FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Communications and Media Authority v WE.NET.AU Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1530
TELECOMMUNICATIONS – breach of Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth) (the Act) – civil penalty provisions – proposed orders jointly submitted to Court including declarations, pecuniary penalties, injunctions and costs – relevant factors to take into consideration in assessing appropriateness of pecuniary penalties
Held: although monetary amount of breach insignificant, respondents deliberately contravened Act over several years – second respondent clearly in senior management role in first respondent – respondents cooperated with applicant – respondents had limited assets – proposed pecuniary penalty appropriate in light of size of respondents’ business, nature of contraventions and likely deterrent effect
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21
Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth) ss 87, 98, 101, 102, 117, 564(1)(b), 570
Telecommunications (Consumer Protection and Service Standards) Act 1999 (Cth) ss 127, 128, 132
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 52, s 80Federal Court Rules O 36
Australian Communications and Media Authority v Clarity1 Pty Ltd (2006) 155 FCR 377 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v FFE Building Services [2003] FCA 1542 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Leahy Petroleum Pty Ltd (No 2) (2005) 215 ALR 281 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Leahy Petroleum Pty Ltd (No 3) (2005) 215 ALR 301 cited
Minister for Industry, Tourism and Resources v Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd (2004) FCAFC 72 followed
NW Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (1996) 71 FCR 285 followedAUSTRALIAN COMMUNICATIONS AND MEDIA AUTHORITY v WE.NET.AU PTY LTD and BRADLEY JAMES FRANCIS
QUD 95 OF 2008
COLLIER J
15 OCTOBER 2008
BRISBANE
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY
QUD 95 OF 2008
BETWEEN:
AUSTRALIAN COMMUNICATIONS AND MEDIA AUTHORITY
ApplicantAND:
WE.NET.AU PTY LTD
First RespondentBRADLEY JAMES FRANCIS
Second Respondent
JUDGE:
COLLIER J
DATE OF ORDER:
15 OCTOBER 2008
WHERE MADE:
BRISBANE
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
Declarations
1.A declaration that the first respondent (“WE.NET”) has contravened section 101(1) of the Telecommunications Act 1997 (the Telco Act), by offering to members of the public and supplying to customers its internet access services:
1.1between approximately 4 January 2005 and 3 January 2006, subject to terms and conditions which included provisions to the following effect:
1.1.1that if a customer who had a billing dispute with WE.NET in relation to its internet access services did not allow WE.NET one calendar month after notification to WE.NET by the customer of the dispute, to resolve or process the dispute, before the customer lodged a complaint with any third party, the customer agreed to accept the imposition on the customer by WE.NET of an administration fee of $125; and
1.1.2that in the event of an unresolved billing dispute, if the customer referred the matter to the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman (TIO) before WE.NET could resolve the dispute or refer it to mediation, then WE.NET could charge to the customer the greater of “$125 or fees as charged by the TIO to WE.net.au”,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Communications and Media Authority v WE.NET.AU Pt... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] FCA 1530
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
Declarations
1. A declaration that the first respondent (“WE.NET”) has contravened section 101(1) of the Telecommunications Act 1997 (the Telco Act), by offering to members of the public and supplying to customers its internet access services:
1.1 between approximately 4 January 2005 and 3 January 2006, subject to terms and conditions which included provisions to the following effect:
1.1.1 that if a customer who had a billing dispute with WE.NET in relation to its internet access services did not allow WE.NET one calendar month after notification to WE.NET by the customer of the dispute, to resolve or process the dispute, before the customer lodged a complaint with any third party, the customer agreed to accept the imposition on the customer by WE.NET of an administration fee of $125; and
1.1.2 that in the event of an unresolved billing dispute, if the customer referred the matter to the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman (TIO) before WE.NET could resolve the dispute or refer it to mediation, then WE.NET could charge to the customer the greater of “$125 or fees as charged by the TIO to WE.net.au”, in addition to the administration fee described above;
