Attorney-General for the State of Queensland v Guy

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Attorney-General for the State of Queensland v Guy [2025] QSC 196

PARTIES:

ATTORNEY-GENERAL FOR THE STATE OF QUEENSLAND

(applicant)

v
EDWIN ARTHUR GUY

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS 11336/16

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

20 August 2025

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

18 August 2025

JUDGE:

Treston J

ORDER:

1. Pursuant to s 30(1) of the DPSO Act, the decision made on 27 March 2017 that the respondent is a serious danger to the community in the absence of an order pursuant to Division 3 of the DPSO Act, be affirmed.

2. Pursuant to s 30(3)(a) of the DPSO Act, the respondent continue to be subject to the continuing detention order made on 27 March 2017.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – SENTENCE – SENTENCING ORDERS – ORDERS AND DECLARATIONS RELATING TO SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDERS OR DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDERS – DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDER – GENERALLY – where the respondent has been subject to a continuing detention order under the Dangerous Prisoners (Sexual Offenders) Act 2003 (DPSO Act) since 2017 – where the Attorney-General applied for a review of the respondent’s continuing detention order under s 27(2) of the DPSO Act – where the respondent’s continuing detention order was subsequently reviewed in 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022 and 2024 – where, on each of those reviews, the court ordered that the respondent continue to be subject to the continuing detention order – where the basis for the respondent’s continuing detention is that due to his age and high care needs, no accommodation is available where he could receive the care and support he requires in a setting that limits his access to potential victims and in which he could otherwise be reasonably and practically managed under a supervision order – where psychiatric evidence considered the respondent’s risk of recidivism to be moderate or below and that that risk could be reduced by a supervision order which, inter alia, allowed him to reside at suitable accommodation and limited his access to potential victims – where the only form of accommodation available to the respondent if he were to be released is not suitable for the respondent’s care needs – where neither Queensland Corrective Services nor the respondent had been able to identify suitable accommodation for the respondent where his risk could be reasonably and practically managed if he were to be released – whether, in those circumstances, the respondent should continue to be subject to a continuing detention order

Dangerous Prisoners (Sexual Offenders) Act 2003 (Qld), s 27, s 30

Attorney-General (Qld) v Francis [2007] 1 Qd R 396
Attorney-General (Qld) v Guy [2017] QSC 105
Attorney-General (Qld) v Guy [2022] QSC 174
Attorney-General (Qld) v Guy [2024] QSC 97
Attorney General for the State of Queensland v GBE [2024] QCA 6

COUNSEL:

J Rolls for the applicant
TS Carlos for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Crown Solicitor for the applicant
Legal Aid Queensland for the respondent

  1. This is the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Attorney-General for the State of Queensland v Guy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QSC 196
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the Attorney-General for the State of Queensland sought a review of a continuing detention order under the Dangerous Prisoners (Sexual Offenders) Act 2003 (DPSO Act) for Guy, a 72-year-old man with a history of serious sexual offences against children, including rape. Guy has been subject to a continuing detention order since 2017, and this was reviewed and affirmed multiple times since then. The court was required to decide whether Guy should continue to be detained under the order or if he could be released under a supervision order. The key legal issues revolved around whether adequate protection of the community could be achieved through a supervision order and if the requirements under section 16 of the DPSO Act could be reasonably and practicably managed by corrective services officers.

The court concluded that while Guy's risk of recidivism was assessed as moderate or below, the primary consideration was the need for adequate protection of the community. Given Guy's age, high care needs due to Parkinson's disease and recently diagnosed metastatic lung cancer, and the lack of suitable accommodation in the community that could manage his care needs and limit his access to potential victims, the court found that the risk could not be reasonably and practicably managed under a supervision order. The evidence indicated that Queensland Corrective Services and Guy himself had been unable to identify a suitable accommodation option. Therefore, the court affirmed the previous decision that Guy remains a serious danger to the community in the absence of a Division 3 order and ordered that he continue to be subject to the continuing detention order.

In summary, the court determined that the primary consideration of community protection outweighed the potential benefits of a supervision order due to the unavailability of suitable accommodation. The court's reasoning was grounded in the need to ensure that Guy's high care requirements and risk of recidivism could be managed effectively, which was not possible under the current conditions. The final orders affirmed the previous decision that Guy is a serious danger to the community and continued his detention under the order.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 30(1) of the DPSO Act, the decision made on 27 March 2017 that the respondent is a serious danger to the community in the absence of an order pursuant to Division 3 of the DPSO Act, be affirmed.

