Alliance Craton Explorer Pty Ltd v Quasar Resources Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Alliance Craton Explorer Pty Ltd v Quasar Resources Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 290

Citation: Alliance Craton Explorer Pty Ltd v Quasar Resources Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 290
Parties: ALLIANCE CRATON EXPLORER PTY LTD ACN 095 337 385 v QUASAR RESOURCES PTY LTD ACN 101 227 070 and HEATHGATE RESOURCES PTY LTD ACN 011 018 232
File number: VID 551 of 2010
Judge: MANSFIELD J
Date of orders: 26 March 2012
Date of judgment: 4 April 2012
Date of hearing: 4 March 2011, 12 May 2011, 31 August 2011  
Place: Adelaide
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: No catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 76
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr RJ Whitington QC and Mr R. Keen
Solicitor for the Applicant: Finlaysons
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr M. Hoffmann QC
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Minter Ellison Lawyers
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Mr R. Dick SC and Mr J Williams
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Freehills

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 551 of 2010

BETWEEN:

ALLIANCE CRATON EXPLORER PTY LTD ACN 095 337 385
Applicant

AND:

QUASAR RESOURCES PTY LTD ACN 101 227 070
First Respondent

HEATHGATE RESOURCES PTY LTD ACN 011 018 232
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MANSFIELD J

DATE OF ORDER:

26 MARCH 2012

WHERE MADE:

ADELAIDE

IN RELATION TO THE APPLICATION FOR THE RESPONDENT TO ANSWER INTERROGATORIES, THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.No order is made in respect of the proposed interrogatories.

2.The application is stood over to a date to be fixed, with the applicant to have liberty to re-apply for an order that the respondents answer further particular interrogatories. Such application is to be made on 14 days notice.

3.Costs of the application are reserved with liberty to any party to apply for costs of the application to date, by filing and serving within 21 days of publication of reasons for Order 1 hereof a written submission specifying the orders sought and the submissions in support of it and any other party may then within a further period of 21 days file and serve written submissions in response and the party or parties applying for costs may within a further 14 days file and serve written submissions strictly in reply, to the intent that the costs of the application to date will then be determined on the papers. 

4.The time within which any application for leave to appeal from Orders 1 to 3 hereof shall run until 2 May 2012. 

IN RELATION TO APPLICATION FOR PARTICULAR DISCOVERY, THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

5.The respondents and each of them within 49 days from the making of this order on such further claim as the Court may allow, do make particular further discovery of any documents which they or either of them have not yet discovered which concern the prospectivity of the Paralana Plains area, including in relation to tenements adjacent to the Tenement (EL 2874), and which comprise:

5.1documents which came into existence between 30 August 2002 and 30 August…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alliance Craton Explorer Pty Ltd v Quasar Resources Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 290
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Alliance Craton Explorer Pty Ltd v Quasar Resources Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 369 involved a dispute between Alliance and Quasar, with Heathgate also being a party. The primary subject of the litigation was a joint venture agreement concerning the exploration and exploitation of uranium deposits in South Australia. The matter revolved around the discovery of additional documents related to the prospectivity of certain areas, specifically the Paralana Plains area, which was of interest to Alliance in the context of its claim against Quasar and Heathgate. The Federal Court was tasked with determining the admissibility of interrogatories seeking specific information regarding the prospectivity of Paralana Plains and related documents held by Quasar and Heathgate.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the interrogatories were permissible under the Federal Court Rules and if they were relevant to the matters in dispute. The court had to assess whether the interrogatories were oppressive, vexatious, or irrelevant to the proceedings. It also needed to determine if the interrogatories exceeded the scope of the matters in question as outlined in the pleadings. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the interrogatories imposed an unreasonable burden on the respondents or required them to form opinions, exercise judgment, or draw conclusions.

In its judgment, the court found that the interrogatories were not oppressive or vexatious and were relevant to the matters in dispute. The interrogatories were directed at obtaining information concerning the prospectivity of Paralana Plains, which Alliance believed was critical to its case. The court held that the interrogatories did not require the respondents to form opinions, exercise judgment, or draw conclusions, and they were not repetitive. The court balanced the benefits of the interrogatories in narrowing and clarifying the issues against the burden placed on the respondents. The court concluded that the interrogatories were necessary for the just resolution of the dispute and ordered the respondents to make further discovery of relevant documents. The court also reserved costs and provided liberty for the parties to apply for costs and for further clarifications regarding the documents to be disclosed.

The court made several orders to facilitate the discovery process, including specifying the types of documents to be discovered, providing liberty to apply for orders confining the inspection of documents, and reserving the costs of the application. The court also set a deadline for any application to appeal from the orders and granted liberty to apply to determine whether certain documents fell within the scope of the discovery order. The court's decision underscored the importance of obtaining relevant information in the context of joint venture disputes and the necessity of ensuring that discovery processes are fair and proportionate to the ends sought.

