Atkinson and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Atkinson and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 3540 (1 October 2021)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/4725

Re:Thomas Atkinson

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

INTERLOCUTORY DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President F Meagher

Date:1 October 2021  

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal refuses the application of the Respondent that the Tribunal make a direction compelling the Applicant to participate in assessments by Dr Naveed and Ms Stephenson.

............................[SGD].......................

Deputy President F Meagher

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) – application for review of decision refusing the Applicant access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme – interlocutory application for direction that the Applicant participate in assessments by an occupational therapist and a psychiatrist – process of balancing risk to Applicant with benefit of obtaining further evidence – procedural fairness – application refused.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 2A, 33

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) ss 26, 36

Cases

Australian Postal Corporation v Hayes (1989) 23 FCR 320; 87 ALR 283; 18 ALD 135
BKQQ and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 732
Liddle and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 507
MDCT and National Disability Insurance Agency [2020] AATA 6036

Secondary Materials

‘Access to the NDIS Operational Guidelines’, National Disability Insurance Agency (Web Page, 6 July 2021) < cl 10.2

REASONS FOR INTERLOCUTORY DECISION

Deputy President F Meagher

  1. Mr Thomas Atkinson (the Applicant) is seeking access to become a participant of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The Applicant applied to the Tribunal on 28 July 2020 seeking review of a decision made by the National Disability Insurance Agency (the Respondent) that he did not meet the criteria to access the NDIS pursuant to the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (the NDIS Act).

  2. During the course of the review, the Respondent requested that the Applicant undergo and participate in an assessment with a psychiatrist and an in-home functional capacity assessment with an occupational therapist. The Applicant indicated that he did not consent to being accessed by practitioners of the Respondent’s choosing. The Respondent then submitted that this was an appropriate case for the Tribunal to make a direction that the Applicant be compelled to participate in an assessment by a psychiatrist and an occupational therapist.

  3. The material before the Tribunal with respect to the application for a direction that the Tribunal compel the Applicant to undertake assessments with a psychiatrist and an occupational therapist relevantly include:

    (a)Submissions from the Respondent in respect of compellability dated 18 June 2021 (Respondent’s Submissions).

    (b)Submissions from the Applicant comprising an email dated 28 June 2021 summarising his position and attaching a 15 page document entitled ‘Thomas Atkinson’s Submissions regarding Respondent’s request to compel applicant to undergo new assessments’ (Applicant’s Submissions filed on 28 June 2021) referencing evidence already before the Tribunal including reports of Ms Neagle, Dr Kan and Dr Andel, summonsed material from Drs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Atkinson and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 3540
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an interlocutory application made by the National Disability Insurance Agency (the Respondent) in proceedings for review of a decision to refuse the Applicant access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme. The Respondent sought a direction that the Applicant participate in assessments by an occupational therapist and a psychiatrist.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether it should exercise its discretion to compel the Applicant to undergo further assessments. This required balancing the potential benefit of obtaining additional evidence against the risk of harm to the Applicant, and considering the Respondent's right to procedural fairness.

The Tribunal determined that it should not exercise its discretion to order the assessments. It noted that there was existing evidence before the Tribunal, and the Applicant was amenable to the Respondent questioning the witnesses who provided that evidence. The Tribunal found that the Respondent had not demonstrated the specific relevance or utility of the proposed further assessments, beyond its general right to procedural fairness. The Tribunal considered that this fairness was sufficiently afforded by the Respondent's access to the Applicant's witnesses, the existing material, and the ability to obtain its own expert opinions on the evidence already presented. The Tribunal also agreed with the Applicant's submission that its witnesses could provide evidence in accordance with the Tribunal's Guide to Giving Expert Evidence.

Accordingly, the Tribunal refused the Respondent's application for a direction compelling the Applicant to participate in the assessments.

Background

Background to the litigation

Atkinson applied for a review of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) that refused Atkinson’s access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). Atkinson sought to challenge the refusal decision on the grounds that it was based on inadequate evidence and process. Atkinson argued that the NDIA did not conduct the necessary assessments to understand Atkinson’s needs and capabilities.

In response, the NDIA made an interlocutory application to the Tribunal requesting that Atkinson participate in further assessments by an occupational therapist, Dr Naveed, and a psychiatrist, Ms Stephenson. The NDIA submitted that Atkinson's existing evidence was insufficient to make a fair and accurate determination of Atkinson’s eligibility and needs under the NDIS. The NDIA argued that further assessments were necessary to obtain additional evidence to balance the risk of harm to Atkinson against the benefit of obtaining further evidence.

Atkinson opposed the NDIA’s application, asserting that the NDIA had ample evidence from Atkinson’s existing material and witnesses to make a fair determination. Atkinson also submitted that any further assessments posed an unacceptable risk of harm to Atkinson due to Atkinson’s significant disabilities and vulnerabilities. Atkinson further argued that procedural fairness had already been afforded by allowing the NDIA to question Atkinson’s witnesses and review the existing evidence. Atkinson suggested that any additional evidence from further assessments could be obtained from Atkinson’s existing witnesses.

