August v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

August v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 682

Citation: August v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 682
Parties:

PETER AUGUST v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION

HELEN AUGUST v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION

File numbers: NSD 420 of 2010
NSD 422 of 2010
Judge: NICHOLAS J
Date of judgment: 28 June 2012
Corrigendum: 3 July 2012
Catchwords:

TAXATION – appeals against Commissioner’s disallowance of objections to income tax assessments – sale of commercial real estate – whether profit derived from sale of properties was income according to ordinary concepts – whether properties acquired for purpose of profit-making by sale

Held: Properties acquired for purpose of profit-making by sale – appeals dismissed 

Legislation: Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) s 95, s 97
Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) s 6-5, s 6-10, s 102-5(1), s 115-25, 115-100, Div 115, Subdiv 115-C   
Cases cited:

Californian Copper Syndicate v Harris (1905) 5 TC 159
Commissioner of Taxation v Cooling (1990) 22 FCR 42
Fabre v Arenales (1992) 27 NSWLR 437
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298
McCormack v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1979) 143 CLR 284

Moana Sand Pty Limited v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1988) 88 ATC 4897

Westfield Limited v Commissioner of Taxation (1991) 28 FCR 333

Date of hearing: 20, 21, 22 and 23 June 2011
Date of last submissions: 1 July 2011
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 175
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr D Russell QC with Mr M Robertson
Solicitor for the Applicant: Meyer Vandenberg Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms J Needham SC with Mr J D Smith
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

August v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 682

CORRIGENDUM

1.In paragraph 1 of the reasons for judgment dated 28 June 2012 substitute “financial years ending 30 June 2006 and 30 June 2007” for “financial year ending 30 June 2006”.

I certify that the preceding one (1) numbered paragraph is a true copy of the Corrigendum to the Reasons for Judgment herein of the Honourable Justice Nicholas.

Associate:

Dated: 3 July 2012


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 420 of 2010

BETWEEN:

PETER AUGUST
Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
Respondent

JUDGE:

NICHOLAS J

DATE OF ORDER:

28 JUNE 2012

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the respondent’s costs (not including those dealt with by orders made on 17 February 2011 and 7 April 2011).

THE COURT DIRECTS THAT:

3.Subject to any appeal, the original exhibits be returned to the party by whom they were tendered after 28 days.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 422 of 2010

BETWEEN:

HELEN AUGUST
Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
Respondent

JUDGE:

NICHOLAS J

DATE OF ORDER:

28 JUNE 2012

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read August v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 682
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of August v Commissioner of Taxation, the applicants, Mr and Mrs August, sought to challenge the Commissioner of Taxation’s disallowance of their objections to income tax assessments. The primary dispute centred around the characterisation of profits derived from the sale of commercial real estate properties as income under ordinary concepts. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the properties were acquired for the purpose of profit-making by sale.

The legal issues before the court were twofold: first, whether the properties were acquired with the principal intention of engaging in a scheme of profit-making by sale, and second, if the purpose of profit-making by sale was a substantial one, thereby characterising the profits as income. The applicants argued that their sole intention was to hold the properties as long-term investments, while the Commissioner contended that the properties were part of a profit-making scheme.

The court examined the surrounding circumstances and the evidence provided by Mr August, including his statements about the properties being a risky investment and his intention to hold them until his death. However, the court found that Mr August's actions, such as discussions with Mr Konstantinou about potential joint ventures and the eventual sale of the properties, indicated a different purpose. The court concluded that the properties were likely acquired as part of a profit-making scheme with the intention to develop, tenant, and sell them for a profit.

The court dismissed the appeal and ordered that the applicants pay the respondent's costs, excluding those already addressed in previous orders. The court also directed that the original exhibits be returned to the parties after 28 days, subject to any appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs (not including those dealt with by orders made on 17 February 2011 and 7 April 2011).

