Andema Pty Ltd v Noosa Shire Council

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT

OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Andema Pty Ltd v Noosa Shire Council [2020] QPEC 46

PARTIES:

ANDEMA PTY LTD (ACN 608 755 997) AS TRUSTEE UNDER INSTRUMENT 717956144

(appellant)

v

NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

2352 of 2019

DIVISION:

Planning and Environment Court

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Planning and Environment Court, Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

9 September 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

20, 23, 24, 27 and 28 April 2020

JUDGE:

Kefford DCJ

ORDER:

1.        The appeal is dismissed. 

2.        The decision to refuse the appellant’s development application, communicated by decision notice dated 6 June 2019, is confirmed.

CATCHWORDS:

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT – APPEAL – appeal against refusal of a development application seeking a development permit for material change of use for a retail and commercial premises – whether the proposed development is of an appropriate height, bulk and scale – whether the roof form is appropriate – whether there are sufficient carparks – whether there is inconsistency between provisions of a code – whether the development should be approved in the exercise of discretion

CASES:

AAD Design Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council [2012] QCA 44; [2013] 1 Qd R 1, applied

Baskerville & Ors v Brisbane City Council & Anor [2010] QPEC 143; [2011] QPELR 333, approved

Gorman & Ors v Brisbane City Council & Anor [2004] QPELR 29, approved

Jakel Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council & Anor [2018] QPEC 21; [2018] QPELR 763, approved

Klinkert v Brisbane City Council [2018] QPEC 30; [2018] QPELR 941, approved

Lake Maroona Pty Ltd v Gladstone Regional Council [2017] QPEC 25; (2017) 224 LGERA 166, approved

Lyons v Brisbane City Council & Ors [2009] QPEC 102; [2010] QPELR 190, approved

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28; (1998) 194 CLR 355, applied

The Planning Place v Brisbane City Council [2018] QPEC 62; [2019] QPELR 396, approved

Zappala Family Co Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council [2014] QCA 147; [2014] QPELR 686, applied

LEGISLATION:

Planning Act 2016 (Qld), s 45, s 59, s 60

Planning and Environment Court Act 2016 (Qld), s 43, s 45, s 47

Planning Regulation 2017 (Qld), s 27

COUNSEL:

B D Job QC and D Purcell for the appellant

C L Hughes QC and H Stephanos for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Connor O’Meara for the appellant

Wakefield Sykes, Solicitor for the respondent

Table of contents

Introduction........................................................................................................................... 3

The decision framework....................................................................................................... 3

What are the issues in this case?........................................................................................... 4

Is the built form of the proposed development appropriate?................................................ 6

Does the proposed development comply with the relevant requirements regarding height and visual impact?.......................................................................................................................................... 9

Will the proposed development present a building height consistent with structures on adjoining and surrounding land?....................................................................................................... 10
Will the proposed development exceed two storeys in height?.................................. 14
Will the proposed development visually dominate the street, adjacent properties, surrounding spaces or the existing skyline?................................................................................................... 16

Does the proposed development comply with the relevant requirements about building bulk…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Andema Pty Ltd v Noosa Shire Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QPEC 46
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Andema Pty Ltd v Noosa Shire Council, the appellant sought to challenge the refusal of a development application by the Noosa Shire Council, which aimed to authorize a material change of use for a retail and commercial premises. The appellant's proposal involved converting the subject land into a retail, dining, and commercial facility, in accordance with the design plans presented. The primary legal issues before the court were whether the proposed development was of an appropriate height, bulk, and scale, whether the roof form was suitable, whether there were sufficient carparks, and whether there was any inconsistency between the provisions of the code. Additionally, the court had to decide whether the development should be approved in the exercise of its discretion.

The court considered the statutory framework provided by the Planning and Environment Court Act 2016 (Qld) and the Planning Act 2016 (Qld). It was established that the appeal was to be heard anew, with the appellant bearing the burden of proof. The court assessed the proposal against the applicable assessment benchmarks in the Noosa Plan 2006 Version No. 9, and considered any matters prescribed by regulation, including the common material lodged in respect of the development application and any development approval for, and any lawful use of, the premises or adjacent premises.

Upon reviewing the evidence and arguments presented, the court concluded that the proposed development did not comply with the relevant roof form requirements, and the non-compliances were material. The court found that the proposed development presented an overall unacceptable impact on the existing streetscape and the intended character of the locality. This was due to a combination of factors, including the significant plot ratio, the incorporation of a parapet instead of a curved or pitched roof, the monotonous timber battens, the height and design details of the proposed awning, and the lack of meaningful setback and openings at level one.