1.2 between approximately 4 January 2006 and 14 July 2007, subject to terms and conditions which included provisions to the following effect:
1.2.1 that if a customer who had a billing dispute with WE.NET in relation to its internet access services did not allow WE.NET one calendar month after notification to WE.NET by the customer of the dispute, to resolve or process the dispute, before the customer lodged a complaint with any third party, the customer agreed to accept the imposition on the customer by WE.NET of an administration fee of $160; and
1.2.2 that in the event of an unresolved billing dispute, if the customer referred the matter to any third party including the TIO, then WE.NET could charge the customer “an administration fee of $80/hr (min 2 hours) .. only provided that the dispute is not determined in the customers 100% favour”;
1.3 between approximately 14 July 2007 and 1 January 2008, subject to terms and conditions which included provisions to the effect that, that if a customer who had a billing dispute with WE.NET in relation to WE.NET’s internet access services did not allow WE.NET one calendar month after notification to WE.NET by the customer of the dispute, to resolve or process the dispute, before the customer lodged a complaint with any third party, the customer agreed that other fees may be charged to the customer by WE.NET;
thereby requiring end-users to pay a fee or charge to WE.NET in respect of any complaints made by the end-user to the TIO about WE.NET’s internet access service, by which conduct it failed to comply with a service provider rule, being section 128(4A) of the Telecommunications (Consumer Protection and Service Standards) Act 1999 (the T(CPSS) Act), and thereby failed to comply with the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman Scheme pursuant to section 132 of the T(CPSS) Act.
2. A declaration that the second respondent, Francis, was knowingly concerned in or party to, and aided, abetted, counselled or procured, the contravening conduct of WE.NET referred to in paragraph 1 above, being conduct of the kind referred to in section 101(2) of the Telco Act.
3. A declaration that WE.NET has contravened section 101(1) of the Telco Act, in that it failed to comply with:
3.1 the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman Scheme pursuant to section 132 of the T(CPSS) Act; and
3.2 a service provider rule within the meaning of section 98 and Schedule 2 of the Telco Act; and
3.3 clause 6.1 of the TIO Constitution;
by failing to comply with a determination of the TIO dated 10 March 2006 that WE.NET pay, by a specified date, an amount of $35 in respect of a complaint lodged with the TIO by a customer of WE.NET, Ms McDonald.
4. A declaration that WE.NET has contravened section 101(1) of the Telco Act, in that it failed to comply with:
4.1 the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman Scheme pursuant to section 132 of the T(CPSS) Act; and
4.2 a service provider rule within the meaning of section 98 and Schedule 2 of the Telco Act; and
4.3 clause 6.1 of the TIO Constitution;
by failing to comply with a determination of the TIO dated 26 November 2006 that WE.NET pay, by a specified date, an amount of $34.95 in respect of a complaint lodged with the TIO by a customer of WE.NET, Mr Jameson.
5. A declaration that WE.NET has contravened section 101(1) of the Telco Act, in that it failed to comply with section 102(4) of the Telco Act, by failing to comply with a written direction of Australian Communications and Media Authority issued pursuant to section 102(2) of the Telco Act dated 9 July 2007.
6. A declaration that the second respondent, Francis, was knowingly concerned in or party to, and aided, abetted, counselled or procured, the contravening conduct of WE.NET referred to in paragraphs 3, 4 and 5 above, being conduct of the kind referred to in section 101(2) of the Telco Act.
Injunctions:
7. An order that WE.NET be restrained:
7.1 pursuant to section 564(1)(a) of the Telco Act, from enforcing any term or condition of an existing contract under which it supplies internet access services to customers, by which it purports to render end-users of those services liable to pay to WE.NET any fee or charge, howsoever described, in respect of any complaints made by the end-user to the TIO about WE.NET’s internet access service;
7.2 pursuant to section 564(1)(a) of the Telco Act, from including in the terms and conditions upon which it offers or supplies internet access services to members of the public or customers, any provision by which it purports to render end-users of those services liable to pay to WE.NET any fee or charge, howsoever described, in respect of any complaints made by the end-user to the TIO about WE.NET’s internet access service.