THE COURT DIRECTS THAT:

3. Subject to any appeal, the original exhibits be returned to the party by whom they were tendered after 28 days.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011

Background

Background to the litigation

In the present case it is accepted by Mr and Mrs August that the relevant profits will constitute income according to ordinary concepts if the properties were acquired for the purpose of profit-making by sale. In this regard, it is now settled that the purpose of profit-making by sale need not be the sole or dominant purpose: Commissioner of Taxation v Cooling (1990) 22 FCR 42 per Hill J (with whom Lockhart and Gummow JJ agreed) at 56-57, and Moana Sand Pty Limited v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1988) 88 ATC 4897 at 4,902-4,904. It is enough, at least in the case of a commercial or business dealing, that the purpose is a substantial (or a not insubstantial) one. GENERAL BACKGROUND For some years prior to 1994, Mr August carried on business as a trader of coins, bank notes and other collectables. After 1994, a company known as Universal Coin Company Pty Ltd (Universal Coin) carried on that business. At all relevant times Mr August and his wife were the sole directors and shareholders of Universal Coin. In 1995 Mr and Mrs August established various other companies and trusts. In that year they formed Toorak. They are the sole directors and shareholders of Toorak. In the same year they established the Toorak Management Unit Trust (Toorak Unit Trust). Each of them holds 50% of the issued units in the Toorak Unit Trust. Toorak is the sole trustee of the Toorak Unit Trust. In 1995 another unit trust, the Wiz Unit Trust (Wiz Unit Trust), was established. All of the issued units in the Wiz Unit Trust are held by Mr August. Toorak is also the sole trustee of the Wiz Unit Trust. In 1997, Mr and Mrs August sold their principal residence in Windsor, Melbourne. The proceeds of the sale of their house included an amount of $200,000 which they decided to invest. Later that year, Mr August went to Canberra where he spoke with Mr Spiros (Jeff) Konstantinou (Mr Konstantinou) about investing in the Canberra property market. Mr Konstantinou and his wife, who lived in Canberra, were originally friends of Mrs August’s parents who also lived there. Mr August met Mr Konstantinou in 1990 at a party to celebrate Mr and Mrs August’s engagement. In 1996 Mrs August approached Mrs Konstantinou and asked her to be godmother to Mr and Mrs August’s eldest child. Mrs Konstantinou suggested that her eldest son, Harry Konstantinou, be godfather. From that time on the relationship between the two families was particularly close. For many years Mr Konstantinou worked as a property developer in Canberra. At some stage Harry Konstantinou became involved in Mr Konstantinou’s business. It is apparent that by 1997, Mr Konstantinou was a very experienced property developer, who was well connected with others involved in the Canberra real estate market. It is also apparent that Mr Konstantinou’s business (or, more accurately, those of the various corporate entities he controlled) included buying and developing commercial real estate that would then be sold, preferably on a fully tenanted basis. The evidence indicates Mr Konstantinou completed many such projects, and that he was extremely astute at identifying commercial sites suitable for these types of developments. It is not surprising, therefore, that Mr August turned to Mr Konstantinou for advice on investment opportunities in Canberra.THE MELBA SHOPSPurchase and development

