Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd v Beck

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd v Beck [2013] FCA 960

Citation: Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd v Beck [2013] FCA 960
Parties: ANN STREET MEZZANINE PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 102 854 866) v CEDRIC RICHARD PALMER BECK & ORS (ACCORDING TO ATTACHED SCHEDULE); NORMAN PHILLIP CAREY & ORS (ACCORDING TO ATTACHED SCHEDULE); FREEHILLS and AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
File number: VID 485 of 2008
Judge: KENNY J
Date of judgment: 23 September 2013
Catchwords: COSTS - Review of taxation – Taxation of costs incurred in complying with subpoena - Award of costs made pursuant to r 24.22 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 – Costs claimed included work in preparing application to set subpoena aside in the context of non-responsive issuing party – No application to set aside subpoena made - No decision made to apply to set subpoena aside – Application dismissed.
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)
Federal Court Rules 1979 (Cth)
Cases cited: Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd (in liq) v Beck & Ors [2011] FCA 1328
A Pty Ltd v Z [2007] NSWSC 999
Australian Coal & Shale Employees’ Federation v Commonwealth (1953) 94 CLR 261
Schweppes’ Ltd v Archer (1934) 34 SR (NSW) 178
Amos v Monsour Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 741
Cachia v Westpac Financial Services Limited [2003] FCA 817
Frontier Assets Pty Ltd v Fishburn [2011] NSWSC 334 Hadid v Lenfest Communications Inc (1996) 65 FCR 350 Fuelxpress Ltd v LM Ericsson Pty Ltd (1987) 75 ALR 284 Re Pan Pharmaceuticals Ltd; Selim v McGrath (2004) 48 ACSR 681
Charlick Trading Pty Ltd v Australian National Railways Commission (1997) 149 ALR 647
Danieletto v Khera (1995) 35 NSWLR 684
Moorehead Nominees Pty Ltd & Ors v Barclays Australia Securities Ltd & Ors (Hill J, 17 May 1991, unreported)
Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Date of last submissions: 5 March 2013
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 63
Counsel for the First Cross-Claimant: M L Coulson and A Metaxas
Solicitor for the First Cross-Claimant: Metaxas & Hager
Solicitor for the Non-Party (Mr Vickers) Minter Ellison

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 485 of 2008

BETWEEN:

ANN STREET MEZZANINE PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 102 854 866)
Plaintiff

AND:

CEDRIC RICHARD PALMER BECK & ORS
(ACCORDING TO ATTACHED SCHEDULE)
Defendants

NORMAN PHILLIP CAREY & ORS
(ACCORDING TO ATTACHED SCHEDULE)
Cross-Claimants

FREEHILLS
First Cross-Respondent

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
Second Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

KENNY J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 SEPTEMBER 2013

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Derrick Vickers have leave to file the affidavit of Elizabeth Mary Harris sworn on 22 February 2013, with effect from 22 February 2013.

2.The application made pursuant to rule 40.34 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) be dismissed.

3.The first cross-claimant pay the non-party’s costs of and incidental to the application.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd v Beck and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 960
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd v Beck revolves around the interpretation and application of Rule 24.22 of the Federal Court Rules, specifically concerning the costs incurred in complying with a subpoena. The dispute was brought before the court to determine whether certain expenses were part of the reasonable loss and expense incurred by the subpoenaed party in complying with the subpoena, thus warranting compensation by the issuing party.

The legal issue before the court was whether certain core items, as detailed in Mr. Vickers' Bill of Costs, were indeed part of the loss and expense incurred in complying with the subpoena issued on 21 November 2011. The crux of the argument was centered on the distinction between the costs incurred as part of the compliance with the subpoena and those incurred in challenging its validity. The court had to determine if the preparation and filing of an application to set aside the subpoena, which were part of the core items, fell within the scope of compliance costs or were instead costs associated with litigation, which would not be compensable under Rule 24.22.

In addressing the issue, the court found that while certain costs associated with seeking advice on compliance and negotiating the scope of the subpoena could be considered part of the compliance costs, the costs related to preparing and filing a motion to set aside the subpoena did not fall within this category. The court reasoned that the filing of such a motion marks a departure from the mere compliance with the subpoena, entering into the realm of litigation where the subpoenaed party challenges the subpoena's validity. Consequently, these costs were not compensable under Rule 24.22. The court's decision hinged on a common sense approach to understanding the nature of particular costs, emphasizing the importance of distinguishing between compliance and litigation costs.

The court granted Mr. Vickers leave to file the Harris affidavit, nunc pro tunc, to ensure the reviewing court had access to the material before the taxing officer. The order of 14 December 2011, which was made under Rule 24.22, was affirmed, but with the clarification that the core items in question were not part of the loss and expense incurred in complying with the subpoena.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) had issued a subpoena to Beck, seeking production of documents and other materials. The plaintiff subsequently applied to the court to compel compliance with the subpoena, which was contested by Beck. As part of the process, the plaintiff's solicitors incurred various costs in advising Beck on compliance with the subpoena and in drafting an application to set aside the subpoena. These costs included expenses related to legal advice, drafting documents, attending client meetings, and other related activities. The taxing officer had determined that some of these costs were not recoverable as costs incurred in complying with the subpoena, leading to the present review by the court.