2. Pursuant to s 30(3)(a) of the DPSO Act, the respondent continue to be subject to the continuing detention order made on 27 March 2017.

Background

Background to the litigation

In deciding whether to make either such order, subs 30(4) DPSO Act provides:“(a)the paramount consideration is to be the need to ensure adequate protection of the community; and(b)the court must consider whether─(i) adequate protection of the community can be reasonably and practicably managed by a supervision order; and(ii) the requirements under section 16 can be reasonably and practicably managed by corrective services officers.”Respondent’s background, antecedents and criminal history With respect to the required matters that I must have regard to in this case I make reference to the following matters with regard to the respondent’s background, antecedents and criminal history. The respondent was born on 5 November 1952. He is presently 72 years of age. In 1998, he was sentenced to 10 years imprisonment for 34 sexual offences against children. Those offences included 16 counts of rape. One complainant was a young female with whom he maintained an unlawful sexual relationship over a six year period beginning when the child was nine years of age. He served most of that sentence before being released on parole. Towards the end of that parole period, he committed another serious sexual offence with a young woman of extremely low intelligence and was sentenced to nine years’ imprisonment. I do not propose to repeat the history of all the risk assessments which have been carried out in relation to this respondent. Most recently they were set out by Justice Cooper as follows:“Dr Lenardon[15]Dr Anna Lenardon interviewed the respondent on 14 June 2023 at the Townsville Correctional Centre. She noted that the respondent does not present with any mental states abnormalities suggestive of major mental disorder. He presents with mixed personality disorder traits but seems to have been reasonably adjusted in custody for the preceding 12 months. Dr Lenardon observed no evidence of psychopathy. She noted that the respondent appeared to have borderline intelligence.[16]Dr Lenardon identified certain matters (lack of psychopathy and major mental disorder, lack of extreme denial or minimisation or blame on others, institutional conduct, advanced aged and physical fragility) as limited protective factors. She noted the absence of protective factors suggesting an active gain or improvement by the respondent such as development of insight into his offending or the development of a relapse prevention plan. Although she noted the respondent’s continuing refusal to engaging in treatment for his sexual offending, Dr Lenardon considered it likely, given his poor response to previous treatment programs and his cognitive deficits, that even if the respondent engaged in further psychological treatment, the therapeutic gain would be minimal.[17] As to the question of risk, Dr Lenardon stated as follows:“Mr Guy continues to pose an unacceptable risk of reoffending if released in the community without supervision. Mitigating strategies to prevent further offending would rely on external measures, such as no access to community unsupervised and no access to vulnerable victims. Based on Mr Guy’s offending history, potential victims would be underage or vulnerable females. Offending could be opportunistic and impulsive or could involve a degree of preparation (i.e, grooming of the victim). The offending could escalate to serious violent sexual offences.If released in the community, Mr Guy will require placement in a nursing home due to his chronic physical condition. The nursing home should have only male residents. Staff members should be able to monitor Mr Guy’s movements within the nursing home to prevent unsupervised access to potential victims. Mr Guy should not access [the] community unsupervised. Regular liaison with nursing home staff by the supervising officer should continue in order to support staff and monitor Mr Guy’s risk.”[18]During her oral evidence, Dr Lenardon clarified that her reference to an “unacceptable” risk of reoffending in the passage extracted above meant at least a moderate unmodified risk of sexual recidivism by the respondent. Her reference to “serious violent sexual offences” in the passage extracted above reflected the fact that the respondent’s prior offending involved a level of physical coercion and prolonged conduct in circumstances where the victim clearly expressed distress. Dr Lenardon also referred to her assessment that the respondent is likely to be highly institutionalised as being relevant to risk assessment where a pathway to the respondent’s earlier offending appeared to be frustration in the context of increased stressors and maladapted coping strategies. Dr Arthur[19]Dr Ken Arthur assessed the respondent at the Townsville Correctional Centre on 23 June 2023. His diagnosis of the respondent remains that set out in his previous reports: that is one of a personality disorder with predominant antisocial traits in the context of borderline intellectual functioning. He again referred to the respondent’s slowly progressing Parkinson’s disease. As in his earlier reports, Dr Arthur observed that while the respondent has a history of offending against children, there is no clear evidence of a paraphilic disorder. [20]Dr Arthur concluded that the respondent’s static risk factors remain unchanged from his previous assessments. Likewise, his dynamic risk factors remain mostly unchanged. Dr Arthur repeated his observation from his earlier reports that the most significant risk factors for recidivism in persons aged over 70 are the presence of persistent sexual deviance and evidence of severely disturbed personality, such as psychopathy. Dr Arthur observed that there is no convincing evidence that the respondent has a persistent deviant sexual drive or suffers from a sexual paraphilia.[21]Taking these various factors into account, Dr Arthur described the respondent’s unmodified risk of sexual recidivism on release as being low to moderate. This risk could be further reduced to low by the application of a supervision order which would limit victim access.[22]Dr Arthur considered that, given the respondent’s behaviour in the community upon release remains untested, it would be prudent to limit his unsupervised access to female children or vulnerable adult women.[23]Dr Arthur acknowledged that, in light of the difficulties which Queensland Corrective Services (QCS) staff have had in sourcing suitable nursing home accommodation, alternate accommodation options should be considered. He stated that a supported living arrangement in either a hostel-type environment or shared care household may be a viable alternative to a nursing home. Dr Arthur considered that ideally this should be a male-only facility even though he regards the respondent as presenting a low risk of harm to women who do not have significant physical or cognitive disabilities. Dr Arthur’s preference remains that the respondent be supervised when he accesses the community, even though he does not have a history of offending in public places against children who are not known to him.[24]During his oral evidence, Dr Arthur expressed a concern that, in circumstances where the respondent can be quite impulsive and act without thinking about consequences, the threat of punishment or sanction may not necessarily limit his behaviour upon his release into the community. Dr Arthur also noted that, although he considered the risk that the respondent’s risk of sexual recidivism to be low, the potential seriousness of the consequences if the risk was to eventuate and the respondent offended against a child remained a concern.”Events since last review

