ASX19 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

ASX19 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2025] FedCFamC2G 1352

File number: MLG 505 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE GOSTENCNIK
Date of judgment: 25 August 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION – protection (class XA) (subclass 866) visa – judicial review – review of decision of the (then) Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) – where Minister’s delegate refused to grant applicant a visa – where Tribunal affirmed delegate’s decision – whether Tribunal’s decision was illogical, irrational or unreasonable – Tribunal’s decision attended by jurisdictional error – writ of certiorari issued – writ of mandamus issued  
Legislation:

Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth)

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 36(2)(a), 36(2)(aa), 91R(1)(a), 91R(1)(b), 91R(1)(c), 359A, 424A

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth) sch 2, div 2, pt 1, item 3

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) sch 2, cl 866.221(2)

Cases cited:

Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration, Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 184, 236 FCR 593

Djokovic v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCAFC 3, 289 FCR 21

LPDT v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 12, 280 CLR 321

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Eden [2016] FCAFC 28, 240 FCR 158

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Sabharwal [2018] FCAFC 160

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Stretton [2016] FCAFC 11, 237 FCR 1

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li [2013] HCA 18, 249 CLR 332

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZIAI [2009] HCA 39

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS [2010] HCA 16, 240 CLR 611

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v SGLB [2004] HCA 32

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Singh [2014] FCAFC 1, 231 FCR 437

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 92
Date of last submission/s: 2 July 2025
Date of hearing: 18 June 2025
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr A Krohn
Solicitors for the Applicant: Wotton Kearney
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr K Sypott
Solicitors for the First Respondent: Mills Oakley
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Submitting appearance, save as to costs

ORDERS

MLG 505 of 2019

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

ASX19

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE GOSTENCNIK

DATE OF ORDER:

25 AUGUST 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.A writ of certiorari issue to quash the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) made on 12 February 2019 in Case No 1622049.

2.A writ of mandamus issue directed to the second respondent requiring it to determine, according to law, the application for review made to the AAT in Case No 1622049.

3.The first respondent pay the applicant’s costs fixed in the sum of $8,371.30.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ASX19 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 1352
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of ASX19 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship involved a national of Papua New Guinea who applied for a Protection (Class XA) visa. The applicant alleged that she feared serious physical and psychological abuse by her husband in Papua New Guinea and had been severely beaten by him on multiple occasions. The application was initially refused by a delegate of the Minister, and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) affirmed that decision. The applicant sought judicial review of the Tribunal's decision, contending that it was affected by jurisdictional error.

The legal issues the court had to decide included whether the Tribunal failed to consider relevant considerations, including the applicant's claims and material questions of fact, whether the Tribunal erred in interpreting or applying the law, whether there was a reasonable apprehension that the Tribunal was biased or did not have an open mind, and whether the Tribunal's decision was otherwise legally unreasonable.