The case came before the court as a review of the taxing officer's decision regarding the recovery of costs under Rule 24.22 of the Federal Court Rules. The plaintiff, Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd, sought to recover certain costs incurred in advising Beck on compliance with the subpoena and in drafting an application to set aside the subpoena. The taxing officer had ruled that some of these costs were not recoverable, and the plaintiff appealed this decision. The court conducted a review of the taxing officer's decision and considered the arguments presented by both parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Brereton J’s analysis foregrounds the importance of a decision to file a motion (or, under the Federal Court Rules, an application) in understanding the point at which the subpoenaed person’s conduct “passed beyond the scope of compliance with the subpoena”. This must be the case. It is consistent with the reality of litigation and the negotiated interactions of opposing legal advisors that the threat of, including steps to prepare for a setting aside application, can, though will not always, be principally part of the strategies of negotiation employed by a party to narrow the scope of an unduly broad subpoena. Consideration about the content of a contemplated application, including the mapping and intellectual testing of its parameters and likely chances of success, can, though will not always, occur squarely in the course of advising as to whether (or to what extent) there should be compliance with an issued subpoena. Where considerations of this kind fall within such advice, the costs also fall within the settled territory described above at [34]. In this situation, an application to set aside the subpoena has not yet been ‘agitated’, in the sense used by Brereton J. This understanding is reflected in the Report of the taxing officer, in the passages set out earlier: see [9] above. A common sense approach to understanding the nature of particular costs was endorsed, in a similar way, in Frontier Assets, the third case on which Mr Carey relied. In Frontier Assets – not a case under this Court’s Rules – also involved the filing of an application to set aside the subpoena in question. The subpoena was, however, ultimately set aside by consent. The circumstances in that case led Harrison J to observe (at [38]) that there had been “a conspicuous absence of reasonable conduct and common sense” on the part of the lawyers and their clients. His Honour continued (at [39] and [40]):Having issued the subpoena, Frontier is liable for the reasonable loss and expense incurred by Mr Wavish in complying with it. …I do not consider that the loss and expense for which [the Rule] provides extends to include the costs associated with a challenge to the validity of the subpoena, or in this case the costs of the motion to set it aside. Costs of compliance can hardly include or incorporate the costs of litigation seeking to impugn or to challenge the very obligation to comply. Those costs must fall to be determined as part of the costs of the motion filed by Mr Wavish on 12 November 2010. However, I do not consider that the filing of the motion automatically had the effect that all or any costs incurred thereafter became costs in the motion as opposed to loss suffered and expense incurred in complying with the subpoena. Frontier and Mr Wavish were effectively corresponding on two fronts after 12 November 2010, sometimes attempting to resolve the issue of compliance with the subpoena and sometimes dealing with the motion to set it aside. Those efforts will have to be examined, with the costs and loss and expense apportioned accordingly.(Emphasis added.)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In this review, I have had regard to the documents annexed to the Harris affidavit on the basis that they were in fact before the taxing officer at the taxation hearing. I would grant Mr Vickers leave to file the Harris affidavit, nunc pro tunc, on the ground that the affidavit does no more than provide the reviewing court with the material that was before the taxing officer and verifies that fact. In so far as Mr Vickers’ submissions rely on those documents, the submissions are not objectionable.CONSIDERATION Rule 24.22 of the Federal Court Rules relevantly provides that:(1)The Court may order the issuing party to pay the amount of any reasonable loss or expense incurred in complying with the subpoena.(2)If an order is made under subrule (1), the Court must fix the amount or direct that it be fixed in accordance with the Court’s usual procedure in relation to costs.…The order of 14 December 2011 was made pursuant to this rule. The principal issue for determination is whether or not the core items were part of Mr Vickers’ “loss and expense incurred in complying with” the subpoena issued on 21 November 2011, since these were the subject of the order made under r 24.22. The Bill of Costs filed on behalf of Mr Vickers detailed the items for taxation, including the core items. Broadly speaking, in the period the challenged items were incurred, the Bill of Costs shows the following work was done: 29 November – 30 November 2011 drafting of communications by Mr Vickers’ solicitor to the client and counsel and to Mr Carey’s solicitor; attendance on the client; and drafting letter to Mr Carey’s solicitor as to hearing on 30 November 2011. (Items 6-8 and 12 were within this period.)5 December – 7 December 2011 attending: (i) the client to discuss work required to comply and preparation of application (to set aside the subpoena) and as to the responses of Mr Carey; (ii) counsel; (iii) with respect to the drafting of application and affidavit material; (iv) Mr Carey’s solicitor. Also perusing and drafting related communications and attending court, including advising as to awaiting Mr Carey’s solicitors’ consent to orders. (Items 15-49 were within this period.) 8 December 2011 drafting letter to Mr Carey’s solicitors seeking response to proposed restriction of scope of subpoena and perusal of Mr Carey’s solicitor’s consent to discharge of subpoena and related matters. (Items 53-54 and 56 were within this period). March 2012various consequential work, including paying counsel’s fees on brief to appear and settle affidavit (as described in Item 79). Relevant principles The courts have accepted that certain expenses or loss, where reasonably incurred, fall within the costs of compliance with a subpoena. These include the cost of advice on whether to comply with the subpoena at all and as to matters of confidentiality: see, with respect to O27, r 4A of the Federal Court Rules 1979 (‘the former Court Rules’), Hadid v Lenfest Communications Inc (1996) 65 FCR 350 (‘Hadid v Lenfest’), citing Fuelxpress Ltd v LM Ericsson Pty Ltd (1987) 75 ALR 284 (‘Fuelxpress’). See also Re Pan Pharmaceuticals Ltd; Selim v McGrath (2004) 48 ACSR 681 at 692 [43]. The costs of compliance have also encompassed the costs of correspondence about the scope of a subpoena: Hadid v Lenfest; Fuelxpress; and Charlick Trading Pty Ltd v Australian National Railways Commission (1997) 149 ALR 647 (‘Charlick v ANR’) at 649.