ALP15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection
Link copied
CaseCopied
23 min read
Full text
FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
ALP15 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR
[2017] FCCA 1418
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Review of decision by Administrative Appeals Tribunal – whether Administrative Appeals Tribunal’s decision affected by jurisdictional error – whether Administrative Appeals Tribunal erred by failing to consider the applicant’s claims cumulatively – whether the Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered all claims made by the applicant – no jurisdictional error – application dismissed.
This is an application pursuant to s.39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) and Pt.8, Div.2 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) for judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal dated 28 September 2016 (“the Tribunal”).
The applicant’s claims and the Tribunal’s decision, the subject of this application, are accurately summarised by counsel for the applicant, Mr Karp, in his written submissions as follows:
“BACKGROUND AND HISTORY
3. The applicant is a Sri Lankan asylum seeker of Tamil ethnicity who arrived in Australia undocumented on 19 September 2012 (CB 1ff). He applied for a Protection Visa on 6 December 2012 (CB 32ff) apparently having been permitted to do so pursuant to s.46A(2) Migration Act. That application was rejected on 23 September 2013 (CB 200-226). An application to the then Refugee Review Tribunal was lodged on 27 September 2013 (CB 229ff). The Tribunal held its s.425(1) hearing on 23 December 2014 (CB 253) and 19 February 2015 (CB 268) and its decision was made on 18 March…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read ALP15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:
This case concerned an application by a Sri Lankan asylum seeker of Tamil ethnicity, ALP15, for judicial review of a decision by the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection. The applicant had arrived in Australia in September 2012 and applied for a Protection Visa, which was initially rejected. Following a previous quashing of a Refugee Review Tribunal decision by this Court, the matter was remitted for a fresh decision. The applicant's claims included past persecution by the Sri Lankan Navy and paramilitary groups, harassment and threats to his livelihood as a fisherman, and a specific incident of abduction and torture in 2012. He also raised concerns about his parents being questioned by Sri Lankan intelligence officers in 2014 and the general difficulties faced by Tamil fishermen.
The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the Tribunal had erred in its assessment of the applicant's claims for protection. Specifically, the Court was required to consider whether the Tribunal had made jurisdictional error in its findings regarding the risk of serious or significant harm to the applicant upon return to Sri Lanka, including harm from the navy, Singhalese fishermen, and the consequences of his illegal departure from Sri Lanka. This involved an examination of whether the Tribunal had properly considered the applicant's membership in particular social groups and the risk of degrading or inhuman treatment as defined by the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth).
The Tribunal accepted that the applicant and his family had experienced harm during their fishing work but was not satisfied that he would suffer serious or significant harm from the navy or Singhalese fishermen, concluding he might only experience low-level harassment. It rejected claims of abduction and his parents being visited by intelligence officers. Regarding the consequences of his illegal departure, the Tribunal found a low, real chance of brief remand in uncomfortable conditions, but not intentionally inflicted torture or worse, deeming this a non-discriminatory enforcement of a general law. The Tribunal also found that any poor prison conditions would not be intentionally inflicted to cause extreme humiliation, and therefore not "significant harm" under the Act.
The Court found that the Tribunal had not made jurisdictional error in its findings. The Tribunal's assessment of the risk of harm, including the consequences of illegal departure and potential prison conditions, was open to it on the evidence before it. The Tribunal correctly applied the relevant legal principles in determining that the applicant had not established a real chance of suffering serious or significant harm, or degrading or inhuman treatment, as contemplated by the *Migration Act*. Consequently, the application for judicial review was dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
The applicant’s claims and the Tribunal’s decision, the subject of this application, are accurately summarised by counsel for the applicant, Mr Karp, in his written submissions as follows:“BACKGROUND AND HISTORY3. The applicant is a Sri Lankan asylum seeker of Tamil ethnicity who arrived in Australia undocumented on 19 September 2012 (CB 1ff). He applied for a Protection Visa on 6 December 2012 (CB 32ff) apparently having been permitted to do so pursuant to s.46A(2) Migration Act. That application was rejected on 23 September 2013 (CB 200-226). An application to the then Refugee Review Tribunal was lodged on 27 September 2013 (CB 229ff). The Tribunal held its s.425(1) hearing on 23 December 2014 (CB 253) and 19 February 2015 (CB 268) and its decision was made on 18 March 2015.4. That decision was quashed by Order of Judge Smith (ALP15 v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2016] FCCA 1151 (5 April 2016). The application was remitted for decision according to law.CLAIMS5. The applicant was born (CB 43) and lived in Trincomalee for the whole of his life whilst in Sri Lanka (CB 79). He claimed to have worked in his family fishing business from 2007 to January 2011 and again from October 2011 to July 2012 with a period of unemployment whilst he was in Singapore and Malaysia (see CB 81). His claims were set out in a statutory declaration