The court found that the Tribunal's decision was indeed affected by jurisdictional error. The Tribunal failed to consider or properly consider several material facts, including the applicant's claims of rape and violence by her husband, her claims of attempted suicide, and the allegation that she had fabricated her claims for protection. The Tribunal also erred in rejecting corroborative documents without making inquiries about their authenticity and in not giving the applicant the opportunity to know that her marriage was an issue on the review. Additionally, the Tribunal's findings were not based on a logically probative basis and were otherwise legally unreasonable. The court quashed the Tribunal's decision and remitted the review application to the Minister for determination according to law.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons explained below, I consider the Tribunal’s decision is attended by jurisdictional error. Accordingly, the decision will be quashed and the review application remitted to the second respondent for it to determine according to law.BACKGROUND The applicant is a national of Papua New Guinea who arrived in Australia on 25 October 2013 as the holder of a Tourist (TR-676) visa. On 29 November 2013, the applicant applied for a Protection (Class XA) visa, with the assistance of a solicitor. That application was accompanied by the applicant’s statutory declaration dated 18 November 2013 which set out the applicant’s claims for protection. In short, the applicant claimed to fear serious physical and psychological abuse by her husband (a man named Joachim) in Papua New Guinea and to have been severely beaten by her husband on multiple occasions. The applicant claimed she fled her home country and was unable to bring her children with her to Australia. The (then) Department of Immigration and Border Protection acknowledged receipt of the application by letter dated 2 December 2013. By letter dated 30 January 2015, the Department invited the applicant to attend an interview scheduled for 25 February 2015 to discuss her visa application and protection claims and enclosed a factsheet titled ‘Important Information About Your Protection Visa Interview’ which briefly set out the applicable criteria for assessing whether a person is a refugee under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act).[1] That letter also requested the applicant provide documentary evidence in relation to her identity, nationality or citizenship, to the Department.[1]Unless otherwise specified or the context otherwise requires, any reference to the Act is a reference to the Act as it was then in force. On 28 April 2015, the applicant’s solicitor wrote to the Department, the effect of which was to make submissions regarding the applicant’s protection claims. The letter asserted that the applicant had suffered grave harm in her home country which constituted persecution, and that the persecution she suffered was due to her membership of a particular social group, being women in Papua New Guinea. The letter enclosed correspondence and medical records from Port Moresby Hospital, and a discharge summary dated April 2003 showing that the applicant had been admitted to that hospital and received treatment for injuries inflicted by her husband. The letter also enclosed extracts from Port Moresby police records showing complaints made by the applicant in December 2012 relating to assaults by her husband. On 2 November 2016, the Department wrote to the applicant, notifying her that it had identified adverse information pertaining to the visa application. The notification of relevant information is relevantly reproduced below:Relationship with Sebastian MambuYou claimed during your Protection visa interview that Sebastian Mambu, a neighbour who lived next door, helped you with your Australian Visitor visa application by falsely claiming that he was your husband. When questioned about the assistance provided to you by Sebastian Mambu, you did not disclose that he accompanied you to Australia. When asked if anyone helped you leave PNG, you replied that no one helped you.However, information obtained by the department is not consistent with these claims, and suggests that Sebastian Mambu was your partner, as claimed in the Visitor visa application.*Departmental records indicate that Sebastian Mambu travelled with you to Australia.*It appears that Sebastian Mambu visited you in Australia. According to information he has provided, he intended to reside at Gray Street St Kilda during his visit to Australia during May 2016. Your address from May 2016 was Grey Street St Kilda.*Sebastian Mambu recorded you as the emergency contact person during his visits to Australia during 2012 to 2014.*Information suggests that you and Sebastian Mambu have a child in common. You listed Sedrick Gahekave, date of birth 2/2/2000 as your child. Sebastian Mambu has claimed that he has a son named Shedrick Mambu, date of birth 2/2/2000.Arrival in AustraliaDuring the Protection visa interview you claimed that you had no plans about what you would do in Australia, apart from getting away from your husband. You stated that you arrived in Cairns, and then travelled to Melbourne because it was far from PNG. You also stated that there was no other reason you travelled to Melbourne.Information on your Passenger Arrival Card is not consistent with this claim. On your Passenger Arrival Card, you wrote your address in Australia as 375 Springvale Road, Tatura, 3616, Vic, Mel. This appears to be a rural property in Victoria.Anonymous allegationAn allegation has been made claiming that you paid a person to tell you how to be a refugee.The source also stated that your husband left you for another woman.