Arumugam and TNT Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

Arumugam and TNT Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2017] AATA 2660 (14 December 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers:         2014/5954, 2016/0865 & 2016/0866

Re:Ilanthirayan Arumugam

APPLICANT

AndTNT Australia Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President I R Molloy

Date:14 December 2017

Place:Brisbane

The reviewable decision dated 30 October 2014 and the two reviewable decisions dated 18 December 2015 are set aside and substituted with the following findings:

1.    As at 4 September 2014 and presently, the Applicant continues to suffer the effects of the low back injury on 11 April 2013.

2. The Applicant is entitled to compensation under ss 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act1988 in respect of the lower back injury on
11 April 2013 from 4 September 2014 to the present time and presently.

3. The Applicant is entitled to compensation under s 19(3) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 at 75% of his normal weekly earnings without deduction for AE from 4 September 2014 to the present time, and presently, in respect of his low back injury.

4. The Respondent is liable to pay compensation under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 in respect of the Applicant’s low back condition, which was significantly contributed to by the nature and condition of his employment with the Respondent.

5. The Respondent is liable to pay compensation under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 in respect of the Applicant’s psychological condition, which was significantly contributed to by his employment with the Respondent.

6. The matter is remitted to the Respondent for calculation of the Applicant’s entitlements as above under ss 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988.

7. The Respondent shall pay the Applicant’s legal costs and disbursements in respect of these proceedings under s 67 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act1988.

...................................[Sgd]....................................

Deputy President I R Molloy

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – Compensation under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) – claims for lower back injuries - whether the effects of the accepted lumbar injury ceased by 4 September 2014 – where accepted injury was on-going – decision under review set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act1988 ss 4, 5B, 14, 16, 19, 67

CASES

Casarotto v Australian Postal Commission (1989) 86 ALR 399
Ogden Industries Pty Ltd v Lucas (1967) 116 CLR 537

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President I R Molloy

14 December 2017

Introduction

  1. The applicant, Mr Arumugam, worked for the respondent, TNT Australia Pty Ltd (“TNT”), from 2007 until September 2014, for most of that time as a dock-hand.

  2. During his time with TNT he reported and lodged claims for workers’ compensation in respect of four injuries all to his lower back. The fourth injury was on 11 April 2013.

  3. On 30 April 2013, a determination was made accepting liability pursuant to s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act1988 (“SRC Act”)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Arumugam and TNT Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 2660
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned Mr Arumugam's claims for compensation under the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth) following a lower back injury sustained on 11 April 2013 while employed by TNT Australia Pty Ltd. The central dispute revolved around whether the effects of this accepted injury had ceased by 4 September 2014, as determined by the respondent, or if Mr Arumugam continued to suffer from its ongoing effects. Mr Arumugam had lodged multiple workers' compensation claims for lower back injuries between 2009 and 2013, with TNT accepting liability for the April 2013 injury, which involved left lumbar apophysitis.

The court was required to determine the nature and extent of Mr Arumugam's ongoing incapacity resulting from the 11 April 2013 injury. Specifically, the court had to assess whether the medical evidence supported the conclusion that the effects of the injury had resolved by September 2014, or if the injury remained an ongoing cause of Mr Arumugam's current condition. This involved evaluating conflicting medical opinions regarding the persistence of symptoms and the impact of pre-existing degenerative changes in Mr Arumugam's lumbar spine.

The court's reasoning focused on the weight of the medical evidence presented. While the respondent relied on Dr English's opinion that the aggravation from the April 2013 injury had ceased by mid-2014, the court found that Mr Arumugam continued to suffer the effects of this injury. The court also considered the reasonableness of ongoing medical treatment, including medication and physiotherapy, for Mr Arumugam's work-related condition. Ultimately, the court set aside the reviewable decisions and substituted its own findings, concluding that Mr Arumugam continued to suffer the effects of the low back injury and was entitled to compensation from 4 September 2014 onwards. The court also found TNT liable for compensation in respect of the applicant's psychological condition, significantly contributed to by his employment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

