Amazon Technologies Inc. v The Echo Label Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re: Opposition by The Echo Label Limited to an application under section 92 of the Act by Amazon Technologies Inc. to remove trade mark registration 670282 – ECHO (class 9) – in the name of The Echo Label Limited

Delegate: Katrina Brown
Representation: Removal Applicant: Not represented at hearing – written submissions by King & Wood Mallesons
Removal Opponent: Sean McManis of Shelston IP
Decision: 2019 ATMO 58
Trade Marks Act 1995 – opposed application for removal under s 92(4)(b) – no use demonstrated in relevant period - discretion exercised in relation to some goods – registration to be partially removed – no award of costs.

Background

  1. The Echo Label Limited (‘the Removal Opponent’) is the registered owner of the following trade mark:

Registration No:

670282

Trade Mark:

ECHO (‘the Trade Mark’)

Priority Date:

22 August 1995

Specification:

Class 9: Records, tapes, discs, CD's; audio visual recording and reproducing apparatus and instrument
(‘the Registered Goods’)

  1. On 15 August 2017 Amazon Technologies Inc. (‘the Removal Applicant’) filed an application pursuant to section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) seeking removal of the Trade Mark from the Register. The removal application was made in respect of all of the Registered Goods; that is for complete removal of the Trade Mark from the Register.

  2. The Removal Opponent filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose the removal application on 24 October 2017, followed by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars on 23 November 2017. 

  3. On 4 December 2017 the Removal Applicant filed a Notice of Intention to Defend the removal application.

  4. The Removal Opponent filed evidence in support of the opposition. No other evidence was filed by either party.  

  5. The matter came before me, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, on 19 February 2019. The Removal Opponent was represented by Sean McManis of Shelston IP. The Removal Applicant was not represented at the hearing however written submissions were filed on its behalf by King & Wood Mallesons in accordance with reg 9.20(5)(c) of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995.  

    The relevant provisions

  6. Part 9 of the Act deals with the removal of trade marks from the Register due to non-use. Section 92(4)(b) relevantly provides:

    (4)An application under subsection (1) or (3) (non-use application) may be made on either or both of the following grounds, and on no other grounds:

    …

    (b) that the trade mark has remained registered for a continuous period of 3 years ending one month before the day on which the non-use application is filed, and, at no time during that period, the person who was then the registered owner:
               (i)  used the trade mark in Australia; or
               (ii) used the trade mark in good faith in Australia;
    in relation to the goods and/or services to which the application relates.

  7. The Removal Applicant alleges that the Removal Opponent did not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Amazon Technologies Inc. v The Echo Label Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] ATMO 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Amazon Technologies Inc. (the applicant) to remove a registered trade mark from the Register of Trade Marks, pursuant to section 92(4)(b) of the Act. The respondent, The Echo Label Limited, sought to rely on evidence of use to rebut the allegation of non-use. The hearing officer was required to determine whether the respondent had demonstrated sufficient use of the trade mark in Australia during the relevant period to avoid its removal from the Register.

The central legal issue was whether the evidence adduced by the respondent, primarily through the declaration of Peter Stack and its annexures, established that the trade mark had been used in Australia in relation to the registered goods within the relevant period. Specifically, the hearing officer had to assess if the evidence demonstrated use of the trade mark as applied for, without substantial alteration, and as a trade mark in the course of trade.

The hearing officer found that the evidence presented by the respondent had deficiencies that prevented satisfaction of the use requirement. While royalty statements indicated sales of recordings produced by the respondent, they did not contain or refer to the trade mark. Furthermore, images of CDs and cover sleeves, intended to illustrate the trade mark's application, were undated and not confirmed by the declaration to represent use within the relevant period. Consequently, the hearing officer was not satisfied that the trade mark had been used in Australia in the relevant period in relation to audio visual recording and reproducing apparatus and instruments.

