Applicant S v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Applicant S v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 1411

MIGRATION – application for order of review of decision of Refugee Review Tribunal affirming decision of respondent’s delegate not to grant a protection visa – applicant claimed fear of persecution in the form of being press-ganged into Taliban militia – whether Tribunal erred in law or fell into jurisdictional error by not considering whether real chance that applicant as a member of a particular social group (able-bodied Afghan males) might be persecuted, by reason of such membership, by forcible conscription into the Taliban militia to fight in the civil war, there being no evidence of any law of general application – whether matter should be remitted with a direction as to the constitution of the Tribunal.

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s 476(1)(b), (c) and (e)

Randhawa v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1994) 52 FCR 437 distinguished
Applicant A v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1997) 190 CLR 225 referred to
Chen Shi Hai v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] HCA 19 followed
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf [2001] HCA 30 applied
Applicant Z v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 881 referred to
Mahmoodi v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 1090 not followed
Wang v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 1599 referred to
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Applicant C [2001] FCA 1332 referred to

APPLICANT S v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND
MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

W 10 of 2001

CARR J
5 OCTOBER 2001
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W 10 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

APPLICANT S
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Respondent

JUDGE:

CARR J

DATE OF ORDER:

5 OCTOBER 2001

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant have leave further to amend his application in terms of the amended minute of proposed further substituted grounds for review filed on 20 July 2001.

2.        The decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal, made on 4 January 2001, be set aside.

3.The matter be remitted to the Tribunal for decision in accordance with the law.

4.In the event that there is a dispute over the constitution of the Refugee Review Tribunal that is to determine the matter, the parties have liberty to apply on that issue.

5.The respondent pay the applicant’s costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W 10 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

APPLICANT S
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND
MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Respondent

JUDGE:

CARR J

DATE:

5 OCTOBER 2001

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application for an order of review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal, made on 4 January 2001, by which the Tribunal affirmed the decision of a delegate of the respondent not to grant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Applicant S v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affai... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 1411
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, a national of Afghanistan, sought a review of the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal, which upheld the respondent's refusal to grant him a protection visa. The applicant arrived in Australia by boat in July 2000 and applied for a protection visa on 25 July 2000. The central issue was whether the applicant's fear of persecution by the Taliban, if returned to Afghanistan, met the criteria for protection under the Refugees Convention. Specifically, the court had to determine if the applicant faced persecution for a Convention reason, such as race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group, or political opinion.

The court examined the applicant's claims and the Tribunal's analysis in detail. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant, a Pashtun of fighting age living under Taliban control, faced a risk of conscription but found that this risk did not constitute persecution under the Convention. The Tribunal noted that while the Taliban's conscription practices were harsh and not internationally condoned, they were not discriminatory for Convention reasons. The Tribunal reasoned that the applicant's fear of conscription was based on general conditions in Afghanistan and not on discriminatory targeting for any of the Convention reasons. The Tribunal also highlighted that the applicant had not shown any evidence of opposition to the Taliban or discriminatory treatment by them. Thus, the Tribunal rejected the applicant's claims of persecution under the Refugees Convention.

The court found that the Tribunal's decision was not in error and granted the application for judicial review. The decision of the Tribunal was set aside, and the matter was remitted to the Tribunal for reconsideration in accordance with the law. Additionally, the respondent was ordered to pay the applicant's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant have leave further to amend his application in terms of the amended minute of proposed further substituted grounds for review filed on 20 July 2001.

2. The decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal, made on 4 January 2001, be set aside.

3. The matter be remitted to the Tribunal for decision in accordance with the law.

4. In the event that there is a dispute over the constitution of the Refugee Review Tribunal that is to determine the matter, the parties have liberty to apply on that issue.

