Austal Ships Pty Ltd (ACN 079 160 679) v Thurlow

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Austal Ships Pty Ltd (ACN 079 160 679) v Thurlow [2006] FCA 1219

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – preliminary discovery - to ascertain prospective respondents – to ascertain whether right to obtain relief – confidential internal research report – procured by employee of competitor – published to third parties to disparage applicant’s product – former employee of applicant now working for competitor – criteria for preliminary discovery satisfied – orders made  

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

East Grace Corporation v Xing (No 2) [2005] FCA 1266 cited

AUSTAL SHIPS PTY LTD (ACN 079 160 679) v STEVE THURLOW
WAD 162 OF 2006

AUSTAL SHIPS PTY LTD (ACN 079 160 679) v JUSTIN PATRICK MERRIGAN
WAD 163 OF 2006

AUSTAL SHIPS PTY LTD (ACN 079 160 679) v INCAT AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 051 556 855), INCAT MARKETING PTY LTD (ACN 084 060 408), INCAT CHARTERING PTY LTD (ACN 059 233 046), INCAT FINANCE PTY LTD (ACN 056 869 946), INCAT OFFSHORE PTY LTD (ACN 071 054 058), INCAT TASMANIA PTY LTD (ACN 054 616 410), INCAT INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 009 570 325), RF CLIFFORD PTY LTD (ACN 009 539 642) and INTER CATS (TASMANIA) PTY LTD (ACN 009 539 642)
WAD 165 OF 2006

FRENCH J
7 SEPTEMBER 2006
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 162 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

AUSTAL SHIPS PTY LTD (ACN 079 160 679)
Applicant

AND:

STEVE THURLOW
Respondent

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

7 SEPTEMBER 2006

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to Order 15A Rules 3 and 6 the respondent, by 6 October 2006, shall make discovery, verified on oath, of any documents which are in his possession, custody or control in the following categories:

any document which came into existence between 1 June 2005 and 16 June 2006 (the Relevant Period) recording or evidencing any communication, whether oral or written, between the respondent and any third party, including Mr Justin Patrick Merrigan and the respondents in action number WAD165 of 2006 (the Incat Group), which contain a reference, directly or indirectly to:

(a)the Thurlow email, a copy of which is exhibited to the affidavit of Christopher Scott Gerrard sworn on 16 June 2006;

(b)the Austal Report, a copy of which is exhibited to the said affidavit of Christopher Scott Gerrard.

2.There is liberty to the applicant to apply on or before 20 October 2006 for an order for the examination of the respondent under Order 15A Rule 3(2)(a).

3.Liberty to apply in relation to the implementation of Order 1.

4.The applicant is to pay the costs of the respondent unless, on or before 18 November 2006, or such other date as may be directed, the applicant commences substantive proceedings substantially as described in the letter from Stables Scott to the respondent dated 12 June 2006 seeking pre-action discovery.  In the event that such action is commenced, the costs of this application will be costs in that action.

Note:   Settlement and entry…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Austal Ships Pty Ltd (ACN 079 160 679) v Thurlow and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 1219
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Austal Ships Pty Ltd (ACN 079 160 679) v Thurlow, the Federal Court was presented with an application for pre-action discovery orders. Austal, a prominent Australian shipbuilding company, sought to obtain specific documents from the respondents, which they believed contained evidence relevant to potential causes of action against them, including breach of confidence and copyright infringement. The application was prompted by concerns that the respondents might possess documents related to confidential information about Austal's projects and intellectual property.

The court had to determine whether the orders sought by Austal were justified and proportionate under the circumstances. The primary legal issue was whether Austal had made reasonable inquiries as required by the rules before seeking the discovery orders and whether the scope of the orders was appropriate given the nature of the information sought. The court was also required to consider whether the orders were necessary to prevent injustice or to facilitate a fair resolution of the potential litigation.

In rendering its decision, the court acknowledged that Austal had conducted reasonable inquiries and that there was a likelihood that the respondents possessed documents that could assist in determining the existence of a cause of action. However, the court found that the scope of the orders sought by Austal was overly broad and not strictly necessary. Consequently, the court modified the orders to be more narrowly tailored to the specific information that Austal needed. The court emphasized the importance of proportionality and reasonableness in such applications, ensuring that the orders did not impose undue burdens on the respondents.