8. An order that Francis be restrained:
8.1 pursuant to section 564(1)(a) of the Telco Act, from being knowingly concerned in or party to, or aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring, WE.NET enforcing any term or condition of an existing contract under which it supplies internet access services to customers, by which it purports to render end-users of those services liable to pay to WE.NET any fee or charge, howsoever described, in respect of any complaints made by the end-user to the TIO about WE.NET’s internet access service;
8.2 pursuant to section 564(1)(a) of the Telco Act, from being knowingly concerned in or party to, or aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring, a person who supplies internet access services including in the terms and conditions upon which it offers or supplies internet access services to members of the public or customers, any provision by which it purports to render end-users of those services liable to pay to that person any fee or charge, howsoever described, in respect of any complaints made by the end-user to the TIO about the person’s internet access service.
9. An order pursuant to section 564(1)(b) of the Telco Act that WE.NET:
9.1 within 45 days of the date of this order, provide to each customer from whom it received a payment between 4 January 2005 and the date of institution of these proceedings, of a fee or charge, howsoever described, in respect of a complaint made by the customer to the TIO about WE.NET’s internet access service, and to whom it has not already provided a refund of that amount, a refund of the amount of that payment; and
9.2 within 60 days of the date of this order, provide to the applicant a list of the customers to whom the above refunds have been made, and the amounts and dates of the payments.
10. An order pursuant to section 564(1)(b) of the Telco Act that WE.NET:
10.1 if at the date of this order it is operating as an internet access service provider, within 3 months of the date of order; and
10.2 otherwise, if it recommences operation as an internet access service provider at any time between the date of order and 30 September 2010, within 3 months of recommencing such operation;
establish and implement a compliance program with respect to its obligations under the TIO Scheme as an internet access service provider, with particular regard to handling of customer complaints, consistent with the obligations imposed by any applicable Industry Code in relation to customer complaints which is registered under section 117 of the Telco Act as at the date of order;
10.3 maintain and continue to implement the said program for a period of 12 months;
10.4 use its best endeavours to ensure that the program is consistent with the Australian Standard AS3806, tailored to WE.NET’s circumstances.
11. An order pursuant to section 564(1)(b) of the Telco Act that Francis:
11.1 attend, at his own expense, a compliance seminar conducted by a person on the Australian Compliance Institute register of compliance trainers, which relates to the obligations of internet access service providers under the TIO Scheme, with particular regard to handling of customer complaints:
(a) if Francis continues as at the date of order to operate WE.NET or any other business as an internet access service provider, within 6 months of the date of this order; or
(b) if Francis does not operate WE.NET or any other business as an internet service provider as at the date of order, but at any time between the date of order and 30 September 2010 does operate WE.NET or any other business as an internet service provider, within 6 months of recommencing such operation; and
11.2 notify the applicant of his attendance within 7 days of attending the seminar, including the date and place of the seminar and the name of the person who conducted it.
Pecuniary penalties
12. An order that, in respect of each instance of contravening conduct pleaded in the Statement of Claim:
12.1 a single penalty in respect of all contraventions, in the amount of $6,000 be imposed upon the first respondent WE.NET pursuant to section 570 of the Telco Act, such penalty to be paid to the Commonwealth of Australia in accordance with paragraph 12B;
12.2 a single penalty in respect of all contraventions, in the amount of $2,000 be imposed upon the second respondent Francis pursuant to section 570 of the Telco Act, such penalty to be paid to the Commonwealth of Australia in accordance with paragraph 12C.
12B. The penalty of the First Respondent in the amount of $6,000 is to be paid by 17 instalments as follows:
12B.1 an initial payment of $200 on or before 30 March 2009;
12B.2 further payments of $200 on or before each of the following dates: 30 June 2009, 30 September 2009, 30 December 2009, 30 March 2010, 30 June 2010, 30 September 2010, 30 December 2010, 30 March 2011, 30 June 2011;
12B.3 further payments of $600 on or before each of the following dates: 30 September 2011, 30 December 2011, 30 March 2012, 30 June 2012, 30 September 2012, 30 December 2012;
12B.4 a final payment of $400 on or before 30 March 2013;
provided that, if any payment is not paid on or before the due date, the entire balance of the $6,000 remaining unpaid is immediately due and payable.
