Antill Ranger & Co Pty Ltd v Commissioner for Motor Transport

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read
93 CLR 83

ANTILL RANGER &COMPANY PRO-

PRIETARY LIMITED

COMMISSIONER FOR MOTOR TRANSPORT DEACON GRIMSHAW

EDMUND T. LENNON PROPRIETARY

THE STATE OF NEW SOUTH WALES AND

DEFENDANTS. OTHERS Constitutional Law (Cth.)-Freedom of inter-State trade commerce and intercourse-

State statute-Validity-Moneys collected in respect of operation of public motor vehicles in course of inter-State trade-Invalidity of statute authorizing collection- Payments made under protest-Claim to recover moneys so paid-Enactment by State of statute extinguishing causes of action and barring remedies-Validity- March 24, 25, The Constitution (63 &64 Vict. c. 12), 8. 92-State Transport, (Co-ordination) Act 1931-1952 (No. 32 of 1931-No. 24 of 1952) (N.S.W.), 88, 18 (4), (5), 37, 47-State Transport Co-ordination (Barring of Claims and Remedies) Act 1954 (N.S.W.), 88. 2, 3, 4-Judiciary Act 1903-1950 (No. 6 of 1903-No. 80 of 1950),

Section 3 of the State Transport Co-ordination (Barring of Claims and Remedies) Act 1954, which purports to extinguish as against the State of New South Wales or its authorized officials every cause of action (a) for the recovery of any sum of money collected pursuant to S. 18 (4) or (5) or S. 37 of the State

93 CLR 84

Transport (Co-ordination) Act 1931-1952 in relation to the operation of any public motor vehicle in the course of or for the purposes of inter-State trade before the commencement of such Act or (b) for any act done in the execution of the State Transport (Co-ordination) Act in relation to the operation of any public motor vehicle in the course of inter-State trade, and S. 4 of such Act, which purports to bar any action suit claim or demand against such State or its authorized officials in respect of any of the matters referred to in S. 3 above-mentioned infringe S. 92 of the Constitution.

Per Fullagar J.: Section 4 of the State Transport Co-ordination (Barring of Claims and Remedies) Act 1954 is invalid in that it conflicts with a paramount law of the Commonwealth, namely S. 58 of the Judiciary Act 1903-1950, which provides that any person making a claim against a State, whether in contract or tort, in respect of a matter in which the High Court has or can have original jurisdiction conferred on it, may in respect of such claim bring a suit against the State in the Supreme Court of such State or in the High Court, if such Court has original jurisdiction in the matter. Antill Ranger &Company Proprietary Limited v. Commissioner for

Motor Transport.

ON REMOVAL under S. 40 of the Judiciary Act 1903-1950.

By writ of summons issued out of the Supreme Court of New South Wales on 23rd July 1954 and specially indorsed pursuant to the provisions of the Common Law Procedure Act 1899 (N.S.W.), S. 24, Antill Ranger &Co. Pty. Ltd. (hereinafter called the plaintiff) sued the Commissioner for Motor Transport (hereinafter called the defendant) to recover the sum of £39,955 16s. 5d. The special indorsement was in the following terms: "To money had and received by the defendant to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Antill Ranger & Co Pty Ltd v Commissioner for Motor Transpor... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1955] HCA 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Antill Ranger & Co Pty Ltd v Commissioner for Motor Transport*, the High Court of Australia considered the validity of the *State Transport (Co-ordination) (Barring of Claims and Remedies) Act 1954* (NSW). The case involved multiple plaintiffs, including Antill Ranger & Co Pty Ltd, Lionel Frederick Deacon, and Edmund T. Lennon Proprietary Limited, who sought to recover moneys paid under protest or to recover damages for actions taken under the *State Transport (Co-ordination) Act 1931-1952* (NSW). The defendants, primarily the Commissioner for Motor Transport and other state officials, relied on the 1954 Act to extinguish the plaintiffs' causes of action and bar their claims.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the *State Transport (Co-ordination) (Barring of Claims and Remedies) Act 1954* (NSW) was a valid exercise of State legislative power, or if it infringed section 92 of the Commonwealth Constitution, which guarantees the freedom of inter-State trade, commerce, and intercourse. Specifically, the Court had to determine if the Act, by extinguishing causes of action and barring remedies related to payments made or actions taken in the course of inter-State trade under the earlier Act, unconstitutionally interfered with this freedom. A further issue raised by one of the plaintiffs concerned the potential conflict between the 1954 Act and section 58 of the *Judiciary Act 1903-1950* (Cth).

The High Court held that sections 3 and 4 of the *State Transport (Co-ordination) (Barring of Claims and Remedies) Act 1954* (NSW) were invalid as they infringed section 92 of the Constitution. The Court reasoned that the Act, by purporting to extinguish causes of action for the recovery of moneys collected or for acts done in relation to inter-State trade, directly impacted the freedom guaranteed by section 92. While the Act dealt with past transactions, its effect was to impose a burden or disability on individuals because they had engaged in inter-State trade, thereby restricting that freedom. Furthermore, Fullagar J. found section 4 of the 1954 Act to be invalid due to its conflict with section 58 of the *Judiciary Act 1903-1950* (Cth), which provides a mechanism for suing a State. The Court's decision meant that the plaintiffs' claims were not barred by the 1954 Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established