon ED, Triquilar Ed, Diane 35ED,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Hughes and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 519
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought proceedings against Richard David Hughes, seeking an order of contempt against him for breaches of two orders made by Allsop J in 2001. The primary legal issue was whether Hughes had breached the court orders by selling oral contraceptives without prescriptions, which the court had previously prohibited. The court examined evidence from the ACCC, including affidavits from United States officials, and testimony from Hughes himself. Hughes admitted to breaching the orders but argued that his actions were intended to advance public good. The court found Hughes in contempt and considered the appropriate punishment, concluding that a fine was insufficient and that imprisonment was necessary to convey the seriousness of his actions. Hughes was ordered to serve six months in prison, with the first two months mandatory and the remaining four months suspended on the condition that he complies with future court orders. Additionally, Hughes was required to transfer the registration of his website to the ACCC and to pay the ACCC's costs.

The court's reasoning was based on the importance of enforcing the orders to protect public health and the need to deter Hughes from further breaches. The court highlighted the serious public interest implications of Hughes' actions and the need for a punitive and deterrent sentence. The final orders included imprisonment, transfer of the domain name, and financial penalties. Hughes' previous incarcerations and his expressed contrition were considered, but the court determined that a substantial sentence was necessary to uphold the authority of the court and to ensure compliance with future orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

3. The respondent Richard David Hughes be imprisoned for a period of six months commencing from today, whereof the first two months must be served in any event.

4. The balance of the above sentence of six months shall be suspended from execution upon the basis however that if the respondent hereafter breaches Order 5 or Order 6 the subject of the foregoing declaratory relief, that provision for suspension shall be deemed to so operate to the effect that the respondent must thereupon be imprisoned for at least the remainder of the six month period not served, namely that residual period of four months.

5. (a) The respondent Richard David Hughes be further ordered to transfer the registration of the domain name in respect of the CrowdedPlanet website being http://www.users.bigpond.com/dilipili/ (‘the domain name’) to the applicant Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (‘the Commission’) within fourteen days of the date of this order.

(b) The respondent Richard David Hughes take all such steps, perform all such acts and sign all such documents as may be reasonably required of him by the Commission within fourteen days of the date of this order, in order to effect the transfer of the registration of the domain name to the Commission.

6. If the respondent does not:

(a) transfer the registration of the domain name to the Commission within fourteen days of the date of those orders; or

(b) otherwise take all such steps, perform all such acts and sign all such documents as may be reasonably required of him by the Commission within fourteen days of the date of these orders to effect the transfer of the registration of the domain name to the Commission.

the Commission is hereby authorised pursuant to Order 37 rule 3 of the Federal Court Rules to take all such steps, perform all such acts and sign all such documents as may be required to enable the registration of the domain name to be transferred to it.

7. Upon the transfer of the registration of the domain name to the Commission, the Commission may place on the worldwide web at a site accessed through the domain name a notice in accordance with the provisions of Schedule ‘A’ to these orders.

8. The respondent pay the Commission’s costs of and incidental to this application.

9. Either party have liberty to apply to the Court on seven days’ prior notice in writing given to the other party in relation to the implementation or carrying into effect of the above orders.

SCHEDULE A

The Notice shall:

(a) be legible and the type shall be at least 12 point, Times New Roman font and right and left justified;

(b) have a bold prominent heading in at least 18 point;

(c) appear in an automatically generated active pop-up window or message box, whereby a member of the public is required to interact with the window or message box to close it;

(d) not be less than 50% of the size of the computer screen;

(e) appear immediately upon access by a customer to the homepage of the CrowdedPlanet website and shall provide a hotlink to the website address http://www.accc.gov.au; and

(f) be in the following terms:

CONSUMER NOTICE

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION

Re: CrowdedPlanet and Richard David Hughes

CrowdedPlanet wishes to advise that the offering for sale or supply, and the sale or supply of birth control pills on and from this website, was in breach of the Trade Practices Act 1974, because by failing to advise certain information, consumers may have been misled. You should be aware of the following information:

(a) it is illegal to supply and purchase the oral contraceptives listed on the CrowdedPlanet website in Australia without a prescription, and it is illegal to supply the oral contraceptives listed on the CrowdedPlanet website the United States of America without a prescription;

(b) there are significant health risks in taking some oral contraceptives without first obtaining medical advice about the suitability of those medications for use by the particular individual;

(c) within Australia free medical assistance, including where appropriate the issuing of a prescription, is available to Australian citizens and permanent residents who are contemplating using oral contraceptives; and/or

(d) it is significantly less expensive to obtain oral contraceptives upon prescription from a pharmacy than it is to buy them from CrowdedPlanet.

