Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emirates

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emirates [2012] FCA 1108

Citation: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emirates [2012] FCA 1108
Parties: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v EMIRATES (ARBN 073 569 696)
File number: NSD 876 of 2009
Judge: KATZMANN J
Date of judgment: 11 October 2012
Catchwords: COMPETITION – price-fixing – collusive understandings – respondent admitted to seven contraventions of s 45(2) Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – enforcement and remedies – application for pecuniary penalties and injunctions under ss 76 and 80 – agreed penalties and injunctions – regulator and respondent filed joint submissions, statement of agreed facts and agreed short minutes of order –whether contraventions occurred – whether the proposed penalties should be imposed – whether quantum of proposed penalties in the appropriate range – matters relevant to imposition of penalty – admissions not made until pleadings had closed and most evidence served – parity with penalties imposed in similar cases
Legislation:

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) 45, 45(2)(a)(ii), 45(2)(b)(ii), 45A(1), 76, 77(2), 80

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191

Cases cited: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cargolux Airlines International SA (2009) ATPR ¶42-282
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Korean Air Lines Co Ltd [2011] FCA 1360
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Malaysia Airline System Berhad (No 2) [2012] FCA 767
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v McMahon Services Pty Ltd (2004) ATPR ¶42-031
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Real Estate Institute of Western Australia Inc. (1999) 161 ALR 79
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Qantas Airways Ltd (2008) 253 ALR 89
Minister for Industry Tourism & Resources v Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd (2004) ¶41–993
J McPhee & Son (Australia) Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2000) 172 ALR 53
NW Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (1996) 71 FCR 285
Trade Practices Commission v CSR Ltd (1991) ATPR ¶41-076
Date of hearing: 11 October 2012
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 58
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr N O'Bryan SC
Solicitor for the Applicant: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr C Scerri QC and Ms D M Bampton
Solicitor for the Respondent: Allens

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NSW DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 876 of 2009

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

EMIRATES (ARBN 073 569 696)
Respondent

JUDGE:

KATZMANN J

DATE OF ORDER:

11 OCTOBER 2012

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The respondent pay the Commonwealth of Australia, within 14 days, a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $7 million in respect of contraventions of s 45(2)(a)(ii) and (b)(ii) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), now the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (the Act) occurring after August 2003, in that:

1.1.     the respondent:

1.1.1.between about October 2001 and September 2005, reached understandings with certain of its competitors for the supply of services, from Indonesia to certain other countries including Australia, for the carriage of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emirates and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 1108
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emirates, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) sought penalties and injunctions against Emirates for price-fixing and collusive arrangements. The court was required to determine whether Emirates had contravened section 45(2) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) by entering into agreements to fix, control, or maintain prices for air cargo services, and whether the proposed penalties were appropriate. The court examined the agreed facts and submissions from both the ACCC and Emirates, who had jointly agreed on the penalties and injunctions.

The court found that Emirates had indeed engaged in the anti-competitive conduct as alleged by the ACCC. The agreements involved the imposition of fuel surcharges and security surcharges on air cargo services, which had the effect of fixing or controlling prices. The court acknowledged the seriousness of the conduct and the potential harm to the competitiveness of Australian exports. However, the court also considered the delay in Emirates making admissions and its cooperation with the ACCC, which warranted some discount on the penalties. Ultimately, the court concluded that the agreed penalties of $7 million for the contraventions and $3 million for the attempted contravention were within the appropriate range and should be imposed. The court also accepted that injunctive relief was appropriate to prevent future anti-competitive conduct.