5. The respondent pay the applicant’s costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

CARR J
This is an application for an order of review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal, made on 4 January 2001, by which the Tribunal affirmed the decision of a delegate of the respondent not to grant a protection visa to the applicant. The applicant, who is a national of Afghanistan, arrived in Australia on 11 July 2000 travelling by boat, with the assistance of a people smuggler. On 25 July 2000 the applicant applied for a protection visa. On 5 September 2000 a delegate of the respondent refused to grant him a protection visa. On 8 September 2000 the applicant sought review of the delegate’s decision by the Refugee Review Tribunal.THE APPLICANT’S CLAIMS AND THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The applicant’s claims, in summary, were as follows:· that he is Pashtun by ethnicity, married and comes from a village in a provincial district where his wife, father, mother and four brothers still live; · he and his family have lived under Taliban control for two years;· about three weeks before his departure from Afghanistan, the Taliban sought to conscript him into their forces, but he was able to pay them off; · about a week before the applicant’s departure from Afghanistan, the Taliban came back and again sought to conscript him into their forces. He was able to stall them off by telling them that he needed to speak to his parents;· he then departed immediately from Afghanistan with the assistance of a people smuggler to whom his father paid over US$6,000;· at the time when the Taliban took over the area in which he lived, they detained him and his father on suspicion of hiding weapons. They were held for 20 days, during which they were maltreated, but then released; · the applicant feared that if he were returned to Afghanistan he would be hanged by the Taliban because of his refusal to fight for them and because he would be accused of being a Godless person because he had gone to a Western country; I set out below a summary of the Tribunal’s reasons and reasons. I have added numbers to the paragraphs to facilitate the references which I make later in these reasons.“FINDINGS AND REASONS1. The Applicant has claimed that he fears persecution at the hands of Taliban, the current regime in Afghanistan. 2. He claims that he is the son of the head of his village and that his father was involved in the opposition to the Taliban and that his house was targeted as a result. 3. The Applicant claimed that he was asked to join the Taliban militia but left the country without doing so. 4. In determining this matter I have considered the Applicant's profile and his claims to determine whether or not he is at risk of harm for a Convention reason and whether or not the nature of Taliban’s “conscription” would bring him to the adverse attention of the authorities for failing to serve. The Applicant's Position as the son of the Village leader [In paragraph 5 to 13 of its reasons the Tribunal considered and rejected the applicant’s claims that he had an enhanced political profile because he was the son of the village leader].The Claim to have been imprisoned. [In paragraphs 14 to 19 the Tribunal dealt with the applicant’s claim to have been imprisoned, expressed some doubt on the matter, and found that had he been imprisoned, the Taliban would not have released him (as he stated) if there was any residual doubt that he may have been opposed to them.]The Social Restrictions of Taliban 20. The Applicant claimed that he was forced to grow his beard and not to listen to taped music and other social restrictions. 21. I accept the Applicant's claims in this regard. 22. [Here the Tribunal referred to portion of a US State Department Country Report]. 23. However, this social restrictions (sic) are imposed uniformly and, accordingly there is no discriminatory element and they can not amount to persecution within the ambit of the Convention. 24. The Applicant has made no claims to have rebelled against these restrictions and thus there is no basis to consider that he has a political opinion imputed to him as a consequence. 25. Therefore, while he may feel angry and frustrated by this restrictions (sic) they do not, of themselves, advance his case in regard to persecution for a Convention reason. Conscription or the Applicant 26. Having considered his claims, as discussed above, I find that the Applicant has no enhanced profile and his is the situation of a young Afghan Muslim man of the Pashtun race who has lived under Taliban for about two years without coming to undue interest of the Taliban becoming fearful that he will be recruited as has been the case with many youths. 27. I find his experience in this regard was in a drive for recruits in his area where his household/business and others in his area were called where young men were seen and called on to fight. 28. This fear of recruitment is understandable when the situation in the ongoing battle for control of Afghanistan is considered and the lack of training or support for these recruited, unskilled youths is taken into account. 29. I have discussed the issue of Taliban’s recruitment and the issue of conscription in general below. 30. The issues which are material to his case and which I accept are: 1. He is Afghan.2. He is Pashtun, the same ethnic group as the Taliban. 3. He is of fighting age and, had faced conscription in Afghanistan and was at risk of facing it again. 4. The Taliban is predominantly Pashtun and does not have a regular conscription programme but, on an ad hoc basis has a practice of rounding up or pressganging young men available at the time into their services. 5. The Taliban has been in control of his area for two to two and a half years and continues to be so. 6. The situation in Taliban held areas has stabilised to the extent that the UN is prepared to facilitate return to them. 31. The information contained in the Cisnet document CX40735 leads me to conclude that the United Nations is satisfied that, in general circumstances it is safe for Afghan citizens to return to Taliban held rural areas considered safe and, the U.N is facilitating that return. 32. [Here the Tribunal again referred to the same US State Department Report]. 