The court's final orders required the respondents to discover specific documents within a defined period, with provisions for further examination and costs allocation. The court also stipulated that if Austal initiated substantive proceedings, the costs of the application would become costs in the substantive action. This decision underscores the need for precision and justification in applications for pre-action discovery, balancing the interests of both parties involved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to Order 15A Rules 3 and 6 the respondent, by 6 October 2006, shall make discovery, verified on oath, of any documents which are in his possession, custody or control in the following categories:

any document which came into existence between 1 June 2005 and 16 June 2006 (the Relevant Period) recording or evidencing any communication, whether oral or written, between the respondent and any third party, including Mr Justin Patrick Merrigan and the respondents in action number WAD165 of 2006 (the Incat Group), which contain a reference, directly or indirectly to:

(a) the Thurlow email, a copy of which is exhibited to the affidavit of Christopher Scott Gerrard sworn on 16 June 2006;

(b) the Austal Report, a copy of which is exhibited to the said affidavit of Christopher Scott Gerrard.

2. There is liberty to the applicant to apply on or before 20 October 2006 for an order for the examination of the respondent under Order 15A Rule 3(2)(a).

3. Liberty to apply in relation to the implementation of Order 1.

4. The applicant is to pay the costs of the respondent unless, on or before 18 November 2006, or such other date as may be directed, the applicant commences substantive proceedings substantially as described in the letter from Stables Scott to the respondent dated 12 June 2006 seeking pre-action discovery. In the event that such action is commenced, the costs of this application will be costs in that action.

1. Pursuant to Order 15A Rules 3 and 6 the respondent, by 6 October 2006, shall make discovery, verified on oath, of any documents which are in his possession, custody or control in the following categories:

any document which came into existence between 1 June 2005 and 16 June 2006 (the Relevant Period) recording or evidencing any communication, whether oral or written, between the respondent and any third party, including Mr Steve Thurlow and the respondents in action number WAD165 of 2006 (the Incat Group), which contain a reference, directly or indirectly, to:

(a) the Thurlow email, a copy of which is exhibited to the affidavit of Christopher Scott Gerrard sworn on 16 June 2006;

(b) the Austal Report, a copy of which is exhibited to the said affidavit of Christopher Scott Gerrard.

2. There is liberty to the applicant to apply on or before 20 October 2006 for an order for the examination of the respondent under Order 15A Rule 3(2)(a).

3. Liberty to apply in relation to the implementation of Order 1.

4. The applicant is to pay the costs of the respondent unless, on or before 18 November 2006, or such other date as may be directed, the applicant commences substantive proceedings substantially as described in the letter from Stables Scott to the respondent dated 12 June 2006 seeking pre-action discovery. In the event that such action is commenced, the costs of this application will be costs in that action.

1. Pursuant to Order 15A Rules 3 and 6 each of the respondents, by 6 October 2006, shall make discovery, verified on oath by an appropriate member or officer of each of the respondents, of all documents which are in its possession, custody or control in the following categories:

any document which came into existence between 1 June 2005 and 16 June 2006 (the Relevant Period) recording or evidencing any communication, whether oral or written, between any of the respondents and any third party, including Steve Thurlow and Justin Patrick Merrigan, which contain a reference, directly or indirectly, to:

(a) the Thurlow email, a copy of which is exhibited to the affidavit of Christopher Scott Gerrard sworn on 16 June 2006;

(b) the Austal Report, a copy of which is exhibited to the said affidavit of Christopher Scott Gerrard.

2. There is liberty to the applicant to apply on or before 20 October 2006 for an order for the examination of any person under Order 15A Rule 3(2)(a).

