Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Get Qualified Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Get Qualified Australia Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 976

File number: VID 896 of 2016
Judges: BEACH J
Date of judgment: 18 August 2016
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – freezing orders – alleged contraventions of the Australian Consumer Law – whether power to grant freezing orders under s 137F(1) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) – the interaction between s 137F and Division 4, Part 7, Chapter 2 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) – whether regulator required to provide undertaking as to damages
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 137F

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 23

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) Division 7.4, Part 7, Chapter 2

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) ss 56, 64

Cases cited:

Australian Communications and Media Authority v Mobilegate Ltd (2009) 256 ALR 85; [2009] FCA 539

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Chaste Corporation (No 1) (2003) 127 FCR 418

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Clinica Internationale Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1006

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Clinica Internationale Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 3) [2016] FCA 284

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Giraffe World Australia Pty Ltd (1998) 84 FCR 512

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Unique International College Pty Ltd (No 4) [2016] FCA 628

Cardile v LED Builders Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 380

Commonwealth of Australia v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd (1980) 147 CLR 39

Curtis v NID Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1072

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Hua Wang Bank Berhad (2010) 273 ALR 194; [2010] FCA 1014

F. Hoffmann-La Roche & Co AG v Secretary of State for Trade and Industry [1975] AC 295

National Australia Bank Ltd v Bond Brewing Holdings Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 271

PT Bayan Resources TBK v BCBC Singapore Pty Ltd (2015) 325 ALR 168; [2015] HCA 36

Trade Practices Commission v Santos Ltd (1992) 38 FCR 382

Date of hearing: 5, 10, 18 August 2016
Registry: Victoria
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 76
Counsel for the Prospective Applicant: Mr N J O’Bryan SC with Ms C Cunliffe
Solicitors for the Prospective Applicant: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Prospective Respondents: Mr T Brennan with Mr J O’Sullivan
Solicitors for the Prospective Respondents: & Legal

ORDERS

VID 896 of 2016
BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION

Prospective Applicant

AND:

GET QUALIFIED AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 144 813 543)

First Prospective Respondent

ADAM MAZEN WADI

Second Prospective Respondent

LAMA AL-NATOUR

Third Prospective Respondent

JUDGE:

BEACH J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 AUGUST 2016

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

INTRODUCTION    

1.Subject to the next paragraph, this order has effect until 10 September 2016 at 4.00pm, save that if the applicant has commenced a substantive proceeding against the prospective respondents prior to that date, this order has effect up to the determination of the substantive proceeding.

2.Anyone served with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Get Qualifi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 976
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) sought to obtain freezing orders against Get Qualified Australia Pty Ltd (GQA), its CEO Mr Adam Mazen Wadi, and Ms Lama Al-Natour, in relation to alleged contraventions of the Australian Consumer Law. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether the power to grant freezing orders under section 137F(1) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) applied, and if so, whether the ACCC was required to provide an undertaking as to damages in accordance with Division 4, Part 7, Chapter 2 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth).

The Court considered the legal principles surrounding freezing orders and the relevant statutory provisions. It was established that the ACCC had standing to apply for such orders and that the court had the authority to grant them under section 137F(1) of the Competition and Consumer Act. Furthermore, the Court found that the ACCC was not required to provide an undertaking as to damages, as the primary focus of the application was to prevent dissipation of assets and not to compensate for losses. The Court also noted that the ACCC had made efforts to minimise prejudice to the respondents by allowing for broad and large monetary exclusions from the freezing orders.

The Court found that there was a real risk of dissipation of assets, as the respondents had not provided sufficient evidence of their financial position, had family and assets overseas, and had made numerous transfers of significant sums of money to recipients abroad. Additionally, the potential adverse effects of the Australian Skills Quality Agency's (ASQA) Notice of Intention to deregister certain RTOs associated with GQA posed a risk of consumers being unable to receive services from GQA. Consequently, the Court concluded that the ACCC had demonstrated a good arguable case for the issuance of freezing orders.

The Court issued the freezing orders in the terms that had been foreshadowed with counsel. The orders prohibited the respondents from removing assets from Australia or disposing of, encumbering, or otherwise dealing with or diminishing the value of any of their assets, whether held in Australia or overseas. The orders also required the respondents to provide information about their worldwide assets and payments made between 1 January 2014 and 5 August 2016, with certain exceptions for living expenses, pilgrimage costs, and reasonable legal expenses. The costs of the application were reserved, and the orders were applicable to certain third parties outside Australia, subject to their compliance with local laws.

Orders

Orders of the court

INTRODUCTION

1. Subject to the next paragraph, this order has effect until 10 September 2016 at 4.00pm, save that if the applicant has commenced a substantive proceeding against the prospective respondents prior to that date, this order has effect up to the determination of the substantive proceeding.