The court issued orders for Emirates to pay the penalties and a contribution towards the ACCC's costs, and imposed injunctive relief to prevent future price-fixing and collusive arrangements. The injunctive relief prohibits Emirates from entering into certain contracts or understandings with competitors that would fix, control, or maintain prices, unless certain exceptions apply. These orders are intended to ensure that Emirates complies with the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) and prevents similar anti-competitive conduct in the future.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The respondent pay the Commonwealth of Australia, within 14 days, a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $7 million in respect of contraventions of s 45(2)(a)(ii) and (b)(ii) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), now the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (the Act) occurring after August 2003, in that:

1.1. the respondent:

1.1.1. between about October 2001 and September 2005, reached understandings with certain of its competitors for the supply of services, from Indonesia to certain other countries including Australia, for the carriage of air cargo containing a provision that they would each impose a charge of a specified amount, described as a fuel surcharge, in respect of those services; and

1.1.2. between about October 2001 and October 2005, reached understandings with certain of its competitors for the supply of services from Indonesia to certain other countries including Australia for the carriage of air cargo containing a provision that they would each impose a charge of a specified amount described as a security surcharge, in respect of those services; and

1.1.3. between about May 2004 and October 2005, reached an understanding with certain of its competitors for the supply of services from Indonesia to certain other countries including Australia for the carriage of air cargo containing a provision that each would impose a charge of a specified amount, described as a customs fee, in respect of those services;

1.2. the provisions of the said understandings had the effect of fixing, maintaining or controlling prices for the said services within the meaning of section 45A of the Act and are therefore deemed to substantially lessen competition within the meaning of section 45(2)(a)(ii) and (b)(ii) of the Act; and

1.3. the respondent gave effect to those provisions:

1.3.1. of the understandings referred to in 1.1.1, from September 2002 to May 2006 inclusive;

1.3.2. of the understandings referred to in 1.1.2, from October 2001 to October 2005 inclusive; and

1.3.3. of the understanding referred to in 1.1.3, from May 2004 until October 2005 inclusive.

2. The respondent pay the Commonwealth of Australia, within 14 days, a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $3 million in respect of an attempted contravention of section 45(2)(a)(ii) of the Act, in that the respondent between on or about 20 June 2005 and 11 July 2005, attempted to make an arrangement or arrive at an understanding with DAS Air Cargo (DAS) and attempted to induce DAS to make an arrangement or arrive at an understanding containing provisions that:

2.1. Emirates and DAS would charge a common rate for the supply of air freight services from Australia; and

2.2. Emirates and DAS would each not undercut the prices offered by the other airline for the supply of air freight services from Australia.

THE COURT ORDERS BY CONSENT THAT:

3. The respondent be restrained, for a period of five years from the date of this order from attempting to make, making, arriving at, or giving effect to, any contract, arrangement or understanding with any of its competitors for the supply of services for the carriage of goods by air, containing provisions which have the effect of fixing, controlling or maintaining the price or any part of the price at which it or any of them will supply those services in competition with each other unless:

3.1. the said contract, arrangement or understanding does not involve or relate to the carriage of goods to or from Australia;

3.2. the said contract, arrangement or understanding is for the purpose of a joint venture for the supply of services for the carriage of goods, which joint venture is carried on jointly by all parties to the contract, arrangement or understanding, within the meaning of s44ZZRP of the Act;

3.3. the said contract, arrangement or understanding is for the purpose of interlining between two or more carriers in the course of supplying services of the carriage of international air cargo; or

3.4. the respondent is specifically authorised to do so under section 88 of the Act or any other Australian statute in accordance with section 51 of the Act.

4. The respondent be restrained for a period of five years from the date of this order from attempting to enter, entering into, or giving effect to, any contract, arrangement or understanding with any of its competitors for the supply of services for the carriage of goods by air containing provisions to the effect that any of them will propose, develop, prepare, follow, implement, adopt or otherwise use any index, model, methodology or formula for the change of prices or any part of prices to be charged by any of them for services provided or which would otherwise likely be provided in competition with any other of them unless:

4.1. the said contract, arrangement or understanding does not involve or relate to the carriage of goods to or from Australia;

4.2. the said contract, arrangement or understanding is for the purpose of a joint venture for the supply of services for the carriage of goods, which joint venture is carried on jointly by all parties to the contract, arrangement or understanding, within the meaning of s44ZZRP of the Act;

4.3. the said contract, arrangement or understanding is for the purpose of interlining between two or more carriers in the course of supplying services of the carriage of international air cargo; or

4.4. the respondent is specifically authorised to do so under section 88 of the Act or any other Australian statute in accordance with section 51 of the Act.