3. Liberty to apply in relation to the implementation of Order 1.

4. The applicant is to pay the costs of each respondent unless, on or before 18 November 2006, or such other date as may be directed, the applicant commences substantive proceedings, substantially as described in the letters from Stables Scott to each of the respondents dated 12 June 2006 seeking pre-action discovery. In the event that such action is commenced, the costs of this application will be costs in that action.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, I am satisfied that there is reason to believe that some or all of the respondents have, or are likely to have, possession of documents which would tend to assist Austal in determining against whom it has a cause or causes of action, at least for breach of confidence and infringement of copyright. I am satisfied also that Austal, having written to the respondents seeking discovery of the documents, before commencing action, has, in the circumstances, made all reasonable enquiries, for the purposes of the Rules so as to justify the making of orders for preliminary discovery. The orders sought by Austal however range far wider than is appropriate and while I propose to accede to their application, the orders made will be considerably narrower in scope than those which have been sought. Factual and procedural background Austal was incorporated and commenced business in 1988. It is a leading designer and manufacturer of high performance aluminium vessels. It is a wholly owned subsidiary of Austal Ltd, which was listed on the Australian Stock Exchange in 1998 and which has a current market capitalisation of about $450 million. Austal manufactures a range of light weight, high speed vessels including monohulls, catamarans and trimarans which range in size from 20 to 130 metres for commercial, military and naval applications. It employs 1,700 people at its shipbuilding facilities located on the waterfront at Henderson, immediately south of Fremantle in Western Australia and at Mobile in Alabama in the United States. Since it was formed Austal has designed and secured orders for manufacture and delivery of about 160 vessels including fast passenger and vehicle-passenger ferries. In June 2003 Austal entered into a contract for the design and construction of a 126 metre trimaran vehicle-passenger ferry for a European ferry operator, Fred Olsen SA. At that time the high speed vehicle-passenger ferry market had been dominated by catamarans. The use of trimarans was a relatively new concept in that market. In September 2003 Austal’s Research and Development Department prepared an internal report dated 25 September 2003 entitled ‘Analysis of the Ship Motion Performance of an Austal 101m Catamaran and a Comparison with a 126m Trimaran in the Irish Sea’ (the Austal Report). The analysis was carried out by a process of mathematical modelling based on wave data for a ferry route from Dublin to Douglas in the Isle of Man and then to Liverpool and return. Wave height statistics for these routes were derived from data collected by service ships during the period from 1854 to 1997 and found in the Global Marine Climatic Atlas (GMCA). For the purpose of analysing the ship’s motion performance a wave scatter diagram for the whole of the year was utilised as illustrated in tables set out in the report and said to represent a through-year surface. Wave direction statistics were also obtained from the GMCA. Three motion criteria were assumed as indicative of the comfort level of passengers travelling on these routes. They were: 1.Motion sickness indices (MSI) – a measure of the level of motion sickness resulting from vertical acceleration over a range of frequencies in accordance with an established methodology. The values were calculated for a position at the centre of the ship’s main passenger cabin over a two hour period. 2.Lateral force estimator (LFE), being a measure of the force in plane with the deck that is an indicator of the force creating a loss of balance of a standing person. This was said to be a function of the vessel’s roll, sway and yaw and was calculated at the centre of the main passenger deck. 3.Roll, which was the estimated rms value of ship roll.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J
Issues
1. Whether the orders for preliminary discovery should be made and, if so, in what scope.
2. Whether the applicant is to pay the costs of the respondent unless the applicant commences substantive proceedings seeking pre-action discovery.

Held
1. The court granted the orders for preliminary discovery but in a considerably narrower scope than sought by the applicant. The respondent was required to make discovery of documents in their possession, custody, or control that recorded or evidenced any communication between them and any third party, including Steve Thurlow and Justin Patrick Merrigan, which referenced the Thurlow email or the Austal Report during the Relevant Period.
2. The applicant was required to pay the respondent's costs unless the applicant commenced substantive proceedings seeking pre-action discovery by a specified date. If such action was commenced, the costs of the current application would become costs in the substantive action.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J

The court examined the circumstances under which preliminary discovery orders could be granted and the extent to which the orders should be limited. The court considered that there was a reasonable belief that the respondents possessed documents relevant to the applicant's potential causes of action for breach of confidence and infringement of copyright. The court was satisfied that the applicant had made all reasonable enquiries as required by the Rules. However, the court found that the scope of the orders sought by the applicant was excessively broad and decided to narrow the scope of the discovery orders. The court reasoned that while the applicant had made out a prima facie case for preliminary discovery, the orders should be tailored to the specific needs of the case, ensuring they were not overly burdensome on the respondents. The court also noted the importance of balancing the applicant's need for information against the respondents' right to protect their documents from unwarranted disclosure. Regarding the costs, the court ruled that the applicant should bear the respondent's costs unless substantive proceedings were initiated by the specified date, ensuring that the applicant did not unduly delay the resolution of the underlying dispute. The court's decision established that while preliminary discovery orders can be granted under specific circumstances, their scope should be carefully limited to prevent unnecessary intrusion into the respondents' affairs. This case reaffirms the principle that preliminary discovery should be proportionate and necessary to facilitate the resolution of the substantive issues in the case.