Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Halkalia Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Halkalia Pty Ltd (No 3) [2017] FCA 522

File number: VID 362 of 2011
Judge TRACEY J
Date of judgment: 17 May 2017
Catchwords: CONTEMPT OF COURT – appropriate penalty – where fourth respondent pleaded guilty to wilful and contumacious contempts of court constituted by failures to comply with previous orders of the court – where fourth respondent of advanced age and ill health
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Sch 2 (“Australian Consumer Law”) s 232

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 31

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 59(2)

Associations Incorporation Act 1985 (SA)

Magistrates’ Courts Act 1989 (Vic) ss 134, 135

Cases cited:

Advan Investments Pty Ltd v Dean Gleeson Motor Sales Pty Ltd [2003] VSC 201

AGL Energy Limited v Hardy [2017] FCA 420

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ACN 117 372 915 Pty Ltd (in liq) (formerly Advanced Medical Institute Pty Limited) [2016] FCA 1437

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Halkalia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2012] ¶ATPR 42-399; [2012] FCA 535

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v World Netsafe Pty Ltd (2003) 133 FCR 279; [2003] FCA 1501

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Michalik (2004) 52 ACSR 115; [2004] NSWSC 1259

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Reid (No 2) [2006] FCA 700

Burwood Council v Ruan [2008] NSWLEC 167

Deckers Outdoor Corporation Pty Ltd v Farley (No 6) [2010] FCA 391

Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2015) 229 FCR 331; [2015] FCAFC 59

Hoffman v Chief of Army (2004) 137 FCR 520; [2004] FCAFC 148

Humane Society International Inc v Kyodo Senpaku Kaisha Ltd (2015) 238 FCR 209; [2015] FCA 1275

Hurd v Zomojo Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 148

Infa-Secure Pty Limited v Crocker (No 2) (2016) 338 ALR 586; [2016] FCA 202

Kazal v Thunder Studios Inc (California) [2017] FCA 238

Louis Vuitton Malletier SA v Design Elegance Pty Ltd (2006) 149 FCR 494; [2006] FCA 83

R v Miceli [1998] 4 VR 588

R v O’Neill [1979] 2 NSWLR 582

R v Smith (1987) 44 SASR 587

R v Tsiaras [1996] 1 VR 398

R v Verdins (2007) 16 VR 269; [2007] VSCA 102

Thunder Studios Inc (California) v Kazal (No 2) [2017] FCA 202

Vaysman v Deckers Outdoor Corporation Inc (2011) 276 ALR 596; [2011] FCAFC 17

Date of hearing: 30 June 2016, 17 March 2017
Registry: Victoria
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 175
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr EJC Heerey QC
Solicitor for the Applicant: Norton Rose Fulbright Australia
Counsel for the First, Second, Third and Fifth Respondents: The First, Second, Third and Fifth Respondents did not appear
Counsel for the Fourth Respondent: Mr G Gilbert
Solicitor for the Fourth Respondent: Galbally & O’Bryan Lawyers

ORDERS

VID 362 of 2011
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Halkalia Pt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 522
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Halkalia Pty Ltd (No 3), the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) sought contempt charges against Mr. Hann, the fourth respondent, for his wilful and contumacious non-compliance with previous court orders. The legal issues at hand revolved around the determination of the appropriate penalty for Mr. Hann's contemptuous conduct, considering his advanced age and ill health. The court was required to weigh the severity of the contempts, the intention behind them, and the personal circumstances of the respondent in order to decide on an appropriate sentence.

The Federal Court, presided over by Justice Bromberg, found Mr. Hann guilty of the contempt charges. The court's reasoning centred on the gravity of Mr. Hann's wilful and contumacious disregard for the court's orders, as well as the evidence of his specific intention to defy the court's authority. Despite his advanced age and ill health, the court held that a period of imprisonment was necessary to uphold the integrity of the court and to deter future contempts. The court imposed a sentence of imprisonment for a total of five months, with the first two weeks to be served in any event, and the balance of the sentence suspended for two years, subject to Mr. Hann refraining from further contravening the court's orders.

The final orders of the court included the imprisonment of Mr. Hann for a total of five months, with a warrant issued for his committal to prison for a period of two weeks. Additionally, Mr. Hann was ordered to pay the ACCC's costs of the application on an indemnity basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The fourth respondent be imprisoned for the following periods:

(a) in respect of Charge 1 – three months;

(b) in respect of Charge 2 – five months;

(c) in respect of Charge 3 – three months;

(d) in respect of Charge 4 – three months;

(e) in respect of Charge 5 – three months;

(f) in respect of Charge 6 – five months;

(g) in respect of Charge 7 – three months; and

(h) in respect of Charge 8 – three months;

with each sentence to be served concurrently with each other sentence.

