Acres Gaming, Inc v Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

OFFICIAL NOTICE

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Application  :          No. 750775 in the name of Acres Gaming, Inc.

Title:          Method for Crediting a Player of an Electronic Gaming Device

Action:          Request for an extension of time to serve evidence in answer to an opposition by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd.

Decision:          Issued  21 February 2005

Abstract

The extension was allowed in spite of a lack of an adequate explanation by the applicant for the delays in the evidence in answer period before the third extension.

Since the third extension, the applicant had faced difficulties with the availability of a first expert. A second alternative expert was engaged and significant progress was made.

Given the nature of the evidence that is intended to be served, it was considered to be in the public interest to allow the extension.

Although the extension was allowed, Acres was found to be less than diligent in completing its evidence in answer. Consequently, no award of costs was made.

PATENTS ACT 1990

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re:Patent Application No. 750775 by Acres Gaming, Inc., and a request for an extension of time to serve evidence in answer to an opposition by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd.       

BACKGROUND

History

  1. Patent application 750775 in the name of Acres Gaming, Inc. (hereafter referred to as Acres) was advertised accepted on 25 July 2002. A notice of opposition was filed by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd (hereafter referred to as Aristocrat) on 24 December 2002. Evidence in support was completed by Aristocrat after three unopposed extensions on 21 November 2003. 

  2. Evidence in answer was initially due on 21 February 2004. The time for serving evidence in answer has already been extended to 21 November 2004 following three extension of time applications. Aristocrat has now objected to the fourth extension of time for service of evidence in answer to 21 February 2005. 

  3. No evidence in answer has been served by the Applicant as yet.

  4. The matter was heard in Canberra on 3 February 2005.  Mr. Boris Golja appeared by telephone on behalf of Acres and filed written submissions prior to the hearing.  Mr John Dower, patent attorney of Freehills, Sydney, represented Aristocrat and also provided written submissions at the hearing.

The previous extensions

  1. The first three extension of time applications were brief and scant on detail as follows:

  • The first extension application stated that “a review and assessment of the evidence in support has commenced but not yet completed”. 

  • The second extension application stated that “the review and assessment of the prior art and statutory declarations forming the opponent’s evidence in support are continuing”. 

  • The third extension application stated that “The review and assessment of the prior art and statutory declarations of the opponent’s evidence in support has progressed and a strategy to address the evidence in support in the applicant’s evidence in answer is being undertaken. This will require the applicant’s evidence to be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Acres Gaming, Inc v Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] APO 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Acres Gaming, Inc. sought an extension of time to serve its evidence in answer to an opposition lodged by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd against Acres' patent application. The dispute was heard by a delegate of the Commissioner of Patents. The central legal issue was whether the Commissioner should grant a fourth extension of time for Acres to serve its evidence in answer.

The court found that while Acres had not provided an adequate explanation for the delays in serving evidence in answer prior to the third extension, the reasons provided for the delays since the third extension were more satisfactory. Acres had faced difficulties in securing the availability of an expert witness and had only recently engaged a second expert who had made significant progress. The nature of the evidence intended to be served, particularly expert declarations addressing prior art and prior use allegations, was significant for the opposition proceedings. The court balanced the public interest in determining the opposition on its merits against the detrimental effect of the delays on the administration of the Patent Office and Aristocrat's interests. The court concluded that allowing the extension was in the public interest, as it would enable Acres to complete its evidence in answer and address the opposition on its merits.

In conclusion, the court allowed the extension of time for Acres to serve its evidence in answer but did not award costs to either party, finding Acres to be less than diligent in completing its evidence in answer. The final order allowed Acres until 21 February 2005 to serve its evidence in answer.

Background

Background to the litigation

Patent application No. 750775, owned by Acres Gaming, Inc., was advertised accepted on 25 July 2002. Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd filed a notice of opposition against the patent application on 24 December 2002. Evidence in support of the opposition was completed by Aristocrat on 21 November 2003. The deadline for Acres to serve evidence in answer was initially set for 21 February 2004 but was extended three times, with the latest extension being requested until 21 February 2005. Acres has not yet served any evidence in answer. The matter was heard in Canberra on 3 February 2005, where Mr. Boris Golja represented Acres and Mr. John Dower, a patent attorney from Freehills, Sydney, represented Aristocrat.

The case involves a request for an extension of time to serve evidence in answer to an opposition filed by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd against Acres Gaming, Inc.'s patent application No. 750775. The application for the patent was advertised accepted on 25 July 2002, and the opposition was filed on 24 December 2002. The time for serving evidence in answer has been extended three times, with the latest request for an extension being considered. The matter was heard by a Delegate of the Commissioner of Patents on 3 February 2005, with written and oral submissions made by both parties. The decision on the extension of time was issued on 21 February 2005.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant, Acres Gaming, Inc., provided an adequate explanation for the delays in serving evidence in answer to the opposition.
2. Whether it is in the public interest to allow the extension of time to serve evidence in answer.
3. Whether Acres Gaming, Inc., was diligent in completing its evidence in answer and if costs should follow the event.

Held
1. The court allowed the applicant, Acres Gaming, Inc., to provide an adequate explanation for the delays in serving evidence in answer only from the third extension. The explanations provided for the delays before the third extension were found to be unsatisfactory.
2. The court held that it was in the public interest to allow the extension of time to serve evidence in answer. This was based on the nature and significance of the evidence that Acres intended to adduce, which was crucial to their defence.
3. The court found Acres Gaming, Inc., to be less than diligent in completing its evidence in answer, particularly before the third extension. As a result, the court decided not to award costs to either party.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The delegate of the Commissioner of Patents, Jagdish Bokil, allowed the fourth extension of time for Acres Gaming, Inc., to serve evidence in answer to the opposition by Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd. Despite Acres' unsatisfactory explanations for the delays before the third extension, the delegate found the reasons provided since the third extension to be satisfactory. The delegate noted that the applicant had faced difficulties in engaging an expert witness and had only recently engaged a second expert who was making significant progress. The delegate considered the public interest in determining the opposition on its merits, the significance of Acres' intended evidence, and the interests of both parties. The delegate concluded that the public interest and Acres' opportunity to present their evidence outweighed Aristocrat's interest in a speedy resolution. The delegate also emphasized that any future extension would require a satisfactory explanation for delays. Costs were not awarded to either party due to the concerns raised by both sides regarding the handling of the case.