Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Amcor Printing Papers Group Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Amcor Printing Papers Group Ltd [2000] FCA 17

TRADE PRACTICES – claim that respondents made and gave effect to an arrangement containing an exclusionary provision – Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 4D, 45(2) – sufficiency of evidence

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – submission of no case to answer – whether moving party must elect to call no evidence – function of judge in ruling on no case submission – whether no case submission should be upheld

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 4D, 45(2), 76, 80
Federal Court Rules, O 32, r 4(1); O 35, r 1
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s 79
Supreme Court Rules (NSW), Pt 34, r 8

Rasomen Pty Ltd v Shell Company of Australia Ltd (1997) 75 FCR 216, followed
Protean (Holdings) Ltd (recs and mgrs appointed) v American Home Assurance Co [1985] VR 187, followed
Rasomen Pty Ltd v Shell Company of Australia Ltd (1996) 71 FCR 540, cited
Compaq Computer Australia Pty Ltd v Merry (1998) 157 ALR 1, cited
Trade Practices Commission v George Western Foods Ltd (No 2) (1980) 43 FLR 55, followed
Residues Treatment & Trading Co Ltd v Southern Resources Ltd (1989) 52 SASR 54, cited
Popovic v Tanasijevic (No 3) [1999] SASC 339, cited
The Union Bank of Australia Ltd v Puddy [1949] VLR 242, referred to
Trade Practices Commission v Nicholas Enterprises Pty Ltd [1978] ATPR 40-097, cited
ASX Operations Pty Ltd v Pont Data Australia Pty Ltd (No 1) (1990) 27 FCR 460, cited
Top Performance Motors Pty Ltd v Ira Berk (Queensland) Pty Ltd (1975) 24 FLR 286, cited
Trade Practices Commission v Email Ltd (1980) 43 FLR 383, cited
Trade Practices Commission v Service Station Association Ltd (1993) 44 FCR 206, cited
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336, followed
Trade Practices Commission v Nicholas Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 2) (1979) 40 FLR 83, cited
Peter Williamson Pty Ltd v Capitol Motors Ltd (1982) 61 FLR 257, cited
Bradshaw v McEwans Pty Ltd (unreported, High Court, 27 April 1951), followed
Luxton v Vines (1952) 85 CLR 352, cited
Nominal Defendant v Owens (1978) 22 ALR 128, cited
Transport Industries Insurance Co Ltd v Longmuir [1997] 1 VR 125, cited

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION & CONSUMER COMMISSION v AMCOR PRINTING PAPERS GROUP LTD & ORS

NG 1245 OF 1998

SACKVILLE J
19 JANUARY 2000
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 1245 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
APPLICANT

AND:

AMCOR PRINTING PAPERS GROUP LTD (ACN 005 146 350)
FIRST RESPONDENT

VISY PAPER PTY LTD (ACN 005 803 234)
SECOND RESPONDENT

ANTHONY NOTT
THIRD RESPONDENT

WILLIAM GUTHRIDGE
FOURTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

SACKVILLE J

DATE OF ORDER:

19 JANUARY 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.   The application be dismissed against all respondents.

2.   The parties file and serve written submissions…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Amcor Print... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 17
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought proceedings against Amcor Printing Papers Group Ltd and others, alleging contraventions of the Trade Practices Act. The central dispute concerned allegations of anti-competitive behaviour in the market for recyclable waste paper in the Illawarra region of Australia. The ACCC argued that Amcor and Visy, two major competitors in the recyclable paper market, had entered into an arrangement that contravened certain sections of the Trade Practices Act, specifically sections 45(2)(a)(i) and 45(2)(b)(i). Additionally, the ACCC sought to establish that certain individuals were knowingly involved in these alleged contraventions.

