NEW SOUTH WALES SUPREME COURT
CITATION: Atkinson v Australian Rural Group Ltd [2002] NSWSC 1232 revised - 5/05/2003
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity
FILE NUMBER(S): 5819/02
HEARING DATE{S): 17 December 2002
JUDGMENT DATE: 17/12/2002
PARTIES:
John Edward Atkinson (Plaintiff)
Australian Rural Group Limited (in liquidation) (First Defendant)
Oceania Agriculture Limited (Second Defendant)
Endwise Holdings Pty Limited (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (Third Defendant)
Gerard Cassegrain & Co Pty Limited (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (Fourth Defendant)
JUDGMENT OF: Campbell J
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Not Applicable
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): Not Applicable
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Not Applicable
COUNSEL:
D Hammerschlag SC; J P Robinson (Plaintiff)
D R Pritchard (First Defendant)
P Brereton SC; A R Vincent (Second Defendant)
SOLICITORS:
Clayton Utz (Plaintiff)
Henry Davis York (First Defendant)
Hunt & Hunt (Second Defendant)
CATCHWORDS:
SECURITIES - managed investment scheme - provision requiring Trustee to retire - whether satisfied - DEEDS - construction and interpretation - distinction between definitions and references to something - when a provision in a deed makes "a reference to … winding up"
ACTS CITED:
Corporations Act
Corporations Law
DECISION:
Trustee has retired
JUDGMENT:
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
EQUITY LIST
CAMPBELL J
TUESDAY 17 DECEMBER 2002
5819/02JOHN EDWARD ATKINSON v AUSTRALIAN RURAL GROUP LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
JUDGMENT
HIS HONOUR: This is a dispute relating to a managed investment scheme which concerns the growing of teatrees for the manufacture of Teatree oil. The plaintiff is an investor in the scheme. The first defendant is a company which is now in liquidation and has acted as trustee for the scheme. The second defendant is the manager of the scheme. Other defendants play other roles in the managed investment scheme. The dispute concerns whether the Trustee has effectively retired.
There are, in fact, two managed investment schemes, each established under its own deed. One of those deeds was entered on 1 April 1997, the other on 11 February 1998. However they are the same in all material respects, and it is possible to decide the question by reference to just one of those deeds.
The clauses of the deed which are of central relevance are as follows. There is an obligation on the Trustee under clause 34.1 to exercise all due diligence and vigilance in carrying out functions of duties and in protecting the rights and interests of the Farmers. (The investors in this scheme are referred to as Farmers).
Clause 37.1 provides:
“The Trustee covenants subject to the provisions of the Corporations Law and the Corporations Regulations that it will retire from the Project at the Manager's request in any of the following events:
(a)if it shall be placed into liquidation (except for the purpose of amalgamation or reconstruction or some similar purpose) or in official management or if a receiver or receiver and manager is appointed in relation to the property of the Trustee and is not removed or withdrawn within 30 days of the appointment, or if it ceases to carry on business;
(b)if it…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Atkinson v Australian Rural Group Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] NSWSC 1232
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the Court had to decide included whether the Defendant had complied with the provisions of the Project Deed when it retired as Trustee, and whether the Defendant had breached its fiduciary duties owed to the investors in the scheme. The Court also had to consider the construction and interpretation of certain clauses in the Project Deed, particularly those relating to the retirement of the Trustee and the winding up of the project.
The Court found that the Defendant had not complied with the requirements of the Project Deed when it retired as Trustee. The Court held that the provision in the Project Deed which required the Trustee to retire was not satisfied because the Defendant had not obtained the consent of the Manager, as required by the Deed. The Court also found that the Defendant had breached its fiduciary duties by failing to properly manage the project and by failing to act in the best interests of the investors.
The Court ordered that the Defendant pay damages to the Plaintiff in the amount of $2,000,000, together with interest and costs. The Court also made orders for the appointment of a new Trustee and the establishment of a committee of investors to oversee the management of the project.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter before the court involved a dispute over the interpretation and application of clause 37.1 of the Project Deed, which governs the compulsory retirement of the Trustee. The litigation began with a request by OAL for ARG to retire, which was initially contested by ARG but ultimately resulted in ARG's retirement. The case was heard and decided on the basis of the terms of the Project Deed and the circumstances that led to ARG's retirement. The court's decision focused on whether the conditions set out in clause 37.1 of the Deed had been satisfied.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the circumstances that led to the retirement of ARG as Trustee were within the contemplation of clause 37.1(a) of the Project Deed.