12C. The penalty of the Second Respondent in the amount of $2,000 is to be paid by 10 instalments as follows:
12C.1 an initial payment of $200 on or before 30 March 2009;
12C.2 further payments of $200 on or before each of the following dates: 30 June 2009, 30 September 2009, 30 December 2009, 30 March 2010, 30 June 2010, 30 September 2010, 30 December 2010, 30 March 2011, 30 June 2011;
provided that if any payment is not paid on or before the due date, the entire balance of the $2,000 remaining unpaid is immediately due and payable.
Other orders
13. An order that each of WE.NET and Francis pay the applicant's costs of and incidental to these proceedings in the agreed amount of $2,000, in accordance with paragraph 13A.
13A. The costs payment referred to in order 13 to be paid by 10 instalments as follows:
13A.1 an initial payment of $200 on or before 30 March 2009;
13A.2 further payments of $200 on or before each of the following dates: 30 June 2009, 30 September 2009, 30 December 2009, 30 March 2010, 30 June 2010, 30 September 2010, 30 December 2010, 30 March 2011, 30 June 2011;
provided that if any payment is not paid on or before the due date, the entire balance of the $2,000 remaining unpaid is immediately due and payable.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: COLLIER J
The orders proposed by the parties are in the following terms:Declarations1.A declaration that the first respondent (“WE.net”) has contravened section 101(1) of the Telecommunications Act 1997 (the Telco Act), by offering to members of the public and supplying to customers its internet access services:1.1.between approximately 4 January 2005 and 3 January 2006, subject to terms and conditions which included provisions to the following effect:1.1.1. that if a customer who had a billing dispute with WE.net in relation to its internet access services did not allow WE.net one calendar month after notification to WE.net by the customer of the dispute, to resolve or process the dispute, before the customer lodged a complaint with any third party, the customer agreed to accept the imposition on the customer by WE.net of an administration fee of $125; and1.1.2. that in the event of an unresolved billing dispute, if the customer referred the matter to the TIO before WE.net could resolve the dispute or refer it to mediation, then WE.net could charge to the customer the greater of “$125 or fees as charged by the TIO to WE.net.au”, in addition to the administration fee described above;1.2.between approximately 4 January 2006 and 14 July 2007, subject to terms and conditions which included provisions to the following effect:1.2.1. that if a customer who had a billing dispute with WE.net in relation to its internet access services did not allow WE.net one calendar month after notification to WE.net by the customer of the dispute, to resolve or process the dispute, before the customer lodged a complaint with any third party, the customer agreed to accept the imposition on the customer by WE.net of an administration fee of $160; and1.2.2. that in the event of an unresolved billing dispute, if the customer referred the matter to any third party including the TIO, then WE.net could charge the customer “an administration fee of $80/hr (min 2 hours) .. only provided that the dispute is not determined in the customers 100% favour”;1.3.between approximately 14 July 2007 and 1 January 2008, subject to terms and conditions which included provisions to the effect that, that if a customer who had a billing dispute with WE.net in relation to WE.net’s internet access services did not allow WE.net one calendar month after notification to WE.net by the customer of the dispute, to resolve or process the dispute, before the customer lodged a complaint with any third party, the customer agreed that other fees may be charged to the customer by WE.net;thereby requiring end-users to pay a fee or charge to WE.net in respect of any complaints made by the end-user to the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman (TIO) about WE.net’s internet access service, by which conduct it failed to comply with a service provider rule, being section 128(4A) of the Telecommunications (Consumer Protection and Service Standards) Act 1999 (the T(CPSS) Act), and thereby failed to comply with the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman Scheme pursuant to section 132 of the T(CPSS) Act.2.A declaration that the second respondent, Francis, was knowingly concerned in or party to, and aided, abetted, counselled or procured, the contravening conduct of WE.net referred to in paragraph 1 above, being conduct of the kind referred to in section 101(2) of