2. The fourth respondent be imprisoned for a period of five months with:

(a) the first two weeks being served in any event; and

(b) the balance of the sentence being suspended from execution on condition that the fourth respondent refrain from contravening any of the orders made herein and binding on him on 28 May 2012 for a period of two years from the date on which the suspension takes effect.

3. A warrant issue for the committal of the fourth respondent to prison for a period of two weeks.

4. The fourth respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the application on an indemnity basis.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Hann has admitted the contempts and, for the reasons which follow, will be sentenced to a period of imprisonment.THE FACTUAL BACKGROUND In 2011, the ACCC commenced this proceeding seeking declarations and other orders against three proprietary limited companies and two natural persons, one of whom was Mr Hann. The proceeding arose out of the making of representations by the respondents — mostly in newspaper advertisements, but also orally — concerning the availability of business opportunities. As I explained in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Halkalia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2012] ATPR ¶42-399 at 45,519; [2012] FCA 535 at [24] (“Halkalia (No 2)”), a typical advertisement contained the following text:Sales distribution business part time, light parcels genuine unique opportunity for purchase amount of $10,000. Potential earnings for 3–4 days per week approximately $800 to $1,000 for the Mature Aged Group, 1800 267 583. It was alleged that the respondents’ conduct conveyed misrepresentations relating to the prospective earnings of the business advertised for sale. It was alleged that the conduct was misleading or deceptive within the meaning of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (“the Act”), in broad terms because there were no reasonable grounds for the representations and because the representations were contrary to fact. The allegation against Mr Hann was that he had engaged in both primary contraventions of the Act and that he was also involved in contraventions by each of the three corporate entities. In order to explain Mr Hann’s involvement, it is convenient to start with a declaration made by this Court on 28 May 2012 in Halkalia (No 2) in respect of the first respondent (“Declaration 1”). It is typical of the declarations made in respect of the other corporate respondents:1.The first respondent, between 10 February 2010 and 10 April 2010, in trade or commerce:(a)in contravention of s 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (“the TPA”), engaged in conduct that was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead and deceive; and(b)in contravention of s 59(2) of the TPA, made false or misleading representations concerning the profitability of a business activity in which it invited other persons to participate, requiring the investment of money by them and the performance by them of work associated with the investment,by causing the publication of the 84 advertisements described in items 1 to 84 of Schedule A to these orders, by which the first respondent represented by each advertisement that:(i)the advertised business, once acquired by a purchaser, had the potential to generate weekly earnings for the purchaser in the stated amount (projected earnings);(ii)there was a realistic prospect that the advertised business, once acquired by a purchaser, would generate the projected earnings; and(iii)there was a reasonable basis for potential purchasers to expect that the advertised business would generate the projected earnings,whereas in fact:(A)the first respondent did not have reasonable grounds for making any of the representations;(B)the advertised business, once acquired by a purchaser, did not have the potential to generate the projected earnings;(C)there was no realistic prospect that the advertised business, once acquired by a purchaser, would generate the projected earnings; and(D)there was no reasonable basis for potential purchasers to expect that the advertised business would generate the projected earnings.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In each case Mr Hann stands charged with engaging in “wilful and contumacious” contempt of court. In Humane Society at [11], Jagot J adopted the following summary of the classes of contempt given by Biscoe J in Burwood Council v Ruan [2008] NSWLEC 167 at [7]:There are three classes of contempt: technical, wilful and contumacious. Technical contempt is where disobedience of a court order (or undertaking to the court) is casual, accidental or unintentional. Wilful contempt is where the disobedience is more than that, but is not contumacious. Contumacious contempt is where there is a specific intention to disobey a court order or undertaking to the court, which evidences a conscious defiance of the court’s authority. Although a contempt may be established, in the circumstances of the case the court may decide not to make any order. The element of intention is relevant to whether any order should be made and, if so, to punishment.The offending which Mr Hann acknowledges is, therefore, of a most serious character.EVIDENCE RELIED UPON BY THE ACCC The ACCC relied upon the following affidavits:(1)the affidavit of Mr David Arthur Ross Shiels, process server, sworn 4 December 2015;(2)the affidavit of Ms Fiona Gai Grant, Assistant Director of the