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 12 February 2019, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision. The applicant was notified of the Tribunal’s decision by letter dated 13 February 2019, which enclosed a copy of the Tribunal’s Statement of Decision and Reasons (Decision). TRIBUNAL’S DECISION AND REASONS The Decision commences with a short summary of the applicant’s circumstances and relevant procedural history at [1]–[4], before recounting the applicant’s claims at [6]–[19] and turning to consider those claims at [20]–[71]. The Tribunal noted at [4] that the issue for it to determine was “whether the applicant ha[d] a well-founded fear of persecution if she returns to Papua New Guinea, or there is a real risk she will suffer significant harm if returned there,” and that based on that assessment, the Tribunal decided to affirm the delegate’s decision. Summarising the applicant’s evidence, the Tribunal records that: (a)the applicant was forcibly married to her husband when she was 15 years old in 1985, following her husband sexually assaulting her. Her husband had paid 1500 kina and 5 pigs as a ‘bride price’ in relation to their marriage. She claimed in her visa application to have seven children: Decision at [6];(b)the serious violence against her started when her husband married his second wife in 2001. She began to raise complaints that he may be at risk of transmitting HIV to her, and he became violent towards her: at [7];(c)her husband was a gambler and a drinker, he was not supportive of his family, and she raised income for the family through working where she could, along with her two eldest children: at [8];(d)there were many occasions she felt seriously threatened by her husband, including: in 2003 where he kicked her, as a result of which she required surgery; in 2010 when he kicked her in the face; in 2011 where he stabbed her in the head with a knife; and in 2013 where he threatened to kill her with a knife: at [9];(e)she sought assistance from the Police on three occasions, and if her husband was arrested, each time he was released shortly thereafter. That she twice fled her family home to stay with friends to escape from her husband, and that she fled Papua New Guinea without her husband’s knowledge: at [10]–[11];(f)she had provided medical evidence indicating that she sought medical treatment in 2003, and a police report relating to an incident in December 2012: at [12];(g)the applicant was interviewed by the Department, and was subsequently notified that the Department had information from her visitor visa, incoming passenger card, the passenger cards of Mr Mambu, and an anonymous ‘dob-in’ letter which did not support her claims indicating that: (i)the applicant had been untruthful about her relationship with Mr Mambu and that he was in fact her partner; (ii)that she had an address in Australia; (iii)that she had paid a person to tell her how to be a refugee in Australia; and (iv)that her husband had left her to be with another woman: at [13]–[14];(h)the applicant responded to these allegations stating that:(i)she was not in a relationship with Mr Mambu and to the extent her documents indicated such, this was only for the purpose of assisting her to flee her husband; (ii)she had recorded her address on arrival in Australia as the address of the person seated next to her on the flight, but she did not reside there; (iii)she could not comment on the anonymous allegation and it ought be given no weight: at [15];(i)the applicant spoke to Mr Mambu in December 2016, during which conversation he threatened her and her family, and he told her that he wanted to travel to Australia but had been informed the Australian authorities were interested in him: at [16];(j)after the hearing, the applicant was sent a letter under s 424A of the Act, and had responded to that letter via her representative: at [17].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal similarly found that there was no real risk that the applicant would suffer significant harm upon return to Papua New Guinea: Decision at [71]. Accordingly, the Tribunal concluded that the applicant did not satisfy the refugee criterion in ss 36(2)(a) or (aa) of the Act, and the decision under review was affirmed. CONSIDERATION By her further amended application the applicant sets out four grounds contending the Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error as follows:1.The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) fell into jurisdictional error in that it did not consider or failed to properly consider relevant considerations including claims, integers of claims and material questions of fact squarely arising on the review by the Tribunal. ParticularsApplicant’s claims to have suffered rape and violence by her husband (a) A letter from a psychologist, dated 2 October 2017 and marked as handed to the Tribunal at hearing on 11 October 2018, stated that the Applicant was raped at the age of 14 (sic) by the man to whom she was shortly afterwards married. Although the Tribunal said it had carefully considered this letter (CB 189, Decision [23]), the Tribunal made no enquiry about this of the Applicant at the Tribunal hearing and made no finding on whether the Applicant had been raped at a young age by the man to whom she was later married. (b) Further, the Applicant claimed to have been married at fifteen years of age to the husband whom she said was later violent to her. (Statement in support of application for protection visa, CB 30, [1].) (c) In the circumstances set out in Particulars (a) and (b), the question whether she had been raped was relevant to the assessment of her credibility and to the assessment of her claims about her marriage and the history of violence in her marriage. Claims to have attempted suicide three times (d)The Applicant claimed in her application for the visa that on three occasions, because of her misery in her marriage, she attempted suicide (Statement in support of application for protection visa, CB 30, [4]), but the Tribunal made no finding about these claims. (Cf. CB 189, Decision [23]) Whether the Applicant’s children could support her and would be willing to do so(e) The Tribunal found that the Applicant’s children could support her and that she could live with them, if she were to return to her country but not live with Sebastian (CB 196, [61]) The Tribunal did not properly consider as required by law if they could and would be willing to support and house her, over 7 years since she left them without notice in Papua New Guinea.Letter accusing Applicant of fabricating her claims for protection (f) There was an allegation in writing that the Applicant had fabricated her claims. The Tribunal in a letter dated 9 November 2018 (“the letter”) put this to the Applicant for comment:“It said that you paid someone to tell you how to be a refugee that you are claiming your husband was violent towards you and your children and seeking protection on those grounds. The source