Arndt v Commissioner for Social Housing (Appeal)

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



ARNDT v COMMISSIONER FOR SOCIAL HOUSING (Appeal)  [2018] ACAT 7

AA 12/2017 (AT 49/2016)

Catchwords:              APPEAL – meaning of ‘income’ under the Commissioner for Social Housing rent rebate program – ‘income’ does not include return of a person’s own money from investment in a self-managed superannuation fund – appeal allowed – onus on applicant for rent rebate to satisfy the Commissioner that a payment from a self-managed superannuation fund is (wholly or in part) return of the person’s own money – practice and procedure – application for adjournment of hearing – adjournment refused – importance of determining tribunal proceedings in a timely manner

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 6, 7, 48, 68

Housing Assistance Act 2007 s 19

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)

Social Security Act 1947 (Cth) s 18

Social Security Act 1991 (Cth) s 8

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1992

Veteran’s Entitlement Act 1986 (Cth) s 35

Subordinate

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2009 r 21

Housing Assistance Public Rental Housing Assistance Program 2013 (No 1) cl 9, 11, 25

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994

Cases cited:               AON Risk Services Australia Ltd v ANU [2009] HCA 27

Arndt v Commissioner for Social Housing [2017] ACAT 16
CIC Australia Ltd v ACT Planning and Land Authority, Mainore Pty Ltd and ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal [2013] ACTSC 96
Commissioner of The Australian Federal Police v Kalimuthu [No 3] [2017] WASC 108
Commissioner for Social Housing v Williams [2017] ACAT 53

Davies and Secretary, Department of Family and Community Services [2002] AATA 904
           JW and JE Carter and Secretary, Department of Social Security [1996] AATA 128
Lend Lease Real Estate Investment Ltd v GPT RE Ltd [2006] NSWCA 207
Little v Commissioner for Social Housing [2017] ACAT 11
Mankey v Commissioner for Social Housing [2015] ACAT 76
McLaughlin and Secretary, Department of Family and Community Services [2003] AATA 298
Miller v Commissioner for Social Housing [2017] ACAT 10
Mitchell v News Group Newspapers Ltd [2013] EWCA Civ 1537
Niedorf v Commissioner for Housing [2003] ACTAAT 51
Peach v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] AATA 781
Re Leo Andrew Flanigan and Director-General of Social Security [1984] AATA 284
Re Sydney Herbert Hungerford v Repatriation Commission [1990] AATA 219
Read v Commonwealth [1988] HCA 26
Secretary, Department of Social Security v Brian McLaughlin & Anor [1997] FCA 1456
Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations v Richards [2007] FCA 1710
The Tenant v Commissioner for Social Housing [2016] ACAT 49

List of

Texts/Papers cited:    Pearce and Geddes, Statutory Interpretation in Australia, 8th edition, 2014

Tribunal:                   Presidential Member G McCarthy

Date of Orders:  22 January 2018

Date of Reasons for Decision:         22 January 2018

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          AA 12/2017

BETWEEN:

ROBIN ARNDT

Appellant

AND:

COMMISSIONER FOR SOCIAL HOUSING

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:Presidential Member G McCarthy

DATE:22 January 2018

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

1.Order 1 of the decision under appeal is amended to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Arndt v Commissioner for Social Housing (Appeal) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] ACAT 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Arndt sought judicial review of the Commissioner for Social Housing's decision to refuse her application for a rental rebate. The applicant argued that the Commissioner had wrongly excluded her annual stipend or pension payments from her self-managed superannuation fund from her assessable income. The Commissioner contended that the payments were not income for the purposes of the Housing Assistance Public Rental Housing Assistance Program 2013 (No 1). The dispute came before the Tribunal to determine whether the Commissioner had exercised his discretion correctly and whether the applicant's submissions regarding the interpretation of "income" in the Program were valid.

The primary legal issue was whether the annual stipend or pension payments from the applicant's self-managed superannuation fund constituted income for the purposes of the Program. The Tribunal examined the relevant statutory provisions and the principles of statutory interpretation. It considered whether the payments were income within the ordinary meaning of the term and whether there were any statutory provisions that excluded such payments from the definition of income. The Tribunal also considered whether the applicant's submissions regarding the nature of the payments were persuasive.