at CB 86-92, and in dot point form in a submission lodged by his then migration agent on 12 June 2014 (CB 174-175). These were in summary;i. He is a young Tamil from Trincomalee in the Eastern Province of Sri Lanka.ii. In 1996 his grandfather was shot and killed by the Sri Lankan Navy.iii. The Sri Lankan military went on a rampage after a bomb exploded in Trincomalee town five minutes after the applicant and his sister passed the spot. This caused the family to flee to India for several months.iv. After their return, in February 2008, he was interrogated by the Karuna Group (a Tamil paramilitary group allied to the government). In May 2008 his cousin disappeared after being taken in for questioning.v. During 2009 the applicant, his father and uncle suffered continual harassment, and beatings at the hands of the Sri Lankan navy whilst trying to work as fishermen.vi. Around January 2011, whilst the applicant was fishing with his father, some unknown men who spoke Tamil came to the applicant’s home and told his mother he was wanted for questioning. Based on his previous experiences and what had happened to his cousin, he left the country. After some months in Singapore and Malaysia, in which he faced many difficulties, he decided to return to Sri Lanka, hoping that the situation had improved.vii. In 2012 he was taken in a white van, interrogated about his knowledge of an LTTE fund raiser known as “Nagulan”, and tortured. He was held for two to three days before being released. He decided to flee the country after that.6. A further claim raised at the first Tribunal’s hearing was that Sri Lankan intelligence officers had questioned his parents in mid-2014. He claimed that they had said that there was a request from the Australian Government as to whether the applicant had a terrorist background or had been involved in criminal activities (CB 313 [45]).7. The ability of Tamil fisherman to pursue their occupation was specifically raised in submissions to the Department at CB 123-125 and 181-185, in a submission following the first Tribunal hearing at CB 283-284, although the information in the latter submission pertained mainly to Indian Tamil fishermen from the state of Tamil Nadu. The specific submissions were that Tamil fishermen were being excluded from traditional fishing areas by Singhalese with the connivance of officials and the military, that Singhalese fishermen and the military continue to mistreat Tamil fishermen by destroying their nets and taking fish from them and in physically attacking them. It was submitted that this threatened the livelihoods of Tamil fishermen.8. The applicant’s solicitor and migration agent lodged another submission after the hearing held by the second Tribunal (CB 351-358). That submission canvassed relevant provisions of the Migration Act, aspects of his credit including his contacts with “Nagulan”, the particular social groups to which he was said to belong. Further country information was annexed to that submission included an Amnesty International report with a detailed section on the deplorable state of prison conditions in Sri Lanka to the effect that applicants who have left the country unlawfully claim that they cannot return because of the risk that they will face such conditions (CB 378-381).THE SECOND TRIBUNAL DECISION9. The Tribunal;(a) Accepted that the applicant, his father and uncle, experienced harm during their fishing work, including in 2009 (CB 396 [78]). It was not however satisfied that the applicant was questioned and beaten by the navy after 2009 (CB 400 [96]). It was not satisfied that he would suffer serious or significant harm by either the navy or Singhalese fishermen, although he may experience some “low level harassment or interference with his work” and that he may have limited avenues of complaint should he experience harassment from the navy or Singhalese fishermen (CB 400 [98]). It interpolate that the applicant complained of nets and catches being stolen.(b) Rejected claims that the applicant was abducted in 2012, or that his parents were visited by men asking for him in 2014 (CB 398 [87]-[88]). It did not consider that he came within the profiles of persons whose protection claims required particularly careful consideration pursuant to the eligibility guidelines set out by the UNHCR in its report dated 5 July 2012 (CB 398 [91] at footnote 1).(c) Accepted that there is a real chance that the applicant would encounter Sri Lankan authorities at the airport and upon return to his home area (CB 399 [94]). After diverting to the question of whether he faced danger from the navy or Singhalese fishermen, it moved to the consequences of his illegal departure from Sri Lanka (CB 400 [99]).10. In this last respect it found that the applicant was likely to be questioned at the airport and charged with the offence of having departed illegally. It accepted that there was a low, albeit real chance that he may spend a brief period in remand in prison conditions which are cramped, uncomfortable and unsanitary until a magistrate is available. It reasoned that this applies to all persons who have left Sri Lanka illegally, and the Tribunal was not satisfied that during the brief period of remand there is a real chance of his suffering intentionally inflicted torture or worse. It also found that such treatment would be the consequence of the non-discriminatory enforcement of a law of general application which was appropriate and adapted to achieving a legitimate state objective. It was therefore not satisfied that any element of the process would involve serious harm (CB 400-401 [100]-[102]).11. Further, considering complimentary protection, which is specifically dealt with in CB 401 [103], the Tribunal did not accept that any severe overcrowding in poor or insanitary conditions would be intentionally inflicted, or would be intended to cause extreme humiliation in terms of the definition of “degrading treatment or punishment” in s.5 of the Migration Act, read with s.36(2A)(e). It was therefore not satisfied that any element of the process would involve, “significant harm” as defined in s.36(2A).”