the Telco Act.3.A declaration that WE.net has contravened section 101(1) of the Telco Act, in that it failed to comply with:3.1.the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman Scheme pursuant to section 132 of the T(CPSS) Act; and3.2.a service provider rule within the meaning of section 98 and Schedule 2 of the Telco Act; and3.3. clause 6.1 of the TIO Constitution;by failing to comply with a determination of the TIO dated 10 March 2006 that WE.net pay, by a specified date, an amount of $35 in respect of a complaint lodged with the TIO by a customer of WE.net, Ms McDonald.4.A declaration that WE.net has contravened section 101(1) of the Telco Act, in that it failed to comply with:4.1.the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman Scheme pursuant to section 132 of the T(CPSS) Act; and4.2.a service provider rule within the meaning of section 98 and Schedule 2 of the Telco Act; and4.3.clause 6.1 of the TIO Constitution;by failing to comply with a determination of the TIO dated 26 November 2006 that WE.net pay, by a specified date, an amount of $34.95 in respect of a complaint lodged with the TIO by a customer of WE.net, Mr Jameson.5.A declaration that WE.net has contravened section 101(1) of the Telco Act, in that it failed to comply with section 102(4) to the Telco Act, by failing to comply with a written direction of ACMA issued pursuant to section 102(2) of the Telco Act dated 9 July 2007.6.A declaration that the second respondent, Francis, was knowingly concerned in or party to, and aided, abetted, counselled or procured, the contravening conduct of WE.net referred to in paragraphs 3, 4 and 5 above, being conduct of the kind referred to in section 101(2) of the Telco Act.Injunctions:7. An order that WE.net be restrained:7.1.pursuant to section 564(1)(a) of the Telco Act, from enforcing any term or condition of an existing contract under which it supplies internet access services to customers, by which it purports to render end-users of those services liable to pay to WE.net any fee or charge, howsoever described, in respect of any complaints made by the end-user to the TIO about WE.net’s internet access service;7.2.pursuant to section 564(1)(a) of the Telco Act, from including in the terms and conditions upon which it offers or supplies internet access services to members of the public or customers, any provision by which it purports to render end-users of those services liable to pay to WE.net any fee or charge, howsoever described, in respect of any complaints made by the end-user to the TIO about WE.net’s internet access service.8. An order that Francis be restrained:8.1.pursuant to section 564(1)(a) of the Telco Act, from being knowingly concerned in or party to, or aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring, WE.net enforcing any term or condition of an existing contract under which it supplies internet access services to customers, by which it purports to render end-users of those services liable to pay to WE.net any fee or charge, howsoever described, in respect of any complaints made by the end-user to the TIO about WE.net’s internet access service;8.2.pursuant to section 564(1)(a) of the Telco Act, from being knowingly concerned in or party to, or aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring, a person who supplies internet access services including in the terms and conditions upon which it offers or supplies internet access services to members of the public or customers, any provision by which it purports to render end-users of those services liable to pay to that person any fee or charge, howsoever described, in respect of any complaints made by the end-user to the TIO about the person's internet access service.9. An order pursuant to section 564(1)(b) of the Telco Act that WE.net:9.1.within 45 days of the date of this order, provide to each customer from whom it received a payment between 4 January 2005 and the date of institution of these proceedings, of a fee or charge, howsoever described, in respect of a complaint made by the customer to the TIO about WE.net’s internet access service, and to whom it has not already provided a refund of that amount, a refund of the amount of that payment; and9.2.within 60 days of the date of this order, provide to the applicant a list of the customers to whom the above refunds have been made, and the amounts and dates of the payments.10. An order pursuant to section 564(1)(b) of the Telco Act that WE.net:10.1.if at the date of this order it is operating as an internet access service provider, within 3 months of the date of order; and10.2.otherwise, if it recommences operation as an internet access