Australian Capital Territory v SMEC Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Australian Capital Territory v SMEC Australia Pty Ltd

Citation:

[2018] ACTSC 252

Hearing Date:

8 May 2018

DecisionDate:

6 September 2018

Before:

McWilliam AsJ

Decision:

See [83]

Catchwords:

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – PRIVILEGE – parliamentary privilege – whether documents in proceedings prepared by Auditor-General are protected from production by s 16(2) of the Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth)

COSTS – where applications in proceedings for provision of documents resolved by consent – whether plaintiff should pay costs of the applications – whether defendants successful on applications

Legislation Cited:

Auditor-General Act 1996 (ACT) ss 6, 6A, 7, 8, 9A, 9BB, 9BC, 9DA, 10, 17, 19, 20, 24, 35, 37
Australian Capital Territory (Self Government) Act 1988
(Cth) s 24
Bill of Rights 1688
(UK) Art 9
Evidence Act 2011 (ACT) ss 10, 119, 126, 130, 131A
Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth) s 16
Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) r 1721

Cases Cited:

British American Tobacco Australia Ltd v Secretary, Department of Health and Ageing [2011] FCAFC 107; 195 FCR 123
Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333
Carrigan v Cash
[2016] FCA 1466
Carrigan v Honourable Senator Cash (in her capacity as Minister for Employment)[2017] FCAFC 86
Cooper v Singh
[2017] ACTCA 21
Fordyce v Fordham [2006] NSWCA 274; 67 NSWLR 497
Gray v Richards (No 2) [2014] HCA 47; 89 ALJR 113
In the matter of the Board of Inquiry into Disability Services (sub nom Szwarcbord v Gallop) [2002] ACTSC 28; 167 FLR 262
New Cap Reinsurance Corporation Ltd (In Liq) & 1 Or v Renaissance Reinsurance Ltd
[2007] NSWSC 258
Re Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs (Cth); Ex Parte Lai Qin (1997) 186 CLR 622
Re OPEL Networks [2010] NSWSC 142; 77 NSWLR 129
Rowley v O’Chee [2000] 1 Qd R 207
R v Chaytor [2010] UKSC 52; 1 AC 684
Stewart v Ronalds [2009] NSWCA 277; 76 NSWLR 99

Parties:

Australian Capital Territory (Plaintiff)

SMEC Australia Pty Ltd (First Defendant)

C.M. Jewell & Associates Pty Ltd (Second Defendant)

Cardno Young Pty Ltd (Third Defendant)

Representation:

Counsel

Mr C Erskine SC with Mr B Katekar (Plaintiff)

Mr R Cheney SC with Ms J Wright (First Defendant)

Mr D Weinberger with Mr B Kaplan (Second Defendant)

Mr A Ounapuu (Third Defendant)

Solicitors

ACT Government Solicitor (Plaintiff)

Clyde + Co (First Defendant)

Hall & Willcox (Second Defendant)

Maddocks (Third Defendant)

File Number:

SC 342 of 2014

  1. The parties in these proceedings are involved in a dispute over what has been described as the North Weston Pond Project (Project). This was a development that took place over the period 2008 – 2013 of a particular site in the district of Weston Creek, the boundaries of which were the Cotter Road, the Molonglo River, the Tuggeranong Parkway and the suburbs of Coombs, Wright and Weston.

Nature of the substantive dispute

  1. Since 2014, the Australian Capital Territory (Territory) has…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Capital Territory v SMEC Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] ACTSC 252
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Capital Territory (ACT) brought proceedings against SMEC Australia Pty Ltd, seeking the production of documents. The central issue was whether certain documents prepared by the Auditor-General were protected from disclosure by s 16(2) of the Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth). Additionally, the court considered whether the plaintiff should bear the costs of the applications for document production, given that the applications were resolved by consent and the defendants were successful in their submissions.

The court examined the nature and scope of parliamentary privilege, particularly in light of Article 9 of the Bill of Rights 1688 (UK). The court noted that Article 9, which is part of Commonwealth law, aims to ensure that Parliament can conduct its business without interference from the Crown or its judges. In considering the scope of this privilege, the court referenced the decision in R v Chaytor [2010] UKSC 52, which highlighted the importance of maintaining Parliament’s sovereignty. The court concluded that the documents in question were indeed protected by parliamentary privilege, as they were closely and directly connected to the proceedings of the Legislative Assembly.

The court also addressed the issue of costs. Given that the parties had resolved the applications by consent and the defendants were successful in their submissions, the court found that the plaintiff should bear the costs of the applications. The court emphasised that the principle of costs following the event applied, and since the defendants were successful on the applications, the plaintiff was liable for the costs.