2. Anyone served with or notified of this order, including you, may apply to the Court at any time to vary or discharge this order or so much of it as affects the person served or notified.

3. In this order:

(a) ‘applicant’, means the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission;

(b) ‘you’, where there is more than one of you, includes all of you and includes you if you are a corporation;

(c) ‘third party’ means a person other than you and the applicant;

(d) ‘First Prospective Respondent’ means Get Qualified Australia Pty Ltd;

(e) ‘Second Prospective Respondent’ means Mr Adam Mazen Wadi; and

(f) ‘Third Prospective Respondent’ means Ms Lama Al-Natour.

4.

(a) If you are ordered to do something, you must do it by yourself or through directors, officers, partners, employees, agents or others acting on your behalf or on your instructions.

(b) If you are ordered not to do something, you must not do it yourself or through directors, officers, partners, employees, agents or others acting on your behalf or on your instructions or with your encouragement or in any other way.

FREEZING OF ASSETS

5. You must not remove from Australia or in any way dispose of, encumber, or otherwise deal with or diminish the value of any of your assets whether held in Australia or overseas.

6. For the purposes of this order:

(a) your assets include:

(i) all your assets, whether or not they are in your name and whether they are solely or co-owned, and whether or not they are owned beneficially;

(ii) any asset which you have the power, directly or indirectly, to dispose of or deal with as if it were your own (you are to be regarded as having such power if a third party holds or controls the asset in accordance with your direct or indirect instructions), including the assets of any companies which are wholly owned by you;

(iii) any funds collected by any person (including any agent) on your behalf; and

(iv) the following assets in particular:

(A) the property described as Lot 139 on Survey Plan 224168 with title reference 50832306;

(B) any money in account 062-000 1503-9609 in the name of Get Qualified Australia at the Commonwealth Bank of Australia.

(b) the value of your assets is the value of the interest you have individually in your assets.

PROVISION OF INFORMATION

7. Subject to paragraph 8, you must:

(a) at or before 4.15pm on Friday 19 August 2016 (or within such further time as the Court may allow) to the best of your ability inform the applicant in writing of:

(i) In the case of each of the Prospective Respondents, all your assets worldwide, giving their value, location and details (including any mortgages, charges or other encumbrances to which they are subject) and the extent of your interest in the assets;

(ii) In the case of the First Prospective Respondent, all payments you have made in the period 1 January 2014 to 5 August 2016, the amount of the payment and the reason for the payment to:

a. the Second Prospective Respondent;

b. the Third Prospective Respondent;

c. Get Qualified Australia –Adelaide Pty Ltd (ACN 162 736 352);

d. Get Qualified Australia – Canberra Pty Ltd (ACN 162 736 914);

e. Get Qualified Australia – Brisbane Pty Ltd (ACN 600 535 868)

f. Get Qualified Australia – Perth Pty Ltd (ACN 162 735 926)

g. Get Qualified Australia – Melbourne Pty Ltd (ACN 601 990 185);

h. Aurion FZE; and

i. International Consultancy FZC.

(iii) In the case of the Second Prospective Respondent, all payments you have made in the period 1 January 2014 to 5 August 2016, the amount of the payment and the reason for the payment to:

a. the First Prospective Respondent;

b. the Third Prospective Respondent;

c. Get Qualified Australia – Adelaide Pty Ltd (ACN 162 736 352);

d. Get Qualified Australia - Canberra Pty Ltd (ACN 162 736 914);

e. Get Qualified Australia – Brisbane Pty Ltd (ACN 600 535 868)

f. Get Qualified Australia – Perth Pty Ltd (ACN 162 735 926)

g. Get Qualified Australia – Melbourne Pty Ltd (ACN 601 990 185)

h. GQ Holdings Ltd;

i. Aurion FZE; and

j. International Consultancy FZE.

(iv) In the case of the Third Prospective Respondent, all payments you have made in the period 1 January 2014 to 5 August 2016, the amount of the payment and the reason for the payment to:

a. the First Prospective Respondent;

b. the Second Prospective Respondent; and

c. Get Qualified Australia - Canberra Pty Ltd (ACN 162 736 914).

(v) In the case of each of the Second and Third Prospective Respondents, all funds received by you from the First Prospective Respondent in the period 1 January 2014 to 5 August 2016, the amount of the payment and the reason for the payment;

(vi) In the case of the Second Prospective Respondent, all funds received by you from “International Consultancy FZC” in the period 1 January 2014 to 5 August 2016, the amount of the payment and the reason for the payment.

(b) within fourteen (14) working days after being served with this order, swear and serve on the applicant an affidavit setting out the above information.

8.

(a) This paragraph 8 applies to the Second and Third Prospective Respondents, because you are not a corporation, if you wish to object to complying with paragraph 7 on the grounds that some or all of the information required to be disclosed may tend to prove that you:

(i) have committed an offence against or arising under an Australian law or a law of a foreign country; or

(ii) are liable to a civil penalty.

