Allen Hardware Products Pty Ltd v Tclip Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

DESIGNS ACT 2003



DECISION OF A DEPUTY REGISTRAR OF DESIGNS

Re:      Registered designs 306284 to 306291 in the name of Allen Hardware Products Pty Ltd, and a request for revocation under s.52 by Tclip Pty Ltd

Delegate: Dave Herald
Decision:

Application for revocation under s.52 – revocation on grounds relating to entitled person. Entitled person found to be Allen Hardware Products Pty Ltd and Tclip Pty Ltd jointly.
Designs 306284 to 306291 revoked.

Background

  1. Designs 306284 to 306291 were filed on 15 March 2005, and were registered on 31 March 2006. The Registered owner is Allen Hardware Products Pty Ltd – which I will refer to hereafter as AHP. The designs all relate to joiners for joining extruded arms to create a structure.

  2. On 26 September 2006 Tclip Pty Ltd [Tclip] commenced the present dispute by filing a request for revocation of these designs under s.52 of the Designs Act. The request was accompanied by a statutory declaration by a Richard Dinning, the managing director of Tclip. In brief, the allegation by Tclip is that they approached AHP for assistance with their product; AHP appropriated their ideas to develop the designs currently in dispute – and consequently AHP was not an entitled person in respect of those designs.

  3. Subsequently directions were made for the filing of evidence – following the approach the subject of review in Somnomed Ltd v Commissioner of Patents [2006] FCA 765, [2006] 69 IPR 237. Following the filing of evidence, including further evidence, the matter was ultimately heard on 4 March 2008. Neither party appeared at the hearing.

    The evidence

  4. Tclip filed evidence in support of their requests in accordance with the directions of the Registrar. That evidence was the same as that filed with the requests. In contrast, AHP did not file any evidence in support of its entitlement to the designs – with the consequence that Tclip had no evidence to respond to. On the other hand, AHP subsequently filed evidence controverting the evidence of Tclip. Tclip subsequently obtained leave to adduce further evidence, and AHP similarly obtained leave to file evidence in response to Tclip’s further evidence.

  5. While the evidence of AHP has a strong focus of trying to discredit the evidence of Tclip, in my view there is broad agreement over the key issues in the present dispute. Importantly, the primary issue of the dispute is whether the material disclosed in the initial contact between the parties was subject to confidentiality. There is remarkably little direct evidence on this issue. However Alan Harper (for AHP) provides a summary of what he asserts happened over this period in his declaration dated 20 February 2008 (which formed part of AHP’s further evidence). While Tclip may not agree with everything that is asserted in this summary, I am of the view that any such disagreement does not have a bearing on the conclusions to be reached. Accordingly I will simply quote what Mr Harper states, and proceed on the basis that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Allen Hardware Products Pty Ltd v Tclip Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] ADO 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Allen Hardware Products Pty Ltd v Tclip Pty Ltd involved a dispute over registered designs 306284 to 306291, filed by Allen Hardware Products Pty Ltd (AHP) and registered on 31 March 2006. Tclip Pty Ltd filed a request for revocation of these designs under section 52 of the Designs Act 2003, alleging that AHP appropriated their ideas to develop the designs, and consequently AHP was not the entitled person in respect of those designs. The Deputy Registrar of Designs, Dave Herald, found that the designs were revoked on grounds relating to the entitled person. The entitled persons were determined to be AHP and Tclip Pty Ltd jointly.

The court examined the issue of whether the disclosure of the designs by Tclip to AHP was made under a fetter of implied confidentiality, and concluded that it was. The disclosure was for a strictly limited purpose, being for the purpose of having United Aluminium prepare extrusion drawings and a quotation for supply of extrusions. The court found that AHP was not free to use that material for any other purpose. The designership of the designs was also considered, and it was concluded that the designs were jointly created by Richard Dinning, Stephen Petith, Alan Harper, and Dylan Retif.

The court determined the entitlement to the designs under section 13 of the Designs Act 2003, and found that the entitled persons in relation to the present designs were Tclip Pty Ltd and AHP. The court also considered the issue of estoppel in pais, but found no evidence to support the existence of such an estoppel. The Deputy Registrar of Designs then declared that at the time the present designs were first registered, Tclip Pty Ltd was an entitled person jointly with AHP, and consequently Designs 306284 to 306291 were revoked.

The court also provided guidance on potential consequential issues, such as the possibility of making a new application for a design, and the implications of the decision on other designs filed by the parties. The court emphasized that the parties should obtain appropriate legal advice on the issues as they relate to themselves.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.