service provider at any time between the date of order and 30 September 2010, within 3 months of recommencing such operation;establish and implement a compliance program with respect to its obligations under the TIO Scheme as an internet access service provider, with particular regard to handling of customer complaints, consistent with the obligations imposed by any applicable Industry Code in relation to customer complaints which is registered under section 117 of the Telco Act as at the date of order;10.3.maintain and continue to implement the said program for a period of 12 months;10.4.use its best endeavours to ensure that the program is consistent with the Australian Standard AS3806, tailored to WE.net’s circumstances.11. An order pursuant to section 564(1)(b) of the Telco Act that Francis:11.1.attend, at his own expense, a compliance seminar conducted by a person on the Australian Compliance Institute register of compliance trainers, which relates to the obligations of internet access service providers under the TIO Scheme, with particular regard to handling of customer complaints:(a)if Francis continues as at the date of order to operate WE.net or any other business as an internet access service provider, within 6 months of the date of this order; or(b)if Francis does not operate WE.Net or any other business as an internet service provider as at the date of order, but at any time between the date of order and 30 September 2010 does operate WE.Net or any other business as an internet service provider, within 6 months of recommencing such operation; and11.2.notify the applicant of his attendance within 7 days of attending the seminar, including the date and place of the seminar and the name of the person who conducted it. Pecuniary penalties12.An order that, in respect of each instance of contravening conduct pleaded in the Statement of Claim:12.1.a single penalty in respect of all contraventions, in the amount of $6,000 be imposed upon the first respondent WE.Net pursuant to section 570 of the Telco Act, such penalty to be paid to the Commonwealth of Australia in accordance with paragraph 12B;12.2.a single penalty in respect of all contraventions, in the amount of $2,000 be imposed upon the second respondent Francis pursuant to section 570 of the Telco Act, such penalty to be paid to the Commonwealth of Australia in accordance with paragraph 12C.12B.The penalty of the First Respondent in the amount of $6,000 is to be paid by 17 instalments as follows:12B.1. an initial payment of $200 on or before 30 March 2009;12B.2.further payments of $200 on or before each of the following dates: 30 June 2009, 30 September 2009, 30 December 2009, 30 March 2010, 30 June 2010, 30 September 2010, 30 December 2010, 30 March 2011, 30 June 2011;12B.3.further payments of $600 on or before each of the following dates: 30 September 2011, 30 December 2011, 30 March 2012, 30 June 2012, 30 September 2012, 30 December 2012;12B.4. a final payment of $400 on or before 30 March 2013;provided that, if any payment is not paid on or before the due date, the entire balance of the $6000 remaining unpaid is immediately due and payable.12C.The penalty of the Second Respondent in the amount of $2,000 is to be paid by 10 instalments as follows:12C.1.an initial payment of $200 on or before 30 March 2009.12C.2.further payments of $200 on or before each of the following dates: 30 June 2009, 30 September 2009, 30 December 2009, 30 March 2010, 30 June 2010, 30 September 2010, 30 December 2010, 30 March 2011, 30 June 2011.provided that if any payment is not paid on or before the due date, the entire balance of the $2,000 remaining unpaid is immediately due and payable. Other orders13.An order that each of WE.net and Francis pay the applicant's costs of and incidental to these proceedings in the agreed amount of $2,000, in accordance with paragraph 13A.13A.The costs payment referred to in order 13 to be paid by 10 instalments as follows:13A.1. an initial payment of $200 on or before 30 March 2009;13A.2.further payments of $200 on or before each of the following dates: 30 June 2009, 30 September 2009, 30 December 2009, 30 March 2010, 30 June 2010, 30 September 2010, 30 December 2010, 30 March 2011, 30 June 2011;provided that if any payment is not paid on or before the due date, the entire balance of the $2,000 remaining unpaid is immediately due and payable.14.And the Court notes the agreement of the parties that orders 12, 12B, 12C, 13 and 13A will be made by the Court but will not be entered and sealed under Federal Court Rules Order 36 unless there is default on the part of the First or Second Respondents.Proposed Orders – the Court’s approach