Applicant Z v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Applicant Z v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs
[2001] FCA 1714

MIGRATION – application for protection visa – meaning of “persecution” – whether Refugee Review Tribunal applied the correct test – whether Tribunal erred in law in equating persecution with “serious harm”.

Chan v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1989) 169 CLR 379 applied
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Guo (1997) 191 CLR 559 applied

Gersten v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 855 referred to

Kord v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 1163 not followed

APPLICANT Z v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION
AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

W 211 of 2001

CARR J
4 DECEMBER 2001 
PERTH

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W 211 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

APPLICANT Z
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Respondent

JUDGE:

CARR J

DATE OF ORDER:

4 DECEMBER 2001

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The application be dismissed.

2.        The applicant pay the respondent’s costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W 211 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

APPLICANT Z
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND
MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Respondent

JUDGE:

CARR J

DATE:

4 DECEMBER 2001

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application for an order of review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal, made on 14 May 2001, by which the Tribunal affirmed the decision of a delegate of the respondent not to grant a protection visa to the applicant.  The applicant, who is a citizen of Iran, arrived in Australia on 18 October 2000.  On 9 November 2000 he lodged an application for a protection visa with the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs under the Migration Act 1958 (“the Act”).  On 13 December 2000 a delegate of the respondent refused to grant a protection visa and on 15 December 2000 the applicant applied for review of that decision.

    THE APPLICANT’S CLAIMS AND THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION

  2. The applicant’s claims, in summary, were as follows:

    ·     He was, at the time of the Tribunal’s decision, 25 years of age and unmarried.

    ·     He lived in Abadan until about 1980 when he moved with his family to Ahwaz.  He completed his schooling in 1995, then did two years military service, after which he worked for two years as an electrician before going into private business as a trader, an occupation which he pursued for about two years until August 2000.

    ·     He claimed often to have been assaulted by the Basiji because he had long hair and wore tight clothes.  The main problem was his hair.  On one occasion his T shirt was torn because it had a representation of the United Kingdom flag on it.  These problems were especially bad in small towns.  On another occasion, while waiting for a bus with other people, he was grabbed by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Applicant Z v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Aff... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 1714
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Applicant Z v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, Applicant Z, an Iranian national, sought a review of the decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs to refuse his application for a protection visa. The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether Applicant Z had a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of political opinion or other Convention grounds if he were to return to Iran. The court needed to decide whether the applicant’s claims regarding his involvement in demonstrations, his appearance, and his alleged persecution by Iranian authorities were credible and sufficient to establish a well-founded fear of persecution.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Applicant Z had a well-founded fear of persecution if he were to return to Iran. The court had to assess the credibility of the applicant’s evidence and determine whether his claims were consistent and supported by the evidence provided. The court considered whether the applicant’s appearance, alleged harassment by the Basiji, his participation in demonstrations, and his interactions with the police were sufficient to establish a fear of persecution under the Refugee Convention.

The court found that Applicant Z’s claims were not credible and did not establish a well-founded fear of persecution. The court found inconsistencies in the applicant’s evidence regarding the timing and nature of the demonstrations, as well as his alleged participation in them. Additionally, the court found that the harassment the applicant faced due to his appearance did not amount to serious harm or persecution under the Convention. The court also found that there was no evidence to support the applicant’s claim that he was pursued by Iranian authorities for his alleged participation in the demonstrations. Based on these findings, the court concluded that Applicant Z did not have a well-founded fear of persecution if he were to return to Iran.

The court dismissed the application and ordered that Applicant Z pay the respondent’s costs. The court found that the applicant’s claims were not credible and did not establish the requisite fear of persecution under the Refugee Convention. The court’s decision was based on a thorough analysis of the evidence provided and a determination that the applicant’s claims were not supported by the evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

