American Airlines Inc v Advantagecard Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Oppositions by American Airlines, Inc. to applications under section 92 of the Act by Advantagecard Pty Ltd to remove trade mark numbers 519305(39), 702930(39), 702934(39), 721814(39), 805290(35)(39) 826664(35)(39) - AAdvantage trade marks – registered in the name of American Airlines, Inc

Delegate:

Iain Campbell Thompson

Representation:

Owner: Eric Ziehlke of Chrysiliou IP

Removal Applicant: Did not appear or file written submissions

Decision:

2013 ATMO 63

Section 96 - s92(4)(a) and (b) trade marks used in good faith during relevant period.

Oppositions to removal established

Background

  1. In these proceedings under section 96 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) Advantagecard Pty Ltd (‘the Removal Applicant’) applied under paragraphs 92(a) and (b) on 14 August 2009 for the removal of the trade marks listed hereunder for all services in respect of which they are registered except, where relevant, for the services, ‘providing a program of bonus flights for frequent travelers.’

    Registration No:             519305

    Priority Date:                   15 September 1989

    Services:Class 39: Services rendered in the carriage or transport of passengers and freight by aeroplane and related or ancillary means of transport; and all other services necessarily connected with or ancillary to such transport including freight forwarding and storage, arranging of tours and travel information

    Trade Mark:  

    Registration No:             702930

    Priority Date:                   20 February 1996

    Services:Class 39: Transportation of passengers by air, including providing a program of bonus flights for frequent travellers

    Trade Mark:  AAdvantage Gold

    Registration No:             702934

    Priority Date:                   20 February 1996

    Services:Class 39: Transportation of passengers by air, including providing a program of bonus flights for frequent travellers

    Trade Mark:  AAdvantage Platinum

    Registration No:             721814

    Priority Date:                   14 November 1996

    Services:Class 39: Services in relation to the transportation of passengers by air, inclusive of providing a program of bonus flights for frequent travellers

    Trade Mark:  

    Registration No:             805290

    Priority Date:                   27 August 1999

    Services:Class 35: Promoting the goods and services of other [sic] by means of an incentive awards program, whereby purchase points are awarded for purchase made from vendor subscribers, which can then be rendered for merchandise and travel

    Class 39: Providing air transportation services featuring a program of bonus flights for frequent travellers

    Trade Mark:  AAdvantage

    Registration No:             826664

    Priority Date:                   7 March 2000

    Services:Class 35: Promoting the goods and services of others by means of an incentive awards program, whereby purchase points are awarded for purchases made from vendor subscribers, which can then be redeemed for merchandise and travel

    Class 39: Transportation of passengers and cargo; travel information and reservation services

    Trade Mark:  

  2. On 1 December 2009 American Airlines, Inc. (‘the Owner’) filed Notices of Opposition (‘the Notices’) to the removal applications.  The Notices state the grounds of opposition to removal which were subsequently argued before me.

  3. The parties have served and filed evidence as discussed hereunder to support their respective positions.

  4. Subsequently both parties were informed of their right…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read American Airlines Inc v Advantagecard Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] ATMO 63
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

American Airlines Inc. (the Owner) opposed an application by Advantagecard Pty Ltd (the Removal Applicant) to remove three trade marks from the Register. The Owner alleged that it had used the impugned trade marks in relation to the services for which they were registered. The proceedings were heard by Iain Campbell Thompson, a Hearing Officer of the Trade Marks Hearings.

The central legal issue before the Hearing Officer was whether the Owner had established, on the balance of probabilities, that it had used the impugned trade marks in relation to the services for which they were registered during the relevant period. This required an examination of the nature of the Owner's operations in Australia, particularly its codeshare arrangements with Qantas and its loyalty program.

The Hearing Officer considered evidence detailing the Owner's history and its significant market share in the USA, along with its "AA device trade mark." The evidence explained that the Owner participates in the oneworld Alliance with Qantas, which facilitates codeshare agreements and reciprocal frequent flyer programs. A codeshare agreement allows multiple airlines to sell space on the same flight, with the flight being operated by one airline but sold under the flight numbers of others. The Owner's codeshare arrangements with Qantas involved flights between the US and Australia, and within Australia, where flights could be purchased under either the Qantas (QF) or American Airlines (AA) codes, even if operated by the other airline. The Hearing Officer found that this evidence demonstrated sufficient use of the impugned trade marks in relation to the registered services.