The application for removal was successful in respect of audio visual recording and reproducing apparatus and instruments, and the registration was directed to be removed from the Register for those goods. However, the hearing officer was satisfied that it was reasonable to exercise discretion and not remove the trade mark in respect of records, tapes, discs, and CDs, and therefore the registration was maintained for those goods. Each party was ordered to bear its own costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In accordance with s 101 of the Act, I may decide to remove the Trade Mark for all or some of the goods identified in the removal application, or if satisfied it is reasonable to do so, decide not to remove the Trade Mark from the Register. Evidence To rebut the allegation of non-use, the Removal Opponent relies on the following declaration which was filed as evidence in support: ·Declaration of Peter Stack (Executive Vice President Global Catalogue Recordings at BMG Rights Management (UK) Limited, the parent company of the Removal Opponent) made on 5 March 2018 with annexures PS-1 to PS-4 (‘Stack Declaration’). Mr Stack deposes that the Removal Opponent commenced operations in 1994 and that the Trade Mark has been used in relation to sound recordings since that time. He further states that the distribution rights for the Removal Opponent’s music catalogue in Australia and New Zealand were exclusively licensed to Liberator Music Pty Ltd (‘Liberator’) from 1 January 2013 to 31 December 2015. After that time, Warner ADA held the distribution rights in Australia and New Zealand. Annexure PS-1 to the Stack Declaration consists of a spreadsheet tabulating royalties in respect of products distributed by Liberator in Australia from July to December 2016. It is declared that the royalties are in respect of ‘recordings produced by the [Removal Opponent] and bearing the [Trade Mark]’. Confidential Annexure PS-3 consists of royalty statements dated from July 2014 to December 2015. It is declared that these royalty statements relate to ‘musical recordings produced by the [Removal Opponent] and distributed in Australia by [Liberator].’ Annexure PS-2 consists of images of CDs and CD cover sleeves which are declared to show how the Trade Mark is typically applied to sound recordings. In these images the Trade Mark is shown on the front of the CD and also on the back of the cover sleeve beneath the list of songs. I note that the images relate to artists and albums specifically listed in the royalty summaries in Annexures PS-1 and PS-3. Annexure PS-4 also consists of images of CDs and cover sleeves which are declared to be further examples of how the Trade Mark was used in relation to sound recordings produced by the Removal Opponent and distributed by Liberator. Discussion and reasons As this is a removal action, it is crucial that the Removal Opponent demonstrates that it, or an authorised user, used the Trade Mark in Australia in relation to the Registered Goods within the Relevant Period. The evidence put forward by the Removal Opponent has deficiencies such that it does not satisfy me that the Trade Mark was used in Australia in the Relevant Period. The deficiencies include:·Although dated within the Relevant Period, the royalty statements do not contain the Trade Mark or any reference to it. Furthermore, the Stack Declaration is silent as to whether the statements in Annexure PS-3 relate to goods bearing the Trade Mark. I note that the Stack Declaration does state that the statements in Annexure PS-1 relate to goods bearing the Trade Mark that were produced by the Removal Opponent and distributed in Australia. On its own this is not sufficient as it does not demonstrate how the Trade Mark was used in relation to the Registered Goods without which I cannot be satisfied of at least three crucial issues: that the alleged use was of the Trade Mark as applied for, was without additions or alterations that substantially affects its identity, or that it was use ‘as a trade mark’. ·The images of the CDs and CD covers are undated. The Stack Declaration does not indicate that these images were taken within the Relevant Period rather it states that the images are typical of how the Trade Mark is applied to sound recordings. Whilst the images may be illustrative of how the Trade Mark is typically used on sound recordings, crucially, the Stack Declaration does not confirm that this typical use was how the Trade Mark was used in the Relevant Period.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The onus is on the Removal Opponent to satisfy me that it is reasonable to exercise the Registrar’s discretion and I am not satisfied in respect of audio visual recording and reproducing apparatus and instruments.Decision The application for removal under s 92(4)(b) of the Act has been successful. However, I am satisfied that it is reasonable to exercise my discretion and not remove the Trade Mark from the Register in respect of records, tapes, discs and CDs. Therefore I direct that, one month from the date of this decision, registration number 670282 be removed from the Register of Trade Marks in respect of audio visual recording and reproducing apparatus and instruments. If the Registrar is served with a notice of appeal within the relevant timeframe, the disposition of this removal application will instead be subject to the decision made by the court. Costs The general rule is that costs follow the event. As both parties were, strictly speaking, partly successful I believe it is appropriate in this case that each party bears its own costs.Katrina BrownHearing OfficerOppositions & HearingsTrade Marks & Designs17 April 2019

