Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Acres Gaming, Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

OFFICIAL NOTICE

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Application  :          No. 750775 in the name of Acres Gaming, Inc

Title:          Method for Crediting a Player of an Electronic Gaming Device

Action:          Request for an extension of time to serve evidence in answer to an opposition under section 59 and an objection thereto by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd

Decision:          Issued  07 April 2005.

Abstract

Application for an extension of time to serve evidence in answer allowed to admit key evidence in relation to prior use.

Previous application for an extension of time to serve evidence in answer had also been objected to and allowed.

Consideration given as to whether terms should be placed on the allowance of the extension.  No terms placed on the extension granted, but terms were proposed in relation to a further request for an extension beyond the allowed period.  The further request was filed after the hearing but was based on reasons that were largely known and discussed at the hearing.  Parties given 7 days to make representations on the proposed terms.

PATENTS ACT 1990

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re:Patent Application No. 750775 by       Acres Gaming, Inc; request for an extension of time to serve evidence in answer to an opposition under section 59 and an objection thereto by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd

BACKGROUND

  1. Patent application 750775 in the name of Acres Gaming, Inc. (hereafter referred to as “Acres”) was advertised accepted on 25 July 2002.  The patent application relates to a method for crediting a player of an electronic gaming device.  A notice of opposition was filed by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd (hereafter referred to as “Aristocrat”) on 24 December 2002.  Evidence in support was completed by Aristocrat almost 11 months later on 21 November 2003.

  2. Evidence in answer was initially due on 21 February 2004.  As a result of a number of previous requests for extensions, the time for serving evidence in answer has been extended to 21 February 2005.  The most recent extension, from 21 November 2004 to 21 February 2005, was considered by a delegate of the Commissioner following an objection to the extension by Aristocrat.  Following a hearing on 3 February 2005, the delegate issued his decision on 21 February 2005 – See Acres Gaming, Inc v Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd [2005] APO 6 (21 February 2005). The history of the previous extensions of time to serve evidence in answer is set out in that decision. Despite some observations that the applicant’s conduct was not consistent with that of an applicant diligently preparing their case during an opposition for at least part of the extended period, the delegate granted the further extension to 21 February 2005.

  3. The applicant has applied for a further extension of time from 21 February 2005 to 21 March 2005 in which to serve evidence in answer.  Aristocrat has objected to that extension.

  4. I heard the parties in Canberra on 18 March 2005.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Acres Gaming, In... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] APO 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Acres Gaming, Inc. involves a patent application 750775 in the name of Acres Gaming, Inc., which pertains to a method for crediting a player of an electronic gaming device. Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd filed a notice of opposition to the patent application, which led to the need for an extension of time to serve evidence in answer to the opposition. The matter was heard by a delegate of the Commissioner of Patents, with the applicant represented by Mr. Boris Golja, patent attorney of Wray & Associates, Perth, and the opponent represented by Mr. Paul Savage, patent attorney of Freehills, Sydney. The legal issues included the relevance of the evidence to be served, the time taken to serve the evidence, and the balancing of the interests of the parties and the public interest in the expeditious disposal of matters in the Patents Office.

The delegate of the Commissioner of Patents considered the evidence to be served in answer to the opposition. The applicant indicated it intended to serve two declarations by their expert, one relating to prior use and the other to other prior art cited in the statement of grounds and particulars. The delegate was satisfied that the evidence to be served in relation to prior use was likely to be highly relevant to the opposition, while the potential relevance of the declaration on other prior art was less apparent but still relevant. The delegate also considered the time taken to serve the evidence, noting that the applicant had previously requested and been granted extensions of time. The applicant's reasons for the extension appeared to largely reiterate information known from the previous hearing, but the delegate considered that progress had been made in preparing the evidence. The delegate decided to allow an extension of time to 23 March 2005 to admit the key evidence served and filed on that date, and proposed terms for a further extension to 21 April 2005.

The final orders of the court were that an extension of time to 23 March 2005 should be allowed to admit the key evidence of Mr. Spencer served and filed on that date, and that the proposed terms for a further extension to 21 April 2005 should be subject to the applicant completing its service of evidence in answer by that date. If the applicant could not complete its second declaration by 21 April 2005, it would be precluded from relying on that evidence in the substantive opposition. The parties were invited to make representations or request to be heard in relation to the latest request for an extension of time within 7 days of the date of the decision. The delegate made no award of costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a patent application 750775 in the name of Acres Gaming, Inc. (Acres) for a method for crediting a player of an electronic gaming device. The patent application was advertised as accepted on 25 July 2002. On 24 December 2002, Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd (Aristocrat) filed a notice of opposition against the patent application. Evidence in support of the opposition was completed by Aristocrat on 21 November 2003. Evidence in answer to the opposition was initially due on 21 February 2004. Due to previous requests for extensions, the deadline for serving evidence in answer was extended to 21 February 2005. A delegate of the Commissioner allowed a further extension from 21 November 2004 to 21 February 2005, following a hearing and an objection by Aristocrat. Despite some observations about the applicant's conduct, the extension was granted. The applicant has now applied for another extension from 21 February 2005 to 21 March 2005 to serve evidence in answer, which Aristocrat has objected to.

The matter before the delegate of the Commissioner of Patents is an application for an extension of time to serve evidence in answer to an opposition filed by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd against Acres Gaming, Inc.'s patent application 750775. The application was heard by the delegate on 18 March 2005. Both parties, represented by their respective patent attorneys, presented written submissions and arguments. The delegate considered the application, taking into account previous decisions and extensions related to this patent application. The delegate's decision on the extension was issued on 07 April 2005.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the delegate should allow an extension of time for Acres Gaming, Inc. to serve evidence in answer to the opposition by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd.
2. If so, whether any terms should be imposed on the granting of the extension.

Held
1. The delegate allowed an extension of time for Acres Gaming, Inc. to serve evidence in answer to the opposition by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd.
2. No terms were imposed on the granting of the initial extension, but terms were proposed for a subsequent extension request.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The delegate considered whether to grant an extension of time for Acres Gaming, Inc. to serve evidence in answer to the opposition by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd. The decision was based on the relevance of the evidence to be served and the time taken to serve the evidence. The delegate noted that the evidence relating to prior use of the claimed invention was likely to be highly relevant, and the second declaration might also have some relevance. However, the delegate acknowledged that Acres Gaming, Inc. had not been as diligent as it should have been in completing the evidence.

The delegate balanced the interests of the parties and the public interest, considering the potential for unnecessary delays and the ability of the applicant to file a divisional application. The delegate also considered the ability of the applicant to meet a fixed date for the start of the trial. The delegate decided to allow an extension of time to 23 March 2005 to serve evidence in answer, admitting the key evidence of the second expert. However, the delegate proposed terms for a further extension to 21 April 2005, requiring Acres Gaming, Inc. to complete its service of evidence by that date. The parties were given 7 days to make representations on the proposed terms.

The delegate also considered the costs of the proceedings. The delegate concluded that each party should bear their own costs, making no award of costs.