ACCC, sworn 4 December 2015;(3)the affidavit of Mr Trevor Richard Blackall affirmed 10 December 2015;(4)the affidavit of Mr Alan Jeffery Pasfield sworn 10 December 2015;(5)the affidavit of Ms Cecily Jane Tilley affirmed 10 December 2015;(6)the affidavit of Ms Kylie Danielle Little affirmed 10 December 2015;(7)the affidavit of Mr Adrian Gordon Ferguson sworn 11 December 2015;(8)the affidavit of Mr Glenn Rex Wright affirmed 11 December 2015;(9)the affidavit of Mr Kelvin Lyall Foote affirmed 10 December 2015;(10)the affidavit of Ms Barbara Louise Meriton affirmed 11 December 2015;(11)the affidavit of Ms Zoe Panagiotopoulos sworn 11 December 2015; and(12)the second affidavit of Mr Shiels sworn 21 December 2015. The second affidavit of Mr Shiels dated 21 December 2015 was an affidavit of service in respect of (inter alia) the other 11 affidavits. The ACCC also relied upon a third affidavit of Mr Shiels sworn 18 February 2016. This was an affidavit of service in respect of a letter to Mr Hann from the solicitors for the ACCC reminding him of the hearing on 11 March 2016 and asking him to inform them which of the ACCC’s witnesses he required to be made available for cross-examination. The ACCC relied further upon the following affidavits:(1)the affidavit of Mr Pierre Guy Millard affirmed 19 April 2016;(2)the affidavit of Mr John Matthew Garrihy affirmed 21 April 2016;(3)the affidavit of Mr Paul Herbert Chatfield affirmed 22 April 2016;(4)the affidavit of Mr Kevin James John Love, a solicitor employed by the ACCC’s solicitors, affirmed 3 May 2016; and(5)the fourth affidavit of Mr Shiels sworn 6 May 2016. The fourth affidavit of Mr Shiels sworn 6 May 2016 was an affidavit of service in respect of (inter alia) the other four affidavits.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The circumstances in which the contempts arose are explained in these affidavits. The following account is drawn from them.Conduct prior to judgment in Halkalia (No 2) In late 2009, in connection with what I described in Halkalia (No 2) as the “Heartlink business” (see at [39]–[40]), a price list was distributed to potential purchasers of a sales distribution business. It was entitled “Heartlink (Community Benefit Products) Wholesale Price List November 2009”. This price list included a “Heartlink Bulk Products” list for “5lt Container Single Item Buy”. On that list were products including dish, floor, and wool wash liquids, spray and wipe cleaner, air freshener, chlorinated cleaner, grill and oven cleaner, shampoo, truck and car wash, engine degreaser, and industrial hand cleaner. A similar price list, dated July 2010, was also distributed. The products on the July 2010 “Bulk Products” list included all of those I have mentioned in relation to the November 2009 list (except wool wash and shampoo), in 5-litre and 15-litre varieties.Tasman Chemicals Tasman Chemicals Pty Ltd (“Tasman Chemicals”) supplied Mr Hann with the products that he, in turn, contrary to the Court’s orders, supplied to retailers or consumers. Tasman Chemicals’ products included kitchen and housekeeping cleaning products, hand soaps, and sanitisers. Ms Barbara Meriton, credit manager of Tasman Chemicals, first had contact with Mr Hann in December 2013, not long after she commenced in that role. She deposed that Mr Hann had, at that time, an existing account with Tasman Chemicals. The account number was 308054. Annexed to Ms Meriton’s affidavit were invoices issued by Tasman Chemicals in respect of that account. Review of those invoices reveals that the invoices dated between 8 August 2012 and 13 November 2013 inclusive were issued to “Heartlink Enterprises P/L”. Invoices between 19 December 2013 and 31 March 2015 inclusive were issued to “Mature Age Group Charity Association”. This was a reference to Mature Age Group Charity Association Inc, ABN 75 657 912 488 (“Mature Age Group”). Invoices from 8 April 2015 to 30 November 2015 inclusive were issued to “Green Triangle Community Group”, which is the trading name of Green Triangle Community Contributors Association Inc, ABN 59 296 404 562 (“Green Triangle”). Tasman Chemicals also issued monthly statements of account. Those dated between August 2012 and November 2015, were addressed, at various times, to Mature Age Group and — especially toward the end of the period — to Green Triangle. The circumstances in which the change from the Mature Age Group to Green Triangle occurred were explained by Ms Meriton. On or about 6 December 2013, Ms Meriton telephoned Mr Hann in respect of unpaid accounts. He did not answer but returned the call on 10 December 2013. A conversation followed to this effect:[Ms Meriton]: “I’m just ringing about an outstanding account you have with Tasman Chemicals. At the moment you’ve got about $2,800 owing for more than 60 days.”[Mr Hann gave an explanation for the lateness in payment, which is not here relevant][Mr Hann]: “I’m currently getting new people on board to sell the products I’m getting from you. So that should help. Part of the problem is that my customers haven’t paid me yet either. That makes it hard for me to pay what I owe you.”[Ms Meriton]: “I understand.”[Mr Hann]: “I should also let you know that the business has changed its name from Heartlink to the Mature Age Group Charity Association. Don’t address the invoices to Heartlink Enterprises anymore thanks. Yeah, I’m working with a charity now.”[Ms Meriton]: “Okay Mr Hann, I’ll amend our customer database.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established