Any consumers with inquiries about this notice may contact the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission on phone number 1300 302 502 or visit the website at [hotlink to:] http://www.accc.gov.au.

This notice has been placed pursuant to an order of the Federal Court of Australia as a result of action taken by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission pursuant to s 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In terms of appropriate punishment for Mr Hughes’ actions, the imposition of a fine was considered by his Honour not to have been adequate, because that course would not have brought home to the applicant the gravity of his contempt, and that the imposition of two weeks’ imprisonment was warranted. However since Mr Hughes had not acted for the purpose of making a profit, but in the interests of advancing the public good as he saw it, his Honour considered that it was appropriate to suspend that term of imprisonment on the condition that Mr Hughes amend the interest site as required by the order within 30 days (ACCC v Hughes (2001) ATPR 41-807). Nevertheless that course was not implemented, and the warrant for imprisonment was executed, after a further hearing before his Honour. The term thereof was from 9 March 2002 to 22 March 2002, and was served in New South Wales. The evidence adduced by ACCC in the present proceedings upon the issue of contempt The testimony first adduced by ACCC in support of ACCC’s case for contempt comprised two affidavits of Marc Scott Griswold, a United States resident, sworn respectively on 22 October 2003 and 15 December 2003. Immediately prior to Mr Griswold appearing from the United States by video link in this Court, Mr Hughes indicated that he did not seek to cross-examine Mr Griswold, stating that ‘… I have no quarrel with that material’. Mr Griswold is a senior special agent of the Food and Drug Administration of the Office of Criminal Investigations in Maryland (USA). That course adopted by Mr Hughes resulted of course in the saving at least of a measure of video link costs, apart from the Court time which otherwise would have been involved in the conduct of the final hearing. Mr Griswold gave affidavit evidence of ordering in March 2003, and subsequent receiving in the US from Australia in April 2003, Levlen 30ED, the order being placed on Mr Hughes’ internet account operated in Australia, for which Mr Griswold caused to be paid $US55.83 to Mr Hughes in Australia. The testimony secondly adduced by ACCC in support of its case for contempt was given by Mr Matelski, a highly qualified United States attorney at law for many years engaged in practice in Washington and specialising in food and drug law in the United States; he happened to be already visiting Australia and hence gave his evidence viva voce. He testified that Levlen ED was not approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration (‘FDA’), and thus could not be legally sold or distributed in the United States, the penalty for infringement being imprisonment and/or pecuniary penalty. It is unnecessary for me to further record the detail of Mr Matelski’s affidavit and subsequent oral testimony, which demonstrated highly qualified expertise, save as to indicate that he pointed to distinctions of relevance, as oral contraceptive pills, between ‘Levlen 28 Tablets’ and ‘Levlen 21 Tablets’ on the one hand, and ‘Hughes Levlen ED’ on the other. In the United States (as in Australia), Mr Matelski explained, oral contraceptives may only be sold by a doctor’s prescription. Mr Hughes questioned Mr Matelski at some length, and it is appropriate to observe, did so respectfully.

Decision

Reasons for decision

CONTI J
Apart from the specific authorities above cited, sentencing principles for breach of an order or undertaking have of course been discussed in numerous authorities. The leading authorities are conveniently summarised by Tamberlin J in the earlier Hughes litigation (that is, in [15]-[20] of (2001) ATPR 41-807 at 42,781-3). I am required of course to bear those principles in mind, in the context of formulating my conclusion below.My conclusions, including conclusions on penalty: Senior counsel for ACCC, Mr Williams SC, rightly submitted that in the light of Mr Hughes’ evidence given at the hearing, it was not in contest that Mr Hughes breached each of the orders in the way and to the extent alleged by ACCC as set out in the Amended Statement of Charge (see [3] and [4] above), Mr Hughes having substantially admitted and not contested those breaches. Even without the admissions and concessions proffered by Mr Hughes, the ACCC’s case was positively established in all material respects, and if I might say so, obviously at very considerable cost. Mr Williams SC further submitted that Mr Hughes is not presently imprisoned ‘in the technical sense’, in that bail has been refused in the South Australian Magistrate’s Court, and for that reason he is presently in custody in Adelaide, and that therefore Mr Hughes ‘would commence to serve the term forthwith upon your Honour’s order’. Mr Williams SC did not dispute that Mr Hughes had expressed contrition in the context of the present proceedings, but asserted that he had similarly behaved by the time of the conclusion of the proceedings before Allsop J, when to use Mr Williams’ description, he was ‘half way through, I think, a one year sentence’ for an unrelated offence. Mr Williams emphasised, in my opinion correctly, that although Mr Hughes has no apparent means, nevertheless he has the ability to acquire a computer, to set up a website, and commence to make offers to sell contraceptive pills, which would not be a costly venture. So much, he asserted, would be a repetition of the conduct which Mr Hughes set about within a month or so of the making of Allsop J’s orders. Moreover as he further rightly emphasised, the implications of selling contraceptive pills, in the absence of doctors’ prescriptions, involve inherently serious public health issues. Mr Williams SC stressed that in the light of the litigation history, Mr Hughes ‘is a person who is simply not to be accepted on his oath in these matters’, and that consequently very serious matters of public interest were here at stake. Senior counsel for ACCC therefore submitted that ‘objective features, without taking subjective mitigated factors into account, would indicate a range of 6 to 18 months in the Commission’s submission’, in order to satisfy the punitive element and also the element of securing compliance with future orders. Only that course would indicate to Mr Hughes that ‘continuing breaches will lead to a steadily escalating range of sanctions until Mr Hughes eventually complies with the orders’, even if the Court was to take the view that a partly suspended substantial sentence would be the appropriate vindication.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: CONTI J

