Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Acres Gaming, Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

OFFICIAL NOTICE

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Application  :          No. 752636 in the name of Acres Gaming, Inc.

Title:          Method of Operating Networked Gaming Devices

Action:          Request of an extension of time to serve evidence in support of an opposition by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd

Decision:          Issued  30 November 2004.

Abstract

Extension granted.

The evidence relates to matters that are only partly particularised.  Explanation of delay and significance of evidence considered with regard to that part of the evidence.  Extension determined in line with the public interest.

PATENTS ACT 1990

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re:Patent Application No. 752636 by Acres Gaming, Inc., and a request for an extension of time to serve evidence in support of an opposition by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd

BACKGROUND

  1. Patent application 752636 in the name of Acres Gaming, Inc. (hereafter referred to as Acres) was advertised accepted on 26 September 2002.  A notice of opposition was filed by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd (hereafter referred to as Aristocrat) on 24 December 2002.  The time for serving evidence in support has been extended until 24 September 2004 without objection.  Acres has objected to the latest request to extend the time for service of evidence in support to 24 December 2004.  The matter was heard in Canberra on 16 November 2004.  Acres did not appear, and filed written submissions prior to the hearing.  Aristocrat was represented by Mr Charles Berman, patent attorney of F B Rice & Co, Sydney.

    The previous extensions

  2. Evidence in support was originally due to be served by 24 June 2003.  A first extension was given to 24 September 2003.  Partial evidence was served on 24 September 2003 (in the form of a declaration by Charles Berman, which introduces into evidence a copy of one of the documents particularised in the statement of grounds and particulars).  Further extensions were given to 24 December 2003, 24 March 2004, 24 June 2004 and 24 September 2004.  Acres did not object to any of these extensions.  The latest extension would take the time for serving evidence in support to 24 December 2004.

  3. The reasons for the various extensions seem to relate to difficulties in locating expert witnesses.  The first extension stated that a potential (unnamed) witness had been identified.  The second extension said a further potential witness (Mr Gosden) had been identified.  The third extension stated that Mr Gosden was very busy.  The fourth extension stated that “further time is required”.  The fifth extension merely referred to “unexpected delays”.

    The present extension

  4. The application for extension of time gives the reason for the extension as:

    “With reference to the Opponent’s earlier application for an extension of time, the Opponent continues to diligently pursue its preparation of evidence in respect of this matter.  As indicated in the previous application for an extension of time, the Opponent encountered unexpected delays.  These delays related to locating a suitable witness for the matter.  The Opponent has…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Acres Gaming, In... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] APO 31
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd applied for an extension of time to serve evidence in support of an opposition to patent application 752636 in the name of Acres Gaming, Inc. The application was heard by a delegate of the Commissioner of Patents, Dr. Barker, on 16 November 2004. Acres did not appear and filed written submissions prior to the hearing. Aristocrat was represented by Mr. Charles Berman, a patent attorney from F B Rice & Co, Sydney.

The legal issues the court had to decide were whether the reasons for the delay in serving evidence were satisfactory, whether the evidence was likely to be significant, and whether the public interest favoured granting an extension of time. The court considered the history of the opposition, the reasons for the delay, the nature and significance of the evidence, and the interests of the parties and the public.

The court found that the delay was due to difficulties in locating an expert witness, which was a satisfactory explanation. The evidence was likely to be significant because it related to matters that were partly particularised and common general knowledge. The interests of Aristocrat and Acres were opposed, but the public interest favoured granting an extension of time. The court allowed an extension of time until 24 December 2004 for Aristocrat to serve evidence in support, and awarded costs against Aristocrat.

The final orders were that Aristocrat be granted an extension of time until 24 December 2004 to serve evidence in support, and that costs be awarded against Aristocrat.

Background

Background to the litigation

Patent application 752636 by Acres Gaming, Inc. was advertised as accepted on 26 September 2002. Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd filed a notice of opposition to this patent application on 24 December 2002. The deadline for Aristocrat to serve evidence in support of its opposition was initially set for 24 June 2003, but was subsequently extended multiple times. The latest extension sought by Aristocrat would push the deadline to 24 December 2004. The reasons for the various extensions related to difficulties in locating expert witnesses. Aristocrat had identified three potential witnesses, but the first two were unable to provide evidence due to conflicts of interest and being too busy, respectively. The third expert, Clive Davies, had recently agreed to assist Aristocrat and required briefing on the matter. Acres objected to the latest extension, noting the history of delays in serving evidence.

The matter came before a Delegate of the Commissioner of Patents regarding Aristocrat's request for an extension of time to serve evidence in support of its opposition to Acres' patent application 752636. The Delegate heard the matter on 16 November 2004, with Aristocrat represented by Mr Charles Berman, patent attorney of F B Rice & Co, Sydney. Acres did not appear but filed written submissions prior to the hearing. The Delegate issued a decision on 30 November 2004, granting the extension of time for Aristocrat to serve evidence in support of its opposition.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Delegate should grant an extension of time for Aristocrat to serve evidence in support of its opposition to the patent application?
2. If an extension should be granted, what are the appropriate terms and conditions for the extension?

Held
1. The Delegate should grant an extension of time for Aristocrat to serve evidence in support of its opposition to the patent application.
2. The appropriate terms and conditions for the extension are that Aristocrat must serve all evidence in support by 24 December 2004.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Delegate, Dr. S.D. Barker, determined that an extension of time should be granted to Aristocrat for serving evidence in support of its opposition to the patent application by Acres Gaming, Inc. The decision was based on a consideration of several factors including the explanation for the delay, the nature and significance of the evidence, and the public interest in resolving the opposition on its merits. The Delegate noted that the reasons for the extension, while initially incomplete, became clearer during the hearing, and the difficulties in locating a suitable expert witness were deemed reasonable. The evidence that Aristocrat intended to submit was found to be relevant and potentially significant, especially as it pertained to matters already referenced in the opposition's particulars. The interests of the parties and the public interest were balanced, leading to the conclusion that the extension was warranted. The Delegate also specified that all evidence must be finalised by 24 December 2004. In terms of costs, the Delegate ruled that Acres, the applicant, should be awarded costs against Aristocrat for their reasonable objection to the extension.

In arriving at this decision, the Delegate applied principles established in prior case law, including the discretionary nature of granting extensions under regulation 5.10, the importance of a satisfactory explanation for the delay, and the significance of the evidence in the context of the public interest and the merits of the opposition. The Delegate also considered the effect of the delay on the administration of the Patent Office and the interests of all parties involved. The decision followed the precedent set by Burchett J in Ferocem Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Patents and others, aligning with the notion that the granting of an extension is a matter of discretion guided by relevant considerations, rather than strict compliance with procedural requirements.