The final orders of the court were that the documents prepared by the Auditor-General were protected by parliamentary privilege, and the plaintiff was to bear the costs of the applications as determined by the court.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [83]

Background

Background to the litigation

In the case of Australian Capital Territory v SMEC Australia Pty Ltd, the primary issue revolves around the scope of parliamentary privilege under s 16(2) of the Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth) and whether it extends to documents prepared by the Auditor-General in the context of proceedings before the court. The Australian Capital Territory (the Territory) commenced proceedings against SMEC Australia Pty Ltd (SMEC), and during the course of the litigation, SMEC sought the production of certain documents prepared by the Auditor-General. SMEC argued that these documents were protected by parliamentary privilege, while the Territory contended that the privilege did not extend to these documents.

The background to the dispute begins with the Australian Capital Territory's self-governance, established under the Australian Capital Territory (Self-Government) Act 1988 (Cth). The Territory's Legislative Assembly, as its legislature, holds certain powers, privileges, and immunities. The crux of the case is the interpretation of s 16 of the Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth), which is designed to incorporate Article 9 of the Bill of Rights 1688 (UK) into Commonwealth law, ensuring that the Parliament can conduct its business without interference. The functions of the Auditor-General, as outlined in the Auditor-General Act 2004 (ACT), include preparing reports for the Legislative Assembly that provide independent evaluations on the management of public sector activities and resources.

The dispute arose as the Territory sought the production of documents prepared by the Auditor-General for use in the proceedings against SMEC. SMEC argued that these documents were privileged and should not be produced, invoking the protection under s 16(2) of the Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth). The Territory, however, maintained that the privilege did not extend to the documents in question, as they were not closely and directly connected with the Legislative Assembly's proceedings. The case thus requires a determination of the extent to which parliamentary privilege applies to documents prepared by the Auditor-General and whether these documents fall within the privileged scope as defined by the courts.

This case, Australian Capital Territory v SMEC Australia Pty Ltd, originated as an application before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory. The matter concerns the scope of parliamentary privilege under s 16(2) of the Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth) and whether documents prepared by the Auditor-General for the Legislative Assembly are protected from production. The matter came before the court following an application by the Auditor-General for a declaration that certain documents were privileged and hence exempt from production in proceedings. The defendants, SMEC Australia Pty Ltd, opposed the application on the basis that the documents were not privileged. The application was resolved by consent with respect to the provision of certain documents, leaving the question of privilege unresolved for the final hearing. Throughout the proceedings, both parties engaged in detailed submissions and arguments concerning the nature and scope of parliamentary privilege and the relevance of extrinsic materials such as the Explanatory Memorandum to the Auditor-General Bill 1996 (ACT). In addition to the privilege issue, the court considered the costs implications of the consent orders resolving the document provision applications.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Unlike the privilege associated with public interest immunity, the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT) (Evidence Act) has no role to play on the question of parliamentary privilege, as s 10(1) of that statute expressly states:This Act does not affect the law relating to the privileges of any Australian Parliament or any House of any Australian Parliament. The Territory became self-governing in 1989 through the Australian Capital Territory (Self Government) Act 1988 (Cth) (Self Government Act). Part III of the Self Government Act establishes the Legislative Assembly as the legislature of the Territory. Part IV deals with the powers of the Legislative Assembly and, within it, s 24 of the Self Government Act provides for the power, privileges and immunities of the Legislative Assembly in the following terms: It is not disputed by the parties that the Legislative Assembly has not, thus far, legislated to make a law “with respect to its powers.” Attention therefore turns to the Commonwealth and the powers held by the House of Representatives and its members and committees. As s 16 of the Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth) (Act) is at the heart of the dispute between the parties, it is set out in full, in the following terms: As submitted by the Territory, the mischief to which the above provision is addressed is clearly expressed in the text of s 16(1). It seeks to remove any doubt that Article 9 of the Bill of Rights 1688 (UK) (Article 9) is part of Commonwealth law. Article 9 is in the following terms: The object and construction of Article 9 is considered below. The functions of the Auditor-General are set out in s 10 of the AG Act: Other relevant features and functions of the position include the following: The Territory has drawn attention to extrinsic materials to assist with an understanding of the Auditor-General’s function. Page 1 of the Explanatory Memorandum to the Auditor-General Bill 1996 (ACT), which became the AG Act, explains that the purpose of the legislation is to “ensure that financial reports and performance information provided to the Legislative Assembly are reliable and complete” and to provide reports to the Legislative Assembly “which contain independent evaluation of the legality, efficiency and effectiveness with which public sector activities and resources are managed.” Those explanatory words do broadly reflect the scheme of the legislation as a whole. Section 37 of the AG Act is also relevant to the arguments of the parties. It provides: It is important to first consider Article 9, which underlies the privilege. In R v Chaytor [2010] UKSC 52; 1 AC 684 (Chaytor), Lord Phillips PSC stated at [47]: His Lordship went on to state at [61] that that there are good reasons of policy to give Article 9 a narrow ambit, restricting it to the purpose for which it was enacted – for the Parliament to conduct its business without interference from the Crown or the Crown’s judges. At [73], his Lordship cited an extract from the Joint Committee on Parliamentary Privilege Report of 1999 (HL Paper 43–1, HC 214–1) to the effect that the nearest definition (of the dividing line between privileged and non-privileged activities) is that the areas in which courts ought not intervene extended beyond proceedings in Parliament, but the privileged areas must be so closely and directly connected with proceedings in Parliament that the intervention would be inconsistent with Parliament’s sovereignty as a legislative and deliberative assembly.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does s 16(2) of the Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth) protect documents prepared by the Auditor-General from production in proceedings, given the purpose of parliamentary privilege under Article 9 of the Bill of Rights 1688 (UK)?

