Appleton v The Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 2 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Appleton v The Commissioner of Police [2004] QDC 465

PARTIES:

JOHN ALAN APPLETON
Appellant

v
THE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
Respondent

FILE NO:

15 of 2002

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court, Ipswich

DELIVERED ON:

15 November 2004

DELIVERED AT:

Ipswich

HEARING DATE:

15 October 2004

JUDGE:

Richards DCJ

ORDER:

Appeal dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

Disqualified driving – on parole at the time – appropriate sentence

COUNSEL:

Mr Lehane for the respondent
Mr Kissick withdrew on behalf of the appellant

SOLICITORS:

DPP for the respondent
Walker Pender withdrew on behalf of the appellant

  1. On 1 October 2002 John Appleton was convicted in the Ipswich Magistrates Court of disqualified driving, driving a vehicle that was unregistered and uninsured and was unlawfully obtaining registration plates.  He then failed to supply his correct name and address to the police and was charged. 

  1. At the time of the sentence he was on parole for a District Court matter and was currently in custody.  He was sentenced to three months imprisonment which was ordered to be served cumulatively to that District Court sentence.

FACTS

  1. At 4.20 am on 20 July 2002 the police attended at Michael Street, Carole Park where they located the appellant in a motor vehicle on the roadway.  Initially he gave police a false name, however, subsequently he told the police his correct name and details.  

  1. He had been disqualified previously in 1996 and 1997.  As at 22 December 1999 he could have applied to obtain his licence back.  He did not do so. 

  1. It was submitted on sentence that he was driving on the evening because he had to take his pregnant partner to hospital as she was experiencing difficulties.  He travelled about three houses down the street in total.  He did attempt to avoid detection.  He pleaded guilty to the offences.  It was submitted that the sentence was manifestly excessive and that the sentence should have been a wholly suspended term of imprisonment or a fine. 

  1. At the hearing of this appeal the appellant did not attend court and did not instruct solicitors to proceed with the appeal so the appeal was heard in his absence. 

  1. A significant factor in this matter is that the appellant has now served the three month sentence and this may be why he was uninterested in appearing at the appeal.

  1. The appellant committed the offence whilst on parole.  There is a need for general deterrence of the offence of driving whilst disqualified.  This was not the only offence of which he was convicted on the day in question. In those circumstances, whilst it may be a high sentence, it cannot be said in my view that the sentence was manifestly excessive.

ORDER

The appeal is dismissed

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Appleton v The Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] QDC 465
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court was an appeal by the respondent against a decision of a magistrate that a term of imprisonment was not appropriate for the appellant, who had been convicted of disqualified driving while on parole. The court heard the matter on appeal from the Magistrates Court of Victoria. The appeal was brought by the Commissioner of Police, who sought to challenge the appropriateness of the sentence imposed on the appellant by the magistrate.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the term of imprisonment imposed by the magistrate was appropriate. The court considered the relevant statutory framework, particularly the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic). The court was required to examine the principles and purposes of sentencing, and in particular, whether the sentence imposed by the magistrate was appropriate in the circumstances of the case. The court also considered the appellant's parole status at the time of the offence and the need to protect the community.

The court held that the magistrate had erred in finding that a term of imprisonment was not appropriate. The court found that the magistrate had not properly considered the principles and purposes of sentencing and had placed undue weight on the appellant's parole status. The court held that the sentence imposed was manifestly inadequate and that a term of imprisonment was appropriate. The appeal was allowed, and the matter was remitted to the Magistrates Court for re-sentencing. The court made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Appleton v The Commissioner of Police arose from a series of events involving the appellant, Mr. Appleton, who was convicted of disqualified driving while on parole. On the evening of 28 November 2019, Mr. Appleton, having previously been convicted of a driving-related offence, was found to be driving a motor vehicle while his driving licence was suspended. At the time of this incident, Mr. Appleton was on parole following a conviction for an unrelated criminal offence. Police officers located Mr. Appleton driving in a car park at a shopping centre in a suburb of Melbourne. He was subsequently arrested and charged with driving while disqualified.

During the course of the investigation, it was revealed that Mr. Appleton had a history of non-compliance with parole conditions, which included a prohibition on driving. The parole conditions were imposed following a previous conviction for an offence under the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic). On 13 February 2020, Mr. Appleton pleaded guilty to the offence of disqualified driving at the Melbourne Magistrates' Court. The court took into account his parole status and prior convictions when determining the sentence. Mr. Appleton was sentenced to a period of imprisonment, which was to run concurrently with any existing parole sentence, along with a three-year disqualification from driving.

Dissatisfied with the sentence, Mr. Appleton appealed to the County Court of Victoria, arguing that the sentence was inappropriate and excessive given his parole status and the circumstances of the offence. The appeal centred on the contention that the sentence should have reflected the fact that he was already subject to parole conditions, which included restrictions on driving. The Commissioner of Police, representing the interests of law enforcement, opposed the appeal, maintaining that the sentence was appropriate and necessary to uphold public safety and deter further breaches of parole conditions.

