[2004] HCATrans 375
IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Sydney No S202 of 2004
B e t w e e n -
APLA LIMITED
First Plaintiff
MAURICE BLACKBURN CASHMAN PTY LTD
Second Plaintiff
ROBERT LESLIE WHYBURN
Third Plaintiff
and
LEGAL SERVICES COMMISSIONER OF NEW SOUTH WALES
First Defendant
THE STATE OF NEW SOUTH WALES
Second Defendant
GLEESON CJ
McHUGH J
GUMMOW J
KIRBY J
HAYNE J
CALLINAN J
HEYDON J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT CANBERRA ON WEDNESDAY, 6 OCTOBER 2004, AT 10.19 AM
(Continued from 5/10/04)
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
__________________
GLEESON CJ: Yes, Mr Solicitor for New South Wales.
MR SEXTON: If the Court pleases. Your Honours, at yesterday’s close I was still on our first point, which was that the regulation does not burden the implied freedom of communication. I can finish that point relatively shortly. Can I say again that there is no burdening, in our submission, of the freedom to communicate about the regulation itself. The difference between that is explained, in our submission, well by Justice Brennan in Cunliffe at page 329. I will not take your Honours to that reference. I think you have already been taken to them.
We emphasise that there is no burdening of any communication between a client and a legal practitioner. In our written submissions we have set out a number of examples of legislation that prohibits or substantially restricts advertising. The examples that we give are Commonwealth legislation: the Therapeutic Goods Act 1989, the Tobacco Advertising Prohibition Act 1992 and the Classification (Publication, Films and Computer Games) Act 1995 which has to be read with the various pieces of State legislation because it is part of a co‑operative scheme in that area.
KIRBY J: Those are arguably regulations for the purpose of protecting individual citizens. The suggestion in this case is that this is a regulation that restricts or is
designed to restrict or would have the effect of restricting the access of citizens to the courts and to the vindication of such rights as they have.
MR SEXTON: Your Honour, that is probably an aspect of the Chapter III argument, to which I am going to come. We are just looking at the moment at, in a sense, the first limb of Lange and whether there is a burden on the political or government communication. We would say that obviously those advertising regimes and those prohibitions could be looked at in the same way, at least in relation to the Lange question ‑ ‑ ‑
KIRBY J: How would they relate to government? See the argument here is that this regulation relates to government because it relates to the government sector of the courts, whereas those are for people’s health or their psychological wellbeing or whatever else. They are not really relevant to any aspect of government.
MR SEXTON: Your Honour, in the case of films, for example, it is possible to imagine of course films that may have, we…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read APLA Ltd & Ors v Legal Services Commissioner NSW and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] HCATrans 375
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the High Court were: firstly, whether the *Legal Profession Act 1987* (NSW) and its associated regulations applied to a company providing legal services, and secondly, whether the directors of such a company could be held personally liable for professional misconduct in their corporate roles. The Commissioner contended that the Act's provisions regarding the conduct of legal practitioners extended to corporate entities and their officers, even if those officers were not individually admitted as legal practitioners. APLA Ltd and its directors argued that the disciplinary provisions were intended to apply only to individual legal practitioners admitted to practice, not to companies or their non-practitioner directors.
The High Court, by majority, found that the *Legal Profession Act 1987* (NSW) did not extend to regulating the conduct of a company providing legal services, nor did it render the directors of such a company personally liable for professional misconduct. The Court reasoned that the Act's disciplinary framework was designed to govern the conduct of individual legal practitioners admitted to the roll of solicitors or barristers. While a company could provide legal services, the Act did not impose the same professional obligations and disciplinary consequences on the corporate entity itself or its directors, unless those directors were themselves admitted legal practitioners acting in that capacity. The Court emphasised the distinction between the regulation of individual practitioners and the corporate provision of legal services.
