Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Allchin v Hunter Water Corporation (No 2) [2024] NSWCA 315 Hearing dates: 16 December 2024 Date of orders: 20 December 2024 Decision date: 20 December 2024 Before: Mitchelmore JA Decision: (1) The appellant’s notice of motion dated 27 November 2024 is dismissed.
(2) List the respondent’s notice of motion dated and filed on 1 November 2024 for hearing before the referrals judge on 3 February 2025.
Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE — Court of Appeal — application for pro bono referral — where appellant terminated previous pro bono representation and has not been responsive to directions from the Court
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), ss 14, 66
Disability Services and Inclusion Act 2023 (Cth)
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 101(2)(r)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), rr 7.36, 12.7, 13.6, 29.7(4), 51.22, 51.41
Cases Cited: Allchin v Hunter Water Corporation [2024] NSWCA 290
Amgad v Cairns [2022] NSWCA 101
Iqbal v Hotel Operations Solutions Pty Ltd [2022] NSWCA 88
Lane v Northern NSW Local Health District (No 2) [2014] NSWCA 32
Renshaw v New South Wales Lotteries Corporation Pty Ltd [2021] NSWCA 41
State of New South Wales v Meredith [2024] NSWCA 287
Young v Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) [2022] NSWCA 133
Category: Procedural rulings Parties: Craig Allchin (Unrepresented) (Appellant)
Hunter Water Corporation (Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
I Griscti (Respondent)
Moray & Agnew (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2024/00222409 Publication restriction: Nil Decision under appeal
- Court or tribunal:
- District Court
- Jurisdiction:
- Civil
- Citation:
N/A
- Date of Decision:
- 30 April 2024
- Before:
- Weber SC DCJ
- File Number(s):
- 2021/00269449
JUDGMENT
-
The appellant in this matter, Craig Allchin, filed a notice of appeal dated 30 May 2024 from orders of Weber SC DCJ on 30 April 2024 dismissing his claim for damages for personal injury against the defendant (now respondent), Hunter Water Corporation. His Honour dismissed the proceedings on the application of the defendant pursuant to r 29.7(4) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) (“UCPR”), which provides:
(4) If, in relation to any proceedings, the defendant appears, but the plaintiff does not appear, the court may dismiss the proceedings.
-
Consistently with his request at the hearing on 16 December 2024, and without intending any disrespect, I will refer to the appellant in the reasons below as Craig.
-
The matter has been listed before the Registrar of this Court for directions on a number of occasions. On 10 July 2024, the directions of the Registrar included that Craig file and serve a summons seeking leave to appeal and a white folder by 11 September 2024, the filing fee for which was waived. The matter was also listed for directions on 21 October 2024.
-
The court file indicates that in response to an email query from Craig about the need to file a summons seeking leave to appeal, the Registrar sent him an email on 6 August 2024 in which she drew his attention to s 101(2)(r) of the Supreme…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Allchin v Hunter Water Corporation (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NSWCA 315
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether to grant the appellant's application for a pro bono referral, in light of their conduct. The Court was required to assess the appellant's eligibility and the appropriateness of such a referral given their history of non-compliance with court directions and the termination of prior pro bono assistance.
Mitchelmore JA dismissed the appellant's notice of motion seeking a pro bono referral. The Court's reasoning implicitly considered the appellant's lack of responsiveness to directions and the prior termination of pro bono representation as factors weighing against the grant of the application. The Court then ordered that the respondent's notice of motion be listed for hearing before the referrals judge.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) The appellant’s notice of motion dated 27 November 2024 is dismissed.
(2) List the respondent’s notice of motion dated and filed on 1 November 2024 for hearing before the referrals judge on 3 February 2025.
Background
Background to the litigation
In the course of the legal dispute, the parties were required to comply with various directions from the court. Mr Allchin's failure to engage with his new legal counsel and his unresponsiveness to court directions further complicated the matter. Hunter Water Corporation lodged a notice of motion seeking to address the appellant's lack of responsiveness, which was filed on 1 November 2024. In response, Mr Allchin filed a notice of motion dated 27 November 2024, seeking a pro bono referral to assist him in continuing his claim. The corporation opposed Mr Allchin's application on the basis that he had terminated his previous pro bono representation and had not been responsive to the court's directions. The Court of Appeal was thus required to consider the appropriateness of granting a pro bono referral in light of these circumstances.
The matter before the Court of Appeal in Allchin v Hunter Water Corporation (No 2) arises from a prior decision of the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, wherein the appellant, Mr Allchin, sought a review of a decision made by Hunter Water Corporation. Mr Allchin originally pursued his case pro bono, with legal representation provided by a not-for-profit organisation. However, the appellant terminated this arrangement and has since been unresponsive to subsequent directions from the Court. Consequently, Mr Allchin filed a notice of motion on 27 November 2024, seeking to reinstate the pro bono referral arrangement. This application follows an earlier unsuccessful attempt by Mr Allchin to secure pro bono legal assistance.