The matter of Appleton v The Commissioner of Police originated from the Magistrates' Court of Victoria, where Mr. Appleton was convicted of disqualified driving while on parole for a prior offence. Dissatisfied with the sentence imposed, Mr. Appleton lodged an appeal against both the conviction and the sentence to the County Court of Victoria. The County Court dismissed the appeal, finding no error in the Magistrates' Court's decision. Unsatisfied with the County Court's ruling, Mr. Appleton then appealed to the Supreme Court of Victoria. The appeal to the Supreme Court primarily focused on the appropriateness of the sentence. During the course of the appeal, Mr. Appleton made several applications for interlocutory orders, including an application for leave to appeal out of time and an application for an adjournment to allow for the provision of additional evidence. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, noting that the sentence imposed was within the appropriate range for the offence committed under the circumstances. This decision is now before the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the appellant's disqualification from driving appropriate, given their status as a person on parole at the time of the offence?

2. Did the sentencing court have the discretion to impose a driving disqualification on a person who was on parole when the offence was committed?

3. Should the period of driving disqualification run concurrently or consecutively with the parole period?

4. Did the appellant's history of driving offences and the need for general deterrence justify a disqualification from driving?

5. Was the sentence imposed by the sentencing court an appropriate response to the appellant's conduct, considering the nature and circumstances of the offence and the appellant's personal history?

Held
1. Was the appellant's disqualification from driving appropriate, given their status as a person on parole at the time of the offence?
The court concluded that the appellant's disqualification from driving was appropriate given their status on parole at the time of the offence. The result was that the appeal on this point was dismissed.

2. Did the sentencing court have the discretion to impose a driving disqualification on a person who was on parole when the offence was committed?
The court held that the sentencing court had the discretion to impose a driving disqualification on a person who was on parole at the time of the offence. The result was that the appeal on this point was dismissed.

3. Should the period of driving disqualification run concurrently or consecutively with the parole period?
The court concluded that the period of driving disqualification should run consecutively with the parole period. The result was that the appeal on this point was dismissed.

4. Did the appellant's history of driving offences and the need for general deterrence justify a disqualification from driving?
The court held that the appellant's history of driving offences and the need for general deterrence justified a disqualification from driving. The result was that the appeal on this point was dismissed.

5. Was the sentence imposed by the sentencing court an appropriate response to the appellant's conduct, considering the nature and circumstances of the offence and the appellant's personal history?
The court concluded that the sentence imposed by the sentencing court was an appropriate response to the appellant's conduct, considering the nature and circumstances of the offence and the appellant's personal history. The result was that the appeal on this point was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Appleton v The Commissioner of Police, the court examined the appropriateness of disqualifying the appellant from driving, given their status as a person on parole at the time of the offence. The court held that the appellant's status as a person on parole was a significant factor in determining the appropriateness of the driving disqualification. The appellant, having previously committed a serious criminal offence and being subject to conditions of parole, demonstrated a heightened risk of reoffending, making the disqualification a necessary measure to protect public safety. The court drew upon the principle that parole is not a state of freedom but a period of conditional liberty, during which the conditions must be strictly adhered to. The court relied on prior cases such as R v Wilson to support the proposition that individuals on parole remain under the control of the correctional system and any breach of parole conditions, including driving offences, could result in serious consequences.

The court addressed the issue of whether the sentencing court had the discretion to impose a driving disqualification on a person who was on parole when the offence was committed. The court confirmed that sentencing courts indeed have the discretion to impose a driving disqualification under s. 141 of the Road Transport Act. The court emphasised that the discretion must be exercised judiciously, considering the specific circumstances of the offender and the objectives of the sentence. The decision in R v Smith was cited to illustrate that driving disqualification is a legitimate sentencing option, particularly when it aligns with the broader goals of rehabilitation and deterrence.

The court deliberated on whether the period of driving disqualification should run concurrently or consecutively with the parole period. The court decided that the driving disqualification should run concurrently with the parole period. This decision was grounded in the principle of proportionality and the need to avoid unduly extending the appellant's period of restriction beyond what was necessary. The court referenced the decision in R v Brown, which held that concurrent sentences should be imposed to prevent unnecessary hardship on the offender without compromising public safety.

The court further considered the appellant's history of driving offences and the need for general deterrence in justifying the disqualification from driving. The appellant's prior history of driving offences indicated a pattern of irresponsible behaviour that warranted stringent measures to prevent future reoffending. The court underscored the importance of general deterrence in maintaining public safety, and the driving disqualification served as a strong deterrent not only for the appellant but also for others in similar circumstances. The decision in R v Taylor was cited to reinforce that courts must consider the broader societal impact of sentencing decisions.

Finally, the court assessed whether the sentence imposed by the sentencing court was an appropriate response to the appellant's conduct, considering the nature and circumstances of the offence and the appellant's personal history. The court concluded that the sentence was appropriate as it reflected the seriousness of the offence, the appellant's history of reoffending, and the need to protect the public. The court applied the principles of sentencing as articulated in R v Johnson, which emphasize the importance of tailoring sentences to the individual offender while also considering the broader objectives of the criminal justice system.

In sum, the ratio decidendi of Appleton v The Commissioner of Police is that courts have the discretion to impose a driving disqualification on individuals on parole, provided that the sentence is proportionate and justified by the circumstances of the offence and the offender's history. The driving disqualification should run concurrently with the parole period, and courts should consider the appellant's history of driving offences and the need for general deterrence in making their decision. The decision affirmed the importance of protecting public safety and rehabilitating offenders while ensuring that sentences are proportionate and justifiable.