The Tribunal found that the Commissioner had failed to properly consider whether the applicant's annual stipend or pension payments from her self-managed superannuation fund constituted income for the purposes of the Program. It held that the payments did constitute income unless the applicant could demonstrate that any part of the payments was a repayment of money she had previously deposited into the fund. The Tribunal held that the Commissioner's decision was therefore flawed and remitted the matter to the Commissioner for re-determination. It also clarified that the Commissioner could regard the payments as income unless the applicant could demonstrate that they were not income for the purposes of the Program.

The Tribunal ordered that the Commissioner's decision be set aside and the matter be remitted for re-determination. It also clarified that the Commissioner could regard the applicant's annual stipend or pension payments from her self-managed superannuation fund as income for the purposes of the Program unless the applicant could demonstrate that any part of the payments was a repayment of money she had previously deposited into the fund.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1. Order 1 of the decision under appeal is amended to read:

The respondent’s decision made on 13 September 2016 is set aside and the applicant’s application for a rental rebate is remitted to the respondent for re-determination.

2. Order 2 of the decision under appeal is amended to read:

In calculating the applicant’s ‘income’ for the purposes of clause 11 of the Housing Assistance Public Rental Housing Assistance Program 2013 (No 1) the respondent may regard the annual stipend or pension the applicant receives from time to time from her self-managed superannuation fund as income, save for any part of the stipend or pension that the applicant demonstrates to the satisfaction of the respondent is a repayment of money that the applicant deposited into the fund.

Background

Background to the litigation

Arndt, the applicant, applied for a rental rebate under the Housing Assistance Public Rental Housing Assistance Program 2013 (No 1) administered by the respondent, Commissioner for Social Housing. The application was initially assessed and subsequently rejected. Arndt appealed this decision, asserting that the respondent had incorrectly calculated her income for the purposes of determining her eligibility for the rebate. The central issue in the appeal was whether the annual stipend or pension Arndt receives from her self-managed superannuation fund should be considered as income for the rebate calculation. Arndt argued that any part of the stipend or pension that was a repayment of money she had deposited into the fund should not be counted as income.

The matter was initially decided by the Social Housing Tribunal, which found against Arndt and dismissed her appeal. Arndt then sought judicial review of the Tribunal's decision in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. The Court of Appeal was asked to review the decision of the original tribunal, focusing on the interpretation of the relevant statutory provisions and the correctness of the Tribunal's application of these provisions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the annual stipend or pension Arndt receives from her self-managed superannuation fund should be regarded as income for the purposes of clause 11 of the Housing Assistance Public Rental Housing Assistance Program 2013 (No 1).
2. If so, whether any part of the stipend or pension that is a repayment of money Arndt deposited into the fund can be excluded from the income calculation.

Held
1. The court held that the annual stipend or pension Arndt receives from her self-managed superannuation fund should be regarded as income for the purposes of clause 11 of the Housing Assistance Public Rental Housing Assistance Program 2013 (No 1).
2. The court further held that if any part of the stipend or pension is a repayment of money Arndt deposited into the fund, that part can be excluded from the income calculation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the first issue by examining the definition of income within clause 11 of the Housing Assistance Public Rental Housing Assistance Program 2013 (No 1). The court found that the definition of income was broad and inclusive, encompassing any money received by the applicant. Given that Arndt's annual stipend or pension from her self-managed superannuation fund constituted money received by her, it fell within the scope of the definition of income. The court thus concluded that the stipend or pension should be regarded as income for the purposes of the program.

In addressing the second issue, the court considered the principle that repayments of one's own money should not be regarded as income. The court found that if the stipend or pension included amounts that represented a repayment of money deposited by Arndt into the fund, those specific amounts should be excluded from the income calculation. The court held that Arndt had the burden to demonstrate to the satisfaction of the respondent that such repayments occurred, allowing for the exclusion of those specific amounts from the income calculation. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that while income derived from a self-managed superannuation fund is to be regarded as income for the purposes of the program, repayments of one's own money can be excluded from the income calculation if properly demonstrated.