CARR J
The applicant’s claims, in summary, were as follows:· He was, at the time of the Tribunal’s decision, 25 years of age and unmarried.· He lived in Abadan until about 1980 when he moved with his family to Ahwaz. He completed his schooling in 1995, then did two years military service, after which he worked for two years as an electrician before going into private business as a trader, an occupation which he pursued for about two years until August 2000.· He claimed often to have been assaulted by the Basiji because he had long hair and wore tight clothes. The main problem was his hair. On one occasion his T shirt was torn because it had a representation of the United Kingdom flag on it. These problems were especially bad in small towns. On another occasion, while waiting for a bus with other people, he was grabbed by a Basiji who asked him if he was a man or a woman, searched him in front of everyone and made him promise to cut his hair.· He had been unable to find full time work, adding that this was a problem common to many young people. He believed that only people who worked for the government had rights while he and others like him had none. · About five months before leaving Iran he had gone to Abadan to buy something in the market and had become involved in a demonstration against the quality of the water supply in that city. He carried a banner which said “Mayor, we want water”.· When some of the demonstrators broke windows in government departments, the applicant decided to return to the home of a relative where he was staying in Abadan. He then returned to Ahwaz.· A week later his relatives in Abadan sent him a message saying that he had been identified at the demonstration and that they had been told to provide his address in Ahwaz.· The following day he went to Teheran to organise his departure from the country because he knew that his name was on a blacklist.· At the hearing before the Tribunal the applicant said that he had distributed some leaflets which had the name of the Mujahadeen-e-Khalq on the bottom. He put them under windscreen wipers of cars in parking lots and distributed some to peoples’ houses. He had done this at night for two or three nights prior to the demonstration. · During the demonstration he said that he got into an argument with the police as a result of which he insulted Iranian leaders. He was then hit from behind by a policeman.· While he was in Teheran the authorities went to his home in Ahwaz; he knew that his life was in danger so he wanted to leave Iran as quickly as possible. He had a genuine Iranian passport which had been issued to him in Ahwaz. He was nervous when he left the airport, but had no other choice.· When he telephoned his family from Indonesia, his father told him that the authorities had detained him and questioned him about the applicant. THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION Rather than attempt to summarise the Tribunal’s findings and reasons, I set them out below. I have added numbered to the paragraphs to facilitate the references which I make later in these reasons.“FINDINGS AND REASONS1. It was somewhat unclear at the hearing whether Mr Homan was claiming that he was at risk of persecution for a Convention reason because of his appearance. The problems caused by his appearance were mentioned when he was interviewed on 22 October 2000, but not in his protection visa application, nor in the written submissions he provided in support of his application for review. When I raised the issue with him at the hearing, he was clearly more interested in discussing the problems he had faced as a result of his claimed involvement in the Abadan demonstrations, stating that he had not left Iran because of the problems caused by his appearance and that he could have changed his appearance if he wanted to avoid problems. Nonetheless, I have considered whether Mr Homan has a claim against the Convention because he faced problems in Iran because of his appearance. 2. From the information Mr Homan provided, it is clear that the most serious harassment he faced involved nothing more than insults and threats in the street. The fact that he was employed or in business from the time he left school until his departure for Australia, indicates that, apart from this occasional harassment, his appearance did not have a serious impact on his life in Iran. While no doubt distressing for Mr Homan, I do not believe these treatment can be considered serious harm constituting persecution within the terms of the Convention. Furthermore, there is nothing in the evidence before me which suggests that he would be more likely to experience serious harm amounting to persecution because of his appearance if he returned to Iran now than he was in the past. I am therefore not satisfied that Mr Homan has a well-founded fear of experiencing persecution in Iran because of the way he dresses and wears his hair. I also doubt that problems caused by appearance would constitute persecution for a Convention reason as I doubt that the harm suffered could be said to have occurred for any of the reasons contained in the Convention. However, as I do not consider the harm which Mr Homan may face on his return to Iran because of his appearance is serious enough to constitute persecution under the Convention, it is not necessary to reach a conclusion on this question. 