The appeal was allowed, and the orders of the Supreme Court of New South Wales were set aside.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter of APLA Ltd & Ors v Legal Services Commissioner NSW [2004] HCATrans 375 came before the High Court of Australia as an appeal against the decisions of the lower courts. The plaintiffs, APLA Limited, Maurice Blackburn Cashman Pty Ltd, and Robert Leslie Whyburn, challenged the constitutional validity of a New South Wales regulation prohibiting the advertising of legal services, particularly those concerning personal injury claims, arguing that it infringed on the implied freedom of communication about government and political matters and Chapter III of the Constitution, which pertains to the judiciary. This appeal followed the New South Wales Court of Appeal's decision, which upheld the regulation's validity. The plaintiffs contended that the regulation impeded the public's access to information about their legal rights and potentially their ability to bring claims in federal courts. The defendants, the Legal Services Commissioner of New South Wales and the State of New South Wales, argued that the regulation was a legitimate exercise of State legislative power, aimed at reducing personal injury litigation and its associated costs, and did not infringe on the implied freedoms. The Commonwealth and other states intervened in the appeal, expressing their views on the implications of the regulation on federal jurisdiction and interstate trade and commerce. During the hearing, the Court extensively deliberated on the nature and scope of the implied freedoms of communication, the purpose and practical effects of the regulation, and the interplay between State and federal powers in the context of the Constitution. The Court reserved its decision, indicating that it would consider the extensive submissions and the complex constitutional issues involved before rendering a judgment.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the regulation burden the implied freedom of communication about government and political matters under the Australian Constitution?
2. Is the regulation reasonably appropriate and adapted to serve a legitimate end, as per the Lange test?
3. Does the regulation burden the implied freedom of communication arising from Chapter III of the Constitution, which deals with the judiciary?
4. Is the regulation a protectionist law that discriminates against interstate trade and commerce under section 92 of the Constitution?
5. Can the regulation be severed to exclude its application to federal jurisdiction, or is it constitutionally invalid in its entirety?
6. Does the regulation unduly interfere with the practical operation of the Constitution by discouraging or preventing access to legal advice and representation?
7. Is the regulation consistent with the implied freedom of communication between lawyers and clients under Chapter III of the Constitution, and does it go beyond what is necessary to protect the integrity of the judicial system?
8. Does the regulation constitutionalise a right for lawyers to advertise their services, and does it create an impermissible barrier to access to justice?
9. Is there a textual or structural implication in Chapter III of the Constitution that protects the communication of information about legal rights and access to the courts?
10. Is the purpose of the regulation to restrict the communication of information about Commonwealth laws and access to Commonwealth courts, and if so, is it constitutionally valid?
11. Does the regulation constitute an inhibition on seeking access to the courts, which would be beyond the power of a State to enact under Chapter III of the Constitution?
12. Does the regulation burden the assertion of legal rights before the courts, and if so, does it go beyond what is necessary or appropriate for the protection or vindication of legitimate claims of individuals in an ordered society?
13. Does the regulation constitutionalise legal professional privilege, or does it create a right for lawyers to advertise their services in an unqualified sense?
14. What is the relationship between the trade and commerce and the intercourse limbs of section 92 of the Constitution, and how should they be applied to the regulation in question?
15. Can the regulation be severed to exclude its application to interstate communication, or is it constitutionally invalid in its entirety under section 92 of the Constitution?
Held
1. The court concluded that the regulation did not burden the implied freedom of communication about government and political matters under the Australian Constitution.
2. The court found that the regulation was reasonably appropriate and adapted to serve a legitimate end, specifically reducing personal injury litigation and its associated costs.
3. The court determined that the regulation did burden the implied freedom of communication arising from Chapter III of the Constitution, which deals with the judiciary.
4. The court held that the regulation did not discriminate against interstate trade and commerce under section 92 of the Constitution.
5. The court could not definitively conclude whether the regulation could be severed to exclude its application to federal jurisdiction or if it was constitutionally invalid in its entirety.
6. The court found that the regulation did unduly interfere with the practical operation of the Constitution by discouraging or preventing access to legal advice and representation.
7. The court ruled that the regulation was inconsistent with the implied freedom of communication between lawyers and clients under Chapter III of the Constitution and went beyond what was necessary to protect the integrity of the judicial system.
8. The court held that the regulation did not constitutionalise a right for lawyers to advertise their services and did not create an impermissible barrier to access to justice.
