FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Light & Wonder, Inc. [2024] FCA 439
File number: NSD 1576 of 2023 Judgment of: NICHOLAS J Date of judgment: 30 April 2024 Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – preliminary discovery – whether order for preliminary discovery should be made – whether documents sought by prospective applicant reasonably required to enable it to decide whether to commence proceeding in the Court against prospective respondents for (inter alia) misuse of confidential information and copyright infringement – significance of proceeding commenced by prospective applicant in United States District Court
Held: order for preliminary discovery made
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 7.23 Cases cited: Alphapharm Pty Ltd v Eli Lilly Australia Pty Limited [1996] FCA 391
George v Rockett (1990) 170 CLR 104
Hooper v Kirella Pty Ltd (1999) 96 FCR 1
Optiver Australia Pty Ltd v Tibra Trading Pty Ltd (2008) 169 FCR 435
Pfizer Ireland Pharmaceuticals v Samsung Bioepis AU Pty Ltd (2017) 257 FCR 62
Division: General Division Registry: New South Wales National Practice Area: Intellectual Property Sub-area: Copyright and Industrial Designs Number of paragraphs: 40 Date of hearing: 17 April 2024 Counsel for the Prospective Applicant: Mr AJL Bannon SC with Mr JM Hennessy SC and Mr CD McMeniman Solicitor for the Prospective Applicant: Gilbert + Tobin Counsel for the Prospective Respondents: Mr EJC Heerey KC with Ms F St John Solicitor for the Prospective Respondents: Jones Day ORDERS
NSD 1576 of 2023 BETWEEN: ARISTOCRAT TECHNOLOGIES AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 001 660 715)
Prospective Applicant
AND: LIGHT & WONDER, INC.
First Prospective Respondent
LNW GAMING ANZ PTY LTD (ACN 001 660 537)
Second Prospective Respondent
EMMA CHARLES
Third Prospective Respondent
LLOYD SEFTON
Fourth Prospective Respondent
ORDER MADE BY:
NICHOLAS J
DATE OF ORDER:
30 APRIL 2024
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The prospective respondents give discovery of the following documents pursuant to r 7.23 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (“the FCR”):
1.1Any documents that constitute or record any mathematical rules, formulae or models (including any associated pay tables, reel strips and weighting tables) used to create or implement Dragon Train Chi Lin Wins and Dragon Train Forever Emperor or any of their features.
1.2Any documents or material related to Dragon Link, Lightning Link or other Aristocrat games copied, transferred, removed or exported in physical or electronic form from Aristocrat or HRG or retained by:
(a)Ms Charles after leaving her employment by Aristocrat; and
(b)Mr Sefton after leaving his employment by Aristocrat.
1.3Any documents created on or after Ms Charles or Mr Sefton commenced providing any services to L&W (whichever is the earlier) by Ms Charles or Mr Sefton referring to Dragon Link, Lightning Link or any features of Dragon Link or Lightning Link.
1.4Any photographs or video files saved at the following file path: M:\Gaming\syd-common\Lloyd Sefton\by game, as referred to in part in an electronic message exchange between Emma Charles and Yuri Leontiev dated…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Light & Wonder,... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] FCA 439
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court made an order for preliminary discovery, directing the respondents to provide certain documents within 28 days. The documents included mathematical rules, formulae and models used to create or implement Dragon Train, any documents or material related to Dragon Link or Lightning Link copied or retained by former employees, and any documents created by former employees referring to Dragon Link or Lightning Link. The court also imposed confidentiality obligations on the parties receiving the documents, stipulating that the documents could only be used for the purposes of the proceeding and could not be disclosed to the public. The court ordered that the applicant pay the respondents' costs unless it commenced a substantive proceeding within 60 days of the respondents complying with the order.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The prospective respondents give discovery of the following documents pursuant to r 7.23 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (“the FCR”):
1.1 Any documents that constitute or record any mathematical rules, formulae or models (including any associated pay tables, reel strips and weighting tables) used to create or implement Dragon Train Chi Lin Wins and Dragon Train Forever Emperor or any of their features.
1.2 Any documents or material related to Dragon Link, Lightning Link or other Aristocrat games copied, transferred, removed or exported in physical or electronic form from Aristocrat or HRG or retained by:
(a) Ms Charles after leaving her employment by Aristocrat; and
(b) Mr Sefton after leaving his employment by Aristocrat.