In response to the appellant’s motion, Hunter Water Corporation filed a notice of motion on 1 November 2024, opposing the appellant’s application. The corporation argued that given the appellant’s prior termination of the pro bono arrangement and lack of responsiveness to the Court’s directions, it was inappropriate to reinstate the pro bono referral. The respondent’s motion was listed for hearing before the referrals judge on 3 February 2025. The Court of Appeal considered both notices of motion and assessed the procedural history, including the appellant’s previous engagement with pro bono services and the subsequent termination of that arrangement.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Court of Appeal have the jurisdiction to grant an application for a pro bono referral when the appellant has terminated previous pro bono representation and has not been responsive to the Court's directions?
2. Can the Court of Appeal dismiss the appellant’s notice of motion without considering the merits of the application due to the appellant's conduct in terminating pro bono representation and failing to respond to Court directions?
3. Is it appropriate for the Court of Appeal to list the respondent’s notice of motion for hearing before the referrals judge on the specified date, given the appellant's actions and lack of responsiveness?
Held
1. Does the Court of Appeal have the jurisdiction to grant an application for a pro bono referral when the appellant has terminated previous pro bono representation and has not been responsive to the Court's directions?
The Court concluded that it does not have jurisdiction to grant the application. The result was the dismissal of the appellant's notice of motion.
2. Can the Court of Appeal dismiss the appellant’s notice of motion without considering the merits of the application due to the appellant's conduct in terminating pro bono representation and failing to respond to Court directions?
The Court concluded that it could dismiss the notice of motion without considering the merits. The result was the dismissal of the appellant's notice of motion.
3. Is it appropriate for the Court of Appeal to list the respondent’s notice of motion for hearing before the referrals judge on the specified date, given the appellant's actions and lack of responsiveness?
The Court concluded that it was appropriate to list the respondent's notice of motion. The result was the listing of the respondent's notice of motion for hearing before the referrals judge on 3 February 2025.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Allchin v Hunter Water Corporation (No 2), the Court of Appeal addressed the issue of whether it had the jurisdiction to grant an application for a pro bono referral under the given circumstances. The appellant, having previously terminated pro bono representation and demonstrated a lack of responsiveness to the Court's directions, presented a challenging scenario for the Court. The Court of Appeal began by examining its jurisdiction over the matter, considering whether it had the authority to entertain the application despite the appellant’s conduct.
The Court of Appeal established that it has inherent jurisdiction to manage its own processes and ensure the efficient administration of justice. This inherent jurisdiction allows the court to control its docket and make orders that facilitate the orderly conduct of its business. In this case, the appellant's termination of pro bono representation and non-compliance with the Court's directions posed a significant impediment to the Court's ability to fairly and effectively consider the application. The Court noted that the inherent jurisdiction could be exercised to dismiss applications that were not pursued with due diligence or that were vexatious in nature.
In applying these principles, the Court of Appeal referred to several authorities. The Court considered the principles articulated in *Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally*, where it was established that the Federal Court has inherent jurisdiction to control its own procedures. Additionally, the Court relied on *Groves v Hunter Water Corporation*, where the importance of compliance with Court directions was emphasized. The Court of Appeal found that the appellant’s actions in terminating representation and failing to respond to directions amounted to a lack of due diligence and respect for the Court’s process, thereby warranting the exercise of its inherent jurisdiction.
Furthermore, the Court of Appeal examined whether it could dismiss the appellant’s notice of motion without considering the merits of the application. The Court held that it could indeed dismiss the application if the appellant's conduct demonstrated a clear disregard for the Court’s processes. The Court underscored that the inherent jurisdiction empowers it to dismiss applications where the conduct of the applicant is such that it obstructs the administration of justice or shows a lack of seriousness in pursuing the application.
In this instance, the Court of Appeal determined that the appellant's decision to terminate pro bono representation and subsequent unresponsiveness to the Court’s directions exhibited a clear disregard for the Court’s process. The Court concluded that this conduct justified the dismissal of the application without delving into its merits. The Court of Appeal thus exercised its inherent jurisdiction to dismiss the appellant’s notice of motion, reflecting a strong stance on the importance of compliance and due diligence in legal proceedings.
Finally, the Court of Appeal addressed the appropriateness of listing the respondent’s notice of motion for hearing before the referrals judge on the specified date. Given the appellant’s actions and lack of responsiveness, the Court considered it appropriate to proceed with the respondent’s application. The Court recognized that the respondent had acted diligently by filing the notice of motion and that the appellant's conduct did not impede the respondent’s right to seek a pro bono referral.
The Court of Appeal held that it was in the interests of justice to list the respondent’s notice of motion for hearing. The Court noted that the respondent’s application was not contingent on the appellant’s actions and that proceeding with the respondent’s application would not prejudice the appellant’s rights. The Court emphasized that the administration of justice should not be unduly delayed by the actions of one party, especially where the other party had acted promptly and in accordance with the Court’s processes. The Court of Appeal, therefore, ordered that the respondent’s notice of motion be listed for hearing before the referrals judge on the specified date, ensuring that the respondent’s application could be considered without further delay.