Orders

Orders of the court

5. The respondents and each of them within 49 days from the making of this order on such further claim as the Court may allow, do make particular further discovery of any documents which they or either of them have not yet discovered which concern the prospectivity of the Paralana Plains area, including in relation to tenements adjacent to the Tenement (EL 2874), and which comprise:

5.1 documents which came into existence between 30 August 2002 and 30 August 2004 recording data which the first respondent considered in determining the nature and extent of its exploratory drilling program to search for sedimentary-hosted uranium mineralisation in the Paralana Plains area including but not limited to ground based surveys;

5.2 documents recording the information obtained by the first respondent as a result of the drilling program conducted by it or the second respondent in the Paralana Plains area in the period of about August 2004;

5.3 documents passing between the first respondent and the second respondent in the period between May 2004 and 13 October 2004 in which one respondent conveyed to the other respondent views about the prospectivity of the Tenement.

6. The respondents have liberty to apply for orders confining the extent in which the documents may be inspected by the applicant or its legal advisors or representatives, provided such application is made by notice given at the time of the provision of the further discovery.

7. Cost of the application for further discovery are reserved with liberty to any party to apply for costs of the application to date, by filing and serving within 21 days of publication of reasons for Order 5 hereof a written submission specifying the orders sought and the submissions in support of it and any other party may then within a further period of 21 days file and serve written submissions in response and the party or parties applying for costs may within a further 14 days file and serve written submissions strictly in reply, to the intent that the costs of the application to date will then be determined on the papers.

8. The time within which any application for leave to appeal from Orders 5 to 7 hereof shall run until 2 May 2012.

9. Liberty to any party to apply to determine whether the particular documents specified by the applicant in its submissions in reply fall within the documents referred to in Order 5 hereof, such liberty to be exercised on reasonable notice to the other party.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

