Anyar v Commissioner for Social Housing (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ANYAR v COMMISSIONER FOR SOCIAL HOUSING (Administrative Review) [2017] ACAT 33

AT 65/2016

Catchwords:   

ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – social housing – rental transfer – valid offer – number of valid offers – applicant’s reasonable accommodation need – human rights – tenant’s right to protection of the family and children

Legislation cited:

ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 9, 68

Housing Assistance Act 2007 ss 19, 21, 32

Human Rights Act 2004 ss 11, 30, 40B

Subordinate Legislation cited:

Housing Assistance Public Rental Housing Assistance Program 2013 (No 1) cl 17, 20, 21, 31(4)(b)

Cases cited:

Bradley v The Commissioner for Social Housing [2015] ACAT 18
Castles v Secretary, Department of Justice [2010] VSC 310
Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 60

Little v Commissioner for Social Housing  [2017] ACAT 11
Miller v Commissioner for Social Housing [2017] ACAT 10

Tribunal:  Senior Member T Foley

Date of Orders:  2 May 2017
Date of Reasons for Decision:         2 May 2017

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY               )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL          )          AT 65/2016

BETWEEN:

ELIZABETH ANYAR
Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER FOR SOCIAL
HOUSING
Respondent

TRIBUNAL:    Senior Member A Foley

DATE:  2 May 2017

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. Pursuant to section 68 of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 the reviewable decision dated 5 September 2016 to remove the applicant’s name from the High Needs Housing list on the register is set aside.

  1. The reviewable decision is substituted with a decision that the applicant’s name is to be returned to the High Needs Housing list in relation to the application for rental transfer (no.95352) with effect from 21 June 2012 for a three (3) bedroom Social Housing accommodation in the Belconnen/Gungahlin area.

………………………………..
Senior Member T Foley

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Elizabeth Anyar (the applicant) seeks review of the decision made by the delegate of the Commissioner for Social Housing (the respondent) on 5 September 2016 (the reviewable decision) confirming the earlier decision by the respondent on 23 February 2016 (the original decision) to remove the applicant’s name from the register of applications for social housing assistance.

  2. Jurisdiction to review the respondent’s decision is conferred on the tribunal by section 32 of the Housing Assistance Act 2007 (the Housing Assistance Act) which is an authorising law for the purposes of section 9 of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (the ACAT Act). The review is an application for review by the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal pursuant to section 68 of the ACAT Act.

  3. In the reasons below, a reference to ‘ACAT’ or ‘tribunal’ refers to the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal generally, whereas ‘Tribunal’ refers to the member who heard the application.

The hearing

  1. The matter was heard on 21 February 2017. The Tribunal had before it the documents provided by the respondent on which its decision was based (the T documents), the submissions and statements of facts and contentions of the parties,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Anyar v Commissioner for Social Housing (Administrative Revi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] ACAT 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Anyar v Commissioner for Social Housing (Administrative Review), the applicant sought a review of the decision by the respondent to remove her name from the High Needs Housing list. The applicant argued that the decision was flawed as it failed to consider her reasonable accommodation needs, particularly the need for a carpet-free property due to her daughter's health condition. The case was brought before the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) for review of the decision dated 5 September 2016.

The central legal issues in the case revolved around the interpretation and application of the criteria for determining reasonable accommodation needs in social housing. The applicant contended that the decision-maker failed to properly consider the evidence regarding her daughter's health condition, which necessitated a carpet-free property. Additionally, there was a dispute over whether the properties inspected by the applicant met the criteria for a valid offer of accommodation. The applicant argued that neither property was suitable due to the presence of dirty carpets, which was not explicitly stated at the time of inspection but later articulated with the assistance of a representative from MARSS.

The ACAT found that the decision-maker did not adequately consider the applicant's reasonable accommodation needs and the evidence supporting the need for a carpet-free property. The tribunal held that the decision-maker should have given proper weight to the medical evidence provided by the applicant and the significance of the carpet-free requirement in light of her daughter's health condition. The ACAT set aside the decision and substituted it with a decision to return the applicant's name to the High Needs Housing list for a three-bedroom social housing accommodation in the Belconnen/Gungahlin area.

The tribunal's reasoning was grounded in the need to ensure that all relevant information was considered in making the decision. The ACAT emphasized that it was not the role of the tribunal to assess the correctness of the previous decision but to determine whether the decision was correct or preferable based on the material before the tribunal. The tribunal concluded that the decision-maker's failure to properly consider the applicant's reasonable accommodation needs led to an outcome that was not in the best interests of the applicant and her family.

Orders

Orders of the court

Pursuant to section 68 of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 the reviewable decision dated 5 September 2016 to remove the applicant’s name from the High Needs Housing list on the register is set aside.

The reviewable decision is substituted with a decision that the applicant’s name is to be returned to the High Needs Housing list in relation to the application for rental transfer (no.95352) with effect from 21 June 2012 for a three (3) bedroom Social Housing accommodation in the Belconnen/Gungahlin area.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 5 September 2016 the reviewable decision maker wrote to the applicant advising that her name would not be returned to the register (the reviewable decision).[19] The applicant was advised that her application for second level review had come before HATRP on 21 July 2016. The respondent’s letter did not advise her of her successful review nor of HATRP’s recommendation that she be granted a further property offer. At the hearing the respondent’s representative advised that its practice was not to provide applicants with the results of a HATRP review when the reviewable decision maker does not accept the HATRP recommendation. In this case the applicant was simply advised “The [HATRP] considered your matter on Thursday 21 July 2016.”[20][19] T-documents pages 128-129[20] T-documents page 128 The letter of 5 September 2016, the reviewable decision, did not come to the applicant’s attention until she visited the respondent’s office on 6 October 2016 to provide additional information on her daughter Apajok’s medical condition. On the 14 October 2016 the applicant applied to ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (the ACAT) for review of the reviewable decision. Two substantive matters of fact are in contention between the parties: The applicant contends with respect to the condition of the properties that she inspected on 22 February 2016 that neither property met her reasonable accommodation needs as they were not carpet free. As such she contends neither was a valid property offer. It was contended on behalf of the applicant that the limited reasons she provided for refusal of both offers at the time of inspection as listed in paragraph 27 above should be seen in the context of her limited English language skills. It was submitted that it was not until the applicant was assisted to complete an application for review on 9 March 2016[21] by a representative of MARSS that she first articulated the significance of the ‘dirty carpets’ as to each property’s unsuitability: The applicant contends with respect to the health conditions of her daughter Apajok that she has provided the respondent with medical evidence that her daughter: The medical evidence which the applicant says supports the need for a carpet free property due to this condition is contained in:(a)medical certificates of Dr John Paek dated 19 April and 30 November 2016; (b)patient health summaries from Dr Safwat Soliman of Main Surgery Blacktown dated 27 August 2016 and 18 January 2017. The applicant contends that the approach the Tribunal must take in deciding the matter is as stated in Bradley v The Commissioner for Social Housing[22] (Bradley): …to have regard to all of the relevant information available at the time the decision. It is the Tribunal’s role to make the correct or preferable decision. It is not the Tribunal’s role to make an assessment of any previous decision made by the Respondent. [22] [2015] ACAT 18 The applicant further contends that the Tribunal’s approach should be consistent with Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs[23] (Drake) to the effect that: The question for the determination of the Tribunal is not whether the decision which the decision-maker made was the correct or preferable one on the material before him. The question for the determination by the Tribunal is whether that decision was the correct or preferable one on the material before the Tribunal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established