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Whilst the respondent’s wish to remain in custody is noted, and his position remains that the application is not opposed, that does not answer the question of whether the court should order continuing detention or whether the respondent should be released from custody subject to a supervision order.Consideration On the basis of the evidence that is before me, which evidence I find to be acceptable and cogent, having regard to the matter set out in s 13(4), I am satisfied to a high degree of probability that the respondent is a serious danger to the community in the absence of a Division 3 order and that the decision made on 27 March 2017 should be affirmed. I therefore turn to the question of what type of order should be made. The absence of suitable accommodation remains the hallmark of this matter. For some time, it has been the case that the respondent cannot live in the Wacol precinct because his need for care and assistance would render that accommodation unsuitable. Previously his care needs were from his Parkinson’s disease, now it is the combination of that disease with his lung cancer. He needs nursing home style accommodation as he cannot reside alone, and 24 hour supervision. I accept that the evidence demonstrates that Queensland Corrective Services is not in a position to provide the type of accommodation that the respondent requires. The recent diagnosis of metastatic lung cancer is one which creates considerable uncertainty in terms of the respondent’s future risk. It may well be with the development of his condition that his risk may change as his disease progresses, but at this point in time the medical evidence demonstrates that his risk remains as moderate or moderate to low risk of sexual recidivism. As the respondent’s risk must be assessed at the date of hearing[2] then his risk remains the same as it has been previously. In circumstances where his accommodation needs are not currently able to be managed in the community, the court has no alternative but to order that he remain subject to the continuing detention order made on 27 March 2017. It may well be that if the respondent’s physical condition deteriorates he will be able to be appropriately managed, perhaps in palliative care, but currently that is not the position.[2]Attorney General for the State of Queensland v GBE [2024] QCA 6 at [57]. In the circumstances, the orders that I make are firstly, pursuant to s 30 (1) of the DPSO Act, the decision made on 27 March 2017 that the respondent is a serious danger to the community in the absence of a Division 3 order be affirmed. Secondly, pursuant to s 30(3) DPSO Act, the respondent continue to be subject to the continuing detention order made on 27 March 2017.