33. For reasons discussed below I find that the Applicant's claims do not come within the Ambit of the Convention. The Applicant's Claims in Regard to Conscription in the Taliban Armed Forces 34. The terms of Article 1 A(2) of the Convention are such that for harm to amount to Convention persecution that harm must have a discriminatory element to it as it states that the persecution must be “for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion.” 35. In the absence of any element of discrimination the harm, even if oppressive or constituting "generalised human rights abuses” does not bring the claims within the ambit of the Convention. 36. In the matter of Applicant A & Anor v MIEA (1997) 190 CLR 225 at 244 Dawson J stated, in reference to claims of serious harm: For my part, however, I do not see how those considerations assist the appellants, since they merely suggest that the persecution which they face is serious and may infringe internationally recognised human rights. That is not the issue in this appeal. The issue is whether that persecution is for one of the five Convention reasons. (my emphasis added) 37. The Courts have held that the harm may be multi faceted and so long as a facet played, "a substantial part in the persecution feared by the applicant that would be persecution 'for reasons of' " (See: Mahespararam v MIMA (unreported, Federal Court of Australia, Madgwick J, 15 Apri1 1999) but that there must be an element of discrimination for one of the five Convention reasons. 38. In Applicant A Brennan CJ stated: ... the feared persecution must be discriminatory. The victims are persons selected by reference to a criterion consisting of, or criteria including, one of the prescribed categories of discrimination (“race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion”) mentioned in Art 1(A)(2). 39. Although the Applicant was interviewed twice by departmental officers and counselled by a solicitor, prior to the hearing and the submission of 13 October 2000 he made no claims to have feared harm at the hands of the Taliban for any reason other than being made to fight for them. 40. I am of the opinion that his representative would have discussed the Applicant's claims and pointed out to him the need for a discriminatory element to exist if his matter was to come within the Convention. 41. I have considered the Applicant's background, the fact that he was raised in a rural village and had little outside contact. I have also taken into account the Applicant's claims, which I accept, that he has had only five years of primary education and considers himself to be illiterate. 42. This would explain his lack of understanding of the Convention and also any confusion he may have held that gave him the misconception that harm, of itself, was sufficient to identify him as a refugee. 43. However, having due regard to the handicaps he faced I have also considered the counsel from his representatives and the nature of the questions put to him by the department to draw out his claims. 44. I accept the information cited above in Cisnet document CX39867, DFAT cable IS500488 to the effect that Taliban does not have a regular conscription policy but has as a practice the recruitment, often forced, of young men regarded to have the potential to fight. 45. I accept that, in some instances, Taliban has been reported to have forced youths of families it regards as being opposed to it to cross mine fields or undertake tasks which could lead to harm for reasons of their opposition. There were reports that some prisoners of the Taliban, including the sons of families that had opposed Taliban social restrictions, had been drafted forcibly and sent to the front. There were also reports that the Taliban forcibly conscripted or attempted to forcibly conscript persons in 1997 and 1998; some of these reports were unconfirmed. US State Department Country Reports on Human Rights Practices 1999. 46. However, I do not accept this is the case in the current matter since I do not accept that he or his family has opposed the Taliban such as to be identified as being of the opposition or that the Applicant was of any adverse concern to them. 47. He has lived under Taliban control for two years and has not come to their adverse attention except the relatively minor annoyance of being told to keep his beard long and not to play taped music. 48. In the time he and his family lived under the control of Taliban he made no claim to have opposed their "social restrictions" and he made no claim to have suffered in a discriminatory way under Taliban. 49. While the ad hoc practice of recruitment and press ganging new recruits including young students as described in the independent material cited above, is not one which would be condoned internationally, Taliban's motivation is solely based on whether or not the recruits are capable of fighting. This selective process which targets young, able bodied males does not amount to discrimination for a Convention reason. The selection of young men or men of fighting age albeit in an "ad hoc" manner does not amount to discrimination and is not Convention related any more than regularised conscription is in other countries. 50. In the matter of Mijoljevic v MIMA [1999] FCA 834 (Branson J, 25 June 1999) the Applicant objected to military conscription on the basis of his pacifist views. The Tribunal found that this objection and the possible consequences of failing to undertake conscription did not bring the Applicant's case within the ambit of the Convention. 51. In determining the appeal Branson J stated: In my view, the conclusion of the Tribunal that the applicant's pacifist views did not provide a basis upon which it could be satisfied that he was a person to whom Australia owes protection obligations under the Refugees Convention was open to it on the evidence and material before it. Further, in my view, the Tribunal's reasons for decision do not suggest that the Tribunal's conclusion in this regard involved any error of law. This Court has on a number of occasions recognised that the enforcement of laws providing for compulsory military service, and for the punishment of those who avoid such service, will not ordinarily provide a basis for a claim of persecution within the meaning of the Refugees Convention (see for example, Murill-Nunez v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1995) 63 FCR 150; Timic v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1998] FCA 1750). See also Hathaway, The Law of Refugee Status at para 5.6.2. (Ibid at 23). 