Arc Engineering Company Pty Ltd v Rendan Holdings Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read
68 CLR 221

ENGINEERING COMPANY PRO-

PRIETARY LIMITED

RENDAN HOLDINGS LIMITED Patent " Convention " application-Opposition Want of novelty-Prior publica-

tion-British specification for same invention published in Australia before Australian application-Patents Act 1903-1935 (No. 21 of 1903-No. 16 of 1935), 88. 56 (e), (f), 121-Patents, Trade Marks, Designs and Copyright (War MELBOURNE, Powers) Act 1939 (No. 66 of 1939), S. 9.

On an application under S. 121 of the Patents Act 1903-1935 for the grant Latham C.J., of a patent for an invention in respect of which an application has already McTiernan and been made in another country to which sub-s. 1 of the section applies, sub-s. 2 precludes an opponent from relying on publication or use in Australia between the date of the application in the other country and the date of the application APPEAL.

On 18th March 1941 Rendan Holdings Ltd. lodged at the Patents Office an application for a patent for an invention under S. 121 of the Patents Act 1903-1935. The applicant had applied in England on 18th January 1939 for a patent for the same invention, and the British specification was published in Australia on 7th November 1940. The Australian application was opposed by A.R.C. Engineering Co. Pty. Ltd. on the grounds of want of novelty and prior publication, the notice of opposition stating that these grounds were based solely on the publication in Australia (after the date of the British applica- tion and before the date of the Australian application) of the appli- cant's British specification. The period of twelve months limited by S. 121 (1) of the Patents Act had expired before the Australian application, but the time was extended by the Commissioner under

68 CLR 222

S. 9 of the Patents, Trade Marks, Designs and Copyright (War Powers)

Act 1939. The Commissioner granted the application, and the opponent appealed to the High Court.

Dean, for the appellant. The object of S. 121 is to give priority over other applicants, but the section does not mean that the applica- tion is to be granted as of course. It must be dealt with as an ordinary application, and it is open to all the usual objections. It can be opposed on any ground mentioned in S. 56. [He referred to Frost on Patent Law and Practice, 4th ed. (1912), vol. 2, p. 313 Romer, Patents and Designs Practice, 2nd ed. (1926), p. 29.] The reference in S. 56 (f) to the date of the application" can only mean the date of the Australian application: This is borne out by SS. 33 3, 38, 42 (b), 64, 67, 69, 86 4. If there is no opposition to an application under S. 121 and a patent is granted, then S. 121 2 applies notwithstanding that there was publication or use before the date of the Australian application, but sub-s. 2 does not apply until the grant has been made. The present case falls within the plain meaning of S. 56, and there is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Arc Engineering Company Pty Ltd v Rendan Holdings Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1943] HCA 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal concerning a patent application made by Rendan Holdings Limited. The application was opposed by A.R.C. Engineering Company Pty Ltd on grounds of want of novelty and prior publication. The core of the dispute centred on the publication of the applicant's British patent specification in Australia before the Australian application was lodged, but after the initial British application date. The applicant had sought an extension of time for their Australian application under the Patents, Trade Marks, Designs and Copyright (War Powers) Act 1939.

The legal issues before the court were whether the grounds of opposition under section 56 of the Patents Act 1903-1935, specifically relating to novelty and prior publication, could be relied upon when the alleged prior publication occurred in Australia between the date of the foreign application and the date of the Australian convention application. The court was required to interpret the interplay between section 121, which governs convention applications, and section 56, which outlines grounds for opposition.

Latham C.J., with whom McTiernan J. agreed, reasoned that section 121 of the Patents Act was intended to place an applicant who had applied for protection in another country in the same position as if they had applied in Australia on the same date. The Chief Justice found that section 121(2) specifically provided that publication or use in Australia during the relevant periods (between the foreign application and the Australian application, and prior to the acceptance of the complete specification) would not invalidate a patent granted under the section. To give this sub-section any practical effect, it must operate to prevent such publications or uses from being grounds for opposition to the grant of the patent. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Arc Engineering Company Pty Ltd lodged an opposition to an application made by Rendan Holdings Limited for a patent under section 121 of the Patents Act 1903-1935. Rendan Holdings had previously applied for a patent for the same invention in England on 18 January 1939 and the British specification was published in Australia on 7 November 1940. Arc Engineering opposed the Australian application on the grounds of want of novelty and prior publication, citing the Australian publication of the British specification as the basis for these objections. The Australian application was lodged on 18 March 1941, after the expiry of the twelve-month period allowed under section 121(1) of the Patents Act but before the grant of a patent. The Commissioner of Patents granted the application and extended the time limit under section 9 of the Patents, Trade Marks, Designs and Copyright (War Powers) Act 1939. Arc Engineering appealed to the High Court, arguing that the opposition on the grounds of prior publication and want of novelty should have been upheld. The Commissioner defended the grant of the patent, arguing that section 121 was intended to give the applicant the same priority as if they had applied in Australia at the same date as their foreign application.