(b) This paragraph 8 also applies to the First Prospective Respondent, which is a corporation, if all of the persons who are able to comply with paragraph 7 on your behalf and with whom you have been able to communicate, wish to object to your complying with paragraph 7 on the grounds that some or all of the information required to be disclosed may tend to prove that they respectively:

(i) have committed an offence against or arising under an Australian law or a law of a foreign country; or

(ii) are liable to a civil penalty.

(c) You must:

(i) disclose so much of the information required to be disclosed to which no objection is taken; and

(ii) prepare an affidavit containing so much of the information required to be disclosed to which objection is taken, and deliver it to the Court in a sealed envelope; and

(iii) file and serve on each other party a separate affidavit setting out the basis of the objection.

EXCEPTIONS TO THIS ORDER

9. This order does not prohibit:

(a) each of the Second and Third Prospective Respondents from paying up to $10,000 per month on ordinary living expenses;

(b) the Second Prospective Respondent transferring to the bank accounts of the Third Prospective Respondent payments of up to $2,000 a week for ordinary living expenses;

(c) the First Prospective Respondent making payments in the ordinary and proper course of its business provided that those payments do not exceed:

(i) $350,000 on suppliers per fortnight; and

(ii) $220,000 on payroll and labour hire expenses per fortnight;

(d) the First Prospective Respondent making any payment due to the Australian Taxation Office;

(e) expenditure by the Second Prospective Respondent on airfares for his forthcoming pilgrimage to Mecca not exceeding $30,000;

(f) the Second Prospective Respondent from paying up to $10,000 per month in total to his mother, Zahia Karamouh, his sisters, Nancy Wadi and Suzy Wadi; and

(g) each of you from paying reasonable legal expenses relating to this application.

10. You and the applicant may agree in writing that the exceptions in the preceding paragraph are to be varied. In that case the applicant or you must as soon as practicable file with the Court and serve on the other a minute of a proposed consent order recording the variation signed by or on behalf of the applicant and you, and the Court may order that the exceptions are varied accordingly.

COSTS

11. The costs of this application are reserved.

THIRD PARTIES

12.Set off by banks

This order does not prevent any bank from exercising any right of set off it has in respect of any facility which it gave you before it was notified of this order.

13.Bank withdrawals by you

No bank need inquire as to the application or proposed application of any money withdrawn by you if the withdrawal appears to be permitted by this order. For the avoidance of doubt, payments to Aurion FZE, GQ Holdings Ltd, International Consultancy FZC and International Consultancy FZE are not permitted by this order.

14.Persons outside Australia

(a) Except as provided in subparagraph 14(b) below, the terms of this order do not affect or concern anyone outside Australia.

(b) The terms of this order will affect the following persons outside Australia:

(i) you and your directors, officers, employees and agents (except banks and financial institutions);

(ii) any person (including a bank or financial institution) who:

(A) is subject to the jurisdiction of this Court; and

(B) has been given written notice of this order, or has actual knowledge of the substance of the order and of its requirements; and

(C) is able to prevent or impede acts or omissions outside Australia which constitute or assist in a disobedience of the terms of this order; and

(iii) any other person (including a bank of financial institution), only to the extent that this order is declared enforceable by or is enforced by a court in a country or state that has jurisdiction over that person or over any of that person’s assets.

15.Assets located outside Australia

Nothing in this order shall, in respect of assets located outside Australia, prevent any third party from complying or acting in conformity with what it reasonably believes to be its bona fide and properly incurred legal obligations, whether contractual or pursuant to a court order or otherwise, under the law of the country or state in which those assets are situated or under the proper law of any contract between a third party and you, provided that in the case of any future order of a court of that country or state made on your or the third party’s application, reasonable written notice of the making of the application is given to the applicant.

16.Substituted service

The Applicant has leave pursuant to rule 10.24 of the Federal Court Rules 2011

(Cth) to serve this order and all documents in this proceeding on the Third Prospective Respondent by delivering them to her husband, the Second Prospective Respondent, and by sending them to the Facebook page located at the URL: http://www.facebook.com/lama.natour.9.