I have also found that the reviewable decision in respect of the nature and conditions claim should be set aside. Facts Mr Arumugam was born in Sri Lanka in 1972, and is of Indian descent. He completed school in Sri Lanka to approximately Australian grade 12 level. He completed a diploma course in accounting at a technical college, and then undertook three years of a Bachelor of Accountancy degree at Eastern University in Sri Lanka. He did not complete the Bachelor’s degree, he says, because of the war in Sri Lanka. In 1997 he came to Australia as a refugee. From 1998 to 2007 he was primarily employed by a number of supermarket companies, mainly as a produce assistant or produce manager. In about May 1997 Mr Arumugam commenced employment as a dock-hand with the TNT. His employment was initially on a casual basis through a labour hire company. On about 4 December 2007 he commenced permanent casual employment directly with TNT working as a dock-hand at the company’s Salisbury and Acacia Ridge depots. Ordinarily he would work 50 to 60 hours per week. In all, as mentioned, he worked for TNT from May 2007 to September 2014. The four lower back injuries for which he lodged workers’ compensation claims were sustained in November 2009, March 2011, November 2012, and April 2013. The first three of these injuries generally required a short time off work, and then resumption of work, perhaps on light duties. In respect of the fourth injury, sustained on 11 April 2013, TNT accepted liability for left lumbar apophysitis under s 14 of the SRC Act, and Mr Arumugam was paid benefits from April 2013 until September 2014. During that time Mr Arumugam underwent various medical treatment, and returned to work on various light duties, including ultimately office duties. Mr Arumugam provided a written statement and also gave oral evidence. He described the incident on 11 April 2013. He said he was in the repack area where damaged or broken freight was repacked to a condition fit for transportation. Mr Arumugam said he was shrink-wrapping a pallet when he experienced pain in his lower back. He continued to work despite the pain and finished his shift.[4] [4] Exhibit 5, paragraph 21. The pain progressed during the night and when he woke in the morning the pain in his back was severe.[5] He reported the incident to his manager, Jason Pecko, and saw a general practitioner, Dr Mor, referred by TNT. He was certified as unfit for work to 17 April 2013, and thereafter fit for suitable duties.[6][5] Exhibit 5, paragraph 22.[6] Exhibit 5, paragraphs 23 & 24. Mr Arumugam was cross-examined on the circumstances of his injury in April 2013. Jason Pecko, his former manager, also gave evidence and was cross-examined. Mr Pecko said that work in the repack area was not physically demanding. It usually involved attaching one end of a roll of cling wrap to a pallet and walking round the pallet until the wrapping was complete. He said there was some but not a lot of bending involved. He agreed there was some lifting involved in stacking or arranging items on the pallet.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 30 October 2014, the decision dated 4 September 2014 was affirmed. As I have said, Mr Arumugam has not returned to work for TNT in any capacity or found other employment. Medical evidence The respondent relied primarily on the evidence of Dr English. The applicant relied primarily on the evidence of another orthopaedic surgeon, Dr Malcolm Wallace, and to a lesser extent, on reports of a general practitioner, Dr David Copeland. The specialists, as well as providing written reports, gave oral evidence, concurrently, by telephone. In his initial report, dated 31 July 2014, Dr English said Mr Arumugam had described onset of lower back pain in approximately 2009, which he associated with his duties at work, and since 2013 a gradual increase in symptoms.[8] Dr English considered that by June 2014 the aggravation caused by the injury in April 2013 had ceased, and Mr Arumugam was fit for non-manual or light work.[9] Dr English considered it was reasonable for Mr Arumugam to continue to take analgesics.[10][8] Exhibit 2, page 230-1. [9] Exhibit 2, page 237.[10] Exhibit 2, page 238. In questioning Dr English maintained his assessment that Mr Arumugam had temporarily aggravated pre-existing underlying degenerative changes affecting his lower spine, and that the effects of the injury in April 2013 had ceased by mid-2014. TNT, in support of Dr English’s view, also relied on other reports and findings. These included a CT scan of Mr Arumugam’s lower back on 23 April 2013 suggestive, it was said, of a long-standing condition, and no disc protrusion or spinal stenosis.[11] [11] Exhibit 1, page 24. TNT relied on a report of Dr William Ryan, orthopaedic surgeon, dated 18 July 2013, which described Mr Arumugam as experiencing a number of episodes of back pain since 2009, usually brought about by bending and twisting, after which he had returned to work in two to six weeks.[12] [12] Exhibit 2, page 318. Reliance was also placed on a report, dated 3 September 2013, of Dr JR Ashwell, orthopaedic surgeon. Dr Ashwell reported that Mr Arumugam had gradual onset of lower back pain and discomfort from 2009, and had a number of episodes of low back pain in the left lumber spine. Dr Ashwell considered Mr Arumugam had a soft tissue ligamentous injury to the thoracic spine area.[13] [13] Exhibit 2, page 278. These reports and others, together with Mr Arumugam’s own descriptions from time to time of his condition or symptoms, were referred to in support of Dr English’s view that Mr Arumugam had a history of exacerbating a pre-existing back condition which resolved in time, and that the injury in April 2013 had similarly resolved by mid-2014. Dr Wallace examined Mr Arumugam in July 2015. He noted Mr Arumugam’s reports of a long history of intermittent lower back pain. Mr Arumugam told Dr Wallace he suffered lower back pain which was worse with bending, lifting and twisting, and radiated to his left lower limb in a non-sciatic radiation. The pain was said to be worse with sitting and standing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As to medical expenses, I find that the medication Mr Arumugam described, Lyrica, Panadeine Forte, and some analgesics, are reasonable in terms of his on-going work-related condition. Some physiotherapy and acupuncture is also reasonable. Conclusion The reviewable decision dated 30 October 2014 and the two reviewable decisions dated 18 December 2015 are set aside and in substitution I find that:1.As at 4 September 2014 and presently, the Applicant continues to suffer the effects of the low back injury on 11 April 2013.2.The Applicant is entitled to compensation under ss 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act1988 in respect of the lower back injury on11 April 2013 from 4 September 2014 to the present time and presently.3.The Applicant is entitled to compensation under s 19(3) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 at 75% of his normal weekly earnings without deduction for AE from 4 September 2014 to the present time, and presently, in respect of his low back injury. 4.The Respondent is liable to pay compensation under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 in respect of the Applicant’s low back condition, which was significantly contributed to by the nature and condition of his employment with the Respondent.5.The Respondent is liable to pay compensation under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 in respect of the Applicant’s psychological condition, which was significantly contributed to by his employment with the Respondent. 6.The matter is remitted to the Respondent for calculation of the Applicant’s entitlements as above under ss 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. 7.The Respondent shall pay the Applicant’s legal costs and disbursements in respect of these proceedings under s 67 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act1988.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.