The case of Arc Engineering Company Pty Ltd v Rendan Holdings Limited originated as an application for a patent lodged by Rendan Holdings Limited under Section 121 of the Patents Act 1903-1935, which pertains to convention applications. The application was made on 18 March 1941, following an earlier application for a patent for the same invention filed in England on 18 January 1939. The British specification for the invention was published in Australia on 7 November 1940. Arc Engineering Company Pty Ltd opposed the application on grounds of want of novelty and prior publication, specifically citing the Australian publication of the British specification as occurring between the date of the British application and the Australian application. Despite the expiry of the twelve-month period stipulated in Section 121(1) before the Australian application was made, the time was extended by the Commissioner of Patents under Section 9 of the Patents, Trade Marks, Designs and Copyright (War Powers) Act 1939. The Commissioner granted the application, prompting Arc Engineering Company Pty Ltd to appeal to the High Court. The appeal centred on whether the publication in Australia could invalidate the patent application under the circumstances described. The High Court, in a unanimous decision, dismissed the appeal, holding that the provisions of Section 121 preclude opposition based on publication or use in Australia between the date of the foreign application and the date of the Australian application, thereby upholding the grant of the patent.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the publication in Australia of the applicant's British specification, after the British application date and before the Australian application date, constitutes a prior publication that can be relied upon to oppose the grant of a patent under the Patents Act 1903-1935.

2. Whether Section 56 (e) and (f) of the Patents Act 1903-1935 can be invoked to oppose a "convention application" for a patent when the publication or use relied upon occurred between the date of the foreign application and the date of the Australian application.

3. Whether Section 121 (2) of the Patents Act 1903-1935 precludes opposition to the grant of a patent on the grounds of prior publication or use in Australia during the periods specified in the section.

4. Whether Section 121 of the Patents Act 1903-1935 should be interpreted to allow opposition to a "convention application" based on publications or uses occurring between the foreign application date and the Australian application date.

5. Whether the Commissioner of Patents correctly extended the time for making the Australian application under Section 9 of the Patents, Trade Marks, Designs and Copyright (War Powers) Act 1939.

Held
1. The court concluded that the publication in Australia of the applicant's British specification, after the British application date and before the Australian application date, does not constitute a prior publication that can be relied upon to oppose the grant of a patent under the Patents Act 1903-1935.
2. The court held that Section 56 (e) and (f) of the Patents Act 1903-1935 cannot be invoked to oppose a "convention application" for a patent when the publication or use relied upon occurred between the date of the foreign application and the date of the Australian application.
3. The court found that Section 121 (2) of the Patents Act 1903-1935 precludes opposition to the grant of a patent on the grounds of prior publication or use in Australia during the periods specified in the section.
4. The court concluded that Section 121 of the Patents Act 1903-1935 should not be interpreted to allow opposition to a "convention application" based on publications or uses occurring between the foreign application date and the Australian application date.
5. The court determined that the Commissioner of Patents correctly extended the time for making the Australian application under Section 9 of the Patents, Trade Marks, Designs and Copyright (War Powers) Act 1939.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed several significant issues concerning the application of the Patents Act 1903-1935 and related legislation. Firstly, the court deliberated on whether the publication of the applicant's British specification in Australia, occurring after the British application date and before the Australian application date, constituted a prior publication that could be used to oppose the grant of a patent. The court found that the publication did not affect the applicant's entitlement to the patent, as the publication was made during the specified period under Section 121 of the Patents Act, which precludes such opposition.

Secondly, the court examined whether Sections 56(e) and 56(f) of the Patents Act could be invoked to oppose a "convention application" based on a publication or use that occurred between the foreign application date and the Australian application date. The court concluded that these sections could not be used to oppose the grant of a patent during this period, as Section 121(2) of the Act explicitly prevents such opposition.

Thirdly, the court considered whether Section 121(2) of the Patents Act precluded opposition to the grant of a patent on the grounds of prior publication or use in Australia during the periods specified in the section. The court found that Section 121(2) was designed to ensure that a patent could be granted even if there was publication or use in Australia during these periods, thereby upholding the applicant's right to priority based on the foreign application date.

Fourthly, the court deliberated on whether Section 121 of the Patents Act should be interpreted to allow opposition to a "convention application" based on publications or uses occurring between the foreign application date and the Australian application date. The court held that such opposition was not permissible, as it would undermine the purpose of Section 121, which is to provide priority to applicants who have filed in another country.

Lastly, the court addressed whether the Commissioner of Patents correctly extended the time for making the Australian application under Section 9 of the Patents, Trade Marks, Designs and Copyright (War Powers) Act 1939. The court accepted that the extension was correctly applied and did not affect the applicant's entitlement to the patent.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that Section 121(2) of the Patents Act 1903-1935 precludes opposition to a "convention application" based on prior publication or use in Australia occurring between the date of the foreign application and the date of the Australian application. The court followed prior authority in interpreting Section 121 to ensure that applicants who have filed in another country receive priority, and distinguished from cases that would allow opposition during this period.