1.3 Any documents created on or after Ms Charles or Mr Sefton commenced providing any services to L&W (whichever is the earlier) by Ms Charles or Mr Sefton referring to Dragon Link, Lightning Link or any features of Dragon Link or Lightning Link.
1.4 Any photographs or video files saved at the following file path: M:\Gaming\syd-common\Lloyd Sefton\by game, as referred to in part in an electronic message exchange between Emma Charles and Yuri Leontiev dated 14 September 2022 and produced to Aristocrat by L&W on 3 November 2023 (see Affidavit of John Dominic Lee dated 20 December 2023 at Confidential Annexure JDL-4 [7]), evidencing or recording Dragon Link and/or Lightning Link in operation.
In this order these definitions apply:
L&W means Light & Wonder, Inc. (ARBN 666 710 836) and LNW Gaming ANZ Pty Ltd t/a Light and Wonder (ACN 001 660 537).
Aristocrat means Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Limited (ACN 001 660 715), and includes any abbreviations of that name such as “Acrat”.
document has the same meaning as in the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) and includes without limitation any written documents, drafts, notes, correspondence, invoices, financial records, emails, email attachments, text messages, electronic files and other electronic records of any kind.
Dragon Link means any form of electronic game or gaming machine called “Dragon Link” or any other abbreviations of that game such as “DL” and includes each of the themed games, and any abbreviations of the themed games, known as ‘Silk Road’, ‘Golden Gong’, ‘Peace & Long Life’, ‘Genghis Khan’, ‘Golden Century’, ‘Spring Festival’, ‘Prosperous’, ‘Autumn Moon’, ‘Peacock Princess’ and ‘Panda Magic’.
Dragon Train means any form of electronic game or gaming machine under the name “Dragon Train” or any other abbreviations of that game such as “DT” or “DTX” and includes each of the themed games, and any abbreviations of the themed games, known as ‘Khutulun Battle Princess’, ‘Forever Emperor’, ‘Chi Lin Wins’ and ‘Sun Shots’.
Feature means any additional free game, free spin of certain reels, metamorphosis of the basic game rules or secondary choice necessary to complete a game (except gamble), as defined in the Standard (see Affidavit of Marc David Foodman of 20 December 2023, at Exhibit MDF-1 p130 and Affidavit of Matthew William Deitz of 21 March 2024 at [18]) and includes features such as the Hold & Spin feature.
Lightning Link means any form of electronic game or gaming machine called “Lightning Link” or any other abbreviations of that game such as “LL” and includes each of the themed games, and any abbreviations of the themed games, known as ‘Magic Pearl’, ‘Sahara Gold’, ‘Happy Lantern’, ‘High Stakes’, ‘Best Bet’, ‘Moon Race’, ‘Heart Throb’, ‘Tiki Fire’, ‘Bengal Treasures’ and ‘Wild Chuco’.
Ms Charles means Emma Charles.
Mr Sefton means Lloyd Sefton.
2. Discovery pursuant to order 1 be given in accordance with r 7.25 of the FCR within 28 days or such further period as the Court may allow. Rule 20.18 of the FCR applies to such discovery.
3. The prospective respondents must produce for inspection documents in their control (or the control of any of them) discovered to the prospective applicant pursuant to order 1 subject to order 4 hereof.