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There are no contemporaneous documents that evidence Mr August’s purposes or intentions when acquiring the Melba shops. Whether or not they were acquired for the purpose or with the intention of engaging in a scheme of profit-making by sale must be determined by reference to all the surrounding circumstances as well as the evidence of Mr August as to his own purposes and intentions.Mr August’s evidence of his purposes and intentions In his affidavit Mr August stated that his sole intention when he acquired blocks 2 and 12 was to find tenants for the shops and hold them as long term investments. He said that at the time those blocks were acquired, he had no intention of selling them. This evidence, and other evidence given by him concerning his intentions, was the subject of extensive cross-examination. In cross-examination Mr August gave evidence that at the time he purchased the Melba shops the possibility of selling them was never in his mind. He said that such a sale “wasn’t even a remote possibility”. Mr August said that in acquiring blocks 2 and 12, he acted on Mr Konstantinou’s recommendation that they were “cheap”. He went on to describe the Melba shops as something he wanted to own forever, and an investment which he wanted to hold until he died. At one point in his cross-examination, Mr August described his purchase of blocks 2 and 12 as “a risky investment” though he also said that there were circumstances that “made it seem less risky”. One of these, I infer, was the possibility of acquiring additional blocks which would accommodate additional tenants. It is likely that Mr Konstantinou was alive to the possibility of enlarging the initial holding over time, not only through the purchase of block 26 (as occurred in 1998) but also by acquiring additional land to build on through the elimination of some car parking spaces (as occurred in 1999). There is no reason why Mr Konstantinou would not have conveyed his thinking in relation to these possibilities to Mr August at the time blocks 2 and 12 were being acquired and it is likely that he would have done so. When it was put to Mr August that he was aware that his initial investment was a “risky investment” Mr August said that “this is where the extra two blocks which we lobbied the government to put onto the market would actually make it a safer investment by having six tenants as opposed to four tenants”. This lobbying (which I infer took place in 1998 or, at the latest, early 1999) had the desired result. By February 1999 the Office of Asset Management had decided to release the land and, by mid 1999, blocks 30 and 31 were controlled by Toorak. The Commissioner submitted that it was significant that in 2004 – the year in which the land and title consolidation, and the renovation, construction and leasing of all six shops had been completed – Mr August began discussing with Mr Hanley the possibility of selling the Melba shops. Since it was Mr August’s evidence that he had no intention of selling the Melba shops in 2004 (or at any prior time), his dealings with the real estate agent, Mr Hanley, beginning in that year, are of considerable importance.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Konstantinou’s own description of his development activities was slightly different to that given by Mr August. Mr Konstantinou said that the properties he purchased were developed so that they might be either sold or leased. As Mr Konstantinou explained, if he got a good price for a property he purchased and developed, he would sell it, but if he did not get a good price he would keep it. Based upon Mr Konstantinou’s evidence, I am satisfied that most of the properties that had been developed by him or his related entities were commercial or industrial properties that he developed, leased and then sold. This is the approach to investment in the Canberra commercial real estate market that I consider Mr August was seeking to emulate when he purchased blocks 2 and 12 in November 1997. Conclusion in relation to the Melba shops I am not satisfied that the Melba shops were acquired as long term investments. Rather, I think it more likely than not that they were acquired by Toorak as part of a profit-making scheme with the principal intention that they be developed, tenanted and sold for a profit. THE HUME PROPERTYThe Purchase of Block 55 Section 6 Mitchell In 2001 Dimensional Developments was formed for the purpose of acting as the manager of a joint venture which, according to a deed dated 6 August 2001, was established by Konstantinou Developments Pty Limited (Konstantinou Developments) as trustee for the S&F Konstantinou Family Trust and Toorak. At all relevant times Mr August and Mr Konstantinou and his sons were the directors and shareholders of Dimensional Developments. Mr August gave evidence that in or around June 2001 he was aware that what he considered to be the best commercial property available in Mitchell in the ACT – Block 55 Section 6 Mitchell – (Block 55 Mitchell) was scheduled to go to auction. He said that the day before the auction he had a conversation with Mr Konstantinou and Harry Konstantinou which, according to his affidavit, was to this effect:[Mr August]: Jeff, I expect that you will be bidding on the Mitchell block of land tomorrow?Jeff:No. I am keeping my powder dry because I am tendering for a big project in Belconnen. I think I am the front runner. [Mr August]: Well, the Mitchell property would be a high quality investment for when you wind down. Would you be interested in it on that basis if I paid for the land and you did the building for investment? That is, we would go halves and I would provide the initial purchase price. We could then think about do [sic] the same thing with future properties later on.Jeff:I will get Harry on speaker to see what he thinks. Harry, Peter proposes a joint venture over the Mitchell block with us [on the above basis]. What do you think?Harry: That is a good idea. I agree.Jeff: I agree. Mr Konstantinou gave an account of a conversation he had with Mr August in 2001 concerning the Block 55 Mitchell property. According to his affidavit, a conversation to the following effect occurred:[Mr Konstantinou]: Peter, a block at the most prominent corner in Mitchell is coming up for auction in a few weeks. I would like to buy it but I have three blocks that I must develop under the Crown leases so cannot afford it at the moment.Peter:How about if I put up the money to buy the block and you can develop it. We can then lease it. We can go 50/50.[Mr Konstantinou]: This is a good idea. I will discuss it with the kids to see what they think.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's reasoning was based on the established legal principles that the purpose of profit-making by sale need not be the sole or dominant purpose, but rather a substantial one. The court relied on authorities such as Commissioner of Taxation v Cooling and Moana Sand Pty Limited v Federal Commissioner of Taxation to support this principle. In applying these principles to the facts, the court examined the surrounding circumstances and evidence provided by Mr August and Mr Konstantinou to determine the intention behind the acquisition of the properties. The court concluded that the properties were acquired for the purpose of profit-making by sale, as evidenced by the development, leasing, and eventual sale of the properties. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the purpose of profit-making by sale need not be the sole or dominant purpose, but rather a substantial one. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by considering the specific circumstances and intentions behind the acquisition of the properties, rather than solely relying on contemporaneous documents or explicit statements of intention.