5. The respondent pay the applicant within 14 days of the date this order is made a contribution towards its costs of and incidental to these proceedings in the sum of $500,000.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The parties agree that a penalty of $3 million in respect of this conduct is appropriate. BACKGROUND The agreed facts provide some context for Emirates’s conduct. After a substantial rise in the global price of aviation fuel in the second half of 1996 Lufthansa announced that it would levy across its entire route network a fuel surcharge of US$0.10 per kg of air freight (or its equivalent in local currency) and on or about 1 November 1996 it acted on the announcement. Not long afterwards (presumably in response to the Lufthansa move), the Cargo Tariff Coordinating Conference of the International Air Transport Association (“IATA”), the peak airline industry body to which major international airlines belong, passed a resolution (resolution 116ss) that IATA prepare and publish a fuel price index for its members. IATA went ahead and published the index in the period 1997 to 1999. Emirates is and was at all material times a member of IATA but not of the Cargo Tariff Coordinating Conference. The IATA index provided for the imposition of fuel surcharges in accordance with a methodology linked to the index. The details are contained in the agreed facts. IATA advised its members not to impose a fuel surcharge until resolution 116ss had received regulatory approval, including from the US Department of Transport. In March 2000 the Department refused approval, finding the index to be contrary to the public interest and in violation of the law. IATA then ceased publishing the index and sent a memorandum on 7 April 2000 to the members of the Cargo Tariff Coordinating Conference informing them that it had done so. Evidently, there were appeals to IATA to continue publishing the list, despite the US decision. This prompted IATA to send a week later, on 14 April 2000, another memorandum to the members of the Conference informing them, amongst other things of the reasons for its decision to discontinue the index. That memorandum disclosed legal advice IATA had received to the effect that if the airlines were to coordinate pricing by reference to the index that could be regarded as “an illegal conspiracy in violation of applicable Competition laws”. I emphasise, however, that there is no evidence that this memorandum (or its contents) came to Emirates’s attention. By late 2001 the price of aviation fuel had fallen and in December 2001 Lufthansa and other airlines which had imposed a fuel surcharge announced its withdrawal. The following month, however, Lufthansa announced a new fuel surcharge based on a methodology, which (like the IATA fuel price index) involved calculations based on the per kilogram weight of international air freight. Emirates is one of several airlines that engaged in anti-competitive conduct during the period in question, notwithstanding the IATA advice. Proceedings have been taken against several of its competitors. Some have reached similar agreements with the ACCC and have been ordered to pay penalties. Some actions are pending. A hearing is due to take place in this Court on 22 October 2012 of applications against Singapore Airlines, Cathay Pacific, Thai Airways and Air New Zealand. I was informed that, with the exception of Air New Zealand, each of these applications arises in whole or in part from the Indonesia Understandings. THE QUESTION OF PENALTY – PRINCIPLES

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It does not matter whether, absent the agreements, I might have come to different conclusions. What matters is whether I am satisfied that the amounts proposed are within the proper range. Of that I am.CONCLUSION In short, as the parties rightly submitted, it is a very serious matter for a major international airline to enter (or, I might add, attempt to enter) into a price fixing arrangement with a competitor. The seriousness with which the community views this conduct is reflected in the magnitude of the maximum penalty for which the Act provides.The conduct was intended to affect the price of Australian exports and could have harmed the competitiveness of those exports in foreign markets. Credit should be given to Emirates for the steps it has taken to prevent this kind of conduct from occurring, and for its cooperation with the ACCC resulting in the agreements that have obviated the need for a hearing. But the delay in making the admissions would reduce the extent of the discount which would have been appropriate had they been made before the ACCC commenced proceedings or at an earlier time before substantial costs had been incurred. For all these reasons, the agreed penalties should be imposed. I also accept that this is a proper case in which to order injunctive relief under s 80. I therefore make the orders in the agreed short minutes of order signed by the parties and dated 19 September 2012.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.