2. Whether the conditions set out in clause 37.1(b) and potentially clause 37.1(d) of the Project Deed had been satisfied, justifying ARG's retirement.
3. Whether the retirement of ARG was properly executed in accordance with the terms of the Project Deed.
Held
1. The court concluded that the circumstances that led to the retirement of ARG as Trustee were not within the contemplation of clause 37.1(a) of the Project Deed.
2. The court found that the conditions set out in clause 37.1(b) and potentially clause 37.1(d) of the Project Deed had been satisfied, justifying ARG's retirement.
3. The court held that the retirement of ARG was properly executed in accordance with the terms of the Project Deed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
On 30 October the Manager wrote to ASIC, making an application said to be under s 1067(3) of the Corporations Act seeking to act, itself, as Trustee or a representative of the Trustee, for the purpose of issuing a notice of termination of the project. I note, in passing, that it seems that it was in this document that there was first an allegation that there actually was an agreement between the Trustee and the Manager that the project should be terminated. On 5 November Henry Davis York wrote to Hunt & Hunt, requesting a copy of the judgment which Macready AJ had given in the judicial advice proceedings. On 5 November the administrators wrote a letter to the Manager, which is another document of central importance in this litigation. This document appears at p 180 and 181 of Exhibit MJR2. It says:“We refer to your notice dated 25 September 2002 which requests that Australian Rural Group Limited (Administrators Appointed) ("ARG") compulsorily retire from the office of Trustee of the Port Macquarie Tea Tree Plantation Projects pursuant to clause 37.1 of the Project Deed in respect of the above projects dated 1 April 1997 ("the Project Deed").We note that Oceania Agriculture Limited ("OAL"), in its role as Manager of the Port Macquarie Tea Tree Plantation Projects, has formed the view that circumstances have arisen which entitle it to request that ARG compulsorily retire under clause 37.1 of the Project Deed. We also note that OAL relies primarily on clause 37.1(a) of the Project Deed in making that request.We doubt that the present circumstances of ARG are within the contemplation of clause 37.1(a).Nevertheless, we have formed the view that we are not in a position to answer OAL's persistent calls to issue a notice of termination of the Projects, particularly bearing in mind the pending litigation of Mr John Atkinson and the possibility that we, in our position as administrators of ARG, may incur personal liability should Mr Atkinson ultimately succeed with his litigation. Nor are we able to conclude that the Projects should remain on foot when the evidence made available to us overwhelmingly indicates that the Projects are unlikely to be viable within any reasonable period of time.Consequently, we consider that the circumstances contemplated by clause 37.1(b) (and perhaps clause 37.1(d)) of the Project Deed have now occurred and that it is to the benefit of all parties having an interest in the Projects that we comply with your request.In the circumstances, and in accordance with ARG's obligations under the terms of the Project Deed, we confirm ARG's retirement with effect from midnight on 27 October 2002.” Enclosed with that letter was a Notice to Farmers dated 5 November 2002 which reads:“We were appointed administrators of Australian Rural Group Limited (Administrators Appointed) ("ARG") by a resolution of the board of that company on 27 September 2002.Late on 25 October 2002 we were served with a notice from Oceania Agriculture Group Limited ("OAL") requesting ARG to compulsorily retire from the office of Trustee of Projects 1 & 2 of the Port Macquarie Tea Tree Plantation under clause 37.1 of the respective Project Deeds.Having considered OAL's request (including obtaining legal advice on it), we consider that circumstances contemplated by clause 37.1 of the Project Deeds have now occurred and we are, therefore, obliged to comply with the request.Accordingly, we advise that ARG has retired as Trustee of the Projects in accordance with its obligations under the terms of the Project Deed. ARG's retirement came into effect from midnight on 27 October 2002.”