The Tribunal considered Atkinson’s opposition and the NDIA’s application in light of the statutory scheme under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) and the Tribunal’s Guide to Giving Expert Evidence. The Tribunal needed to balance Atkinson’s risk of harm against the NDIA’s need for additional evidence to make a fair determination of Atkinson’s eligibility and needs under the NDIS. The Tribunal also needed to consider whether Atkinson had been afforded procedural fairness given the existing evidence and witness questioning.

Atkinson and the National Disability Insurance Agency involved an application for review of a decision refusing the applicant access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme. The matter came before the Tribunal on an interlocutory basis, specifically in response to an application by the National Disability Insurance Agency for a direction that the applicant participate in assessments by an occupational therapist and a psychiatrist. This application was made in the context of ensuring procedural fairness and the collection of further evidence. The Tribunal considered the risk to the applicant against the benefit of obtaining additional evidence through these assessments. The process involved balancing the procedural fairness requirements with the potential risk of harm to the applicant. The Tribunal examined the evidence already before it, the applicant's willingness to have their existing witnesses questioned, and the ability of the respondent to summon material and obtain expert views. The applicant argued that any additional witnesses could provide evidence in accordance with the Tribunal’s Guide to Giving Expert Evidence, which the Tribunal acknowledged. Ultimately, the Tribunal decided that the discretion should not be exercised, and refused the respondent's application to compel the applicant to participate in further assessments.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In all the circumstances this is not a case in which the Tribunal considers the discretion should be exercised. There is evidence before the Tribunal, in respect of which the Applicant is content for the Respondent to ask questions of the witnesses who have provided it. The Applicant swears to a significant risk of harm. The Respondent can point to nothing specific to satisfy the Tribunal of the relevance or utility of the further assessments other than its right to procedural fairness, which in the context of this case the Tribunal considers is afforded by access to the Applicants witnesses, the summonsed material and the ability to obtain its own expert’s views as to the evidence already before the Tribunal. As to the ability for additional witnesses to provide evidence in accordance with the Tribunal’s Guide to Giving Expert Evidence, the Applicant has observed that it may be provided to his witnesses and they can give their evidence accordingly. The Tribunal agrees with that observation.INTERLOCUTORY DECISION For the reasons outlined above, the Tribunal refuses the application of the Respondent that the Tribunal make a direction compelling the Applicant to participate in assessments by Dr Naveed and Ms Stephenson.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, in the case of Atkinson and National Disability Insurance Agency, addressed the issue of whether the Tribunal had the discretion to compel the Applicant to undergo further assessments by an occupational therapist and a psychiatrist under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). The court found that the Tribunal's discretion was not to be exercised in this case, given the existing evidence and the Applicant's expressed concerns about potential harm. The court relied on the principle that the exercise of discretion should be reserved for cases where it is necessary to obtain further evidence that is critical to the decision-making process and where the benefits of such evidence outweigh any potential harm to the Applicant.

In considering the balance between the risk of harm to the Applicant and the benefit of obtaining further evidence, the Tribunal adopted a cautious approach. It recognised that while the Respondent had a right to procedural fairness, this right must be weighed against the Applicant's significant risk of harm. The court applied the principle that procedural fairness is not an absolute right but must be balanced with other considerations, including the well-being of the Applicant. The authorities cited by the court underscored the importance of ensuring that the process does not exacerbate the Applicant's existing vulnerabilities.

The court also examined whether the Applicant's right to procedural fairness was adequately satisfied by access to their witnesses, the summonsed material, and the ability to obtain expert views on existing evidence. The Tribunal determined that these measures sufficiently addressed the need for procedural fairness. The Applicant's ability to present their case through their witnesses and the Tribunal's capacity to seek expert opinions on the existing evidence provided a robust framework for a fair assessment. The court referenced prior cases to support the notion that procedural fairness can be achieved through these means without necessitating additional invasive assessments.

Further, the court addressed the issue of whether additional witnesses could provide evidence in accordance with the Tribunal's Guide to Giving Expert Evidence. The Applicant noted that their witnesses could be provided with the Guide, enabling them to give evidence accordingly. The court agreed with this observation and held that the existing process already allowed for the presentation of expert evidence. This decision reinforced the view that the Tribunal's current procedures were sufficient to meet the requirements of procedural fairness without the need for additional assessments that could pose a risk to the Applicant.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the Tribunal has the discretion to compel further assessments under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth), but it should exercise this discretion judiciously, balancing the need for further evidence against the risk of harm to the Applicant. The court held that procedural fairness can be achieved through access to witnesses, summonsed material, and expert opinions on existing evidence, and additional witnesses can provide expert evidence in line with the Tribunal’s guidelines. The decision also reflects a departure from prior authority to the extent that it emphasizes the importance of protecting the Applicant's well-being over the Respondent's right to procedural fairness.