52. In the current matter the Applicant has claimed he fears harm if he is taken to fight for Taliban. He also claims to have pacifist views in that he claims he would be forced to kill people and, he against (sic) the fighting that is happening and has no reason to kill anyone. 53. He also claims that Taliban is a foreign force from neighbouring Pakistan. 54. I have considered the information before me and, while I am left in no doubt that Taliban is by most standards a ruthless and despotic political body founded on extremist religious tenets. It is, nevertheless the body which controls 90 percent of Afghanistan and, though not internationally recognised by many states, is the current de facto government of Afghanistan. 55. While I accept that Pakistani extremists both promote and support the movement and accept the evidence cited above that many Afghan Taliban were trained in Madrassas in Pakistan I do not accept the Applicant's views that it is a foreign force. It is, according to independent material a "Pashtun-dominated ultra-conservative Islamic movement” headed by Mullar Omar of Afghanistan. 56. I do not intend to further consider the issue of whether or not it is a foreign force as this would not, in any event, convert the Applicant's fear to a Convention based claim.57. As discussed above it is clear that Taliban does not have, as a policy, a regularised military service or conscription programme but rather, takes young men at random, as needed for its military purposes and I accept the DFAT advice in cable IS5OO488 of 21 October 1996 to the effect that thousands of young men have left Afghanistan for this reason. 58. I find that this is what occurred in the case of the Applicant who had managed to avoid recruitment in one drive by paying the recruiters off and, in a second drive stalled them by saying he needed to speak to his parents. 59. The nature of the recruitment process is such that there are no criteria for selection save being able bodied and, being in the wrong place at the wrong time. 60. By his own account he was approached in an ad hoc recruitment drive and, I also find that the recruiters in that exercise were not seriously concerned whether he did fight or not as they were equally content with being payed (sic) to allow him to avoid the recruitment drive. 61. When the second group came they took no action when he said he wanted to speak to his parents first and indicated that he may also pay them. 62. Given Taliban's rigid approach to compliance this action leads me to conclude they were not concerned about the Applicant who had no skills or any significant value to them apart from his youth and the fact he was able-bodied. No immediate follow up occurred and he was not required to report to them. 63. This leads me to conclude that he was not targeted to the extent that he was listed or registered for recruitment by the Taliban but was merely seen as a young man who was available in that area at that time and, in the random manner of such an ad hoc drive he was able to avoid recruitment for a second time. 64. There is no regular programme neither is there in the independent material or the Applicant's evidence any indication of a penalty for failure to serve. 65. In the Applicant's case, he has given an account which indicates he evaded service by leaving the area to avoid recruitment. 66. The large numbers of young men doing so, his minimal profile as a rural villager and the random nature of recruitment leads me to conclude that his departure from the area shortly after a recruitment drive would not have brought him to the attention of the Taliban such that he would be of concern or that an imputed political opinion would be attributed to him. 67. While I have sympathy for this young man and the tragic plight of his country over the past twenty years and under the current control of the extremist Taliban movement I find that his fear is that of many young men in his circumstances that, for non Convention reasons he will be recruited to fight for Taliban and that, the consequences could be that he may face serious harm or death. 68. However, as discussed above I do not accept that he is of concern to the Taliban as someone who is opposed to them for speaking out against them nor, do I find that his departure to avoid the ad hoc conscription practices of the Taliban would lead them to consider he was politically opposed to them. 69. Large numbers of people who formerly fled Afghanistan are returning, in conditions which UNHCR considers safe. 70. I find that this young man can do as thousands of his fellow citizens are doing and not face a "real chance" of persecution for a Convention reason. 71. In summary , I find that the Applicant is a national of Afghanistan and is a Pashtun who could be considered to be of fighting age by the Taliban. 72. I accept that he may face serious harm as a consequence of being recruited into the Taliban militia as a consequence of fighting but, I find this harm would be the consequence of fighting between two opposing forces and, although he may not be committed to the aims and objectives of the Taliban, the motivation of the Taliban in recruiting him would be solely because he is a male with the potential to fight and for no other reason. 73. This being the case, I find that his claims are such that I can not be satisfied that he faces discriminatory treatment for any one or a combination of the five Convention reasons or for an aggregate of other reasons with a component of any of the five Convention reasons. 74. This being the case, any fears he may hold in that regard are not well-founded and his claims do not bring the matter within the ambit of the Convention. CONCLUSION 75. Having considered the evidence as a whole, the Tribunal is not satisfied that the applicant is a person to whom Australia has protection obligations under the Refugees Convention as amended by the Refugees Protocol. Therefore the applicant does not satisfy the criterion set out in s.36(2) of the Act for a protection visa.” GROUNDS OF THE APPLICATION

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: CARR J

Full text does not contain this section.