The primary legal issues before the court involved determining whether Amcor and Visy had indeed made or entered into an arrangement that restricted competition, as alleged by the ACCC. Furthermore, the court had to assess if the individuals associated with these companies were knowingly involved in such anti-competitive activities. This required a careful examination of the evidence presented by the ACCC, including affidavits and documentary evidence, to ascertain whether the alleged contraventions had been proven to the requisite standard of proof.

The court found that the evidence presented by the ACCC did not sufficiently establish the alleged anti-competitive arrangement between Amcor and Visy. The testimonies from key witnesses, such as Mr Gandy and Mr Clarke from Flagstaff, although largely consistent, did not definitively support the ACCC's claims. Additionally, the court noted that the ACCC's evidence fell short of the required standard of proof. Consequently, the court upheld the no case submission made by the respondents, leading to the dismissal of the application against all remaining respondents.

In light of the dismissal, the court ordered that the application be dismissed against all respondents and directed the parties to file and serve written submissions on the question of costs. This decision underscored the necessity for the ACCC to provide compelling evidence to substantiate allegations of anti-competitive behaviour under the Trade Practices Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed against all respondents.

2. The parties file and serve written submissions on the question of costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the purposes of the election issue and the no case submission it is not necessary to resolve this apparent conflict between Mr Clarke and Mr Gandy on what is essentially a peripheral issue. I have approached these questions on the assumption that Mr Gandy’s account (the version arguably more favourable to the ACCC) is more likely to be accurate. This is not necessarily the view I would have taken had it become necessary to resolve the factual question in the light of all the evidence.The Facts There are basically four categories of waste paper: high grade white paper (used as a substitute for virgin pulp when impurities such as ink are removed); mixed grade papers; cardboard and packaging; and newsprint. Within each category there are sub-categories. Throughout 1996, Visy and Amcor were in competition to secure supplies of recyclable waste paper from the Illawarra region and elsewhere in Australia. The individual respondents at this time occupied the respective positions identified in the pleadings. During the seven months or so preceding the relevant events, Visy was concerned to reduce the cost of securing recyclable waste paper for its operations. It was also concerned about the activities of Amcor, especially in taking over Visy’s sources of supply and in quoting what Visy regarded as “very high rates” to suppliers or potential suppliers of waste paper. The concerns were expressed in a number of internal Visy memoranda written during the period 19 December 1995 to 19 July 1996. A memorandum of 12 July 1996 from Mr Gerard, Visy’s Procurement Manager, to Mr Guthridge referred to Amcor’s “invasions” and its “active quoting ‘OVER THE TOP’ prices”. A memorandum of 19 July 1996 from Mr Gerard to Mr Guthridge referred to Amcor “hamper[ing] our agenda with aggressive pricing on our clients”. The memorandum identified accounts which Visy “were unable to reduce due to [Amcor’s] pricing”. From about 1992, Flagstaff had carried on operations in the Illawarra area collecting waste paper and cardboard and packaging and on-selling the material collected. In about mid-1996 Flagstaff was the supplier of about fifty per cent of the recyclable paper and cardboard sourced from the Wollongong area. At that time, Flagstaff sales of waste paper and cardboard on a monthly basis were as follows:(i)Approximately thirty tonnes of “Stainless White” was sold to Amcor at a price of $300 per tonne (that is, $9,000 per month). Amcor referred to this category of waste paper as “Shoalhaven white” or “Shoalhaven grade”, apparently because it was processed at Amcor’s Shoalhaven mill which had facilities for so-called de-inking. The paper came from BHP’s stainless steel mill at Wollongong.(ii)Approximately forty-five tonnes of “Mixed White” (sometimes called “P3” grade) was sold to a company called Tredex Recycling Pty Ltd (“Tredex”) at $250 per tonne (that is, $11,250 per month). Tredex paid Flagstaff directly for the P3 grade paper, but Mr Peoples appears to have arranged the sales and to have received a margin or fee for doing so. Tredex exported the recycled paper acquired from Flagstaff.