Anderson v Bourke; Myrteza v North Burleigh Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Anderson v Bourke & Ors; Myrteza v North Burleigh Pty Ltd & Ors [2018] QSC 126

PARTIES:

11485 of 2017:
SONYA MARGARET ANN ANDERSON AS TRUSTEE OF THE ANDERSON FAMILY (NO 2) TRUSTALAN JAMES BOURKE
(plaintiff)
v
SOUTH MACLEAN HOLDINGS PTY LTD
ACN 166 890 080 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE SMH TRUST

(first defendant)
and
JAMIE BOURKE
(second defendant)
and
ACN 128 875 810 (FORMERLY JAMCAM PTY LTD) AS TRUSTEE OF THE IPSWICH UNIT TRUST
(third defendant)
and
TIMOTHY DELANEY
(fourth defendant)
and
JB SUPER COMPANY PTY LTD ACN 603 444 695
(fifth defendant)
and

(sixth defendant)

10886 of 2017:
DUKOS MYRTEZA

(plaintiff)

v
NORTH BURLEIGH PTY LTD ACN 121078 199

(first defendant)
and
WAYNE MELVILLE COLLIE
(second defendant)
and
SOUTH MACLEAN HOLDINGS PTY LTD
ACN 166 890 080 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE SMH TRUST

(third defendant)
and
JB SUPER COMPANY PTY LTD ACN 603 444 695
(fourth defendant)
and
JAMIE BOURKE
(fifth defendant)

FILE NOS:

11485 of 2017 and 10886 of 2017

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

31 May 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

3 May 2018

JUDGE:

Applegarth J

ORDERS:

11485 of 2017:

1.     The claim against the fifth defendant be struck out.

2.     The statement of claim filed 2 November 2017 and the amended statement of claim filed 18 April 2018 against the first, second, third, fourth and sixth defendants be struck out.

3.     Caveat No 718335433 and Caveat No 718335431 be removed forthwith.

4.     The plaintiff pay the first, second, third, fourth and sixth defendants’ costs of and incidental to the applications filed 25 February 2018.

5.     The costs of the fifth defendant are reserved.

10886 of 2017:

1.     The plaintiff’s application be dismissed.

2.     The plaintiff pay the third defendant’s costs of and incidental to the application to be assessed.

CATCHWORDS:

MORTGAGES – MORTGAGES AND CHARGES GENERALLY – ACCOUNTS – DUTY TO ACCOUNT AFTER MORTGAGEE EXERCISES POWER OF SALE – duty to account dependent on surplus – fact of surplus not pleaded – striking out of pleading

TORTS – MISCELLANEOUS TORTS – CONSPIRING TO INJURE – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – where plaintiff alleges unlawful means conspiracy against the defendants –  where the defendants apply for the pleadings against them to be struck out – where the plaintiff does not properly identify the relevant wrong which is said to constitute the unlawful means – where the plaintiff does not properly plead causation or loss – whether pleadings are embarrassing

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – PLEADINGS – FORM OF PLEADING – OTHER MATTERS – STRIKING OUT – where pleadings are embarrassing, tend to cause prejudice or delay a fair trial or contain scandalous or unnecessary allegations – requirement for clear pleading – pleading allegations of wrongdoing and dishonesty –  pleading basis for equitable remedies – pleading causation and loss

Land Titles Act 1994 s 129
Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) s 85
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Anderson v Bourke; Myrteza v North Burleigh Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QSC 126
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Anderson v Bourke; Myrteza v North Burleigh Pty Ltd, the court was presented with a complex dispute involving multiple parties and allegations of conspiracy, fraud, and breaches of duty. The primary dispute centred around the sale of property known as the 301 Property, the obligations of the mortgagee, and the alleged collusive agreement among the parties. The plaintiff, Anderson, sought compensation and an account from North Burleigh, the mortgagee, as well as damages from several other defendants, including Mr Delaney, for their alleged roles in a fraudulent scheme.

The court was tasked with determining several key legal issues. These included whether North Burleigh had a duty to account to Anderson post-sale, the nature and validity of the alleged conspiracy, and the adequacy of the plaintiff's pleadings regarding causation and loss. The court also had to consider the defendants' applications to strike out the plaintiff's claims for being embarrassing, vexatious, and lacking in particulars.

The court found significant deficiencies in the plaintiff's pleadings. It determined that the plaintiff had not properly pleaded the existence of a surplus, which was a critical element of her claim against North Burleigh. Additionally, the court found that the plaintiff's allegations against Mr Delaney were not supported by particulars and were therefore embarrassing and vexatious. The court held that the plaintiff's claims were speculative and lacked the necessary factual basis, leading to the conclusion that the pleadings against Mr Delaney should be struck out. The court also found that the plaintiff's claims against other defendants were similarly defective and ordered that their pleadings be struck out as well.

In summary, the court granted the defendants' applications to strike out the plaintiff's claims, finding them to be inadequately pleaded and vexatious. The court ordered the plaintiff to pay the costs of the defendants in relation to the applications.

Orders

Orders of the court

11485 of 2017:

1. The claim against the fifth defendant be struck out.

2. The statement of claim filed 2 November 2017 and the amended statement of claim filed 18 April 2018 against the first, second, third, fourth and sixth defendants be struck out.

3. Caveat No 718335433 and Caveat No 718335431 be removed forthwith.

4. The plaintiff pay the first, second, third, fourth and sixth defendants’ costs of and incidental to the applications filed 25 February 2018.