Consequently, the court dismissed the appeal and confirmed the decision to refuse the appellant's development application. The court held that the proposed development did not comply with specific outcomes and overall outcomes of the Eastern Beaches Locality Code and could not be approved in the exercise of its discretion. The final orders included dismissing the appeal and confirming the decision to refuse the appellant's development application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

2. The decision to refuse the appellant’s development application, communicated by decision notice dated 6 June 2019, is confirmed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The issue for me to determine is whether the proposed development should be approved or refused.The decision framework The statutory framework in the Planning and Environment Court Act 2016 (Qld) and the Planning Act 2016 (Qld) applies. The appeal proceeds by way of hearing anew.[1] The appellant bears the onus.[2] [1]Planning and Environment Court Act 2016, s 43.[2]Planning and Environment Court Act 2016, s 45. The appellant seeks a development permit to authorise it to carry out a material change of use of the subject land. It wishes to use the subject land for a retail, dining and commercial facility generally in accordance with the design reflected in the plans provided as Exhibit 4.1. The development application made to facilitate that outcome required code assessment. As such, the Court’s assessment must be carried out only:(a)against the applicable assessment benchmarks in the Noosa Plan 2006 Version No. 9 (“the Planning Scheme”);[3] and(b)having regard to any matters prescribed by regulation, including the common material lodged in respect of the development application[4] and any development approval for, and any lawful use of, the premises or adjacent premises.[5][3]The Noosa Plan 2006 Version No. 9 was the categorising instrument in force at the time the development application was properly made on 19 December 2018.[4]Planning Regulation 2017 (Qld), s 27(1)(g).[5]Planning Regulation 2017, s 27(1)(g). In deciding the appeal, the Court must confirm the decision appealed against, change the decision appealed against, or set it aside and either make a decision replacing it or return the matter to the Council with directions that the Court considers appropriate.[6] The decision must be based on the assessment.[7] The Court must approve the application to the extent it complies with all the assessment benchmarks.[8] To the extent that the proposed development does not comply with all or some of the assessment benchmarks, the Court may decide to refuse the application only if compliance cannot be achieved by the imposition of development conditions.[9] Even if the development does not comply with some of the assessment benchmarks, the Court may decide to approve the application.[10] [6]Planning and Environment Court Act 2016, s 47.[7]Planning Act 2016, s 59(3).[8]Planning Act 2016, s 60(2)(a).[9]Planning Act 2016, s 60(2)(d).[10]Planning Act 2016, s 60(2)(b). The question of whether departure from an assessment benchmark warrants refusal is a separate and distinct question. I respectfully agree with the observations of His Honour Judge Williamson QC in Klinkert v Brisbane City Council.[11] He observed that although the discretion is expressed in permissive and broad terms, it is subject to an important constraint, namely the constraint expressed in s 59(3) of the Planning Act 2016 requiring the decision to be based on the assessment carried out only against the assessment benchmarks and having regard to prescribed matters. I also adopt the observations of His Honour Judge Williamson QC in Smout v Brisbane City Council,[12] where His Honour observed that given the size and complexity of modern performance based planning schemes, not every non-compliance will warrant refusal.[11][2018] QPEC 30; [2018] QPELR 941, 957 [102]. Leave to appeal was granted by the Court of Appeal but the appeal was dismissed in Brisbane City Council v Klinkert [2019] QCA 40; (2019) 236 LGERA 88.[12][2019] QPEC 10; [2019] QPELR 684, 694 [54].What are the issues in this case?

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For the reasons provided above, the proposed development does not comply with the relevant roof form requirements and the non-compliances are material.Conclusion regarding built form, character and visual amenity considerations In Jakel Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council & Anor,[27] I observed:“Whether the proposed development acceptably responds to the performance outcomes and overall outcomes with respect to height, bulk, scale, setbacks, transitions and separations and is acceptable in terms of its character and amenity impacts, is an evaluative judgment on which reasonable minds might differ. Questions of consistency of bulk and scale with streetscape character and amenity involve judgments that are “inherently subjective and can be nebulous”.”[27][2018] QPEC 21; [2018] QPELR 763, 822 [277] citing Caltibiano v Brisbane City Council [2004] QPEC 36; [2005] QPELR 60, 64 [24] and Quintenon Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council [2016] QPEC 64; [2017] QPELR 88, 101 [62]. As I also noted in that case,[28] sometimes subtle variations in dimensions from surrounding built form can, in combination, result in an overall unacceptable impact. This is such a case. [28]citing the observations of His Honour Judge Jones in BTS Properties (Qld) Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council [2015] QPEC 47; [2015] QPELR 943, 961 [67]. I accept the evidence of Mr Powell that various dimensions of the proposed building and elements of its design are consistent with other nearby buildings. There are aspects of the proposed development that are also consistent with the existing approval, such as the plot ratio. Nevertheless, my overall impression of the proposed development is that it presents as an overdevelopment of the subject land in its locational context. It is an unacceptable outcome in terms of visual impact on the existing streetscape and having regard to the intended character of the locality. The overall unacceptable impact is not attributable to a single dimension of the proposed development, but is evident from a combination of:(a)the significant plot ratio, which is a metric that reflects the proposed development’s high site coverage across two levels and absent features, such as balconies, that might otherwise mitigate the consequential appearance of bulk; (b)the incorporation of a parapet rather than a curved or pitched roof; (c)the monotonous timber battens, which exacerbate the building’s verticality;(d)the height and design details of the proposed awning, which will cause the awning to have a low, heavy and potentially oppressive presence on the public space; and(e)the lack of meaningful setback and openings at level one, which will create an impression that the building crowds the street and looms over it. Having regard to the combined effect of these design attributes, I am not persuaded that the proposed development complies with specific outcomes O4 b) and c), O6 a) and b), O10 a), O12 a) to d), O61 d), e) and g) and probable solutions S4.1 e), S12.1 and S12.2 of the Eastern Beaches Locality Code. It is also not consistent with overall outcomes 7.7.2 g) i., ii. and iv., and jj) iv. of the Eastern Beaches Locality Code.