Andrew Yiasemides and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

[2014] AATA 51

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2013/2611

Re

Andrew Yiasemides

APPLICANT

And

Inspector-General in Bankruptcy

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms N Bell, Senior Member

Date 3 February 2014 
Place Sydney

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

............[Sgd]............................................................

Ms N Bell, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

BANKRUPTCY – refusal of Inspector General to enter on National Personal Insolvency Index

 – applicant claims administration of his estate was finalised – was the administration of the estate finalised – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), ss 19, 149, 184A

Bankruptcy Regulations 1966 (Cth), reg 8.14

CASES

Ferella and Another v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2010] FCA 766

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Insolvency and Trustee Service Australia, The Bankruptcy Regulator, Vol 5, Issue, May 2006

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms N Bell, Senior Member

3 February 2014 

  1. Andrew Yiasemides seeks review of the decision of the Inspector General in Bankruptcy to refuse to make an entry on the National Personal Insolvency Index stating that the administration of Mr Yiasemides’ bankrupt estate was finalised no later than 17 February, 2001.

  2. Mr Yiasemides became bankrupt in February 1998 after presenting a debtor’s petition. The Official Trustee was appointed as the Trustee of Mr Yiasemides’ bankrupt estate and an initial report to creditors was made by the officer acting on behalf of the Official Receiver.

  3. On 11 January, 1999, Mr Yiasemides sought the Official Trustee’s consent to travel overseas. After a telephone conversation between Mr Yiasemides and an officer of the Official Receiver on 15 January, a file note was made by the officer. Three days later Mr Yiasemides received a letter from the Official Receiver advising his travel overseas had been approved on the condition that he inform the Trustee within seven days of his return to Australia.

  4. In August 1999 Mr Yiasemides contacted the Official Receiver regarding the format for an offer of composition. The following day the Official Receiver wrote to Mr Yiasemides enclosing a suggested format for an offer of composition. In October 1999 an officer of the Official Receiver wrote again to Mr Yiasemides with advice as to the sum required to pay out his bankruptcy.

  5. On 17 February, 2001, by operation of section 149 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966, Mr Yiasemides was discharged from bankruptcy.

  6. On 5 August 2011 the Official Trustee received a “Consent to Act” from Paul Leroy. Mr Leroy is now the Registered Trustee of Mr Yiasemides’ estate.

  7. Mr Yiasemides contends that the administration of his estate was finalised, first, at the time he was given approval in January 1999 to travel overseas and is evidenced by the terms of the officer’s file note. He further contends that by the time of Mr Yiasemides’ automatic discharge from bankruptcy the administration of the estate was finalised. The Inspector-General contends that the file note is not evidence of finalisation and that in fact the estate has never been finalised. The Inspector-General also contends that, even if, as a matter of fact, the administration of the estate had been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Andrew Yiasemides and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 51
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Andrew Yiasemides applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) to review a decision of the Inspector-General in Bankruptcy, who refused to enter on the National Personal Insolvency Index that Mr Yiasemides' estate had been finalised. The AAT was required to determine whether the administration of Mr Yiasemides' estate had indeed been finalised and, if so, whether the Inspector-General should make an entry on the Index to that effect.

The central issue before the AAT was whether the administration of Mr Yiasemides' estate had been finalised. Mr Yiasemides argued that it had been finalised, relying on a file note from 1999 and the lack of any administrative activity in his estate from his discharge in 2001 until 2011. The Tribunal considered the contents of the file note and the absence of administrative activity, but ultimately found that the administration of the estate had not been finalised. The Tribunal concluded that the file note did not explicitly state that the estate had been finalised and that the absence of activity in the estate did not necessarily mean that the administration had concluded. Therefore, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the Inspector-General not to enter on the Index that the estate had been finalised.

The Tribunal's reasoning hinged on its interpretation of the file note and the lack of administrative activity. It held that the file note did not clearly indicate that the estate had been finalised, and that the absence of activity in the estate did not imply finalisation. Consequently, the Tribunal found that the decision of the Inspector-General was correct and should be affirmed. The Tribunal did not need to consider the other issues raised by Mr Yiasemides, as the central issue of finalisation had been resolved against him. The AAT's decision was that the decision under review should be affirmed, and no entry should be made on the Index to indicate that the estate had been finalised.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I find that the administration of the estate was not finalised. It follows that the other issues in this application fall away.DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The issues for me to consider are:(i)Was the administration of the estate finalised?(ii)If so, should the Inspector-General in Bankruptcy make an entry on the Index to the effect that the estate was finalised and, if so, in what terms?WAS THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE ESTATE FINALISED? Mr Yiasemides relies primarily on the combination of a file note made in January 1999 and an absence of activity in the estate after his discharge from bankruptcy in 2001 up until 2011. The file note was made by Mr Ian Keller, delegate of the Official Receiver, on 15 January 1999 following Mr Yiasemides’ request for approval to travel overseas. The request for approval to travel overseas is preceded in the file by a file note by Mr Keller on 17 February 1998 that notes one unsecured creditor for the sum of $1.3 million and nil assets and says:The bankrupt does not meet the criteria for early discharge.The bankrupt is not required to make compulsory contributions.A dividend to creditors is not likely.No Proofs of debt need to be lodged.Further notices will not be issued. The next document in the file appears to be a letter to Mr Yiasemides on behalf of the Official Receiver, by another officer, that advises him, among other things, that he is obliged to retain records, deliver documents relating to securities in which he has an interest and disclose all goods, property and monies belonging to him or acquired by him during the course of the bankruptcy. Then, after the request for approval to travel, the file note of interest appears. It says:The abovementioned became bankrupt on 16.2.98 – S.55.Bankrupt employed as a consultant by Concept Manufacturing P.L..In a letter dated 11.1.99 his employer advises that the bankrupt is required to travel to Hawaii on business, departing Australia on 10.2. 99 and returning on 20.2.99. The employer will meet all expenses.Nil realisable assets.1 creditor only – Tax – $1.3 million dollars – bankrupt was a director of Chem-Cal Industries P/L – bankrupt states than an administrator was appointed in 1993 and assured the bankrupt that the company had no tax liability, due to tax credits. Bankrupt later discovered substantial tax was outstanding & Tax looked to him for payment.Nothing outstanding & estate finalised.I recommend that the application be granted. Mr Yiasemides set great store by that part of the file note that says:Nothing outstanding & estate finalised. Mr Yiasemides also submitted that there is a positive duty on the Official Trustee to finalise the administration of an estate. He submitted that this duty arises out of section 19 of the Act and, in particular, the following duties listed in that section:(j) administering the estate as efficiently as possible by avoiding unnecessary expense;(k) exercising powers and performing functions in a commercially sound way. He also pointed to the ten year period following his discharge from bankruptcy during which there appear to have been no acts of administration of the estate.