(iii)Approximately sixty-four tonnes of waste cardboard was sold to Visy at $70 per tonne after Flagstaff paid $15 per tonne transportation costs (that is, $4,480 per month).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The ACCC alleges that(i)by making the arrangement or arriving at the understanding between them Amcor and Visy contravened s 45(2)(a)(i) of the TP Act (par 24);(ii)Messrs Nott and Guthridge were each directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or party to, the contravention by Amcor and Visy of s 45(2)(a)(i) of the TP Act, within the meaning of s 76(1)(e) and s 80(1)(e) of the Act (pars 25, 26); (iii)by giving effect to the exclusionary provision Amcor contravened s 45(2)(b)(i) of the TP Act (par 31); and(iv)Mr Nott was directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or party to, the contravention by Amcor of s 45(2)(b)(i) of the TP Act, within the meaning of s 76(1)(e) and s 80(1)(e) of the Act (par 32).The Evidence Mr Catterns read five affidavits in support of the ACCC’s case. These were made by · Mr Gandy, the Chief Executive Officer of Flagstaff (who made two affidavits);· Mr Clarke, at the relevant time the Group Marketing Manager of Flagstaff;· Mr Peoples, a former employee of Amcor who, at the relevant time, provided (through a private company) consultancy services to the waste paper industry and bought and sold recyclable waste paper; and· Mr McKay, an officer of Telstra Corporation Ltd.In addition, Mr Catterns tendered some documentary evidence. Mr McKay gave uncontested evidence that telephone records showed that two telephone calls were made from Mr Guthridge’s mobile telephone to Mr Nott’s telephone number at Amcor in Melbourne. The first call was made from Fairfield in Sydney at 12:22 pm on 25 July 1996 and lasted for forty-two seconds. The second was made from Brisbane at 12:49 pm on 26 July 1996 and lasted for four minutes and fourteen seconds. Messrs Gandy, Clarke and Peoples were cross-examined by the respondents’ counsel, although not at any length. It is fair to say that there was no attempt to impugn the credit of any of the three witnesses. With one exception, their evidence was in substance consistent. It follows that, subject to that qualification, on the evidence adduced in the ACCC’s case the primary facts were not in dispute. This of course is not to say that the respondents would not have disputed or explained some aspects of the evidence had they gone into evidence themselves. The important point for present purposes is that an assessment of the ACCC’s case gives rise to no issue of credit and, subject to the one exception to which I have referred, no need to resolve any conflict in the evidence. The exception is that Messrs Gandy and Clarke gave somewhat different accounts as to the likelihood that Flagstaff would have been prepared to accept an exclusive arrangement of the kind envisaged by the Amcor Offer. Mr Clarke’s account was that Flagstaff had a firm policy of not entering exclusive arrangements with a single purchaser of recyclable paper and cardboard; that the Amcor Offer had been discussed with Mr Gandy (to whom Mr Clarke reported); and that there was no prospect that the offer would be accepted. Mr Gandy, for his part, accepted that Flagstaff considered it not particularly prudent to put all its eggs in one basket and that one reason it had not accepted the Amcor Offer by 9 August 1996 (the date Amcor withdrew it) was its wariness about supplying only a single purchaser of recyclable paper and cardboard. However, he thought that Flagstaff might still have been prepared, subject to Board approval, to accept an exclusive offer from Amcor, depending on the terms of the offer. It is not in dispute that none of the reservations held by Flagstaff about the Amcor Offer was communicated to Amcor.

Decision

Reasons for decision

SACKVILLE J
In my opinion, the evidence adduced by the ACCC, assessed as a whole, falls well short of establishing to the required standard that Visy and Amcor made or entered into the pleaded arrangement or understanding. The respondents’ no case submission must be upheld.Conclusion Since the respondents’ no case submission has been upheld, the application against all four remaining respondents must be dismissed. I shall give the parties an opportunity to make submissions on costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: SACKVILLE J

Full text does not contain this section.