The Hearing Officer decided that the Owner had established its opposition to the removal of the trade marks from the Register. Consequently, the Removal Applicant was ordered to pay the Owner's costs on the official scale, to be apportioned between the oppositions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence served and filed by the parties in these matters comprises statutory declarations being:Evidence in SupportCharles SultanStephen LimbrickEvidence in AnswerMark TrumanEvidence in ReplySuzanne Rubin Charles Sultan is Vice President Partner Marketing of the Owner. Mr Sultan details the history of the Owner from its roots in the 1920s through to the Aviation Corporation in 1928 which acquired many existing aviation companies and which were incorporated into American Airways Inc. in 1930 which changed its name in 1934 to that of the Owner – American Airlines, Inc. By 2007 the Owner’s market share in the USA was 18% and its ‘house’ trade mark is that which appears below:(‘the AA device trade mark’) The device component of the AA device trade mark is a stylised American eagle and the AA device trade mark appears within impugned registrations 519305, 721814 and 826664. There are two factors attested to by Mr Sultan which bear on the Owner’s allegation that it has used the impugned trade marks. Firstly, the Owner has a codeshare arrangement with QANTAS; and, secondly, it has an extensive loyalty program which it operates (and the Removal Applicant appears – via its seeking to limit the impugned registrations to ‘providing a program of bonus flights for frequent travellers’ – to implicitly agree that the Owner has provided this loyalty program). In order to explain my decisions, it is necessary to discuss the nature of both ‘codeshare’ and the loyalty program.Codeshare Mr Sultan explains:American Airlines' presence in Australia is manifested in its involvement with the oneworld Alliance and its partnership with Qantas. The nature of the association of American Airlines with Qantas stems from their historical relationship and the fact that both airlines are members of the oneworld Alliance which brings together eleven of the leading airlines in the world. The Alliance provides a close link between American Airlines and Qantas in a range of services which include the mutual recognition of frequent flyers. Launched early in 1999, February 2009 marked the 10th anniversary of the oneworld Alliance. Originally made up of five respected airlines, including American and Qantas Airlines, in a few years, oneworld has become one of the strongest air transport networks in the world, reaching cities all over the globe. oneworld has been named the World's Leading Airline Alliance at the World Travel Awards for six years in a row, a reflection of the Alliance's dedication to quality.Qantas and American Airlines, cooperate through codeshare agreements, reciprocal frequent flyer programs and lounge access arrangements. The relationship began in 1989 with what was, at the time, the world's first commercial codeshare agreement. A codeshare is the practice of more than one airline selling space on the same flight, where a seat can be purchased on one airline but is actually operated by a cooperating airline under a different flight number or code. American Airlines codeshares on Qantas transpacific flights between the U.S. and Australia and New Zealand, as well as Qantas flights within and between select destinations in Australia and New Zealand. Through its codeshare agreement with Qantas, American Airlines offers flights to Australia via Adelaide, Brisbane, Cairns, Melbourne, Perth and Sydney. Thus, for example, an Australian passenger can purchase a flight on to the United States, and each leg is listed under both the QF code (for Qantas), even though a leg of the trip may be operated by American Airlines. The same leg of the trip operated by American Airlines would be cross-listed under the AA code (for American Airlines) for purchasers. An Australian passenger may purchase the identical flight on and here the flight would be listed under the AA code. Conversely, a United States passenger may purchase a flight on to Australia and each leg is listed under the AA code, even though one or more legs of the trip may be operated by Qantas. The same leg of the trip operated by Qantas would be cross-listed under the QF code for purchasers.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, in my consideration the Owner has shown, on the balance of probabilities, that it has used the impugned trade marks in relation to the services in respect of which they are registered during the relevant period.Decision Subsection 101(1) provides:101Determination of opposed application—general(1)Subject to subsection (3) and to section 102, if:(a)the proceedings relating to an opposed application have not been discontinued or dismissed; and(b)the Registrar is satisfied that the grounds on which the application was made have been established;the Registrar may decide to remove the trade mark from the Register in respect of any or all of the goods and/or services to which the application relates. The Owner has established its opposition to the removal of the trade marks from the Register.Costs Costs may follow the event and I order costs at the official scale against the Removal Applicant to be appropriately apportioned between the oppositions. Accordingly, the Owner is entitled, for instance, to claim its costs once for its evidence in support; once for its evidence in reply, and once in relation to its attendance at the hearing but is entitled each official fee incurred as a result of its opposition to the removal of the impugned trade marks.Iain Campbell ThompsonHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings21 August 2013

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established