2. Should the plaintiff pay the costs of applications for the provision of documents where those applications are resolved by consent?

3. Were the defendants successful on the applications for the provision of documents, thereby potentially warranting an award of costs against the plaintiff?

Held
1. The court concluded that s 16(2) of the Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth) does not protect documents prepared by the Auditor-General from production in proceedings, given the purpose of parliamentary privilege under Article 9 of the Bill of Rights 1688 (UK). The result was that the Auditor-General's documents were not protected from production.

2. The court concluded that the plaintiff should not pay the costs of applications for the provision of documents where those applications are resolved by consent. The result was that the plaintiff was not ordered to pay the costs of the resolved applications.

3. The court concluded that the defendants were not successful on the applications for the provision of documents, thereby not warranting an award of costs against the plaintiff. The result was that no costs were awarded against the plaintiff.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Australian Capital Territory v SMEC Australia Pty Ltd involves several significant issues regarding parliamentary privilege, costs, and the provision of documents in legal proceedings. The court's reasoning on these matters is detailed and well-founded, establishing clear precedents for future cases.

Firstly, the court addressed whether s 16(2) of the Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth) protected documents prepared by the Auditor-General from production in the proceedings. The court examined Article 9 of the Bill of Rights 1688 (UK), which underpins parliamentary privilege. It referenced the decision in R v Chaytor [2010] UKSC 52, where Lord Phillips PSC explained that Article 9 should be given a narrow ambit to ensure that Parliament can conduct its business without interference. The court found that the Auditor-General's role in providing independent evaluation to the Legislative Assembly was closely connected with parliamentary proceedings, aligning with the purpose of Article 9. Consequently, the court held that s 16(2) of the Act protected these documents from production, establishing that parliamentary privilege extends to documents prepared by the Auditor-General for the Legislative Assembly.

Secondly, the court deliberated on whether the plaintiff should bear the costs of applications for the provision of documents when those applications were resolved by consent. The court considered the principle of costs in legal proceedings, emphasizing that costs are typically borne by the party who is unsuccessful in their application. However, the court noted that when applications are resolved by consent, it may be unjust to allocate costs to one party, as both parties may have contributed to the resolution. The court found that in this instance, the plaintiff should not be required to pay the costs of the applications as they were resolved by mutual agreement, thus ensuring fairness in the proceedings.

Lastly, the court examined whether the defendants were successful on their applications for the provision of documents, which could potentially warrant an award of costs against the plaintiff. The court held that the defendants were not successful on their applications, as the documents in question were protected by parliamentary privilege. Consequently, the defendants were not entitled to an award of costs against the plaintiff. The court's decision underscored the importance of correctly identifying the scope of parliamentary privilege to determine the success of an application and the appropriate allocation of costs.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that s 16(2) of the Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth) protects documents prepared by the Auditor-General from production in legal proceedings, given the purpose of parliamentary privilege under Article 9 of the Bill of Rights 1688 (UK). Additionally, when applications for the provision of documents are resolved by consent, the unsuccessful party should not be required to pay the costs of those applications. Finally, if the defendants are not successful on their applications for the provision of documents, they are not entitled to an award of costs against the plaintiff. The court's decisions on these issues provide clear guidance on the application of parliamentary privilege and the allocation of costs in legal proceedings.