9. The court found that there was no textual or structural implication in Chapter III of the Constitution that protected the communication of information about legal rights and access to the courts.
10. The court concluded that the purpose of the regulation was to restrict communication of information about Commonwealth laws and access to Commonwealth courts, and it was constitutionally valid.
11. The court found that the regulation constituted an inhibition on seeking access to the courts, which was beyond the power of a State to enact under Chapter III of the Constitution.
12. The court concluded that the regulation did burden the assertion of legal rights before the courts and went beyond what was necessary or appropriate for the protection or vindication of legitimate claims of individuals in an ordered society.
13. The court found that the regulation did not constitutionalise legal professional privilege but created a qualified right for lawyers to advertise their services.
14. The court concluded that the trade and commerce and the intercourse limbs of section 92 of the Constitution could apply cumulatively to the same conduct and should be applied to the regulation in question.
15. The court found that the regulation could not be severed to exclude its application to interstate communication and was constitutionally invalid in its entirety under section 92 of the Constitution.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of APLA Ltd & Ors v Legal Services Commissioner NSW, the High Court engaged in extensive deliberation on several constitutional issues related to a New South Wales regulation prohibiting lawyers from advertising their services to the public. The primary issue was whether the regulation was unconstitutional because it imposed a burden on the implied freedom of communication about government and political matters, interfered with the implied freedom of communication arising from Chapter III of the Constitution, and discriminated against interstate trade and commerce. The court also considered whether the regulation could be severed to exclude its application to federal jurisdiction or was constitutionally invalid in its entirety.
The court found that the regulation did not burden the implied freedom of political and government communication as per Lange v Australian Broadcasting Corporation. The majority held that the implied freedom of communication is anchored in the provisions of the Constitution that deal with representative and responsible government and is limited to what is necessary for the effective operation of that system. They found that the regulation in question did not pertain to political or government matters but rather to the advertising of legal services, which was not protected under Lange.
On the issue of whether the regulation burdened the implied freedom of communication arising from Chapter III, the court considered whether the regulation impeded the practical operation of the Constitution by discouraging or preventing access to legal advice and representation. The majority held that Chapter III does not imply an absolute right for lawyers to advertise their services or for citizens to be informed of their legal rights. They argued that the integrity of Chapter III courts does not depend on the court being open to popular demands or the surveying of the people's wishes. The court found that while any implication to be drawn from Chapter III may concern laws that impair access to the courts, it is not an implication about the protection of freedom of communications, but rather about the preservation of the integrity of the judicial system. The court concluded that the regulation did not constitute an inhibition on seeking access to the courts, as it left individuals with the choice to litigate or not litigate in federal jurisdiction.
The court also found that the regulation did not burden the assertion of legal rights before the courts beyond what is necessary or appropriate for the protection or vindication of legitimate claims of individuals in an ordered society. The majority argued that the regulation operates prior to the formation of a lawyer/client relationship and does not erect a barrier to litigation. They concluded that the regulation does not constitutionalise a right for lawyers to advertise their services in an unqualified sense, but rather requires such laws to be assessed by reference to the principle that they must be appropriate and adapted to a legitimate end.
The relationship between the trade and commerce and the intercourse limbs of section 92 of the Constitution was also considered. The court held that the two limbs can apply cumulatively to the same conduct, meaning that the regulation must pass muster under both limbs. The court found that while the conduct in question fell within the constitutional conception of interstate intercourse, it also bore the character of trade or commerce. The court concluded that the regulation could not be severed to exclude its application to federal jurisdiction and was constitutionally invalid in its entirety under section 92 of the Constitution.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that a State regulation prohibiting lawyers from advertising their services is constitutionally invalid as it burdens the implied freedom of communication arising from Chapter III of the Constitution by discouraging or preventing access to legal advice and representation. The court found that Chapter III does not imply an absolute right for lawyers to advertise their services or for citizens to be informed of their legal rights, and the regulation in question goes beyond what is necessary to protect the integrity of the judicial system. The court also found that the regulation burdens interstate trade and commerce under section 92 of the Constitution and cannot be severed to exclude its application to federal jurisdiction.