Andrea Kelk and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

[2013] AATA 75

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/0259;

2011/1494;
2011/1499;

2011/5444

Re

Andrea Kelk

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President P E Hack SC

Date 15 February 2013
Place Brisbane

In each application the decision under review is affirmed.

..........................[Sgd]..............................................

Deputy President P E Hack SC

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – incapacity – not satisfied psychological condition contributed to, to a significant degree, by employment – not satisfied applicant suffered from injury to hands, arms and shoulders – not satisfied applicant suffered from any difficulties with voice in the relevant period – not satisfied applicant’s accepted injury resulted in permanent impairment – each decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 14, 19, and 24

Cases

Secondary Materials

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President P E Hack SC

Introduction 

  1. The applicant, Mrs Andrea Kelk, is a long-term employee of the respondent, Australian Postal Corporation (Australia Post).  Mrs Kelk says that she suffers from a variety of ailments which she attributes to her employment with Australia Post.  She made claims for compensation pursuant to the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (the SRC Act). Australia Post rejected most of those claims.

  2. Mrs Kelk now seeks a review of Australia Post's decisions to reject the claims.

    Background

  3. I will start with some uncontroversial background.  Mrs Kelk commenced employment with Australia Post in 1995 when she was about 28 years old.  Initially she worked as a postal services officer.  In 2000 she commenced work as a Senior Customer Service Consultant at Australia Post’s Milton customer relations centre.  From about 2007 Mrs Kelk commenced dealing with customer enquiries received by e-mail.  She was required to use a computer keyboard and mouse during her working day and, from time to time, used a telephone.  Mrs Kelk says that during this period of her employment she began to suffer pain in her left hand and arm.  Subsequently she was able to move to a position that involved significantly less keyboard work which she says reduced the pain in her hand and arm.

  4. Mrs Kelk's role changed again in February 2010 when she joined a group of employees dealing with complaints and enquiries about mail redirections.  In this role, she said, the amount of typing required significantly increased[1]. Moreover, she said, she was dealing with more complex complaints that required more time to resolve and “all”[2] the customers she dealt with were irate.

    [1]           Exhibit 3, paragraph 16.

    [2]           Transcript page 26, line 7.

  5. In around April or May 2010 Mrs Kelk says that she first noticed her voice becoming weaker, she found it difficult to swallow and developed pain and what she described as tension in her throat.  She says that she consulted her general practitioner, Dr Peter Hew, when the problem started. However that doctor’s first clinical note of an attendance concerning her throat is on 17 July 2010 and the note of the subsequent consultation on 24 July 2010 refers to the symptoms having been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Andrea Kelk and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 75
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mrs Andrea Kelk brought a claim against Australia Post for compensation for injuries she sustained during her employment. The case was determined by the Federal Court of Australia. Mrs Kelk commenced employment with Australia Post in 1995 and over the years, her role changed multiple times, involving increased use of computer keyboards and dealing with customer complaints. She claimed to have developed pain in her left hand and arm, as well as issues with her voice and throat, which she attributed to her employment conditions and duties.

The primary legal issue for the court was whether Mrs Kelk's injuries were caused by her employment with Australia Post. The court had to determine if the injuries were a result of the specific duties and conditions of her employment, such as the increased workload and typing demands, or if they arose from other causes. The court also needed to assess the credibility of Mrs Kelk's claims and the evidence presented by both parties.

The court found that Mrs Kelk's injuries were not solely attributable to her employment with Australia Post. The court considered the evidence, including medical reports and witness statements, and concluded that while her employment may have contributed to her condition, other factors, such as her general health and lifestyle, also played a role. The court held that Australia Post was not liable for compensation as Mrs Kelk's injuries were not exclusively work-related.

The court's decision was that Australia Post was not liable for compensation to Mrs Kelk for her injuries. The court dismissed her claim and ordered her to pay Australia Post's costs of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mrs Kelk now seeks a review of Australia Post's decisions to reject the claims.Background I will start with some uncontroversial background. Mrs Kelk commenced employment with Australia Post in 1995 when she was about 28 years old. Initially she worked as a postal services officer. In 2000 she commenced work as a Senior Customer Service Consultant at Australia Post’s Milton customer relations centre. From about 2007 Mrs Kelk commenced dealing with customer enquiries received by e-mail. She was required to use a computer keyboard and mouse during her working day and, from time to time, used a telephone. Mrs Kelk says that during this period of her employment she began to suffer pain in her left hand and arm. Subsequently she was able to move to a position that involved significantly less keyboard work which she says reduced the pain in her hand and arm. Mrs Kelk's role changed again in February 2010 when she joined a group of employees dealing with complaints and enquiries about mail redirections. In this role, she said, the amount of typing required significantly increased[1]. Moreover, she said, she was dealing with more complex complaints that required more time to resolve and “all”[2] the customers she dealt with were irate.[1] Exhibit 3, paragraph 16.[2] Transcript page 26, line 7. In around April or May 2010 Mrs Kelk says that she first noticed her voice becoming weaker, she found it difficult to swallow and developed pain and what she described as tension in her throat. She says that she consulted her general practitioner, Dr Peter Hew, when the problem started. However that doctor’s first clinical note of an attendance concerning her throat is on 17 July 2010 and the note of the subsequent consultation on 24 July 2010 refers to the symptoms having been present “since beginning of month”. In July 2010 Mrs Kelk’s supervisor was Mr Joel Muir. On 22 July 2010 Mrs Kelk had a number of conversations with Mr Muir which he documented at the time in an “Issue Register”[3]. It will suffice for present purposes to note that in the afternoon of that day Mr Muir is recorded saying to Mrs Kelk that she “looked noticibly [sic] upset” and that, according to Mr Muir, Mrs Kelk told him,… that she would not take anymore [sic] calls today as she thought the new expectations were stupid and not reasonable.The following day Mrs Kelk called in sick. Mr Muir's note of the conversation reads, Andrea advised that she believes the work load [sic] is unreasonable and she is very emotional. This has led to her being unwell and stressed. I advised due to her stating this as a work related [sic] we will have to follow the specified process. … She is also lodging a compliant [sic] with com care [sic].Mrs Kelk did not return to work thereafter until early October 2010.[3] Exhibit 30. Mrs Kelk attended Dr Hew on 24 July 2010. He subsequently reported her complaints in these terms[4],Mrs Kelk stated she had become even more stressed at work since the unrealistic demands placed by management at the Australia Post Call Centre at the beginning of this year. She stated that she was having to be constantly typing on her keyboard with customer on hold online. She stated that staff numbers had been reduced and as a consequence her workload and the workload of remaining staff had trebled. This was causing her to;1. develop tension headaches in her temporal area, shoulder and neck.2. pains in both her arms, forearms, wrist, dorsum of hands and fingers from continual typing without appropriate breaks3. making her ill tempered, teary and tense.She also states that her symptoms are worse at the end of her working shift and improves with rest over the weekends. She also states that she leaves work in a highly stressed state at the end of a shift.Mrs Kelk also complained of foods and liquids getting caught in her throat when she swallows. However a subsequent barium swallow was reported normal. This she attributes to being caused from stress from her work.[4] Exhibit 2(1), page 187.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.