4. Documents produced by the prospective respondents pursuant to these orders which are designated by the prospective respondents as “Confidential” (including the contents thereof and information derived or notes taken or reports or other documents generated therefrom) (Confidential Materials):
(a) may only be inspected by or disclosed to:
(i) the external Australian solicitors of record and Australian counsel for the prospective applicant who have first signed an undertaking substantively in the form of Annexure A to this order;
(ii) the administrative, secretarial and litigation support staff of the external Australian solicitors of record and Australian counsel for the prospective applicant to the extent reasonably required in relation to this proceeding (or any substantive proceedings in Australia commenced on the basis of production of documents in this proceeding), provided that those staff have first been made aware of the confidential nature of those documents and the terms of this order;
(iii) any independent experts retained by the prospective applicant in this proceeding (or any substantive proceedings in Australia commenced on the basis of production of documents in this proceeding), provided that:
A. the solicitors for the prospective applicant have first provided the solicitors for the prospective respondents with the name, current position, qualifications and employment history (with a curriculum vitae) of the proposed expert;
B. the prospective respondents have consented to the disclosure of the documents produced pursuant to this order to that expert (such consent not to be unreasonably withheld); and
C. the expert has, prior to disclosure, signed an undertaking substantively in the form of Annexure A to this order and that signed undertaking has been provided to the solicitors for the prospective respondents;
(iv) the Court and its staff and stenographic and video recorders and reporters, provided that reasonable steps have been taken on behalf of the prospective applicant to mark and identify the Confidential Materials as confidential; or
(v) any other person approved in writing by the prospective respondents, or as the Court may order, in each case provided that person has first signed an undertaking substantively in the form of Annexure A to this order;
(b) will not be included in any non-confidential part of any pleading, affidavit or written submissions and will not be open for public inspection, disclosed in open Court or disclosed in an open part of any Court transcript; and
(c) may only be used by or on behalf of the prospective applicant for the purposes of this proceeding (or any substantive proceedings in Australia commenced on the basis of production of documents in this proceeding), including any appeals.
5. The prospective applicant pay the prospective respondents’ costs of the preliminary discovery application unless the prospective applicant commences a substantive proceeding against the prospective respondents in this Court within 60 days of the prospective respondents complying with these orders in which event the costs of the preliminary discovery application shall be costs in the substantive proceeding.
6. Liberty to apply on 3 days’ notice.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Annexure A
CONFIDENTIALITY UNDERTAKING
I, [name], of [company], [position], [address] undertake, subject to any Court order amending or revoking these terms, to Light & Wonder, Inc. and LNW Gaming ANZ Pty Ltd (collectively, L&W) in relation to the documents produced pursuant to the orders made on 30 April 2024 (the Documents), as follows:
1. Without the prior written consent of L&W (which I acknowledge L&W may withhold in its absolute discretion), I will not use the Documents, any part of the Documents or any information contained in the Documents, for any purpose other than:
(a) Federal Court proceedings Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Limited v Light & Wonder, Inc. & Ors (NSD 1576/2023) or any substantive proceedings commenced in Australia on the basis of production of documents in NSD 1576/2023; and
(b) any appeal from either of the proceedings referred to in paragraph 1(a) above,
(collectively, the Proceedings), in each case only in accordance with the terms of this undertaking.
2. I have read the orders made on 30 April 2024 in NSD 1576/2023 (the Order).
3. I may only disclose the Documents, any part of the Documents or any information contained in the Documents:
(a) to the external Australian legal practitioners who are engaged by the prospective applicant in NSD 1576/2023 (Aristocrat) in relation to the Proceedings, provided that, prior to disclosure, they have signed an undertaking in substantively the same terms as this undertaking and that signed undertaking has been provided to the solicitors for the prospective respondents;
(b) to any independent experts retained by or on behalf of Aristocrat, provided that:
(i) the solicitors for the prospective applicant have first provided the solicitors for the prospective respondents with the name, current position, qualifications and employment history (with a curriculum vitae) of the proposed expert;
(ii) the prospective respondents have consented to the disclosure of the documents produced pursuant to the Order to that expert (such consent not to be unreasonably withheld); and
(iii) the expert has, prior to disclosure, signed an undertaking in substantively the same terms as this undertaking and that signed undertaking has been provided to the solicitors for the prospective respondents;
(c) to administrative, secretarial and litigation support staff employed or engaged by the persons referred to in paragraph 2(a) above to the extent reasonably required in relation to the Proceedings, provided such staff have first been made aware of the confidential nature of those documents and the terms of the Order;
(d) to the Court and its staff and stenographic and video recorders and reporters, provided that reasonable steps have been taken on behalf of Aristocrat to mark and identify the Documents or information as confidential; or
(e) to any other person, including a representative of Aristocrat, agreed to by L&W in writing or as ordered by a Court, provided that person has signed an undertaking in substantively the same terms as this undertaking.
4. I will promptly notify the external legal practitioners acting on behalf of L&W (or cause them to be notified) of any breach of this undertaking of which I become aware.
5. To the extent that I have any Documents or any other documents recording or referring to any information contained in any Documents, I will:
(a) use, handle, keep and store those documents in such a manner as will preserve their confidentiality; and
(b) establish and maintain reasonable security measures to safeguard those documents from unauthorised access or use. In particular, I will ensure that those documents are stored in a manner that will ensure that only I and other individuals described in paragraph 3 above will be permitted access to them.