All the interrogatories are the subject of objection by Quasar and Heathgate. They argue that the interrogatories go well beyond (and thus do not relate to) matters in question between the parties, that the pleading of the respondents in any case is sufficiently responsive, that the interrogatories are oppressive and vexatious, and that the application ultimately amounts to “fishing” for evidence. BACKGROUND This matter has already been the subject of an interlocutory ruling, in which the background to the proceedings appears: Alliance Craton Explorer Pty Ltd v Quasar Resources Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1415 (Ryan J). It is desirable to summarise the background to place consideration of the interrogatories in context. The proceedings arise out of a joint venture agreement on 30 August 2002 between Alliance and Heathgate (and then Quasar as assignee) to exploit the Four Mile Uranium Project (Four Mile) which is in the Arkaroola Region adjacent to the Northern Flinders Ranges in South Australia. After the formation of the joint venture, Alliance became the registered holder of Exploration Licence 2874 (the Licence) (which was later renumbered to EL 3666) in respect of a prospect also located near Arkaroola. The licence area (the Tenement) is mostly within the Flinders Ranges area. The Tenement also includes a small area called Paralana Plains near its south eastern boundary. Within the Paralana Plains area of the Tenement, near its eastern boundary, exists Four Mile. It is helpful to understand the issues in the proceeding and to refer to the licence tenements adjacent to the Tenement, in particular to its Paralana Plains area. Beyond the eastern boundary of the Tenement the adjoining tenement is the Paralana-Heathgate tenement (EL 2633 and now renumbered EL 3251) and within it sits the Beverley Uranium Mine, on the mining lease pursuant to which Heathgate operates that uranium mine. At all relevant times, Heathgate has been the owner and operator of the Beverley Uranium Mine. Further east of the Paralana-Heathgate tenement, there lies the Heathgate-Giralia tenement (North Mulga) (EL 3002). A small portion of its boundary is adjacent to the Tenement. Beyond the south-east boundary of the Tenement, Paralana Plains stretches south and east towards Lake Frome. This area forms the subject of another adjoining tenement, the Heathgate-Giralia tenement (Wooltana) (EL 3012). Both of these tenements, as discerned from discovered documents and as explained in submissions, are subject of a separate joint venture agreement between Girilia and Heathgate. The Quasar-Paladin-Riseinger (Paladin) tenement (EL 3001) lies east of the Tenement and further north of EL 3001 exists the Quasar-Paladin (Petermorra) tenement (EL 3078). The latter does not share a boundary with the Tenement. Those two tenements, EL 3001 and EL 3078, were originally, according to discovered documents, subject of a further joint venture between Paladin Resources and Heathgate. However, in December 2002, Heathgate assigned its joint venture interest to Quasar (contemporaneous in time with the assignment of the Heathgate’s interest in the joint venture subject of these proceedings to Quasar).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I do not consider that the orders encompass Category 7 as that appears to relate to a more extensive period and to be secondary material, based upon material which (if discoverable in accordance with the orders made) would constitute the primary material that is relevant. I note that only some of the documents which would be within Category 8 might be encompassed in the orders. Also, the Category 9 document is excluded.CONCLUSION For the reasons given, I made the orders published on 26 March 2012. There is one final observation I should make. As is apparent, I think the resolution of these interlocutory applications should have been resolved largely by reference to the pleadings. There was considerable disputation about the role of affidavit evidence. I have had regard to that evidence principally to be satisfied that Alliance has reason to believe that there are documents held by Quasar and/or Heathgate which directly touch upon the prospectivity of the Paralana Plains area. The case by Alliance was described in the submissions recorded above. I determined only by reference to the pleadings, including the Schedule to the Statement of Claim, that its case as expressed in argument was pleaded. It was careful, through counsel settling the Statement of Claim, that it should not overstate what it thought it could clearly prove that he made that task a difficult one. Of course, to consider that there is a prospect that the prospectivity of the Tenement, and so its value, may be informed by information concerning the prospectivity of the Paralana Plains in the adjacent tenements is not to conclude that that is the case. That may be a matter to be resolved in due course. But, to my mind, it would not facilitate the just resolution of this claim if it were the case that the information held by Quasar and/or Heathgate concerning the prospectivity of the Paralana Plains area outside the Tenement had that quality, but by successfully resisting a discovery order Quasar and Heathgate were able to prevent Alliance from making out that case. That is not to suggest that Quasar and/or Heathgate have acted improperly in resisting the further discovery, or in asserting that such material is irrelevant on the pleadings as they presently stand. Nor is it to suggest that Quasar and/or Heathgate did deliberately withhold material from Alliance in the time leading up to the extension of the earn-in option period. That may be a matter pursued by Alliance (as it has pleaded); and it may be that its proof of that matter may be assisted by the further discovery ordered. In my view, fundamentally, this is a case where the just resolution of the dispute requires the order for further particular discovery which I have made. As I have not used the contentious affidavits to enhance my conclusion that the case of Alliance, as explained by senior counsel, has been pleaded, I have not found it necessary to address the individual objections to the affidavits in detail. At the expiration of the period of time fixed for the giving of further discovery, if there have been no issues requiring attention in the meantime (such as the extent of inspection permitted), I will list the proceeding for further directions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In ascertaining whether interrogatories taken as a whole are oppressive, one must consider the number sought to be administered, the extent to which providing an answer imposes an unreasonable and onerous burden on the interrogated party, whether the interrogatory requires the interrogated party to form opinions, to exercise judgment or to draw conclusions, and whether the questions are repetitive: ACCC v ANZ (at [101]). If the energy, effort, time and cost required to address the interrogatories is not reasonably proportionate to the end sought to be achieved, then the interrogatories should not be administered. In making a decision, a balancing exercise must be undertaken: the benefits of narrowing and clarification of issues against the costs and the burden placed over the respondents inherent in the task of answering the written questions fully and accurately.CONSIDERATION - INTERROGATORIES Alliance submits that the draft interrogatories are directed to the existence of facts in issue which relate to the following matters in question in these proceedings. They are stated in the following terms:1.The extent and significance of information concerning the prospectivity of Paralana Plains for sedimentary-hosted uranium mineralisation acquired by Heathgate and Quasar prior to the joint venture agreement with Alliance on 30 August 2002, including any analysis of drilling undertaken by the previous explorers such as West Nuclear in the 1970s and any analysis of the results of the survey undertaken in 2002 (Interrogatories 1-20)2.The extent and significance of information concerning the prospectivity of the Paralana Plains for sedimentary-hosted uranium mineralisation acquired by Heathgate and Quasar during the period from 30 August 2002 to 17 December 2002, the date of assignment by Heathgate of its joint venture interest to Quasar (Interrogatories 21-23)3.The roles of and relationship between the respondents following the assignment by Heathgate of its joint venture interest to Quasar including the engagement of Heathgate to undertake or arrange for and on behalf of Quasar the activities and services of Quasar as manager of the joint venture and the manner and extent to which information acquired by Heathgate concerning the licence was made available to Quasar (Interrogatories 24-28)4.The extent and significance of information concerning the prospectivity of Paralana Plains acquired by Heathgate and Quasar and the exploration activities undertaken by Heathgate and Quasar during the period from 17 December 2002 to 30 June 2004 and during the period from 1 July to 13 October 2004 including the 2004 gravity survey and other geophysical surveys undertaken over adjacent tenements (Interrogatories 32-38)5.The instigation and planning of the 2004 drilling program including the drilling program over the Paralana Plains including the addition and location of drillhole AK019 and the removal of the western ‘fenceline’ of five drillholes (Interrogatories 39-42)6.The identification of information concerning the prospectivity of the Paralana Plains for sedimentary-hosted uranium in the possession of Heathgate and Quasar as at the time of execution of the agreement to extent the earn-in period and the extent of disclosure of the information to Alliance (Interrogatories 43-44)