Other affidavit testimony tendered by ACCC, largely of a more formal nature, comprised the following:(i) Michelle Novotny, a handwriting expert, sworn 10 October 2003;(ii)Jeremy Craig Roach, an ACCC investigator, sworn 29 October 2003; his testimony was of an entrapment nature, and related to an offer to supply, though not any subsequent actual supply; he was cross-examined in some detail by Mr Hughes;(iii)Matthew Douglas French, also an ACCC investigator, who was not cross-examined by Mr Hughes on his affidavit sworn 29 October 2003; (iv)Nicholas Steven Ellis, a senior ACCC investigator, as to two of the three of his filed affidavits, namely those of 29 October and 31 October 2003; he was cross-examined by Mr Hughes; there was also tendered exhibit A1 to Mr Ellis’ earlier affidavit of 24 September 2003, but no other aspect or segment of that initial affidavit; his testimony related largely to what appeared on the ‘CrowdedPlanet’ website of Mr Hughes on or about 28 February 2003;(v)Ulrich Adami, whose affidavit sworn on 30 October 2003 deposed to the circumstance that the access to the internet in Australia utilises telephone services in Australia; and(vi)Ian McNeilly, the ACCC solicitor having the conduct of the proceedings, whose affidavits sworn on 3 May 2002 and 29/30 October 2003, related to essentially formal matters such as service of the orders of Allsop J, and compliance with the requirements of s 78B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth).The first day of the hearing was largely taken up by the adducement of this, and what I shall summarise in the next segment of these reasons.The applicant’s incarcerations unrelated to the ACCC proceedings The incarceration of Mr Hughes in Australia for offences of assault or threatened assault, being apart from the two weeks sentence imposed by Tamberlin J for contempt of this court (see [8] above), emerged in the course of the proceedings. The first of those matters is recorded in the transcript as shortly follows, being material volunteered by Mr Hughes. The context was the contempt of court proceedings conducted before Tamberlin J at the initiative of ACCC, to which reference has already of course been made, and in relation to which a two weeks custodial offence was imposed for breach of injunctions of this Court. I extract below from the transcript of what Mr Hughes testified to the Court concerning the first incident of assault, in relation to which he was apparently separately dealt with and imprisoned.‘MR HUGHES: And my writing is pretty dreadful. May I just finish off this secret incident? It is perhaps better just to try and summarise it because you won’t know how dreadful it was. I knew I was going to gaol for 2 weeks. In my muddled brain I thought I was going to gaol as a martyr for a higher cause. I brought with me from South Australia a scientific computer – it was actually in summary a weather computer.HIS HONOUR: At that stage you were living in South Australia?MR HUGHES: Since ’99 I’ve been commuting backwards and forwards once a month between Wollongong and South Australia, particularly Kangaroo Island which is a very windy island with very poor quality electricity. I had a weather computer with 1 month’s intensive data init. I had been warned by the people who made the weather computer that if the battery went flat I would lose the data. I did own a lap-top computer at that stage. The box on the mast could have been downloaded for a lap-top but I didn’t have a lap-top at that stage, I brought it back with me.Knowing that I was being imprisoned for 2 weeks because the Judge had forewarned me and telegraphed his… well in advance, I attempted to plug it into the wall to fully charge the battery before I was taken off to the MRRC. The court attendant thought it was a bomb. I lost my temper and said sarcastically but loudly and rudely and bad-temperedly, “Of course it’s a bomb” and it was taken to be a bomb and then I served 12 months in prison.’I refer to that evidence solely as background material which arose in the course of the proceedings before me. It is not material which bears upon the offences the subject of the present application concerning conduct in contempt of Court.