states that your husband left you for another woman, that you have tattoos on your hand and a badly broken nose.” (CB 175) (g)The Applicant’s then representative replied on 23 November 2018 and submitted that no adverse weight should be put on the letter; “Given these matters, we respectfully submit that a negative inference in relation to the applicant’s credibility should not be drawn from the dob-in, especially given it is anonymous and the person who made the dob-in may have done so to be vindictive to our client. “ (CB 180)(h) Despite the circumstances set out in Particulars (f) and (g) to this Ground, the Tribunal made no finding about the letter or its contents. It neither said that it had ignored the contents of the letter, nor did it make a finding about which (if any) parts of the letter it accepted as truthful or reliable, including the letter’s reference to the Applicant’s “husband” which reference supported her claim to be married, but these were material questions arising on the review by the Tribunal.2.The Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error in that it erred in interpreting or applying the law. ParticularsNot making findings (a) Further or in the alternative to the Particulars to Ground 1, the Tribunal did not make findings on material questions of fact necessary to its review under sections 412 and 414 of the Migration Act 1958 (“the Act”) of the decision by the Minister’s delegate. Not making inquiries about corroborative documents (b) The Tribunal had a copy of a medical report from a hospital (CB 79-81, noted by the delegate at CB 105), and of a report to a police station (CB 81, noted by the delegate at CB105), both in Papua New Guinea. The Tribunal rejected them as non-genuine documents of no weight, without any inquiry of the apparent authors. (CB 194, [45]-[49]) (c) The Tribunal did not make inquiries under section 424A of the Act about the authenticity of the ostensibly corroborative documents mentioned in Particular (b) to this Ground, but it rejected them as non-genuine documents and deserving no weight, because of internal inconsistencies and because of information about the prevalence of fraudulent documents in Papua New Guinea.Doubt about finding – “real chance” (d) The Tribunal said, “Even if [the Applicant] could not cohabit with Sebastian on return…” (CB 196, Decision [61]), which suggests that this was a material question of fact in the Tribunal’s mind, and indicates an element of doubt by the Tribunal about its earlier finding that, “I find that the applicant can return to Port Moresby and live there. I find that she could return either to live with Sebastian and resume their relationship – there being no information before me that he would harm her…” (CB 196, [60]) (e) The finding by the Tribunal that the Applicant was not owed protection, despite the element of doubt in the Tribunal’s findings set out in Particular (d) to this Ground, shows that the Tribunal was not correctly interpreting or applying the terms “well-founded fear”, “real chance” and “real risk” in sections 5H, 5J, 36(2)(a) and 36(2)(aa) of the Act. (f) In breach of section 425 of the Act, the Tribunal did not give the Applicant the opportunity to know that it was an issue on the review whether she had ever been married to the man she said was her husband.3. The Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error in that there was a reasonable apprehension that it was biased or did not have an open mind. Particulars(a)Further or in the alternative to Particulars (f), (g) and (h) to Ground 1, and by reason of the matters set out in those Particulars, there was a reasonable apprehension that the Tribunal was biased or did not have an open mind. 4. The Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error in that it did not have a logically probative basis for findings or was otherwise legally unreasonable.ParticularsRejection of corroborative evidence and claims without making inquiries (a) Further or in the alternative to Particulars (b) and (c) to Ground 2, the Tribunal was legally unreasonable to have rejected the corroborative documents referred to in those particulars as non-genuine and of no weight, and the claims which they ostensibly supported, without making inquiries of the ostensible authors or issuing authorities. (CB 79-81; 194, [45]-[49])Rejection of claim to have been married to the man the Applicant claimed (b) The Tribunal’s finding that, “The applicant has been in a relationship with Sebastian Mambu from at least 2000, when the applicant, I find, had a child ... with Sebastian Mambu. I find that the applicant was in a relationship with Sebastian from 2000 until at least 2014…” (CB 195, [52]) was based on the paternity of the child. This was not a logical foundation for the proposition that the Applicant was never married to another man, not (sic) that she had not continued cohabiting with her husband up to 2013. (CB 195, [52])Rejection of claim to have been assaulted (c) Further or in the alternative to particulars (a) to (d) to Ground 1, the Tribunal rejected the claim that the Applicant had been assaulted by her husband, (CB 195, [52]) on the basis of its findings on the Applicant’s general credibility, and about the documents, the relationship with Sebastian and the paternity of her children, but without any discrete consideration of the circumstantial claims of the assaults (described by the Tribunal at CB 195 [52]) and injuries, and the three attempts at suicide. Finding that the Applicant’s children could support her(d) Further or in the alternative to Particular (e) to Ground 1, the Tribunal referred to no evidence for its finding that the Applicant’s children could support her and that she could live with them, if she were to return to her country but not live with Sebastian. (CB 196, [61]) The Tribunal did not properly consider if they would be willing to support and house her, over 7 years since she left them without notice in Papua New Guinea. (e) Further or in the alternative to Particular (e) to Ground 1 and particular (d) to this Ground, there was no reference by the Tribunal to any evidence for its finding that the support of the Applicant’s children would allow her to return and live in reasonable safety, (CB 197, [66]) despite the level of risk noted by the Tribunal in Port Moresby, especially to a single woman. (CB 196, [64]).