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

To rebut the allegation of non-use, the Removal Opponent relies on the following declaration which was filed as evidence in support: ·Declaration of Peter Stack (Executive Vice President Global Catalogue Recordings at BMG Rights Management (UK) Limited, the parent company of the Removal Opponent) made on 5 March 2018 with annexures PS-1 to PS-4 (‘Stack Declaration’). Mr Stack deposes that the Removal Opponent commenced operations in 1994 and that the Trade Mark has been used in relation to sound recordings since that time. He further states that the distribution rights for the Removal Opponent’s music catalogue in Australia and New Zealand were exclusively licensed to Liberator Music Pty Ltd (‘Liberator’) from 1 January 2013 to 31 December 2015. After that time, Warner ADA held the distribution rights in Australia and New Zealand. Annexure PS-1 to the Stack Declaration consists of a spreadsheet tabulating royalties in respect of products distributed by Liberator in Australia from July to December 2016. It is declared that the royalties are in respect of ‘recordings produced by the [Removal Opponent] and bearing the [Trade Mark]’. Confidential Annexure PS-3 consists of royalty statements dated from July 2014 to December 2015. It is declared that these royalty statements relate to ‘musical recordings produced by the [Removal Opponent] and distributed in Australia by [Liberator].’ Annexure PS-2 consists of images of CDs and CD cover sleeves which are declared to show how the Trade Mark is typically applied to sound recordings. In these images the Trade Mark is shown on the front of the CD and also on the back of the cover sleeve beneath the list of songs. I note that the images relate to artists and albums specifically listed in the royalty summaries in Annexures PS-1 and PS-3. Annexure PS-4 also consists of images of CDs and cover sleeves which are declared to be further examples of how the Trade Mark was used in relation to sound recordings produced by the Removal Opponent and distributed by Liberator. Discussion and reasons As this is a removal action, it is crucial that the Removal Opponent demonstrates that it, or an authorised user, used the Trade Mark in Australia in relation to the Registered Goods within the Relevant Period. The evidence put forward by the Removal Opponent has deficiencies such that it does not satisfy me that the Trade Mark was used in Australia in the Relevant Period. The deficiencies include:·Although dated within the Relevant Period, the royalty statements do not contain the Trade Mark or any reference to it. Furthermore, the Stack Declaration is silent as to whether the statements in Annexure PS-3 relate to goods bearing the Trade Mark. I note that the Stack Declaration does state that the statements in Annexure PS-1 relate to goods bearing the Trade Mark that were produced by the Removal Opponent and distributed in Australia. On its own this is not sufficient as it does not demonstrate how the Trade Mark was used in relation to the Registered Goods without which I cannot be satisfied of at least three crucial issues: that the alleged use was of the Trade Mark as applied for, was without additions or alterations that substantially affects its identity, or that it was use ‘as a trade mark’. ·The images of the CDs and CD covers are undated. The Stack Declaration does not indicate that these images were taken within the Relevant Period rather it states that the images are typical of how the Trade Mark is applied to sound recordings. Whilst the images may be illustrative of how the Trade Mark is typically used on sound recordings, crucially, the Stack Declaration does not confirm that this typical use was how the Trade Mark was used in the Relevant Period.