17.Liberty to apply

You have liberty to apply on 24 hours’ notice.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As to prejudice flowing from the orders, I have sought to minimise this by allowing for broad and large monetary exclusions from the freezing orders, so that the prospective respondents’ business and activities are not unduly restricted. If necessary I can make further modifications. I do of course accept that on any view, even with the carve outs, inconvenience and some prejudice will be caused to the prospective respondents as a consequence of these orders, including reputational issues vis-à-vis dealing with third parties. I have taken this into account.(c) Evidence concerning the risk of dissipation The question is whether there is a danger or real risk of dissipation of assets such that any judgment would in whole or in part go unsatisfied. But it is not necessary to show evidence of a respondent’s positive intention to frustrate a judgment (see Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Hua Wang Bank Berhad at [10] per Kenny J). One can look at the objective threat or risk and its potential effect. But I accept that solid evidence of a danger or dissipation or disposal of assets ought to be produced. In terms of the risk of dissipation, I would note the following:(a)First, it is not apparent what assets are held by GQA or Mr Wadi and Ms Al-Natour. The prospective respondents have not provided documentary evidence as to their financial position. Indeed Mr Wadi’s evidence is that if GQA were placed in liquidation, it would not be able to pay its existing trade creditors in full or at all after payment of liquidation fees. Mr Wadi has stated that the value of GQA as a going concern is approximately $50 million. This is a bare assertion. Its tangible assets are between $1 million to $2 million at most.(b)Second, Mr Wadi and Ms Al-Natour were born overseas (in Lebanon and Jordan respectively). Ms Al-Natour is not a citizen of Australia – she is a permanent resident. Ms Al-Natour is currently in Jordan, and Mr Wadi’s evidence is that she is not expected to return for some time. It is apparent from Mr Wadi’s evidence that Ms Al-Natour has family and significant assets (including a vehicle) in Jordan. Mr Wadi intends to travel overseas to Mecca for four weeks from 26 August 2016. If Mr Wadi and Ms Al-Natour relocate overseas it would be difficult to enforce any judgment against them.(c)Third, GQA and Mr Wadi have made numerous transfers of significant sums of money to recipients in Jordan and the United Arab Emirates between February 2015 and 21 June 2016. Indeed, Mr Wadi’s evidence is that he and GQA have made significant payments to overseas bank accounts since February 2015, to family members and to a company based in the United Arab Emirates which was established to supply consultancy and other services to GQA. Further, GQA is restructuring to move some of its “back office” operations to other countries and had transferred capital to Dubai for this purpose. Further, it is apparent from the recent and significant transfers to the Philippines that some parts of GQA’s operations may already have been moved off-shore.(d)Fourth, GQA’s business is likely to be adversely affected by ASQA’s Notice of Intention to make a decision to impose a sanction on each of Get Qualified Australia - Adelaide Pty Ltd, Get Qualified Australia - Canberra Pty Ltd and Get Qualified Australia - Brisbane Pty Ltd (the GQA RTOs) by cancelling the registration of each of the RTOs. Mr Wadi is the CEO and point of contact for each of these entities. I accept that the Notice is preliminary. But there is a real risk to say the least that ASQA will ultimately take serious action concerning these RTOs, which are very significant to GQA’s overall business model, albeit that their direct financial contribution is small. ASQA’s actions are likely to have a material effect on GQA’s ability to offer services. 2037 of the 7250 GQA customers have received qualifications since 1 March 2013 (28%) from a GQA RTO. Of GQA’s 2388 enrolled clients, 867 (36%) are recorded as having a GQA RTO listed as the “Target RTO”. Mr Wadi’s suggestion that “cessation of the operations of the GQA RTOs will have little financial impact on GQA’s business” is untenable.(e)Fifth and accordingly, there is a heightened risk that consumers who have contracted with GQA may not be able to receive services from them. Mr Wadi has given evidence that an inability to provide services to current clients may expose GQA to an action for breach of contract and a liability to refund consumers. Mr Wadi has observed that it is also likely that damage to reputation may adversely affect GQA’s business. But it is very likely that ASQA’s actions in deregistering RTOs associated with GQA will damage GQA’s reputation.(f)Sixth, Mr Wadi has given evidence of the following. GQA’s principal asset is goodwill, which is geographically confined. It does not own any substantial plant or equipment and leases its premises. GQA is wholly funded by its cash reserves, which are $1.1 million to $1.3 million cash (equivalent to only 4-5 weeks’ trading expenses, according to Mr Wadi). GQA’s total expenses are about $285,000 per week on the figures provided (although Mr Wadi has asserted $385,000 per week). Without a copy of GQA’s accounts, it is not apparent from the financial information produced whether GQA is solvent, or that GQA would be in a position to meet a significant judgment against it. Finally on this aspect, GQA produced a “Profit & Loss – Summary” and “Cash Flow Statement” for, inter alia, parts of 2016. Frankly I found it opaque and unsatisfactory in form. Moreover, it gave rise to more questions than it answered.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, even if I were to have held that there was no good arguable case for accessorial liability against Ms Al-Natour, I would have treated her as a third party and justified a freezing order in accordance with the principles discussed in Cardile v LED Builders Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 380. She clearly has received funds sourced ultimately from GQA and may hold assets acquired with such funds.CONCLUSION I will make orders in the terms that I have foreshadowed with counsel.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established