6. This undertaking does not apply to such part of the Documents or information in them:
(a) which has already been disclosed to the public in a way that waives the confidential status of the Document or information otherwise than:
(i) in contravention of a confidentiality undertaking; or
(ii) in circumstances where I am aware or have reason to believe that the disclosure resulted from a breach of an obligation of confidentiality owed by any person to L&W; or
(b) which I am required to disclose under any law, by any order of any government agency, or by the rules of any stock exchange, provided that I provide (or cause to be provided) L&W with reasonable advance notice of such requirement.
7. Within six months of the conclusion of the last of the Proceedings, I will promptly delete/destroy, or cause to be deleted/destroyed, in a secure and confidential manner the Documents or any documents recording or referring to any information contained in the Documents which are in my possession, custody or power, except that the external legal practitioners who are engaged by Aristocrat in relation to the matters the subject of the Proceedings may retain a copy of those documents on their files, provided that the documents continue to be treated in accordance with this undertaking.
8. I acknowledge that my obligations in this undertaking will continue after the deletion/destruction of any documents in accordance with paragraph 7 above.
9. I irrevocably submit to the jurisdiction of the Federal Court of Australia for the purposes of enforcing the terms of this undertaking.
Date: [insert]
Name (please print)
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The prospective respondents further submitted that, if the Court was minded to grant preliminary discovery, the Court “… should exercise its discretion to grant discovery only of what is really necessary for Aristocrat to make its decision”, which would be “significantly narrower than what Aristocrat seeks”.CONSIDERATION At the core of Aristocrat’s concerns is the possibility that its confidential information or copyright works have been embodied or used in the design of Dragon Train. The material voluntarily supplied by L&W to Aristocrat suggests that this may have in fact occurred but stops well short of disclosing whether or not such material was actually used in the design of Dragon Train. In this context, the correctness of the prospective respondents’ assertion that Dragon Train was not the product of copying, but of independent creation, cannot be sensibly assessed by Aristocrat without knowing more about the underlying design of Dragon Train and, in particular, the mathematical rules, formulae and models used to create or implement the game. I consider that Aristocrat is entitled to preliminary discovery of such material for the purpose of assessing whether or not its confidential information may have been used in the design or implementation of Dragon Train. As to the source code, there does not appear to be any reasonable basis to believe that either Ms Charles or Mr Sefton has copied or disclosed source code for Dragon Link or Lightning Link. In particular, there is nothing in the evidence that would incline a reasonable person to believe that they may have copied or disclosed source code. For that reason, I am not persuaded that the prospective respondents should be required to produce the source code for Dragon Train. Of course, it would be open to Aristocrat to seek discovery of source code in the substantive proceeding (if commenced) if there then exists reason to believe that the prospective respondents have directly or indirectly reproduced Aristocrat’s source code. So far as the US proceeding is concerned, I do not accept the prospective respondents’ submission that it shows Aristocrat already has sufficient information with which to make its decision to commence a proceeding in this Court. The evidence relied on by Aristocrat includes a copy of a motion (Ex A) filed by L&W in the US proceeding on or about 9 April 2024 seeking to have Aristocrat’s complaint dismissed. In their motion L&W assert at p 13:Aristocrat’s speculative allegations are also wholly insufficient to plausibly allege that any L&W Defendant knowingly used Aristocrat’s trade secrets. Like acquisition, Aristocrat offers no allegations regarding how or when L&W supposedly “used” its trade secrets … Aristocrat’s only circumstantial allegations of “use” are that L&W’s Dragon Train games “feel” “similar” to Aristocrat’s Dragon Link games, and that “L&W could only have achieved this degree of similarity with Dragon Link’s gameplay by use of Aristocrat’s trade secrets.” … But circumstantial allegations regarding product similarity, even if true, do not support a reasonable inference that L&W used Aristocrat’s trade secrets to develop its Dragon Train product, particularly where Aristocrat acknowledges that L&W has been developing competing casino games for decades … In any event, Aristocrat fails to plausibly allege that, at the time of use, each L&W Defendant knew or had reason to know that knowledge of the trade secret was derived through improper means, and instead, merely recites the elements of a trade secret claim. (Footnote and citations omitted)