5. The costs of the fifth defendant are reserved.

10886 of 2017:

1. The plaintiff’s application be dismissed.

2. The plaintiff pay the third defendant’s costs of and incidental to the application to be assessed.

Background

Background to the litigation

In summary, if North Burleigh as mortgagee exercising power of sale has an obligation to account to Anderson, then that obligation survives regardless of the contract price for which the 301 Property was sold. If by selling the property for $1 million North Burleigh breached its statutory duty to exercise reasonable care to obtain market value then Anderson’s claim for compensation against North Burleigh survives. She is prosecuting a claim against North Burleigh for the difference between the sale price of $1 million which was accounted for and what she asserts may be the true value of the 301 Property at the time it was sold. The alleged collusive agreement or conspiracy has not caused the loss of her claims for an account or compensation against North Burleigh. Anderson has not pleaded that had there not been the “collusive agreement” and, instead, North Burleigh had sold the 301 Property for its market value, observing its obligations under s 85 of the Property Law Act, that the proceeds of sale would have been sufficient to discharge the mortgage debt then due to North Burleigh, and debts then due to subsequent mortgagees such as Mr Myrteza, and left her with a surplus. Background The 301 Property was originally owned by Pearlbran Pty Ltd as Trustee of the Maclean Land Trust. It is alleged that Pearlbran was in financial difficulties, with various proceedings commenced against it by financial institutions. At different stages it had registered mortgages in favour of Ascent Funds Management Ltd and Win Mezz No 19 Pty Ltd. In circumstances which are unclear, and which are alleged by Mr Delaney to have involved a transfer to defeat creditors, Pearlbran Pty Ltd as Trustee of the Maclean Land Trust is alleged to have transferred its interests in the 301 Property to Steven John Anderson and David Anthony Anderson as Trustees of the Anderson Family Trust No 2. This is alleged to have been a fraudulent scheme by them and others, including the present plaintiff, to remove any assets held by Pearlbran Pty Ltd so as to avoid paying creditors. In about December 2007, Pearlbran Pty Ltd as Trustee of the Maclean Land Trust entered into a short-term loan agreement with North Burleigh for an advance of $1,200,000 for a term of one month with interest payable at five per cent per month, or at seven per cent per month if in default. This first loan was secured by way of a second mortgage over land then described as Lot 310. At the time of this advance there was a first mortgage over the property securing a loan by Ascent Funds Management Pty Ltd, which Mr Collie says was owed in excess of $3,600,000. There was development approval in place for the subdivision of the property. The borrower defaulted on the North Burleigh loan and failed to repay any of the principal amount upon the expiry of its term. It seems that it was also in substantial default under the first mortgage and Ascent Finance intended to take possession of the property. At that stage no substantive works had been taken towards subdividing the property. The property was transferred from Pearlbran to the Trustees of the Anderson Family No 2 Trust in about April 2008.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The pleading does not disclose in any intelligible form plead facts from which to infer that Mr Delaney was a party to the 301 Property Collusive Scheme from its inception and thereby knew of it. The things that it does plead are consistent with his acting as a solicitor for the purchaser of the 301 Property, including conduct which would be undertaken by a solicitor in any such transaction, such as the lodging of a Form 1 which reflected the consideration stated in the contract. The pleading does not disclose, nor does any evidence before me disclose, that Mr Delaney knew that the consideration for the 301 Property was other than the stated price of $1 million. The pleading, far from alleging that he was a party to the alleged conspiracy from its inception, does not include him as one of the parties who struck what Anderson alleges as the trade involving the Ipswich property and the Southport property. It is not alleged that he had any role in the Brilab contract negotiation or termination. The pleading is consistent with his acting as a solicitor in a transaction. If it be supposed for the purpose of argument that in doing so he facilitated a scheme that was hatched by Mr Collie and Mr Bourke, then he facilitated the settlement of the relevant sale transaction. It does not make him a party to the alleged conspiracy. Conclusion – Mr Delaney’s application There are fundamental deficiencies in relation to this proceeding against all defendants in terms of matters which are unnecessarily pleaded and the omission to plead matters which are fundamental to the allegation that Anderson suffered loss. This proceeding seems to be contingent upon the allegation made in proceeding 7032/16 about North Burleigh having a duty to account. Anderson fails to plead that had North Burleigh properly accounted for the true value of the 301 Property she would have received a surplus. Presently I am concerned with the defects in the pleaded claim against Mr Delaney. They are many and varied. The implicit assertion that he was a party to a conspiracy from its inception lacks particularity. It is embarrassing and Anderson’s inability to provide particulars or give any indication as to when and how such particulars would be forthcoming justifies paragraph 22 being struck out against him. The alleged conspiracy or collusive agreement is not one which alleges in an intelligible form an unlawful means conspiracy. Insofar as it appears to allege that there was an unlawful means conspiracy in respect of breaches of fiduciary duty, the claim is unsound in law. The pleading of causation and loss is deficient and embarrassing. Ultimately, the pleading makes speculative and unparticularised allegations against Mr Delaney including allegations of what he knew. For good reason, the pleading rules require material facts in support of such allegations to be pleaded. The claim and the pleading against Mr Delaney are vexatious. The original allegations that he was a party to a collusive scheme were serious allegations which should not have been pleaded without a proper foundation. Allegations of dishonesty of any kind should not be lightly made. Rather than resile from them, Ms Anderson and her legal advisers added a misconceived claim against Mr Delaney alleging the tort of conspiracy by unlawful means and included serious allegations of criminal conduct. The material before me does not support the suggestion that Mr Delaney knew that the 301 Property was worth anything like $5.3 million. Anderson’s pleading in places gives it a value in a range starting at $1 million, so it is hard to see why Mr Delaney would know that its value was more than $1 million. He was not required to investigate its value.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established