3. I do not believe that Mr Homan participated in a demonstration protesting about the quality of the water in Abadan August 2000. In the first place, as noted above, the demonstrations took place in early July, not August. Secondly, I find it unlikely that someone who had had no previous involvement in politics would decide to join a protest about the quality of the water in a city which he only visited occasionally. Third, and most importantly, when he was interviewed on 22 October 2000, Mr Homan said that the police had not taken any action against the demonstrators on the day of the march. This is not correct. As Mr Homan states in his later submissions, a number of demonstrators were shot and killed by police on the day of the protest. I do not believe that Mr Homan would have said there was no police interference in the demonstration when he was interviewed on 22 October 2000 if he had been a participant. I believe that he changed his evidence after he applied for a protection visa because he had obtained more information on the demonstration and knew that his initial story was flawed. 4. And these are not the only problems with Mr Homan's evidence on this matter. His claim that the Mujahadeen-e Khalq organised the demonstrations in Abadan, made for the first time at the hearing, is at odds with the information in the reports which I have read, none of which suggest that the Mujahadeen-e Khalq played any part in the demonstrations (see sources cited above). It is also at odds with his earlier statements. When describing the demonstrators during his interview on 22 October 2000, Mr Homan said that three groups of people were involved, those who were protesting about the water, trouble-makers who robbed shops and informers. It is clear from the evidence regarding the Mujahadeen-e Khalq cited above that those associated with it face a high chance of experiencing problems with the authorities, and it is not plausible that Mr Homan would have failed to mention their role in the demonstration or his own role in distributing leaflets produced by them when describing the participants in the event during this interview. Furthermore, it is not plausible that someone who had never been involved in politics and did not support the Mujahadeen would decide to distribute leaflets bearing the Mujahadeen name in public places such as car parks or to people's homes, an act which would clearly involve a high risk of attracting the attention of the authorities and suffering serious consequences. 5. There was no mention of the alleged attack on Mr Homan by police during the demonstration which lead to him insulting Iran's leaders when he was interviewed on 22 October 2000. On the contrary, as noted above, he said that the police had not inferred with the demonstrators on the day of the demonstration and that he himself had not experienced any problems on that day. It is not plausible that he would have failed to mention that he was hit by police during the demonstration if this had occurred. And he certainly would not have said that the police did not interfere with the marchers if he had heard gunshots and had been hit on the head by a policeman. 6. Finally, even if I accepted that Mr Homan participated in the Abadan demonstration (which I do not), it is not plausible that he would have been identified and pursued across Iran because of this. According to his evidence he was one of about 50,000 participants. As he was not from the local area and had no previous political involvement, I do not believe the would (sic) have been identified by the authorities after the event as a participant. Furthermore, as noted above, information from DFAT indicates that most, if not all, of those arrested at the time of the demonstrations were detained because of their involvement or suspected involvement in violence, and most were not detained for long. None of the sources consulted suggest that there were widespread arrests of ordinary participants after the event. In these circumstances, it is not plausible that the authorities would have any continuing interest in Mr Homan. 7. After considering all of the relevant evidence, I do not accept that Mr Homan distributed leaflets for the Mujahadeen-e Khalq, nor that he participated in a demonstration in Abadan in July or August 2000, nor that he was involved in scuffle with the police during this demonstration during which he insulted Iran's leaders, nor that he was pursued by the authorities because of these alleged events. I am therefore not satisfied that Mr Homan has a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of political opinion because he participated in demonstrations in Abadan in July or August 2000. 8. I am not satisfied that Mr Homan left Iran illegally. In the first place, as I do not accept that he was of interest to the authorities because of his involvement in the Abadan demonstration, there is nothing in the evidence before me which suggests that he was of interest to the authorities for political or any other reason and therefore no reason why he would not have been able to leave Iran legally. Secondly, there is no mention of illegal departure in his 22 October 2000 interview. When his departure was discussed on that occasion he said that he had to leave quickly before he was blacklisted and that he said that he was nervous when he left from the airport, but said nothing about paying bribes to avoid problems. I believe that he would have said something about paying bribes when his departure was discussed during this interview if this claim were true. As I do not accept that Mr Homan left Iran illegally, it follows that I do not accept that he had a well-founded fear of persecution for a Convention reason because of his illegal departure. CONCLUSIONS 9. I am not satisfied that Mr Homan has a well-founded fear of persecution for any of the reasons contained in the Convention. He is therefore not someone to whom Australia has protection obligations under the Refugees Convention and is thus not entitled to a protection visa.” GROUNDS OF THE APPLICATION AND MY REASONING

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: CARR J