Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Acres Gaming Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

NOTICE

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Application  :          No. 754689 in the name of Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd

Title:          Slot Machine Game and System with Improved Jackpot Feature

Action:          Request for an extension of time to serve evidence in support of an opposition by Acres Gaming Inc.

Decision:          Issued 17 January 2005           .

Abstract

A satisfactory explanation for the delay was given.  The extension of time was allowed.

Aristocrat was justified in objecting to the current extension, as it appeared to be inconsistent with the reasons given for previous extensions of time and as little progress appeared to have been made.  Nevertheless, a satisfactory explanation for the delay in the current extension was given. 

Furthermore considering the nature of the evidence that is intended to be served, it was considered to be in the public interest to allow the extension.  In particular, it was considered that the proposed Dimond declaration could address the issues raised in the statement of grounds and particulars.

Acres was considered to be less than diligent in completing its evidence in support and consequently, no award of costs was made.

PATENTS ACT 1990

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re:Patent Application No.754689 by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd and a request for an extension of time in which to serve evidence in support of an opposition by Acres Gaming Inc.   

BACKGROUND

  1. Patent application 754689 in the name of Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd (hereafter referred to as Aristocrat) was advertised accepted on 21 November 2002.  Acres Gaming, Inc (hereafter referred to as Acres) filed a notice of opposition on 21 February 2003.  The time for serving evidence in support had been extended until 21 November 2004 without objection. Aristocrat has objected to the latest request to extend the time for service of evidence in support to 21 January 2005. 

  2. The matter was heard in Canberra on 16 December 2004.  Boris Golja, patent attorney of Wray & Associates, who appeared by telephone, represented Acres.  Mr Chris Owens, patent attorney of F B Rice & Co, Sydney represented Aristocrat.  Both parties filed written submissions prior to the hearing.

    Previous extensions

  3. Evidence in support was due to be filed by 21 August 2003.  Further extensions were given on 21 November 2003, 21 February 2004, 21 May 2004, 21 August 2004 and the last was given on 21 November 2004.  Partial evidence in support containing the patent specifications that were particularised in the statement of grounds and particulars (herein after referred to as SGP) was filed on 21 May 2004.  Aristocrat did not object to any of the previous extensions.

    Current extension

  4. In the current extension, an unnamed expert has being retained to provide evidence of common general knowledge.  As yet the expert has not had the time within which to provide this evidence.  The expert is also involved in another opposition and has being required to spend time abroad.  Further, the expert witness has been unavailable for six…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Acres Gaming Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] APO 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Acres Gaming Inc is a case where the court was asked to decide whether Acres Gaming Inc should be granted an extension of time to serve evidence in support of its opposition to a patent application filed by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd. The dispute arose as Acres had already been granted several extensions of time to serve its evidence in support, and Aristocrat argued that Acres had not made sufficient progress in preparing its evidence. The court was required to decide whether the extension of time should be granted, and if so, whether any costs should be awarded. The court's reasoning was based on the principles established in previous cases, such as Ferocem Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Patents, A Goninan & Co Ltd v Commissioner of Patents, and National Starch & Chemical Company v Commissioner of Patents. These cases established that the power to grant an extension of time is discretionary and that relevant considerations include the explanation of the delay, the public interest, and the interests of the parties involved. In this case, the court found that Acres had provided a satisfactory explanation for the delay in serving its evidence in support, and that it was in the public interest to allow the extension as the evidence was likely to be relevant to the opposition proceedings. The court also noted that Acres had been less than diligent in completing its evidence in support and therefore made no award of costs. The final orders of the court were to allow the extension of time for Acres to serve its evidence in support and to make no award of costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Patent application 754689 by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd was advertised as accepted on 21 November 2002. Acres Gaming Inc filed a notice of opposition on 21 February 2003. The initial deadline for serving evidence in support was 21 August 2003, but multiple extensions were granted over the following 18 months, with the last extension expiring on 21 November 2004. Despite these extensions, Acres had only filed partial evidence containing patent specifications particularised in the statement of grounds and particulars. Aristocrat objected to the latest request for an extension to 21 January 2005, arguing that Acres had not made sufficient progress and had not identified a second expert witness. Acres argued that it was difficult to obtain expert witnesses in the gaming industry and that the applicant's high profile made it challenging to find impartial experts. Acres also sought to retain a second expert as a precaution in case the first expert became unavailable.

The matter came before the Delegate of the Commissioner of Patents for a decision on whether to grant an extension of time for Acres Gaming Inc to serve evidence in support of its opposition to Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd's patent application 754689. Both parties filed written submissions and appeared at a hearing in Canberra on 16 December 2004. The Delegate considered the submissions and the history of previous extensions before issuing a decision on 17 January 2005.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether a satisfactory explanation was given for the delay in serving evidence in support of the opposition.
2. Whether it is in the public interest to allow the extension of time to serve evidence in support of the opposition.
3. Whether the interests of other parties involved in the opposition are adversely affected by allowing the extension of time.
4. Whether the interests of the party seeking the extension outweigh the interests of other parties involved in the opposition.

Held
1. The court found that a satisfactory explanation was given for the delay in serving evidence in support of the opposition.
2. The court concluded that it is in the public interest to allow the extension of time to serve evidence in support of the opposition.
3. The court determined that the interests of other parties involved in the opposition are not adversely affected by allowing the extension of time.
4. The court found that the interests of the party seeking the extension outweigh the interests of other parties involved in the opposition.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The delegate of the Commissioner of Patents considered the application for an extension of time to serve evidence in support of the opposition, filed by Acres Gaming Inc. The delegate assessed the circumstances surrounding the delay in serving evidence, taking into account the principles established in relevant case law and the Patents Regulations. The delegate found that Acres provided a satisfactory explanation for the delay, as the expert witness had been unable to allocate the required time to undertake and complete the task due to various factors, including normal occupational duties and periods of unavailability. The delegate also considered the public interest in determining a serious opposition on its merits, noting that the evidence sought to be adduced by the expert witness was relevant to the opposition proceedings. Furthermore, the delegate found that the interests of the party seeking the extension outweighed the interests of other parties involved in the opposition. Consequently, the delegate allowed the extension of time to 21 January 2005 for Acres to serve its evidence in support. However, the delegate made no award of costs, considering that little progress had been made in 18 months and that Acres was less than diligent in completing its evidence in support.