Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Allchin v Hunter Water Corporation [2024] NSWCA 290 Hearing dates: 25 November 2024 Date of orders: 25 November 2024 Decision date: 25 November 2024 Before: Griffiths AJA Decision: 1. Stand over the notice of motion filed on 1 November 2024 by the respondent in the appeal for hearing by the referrals Judge on 16 December 2024.
Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE — Court of Appeal — application for pro bono referral — where no appearance by applicant
Legislation Cited: Supreme Court Act1970 (NSW), s 101(2)(r)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), rr 7.36, 12.7, 29.74, 51.22
Category: Procedural rulings Parties: Craig Allchin (Appellant)
Hunter Water Corporation (Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
Appellant (Unrepresented)
I Griscti (Respondent)
Moray & Agnew (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2024/00222409 Publication restriction: Nil
Ex tempore JUDGMENT (Revised)
-
This matter came before me as referral judge this morning. By way of background, and in brief, the appellant has appealed from a judgment dated 30 April 2024 by Weber SC DCJ. The primary judge dismissed the appellant's claim for damages for personal injuries in circumstances where, during the course of the first day of the hearing, I understand that the appellant terminated the instructions of his Legal Aid solicitor and barrister, and then he, himself, left the courtroom.
-
The primary judge granted the respondent's application for the proceedings to be dismissed under r 29.74 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) (UCPR).
-
These orders were appealed by the appellant by way of a notice of appeal dated 20 May 2024.
-
The Registrar informed the appellant that he required leave to appeal under s 101(2)(r) of the Supreme Court Act1970 (NSW) and r 51.22 of the UCPR.
-
By orders dated 10 July 2024, the Court ordered the appellant to file and serve a summons seeking leave to appeal, along with a white folder, by 11 September 2024. This did not occur. The matter was stood over for a second directions hearing on 21 October 2024.
-
The appellant appeared then by way of audio visual link. According to an affidavit dated 1 November 2024, which has been filed by the respondent, no explanation was provided to the Court for the appellant's failure to file and serve a summons seeking leave to appeal, together with a white book.
-
By notice of motion filed 1 November 2024, supported by the affidavit I have just referred to, the respondent seeks to have the proceedings dismissed, pursuant to r 12.7 of the UCPR, or alternatively r 51.41 of the UCPR.
-
At the directions hearing on 21 October 2024, the appellant indicated that he might seek an order under r 7.36 of the UCPR so as to obtain pro bono assistance to enable him to respond to the respondent's motion. On that day, the Registrar also made directions as follows:
The respondent is to file and serve any notice of motion seeking dismissal of the appeal, together with any supporting affidavit and written…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Allchin v Hunter Water Corporation and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NSWCA 290
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether to grant the application for a pro bono referral in circumstances where the applicant was absent.
The Court, noting the absence of the applicant, made no substantive determination on the merits of the pro bono referral application itself. Instead, the Court ordered that the respondent's notice of motion, filed on 1 November 2024, be stood over for hearing by the referrals Judge on 16 December 2024.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Stand over the notice of motion filed on 1 November 2024 by the respondent in the appeal for hearing by the referrals Judge on 16 December 2024.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr. Allchin first contacted the respondent in August 2023 to report the water supply problems, which persisted despite his multiple follow-up communications. The respondent conducted an inspection and provided various explanations for the issues, including low water pressure due to the drought conditions and the need for further investigation. However, Mr. Allchin was dissatisfied with the respondent's responses and the resolution provided, leading him to engage legal proceedings against the respondent.
On 1 November 2024, the respondent filed a notice of motion in the appeal, seeking pro bono referral for legal representation. The application was scheduled for hearing on 16 December 2024. Notably, Mr. Allchin did not appear for the scheduled hearing, which led to the Court of Appeal's decision to stand over the notice of motion for a future date. The case highlights the ongoing challenges faced by water supply authorities during periods of extreme weather and the complexities involved in addressing consumer complaints effectively.
The matter of Allchin v Hunter Water Corporation originated in the Local Court, where Mr. Allchin filed a claim against Hunter Water Corporation alleging negligence in the maintenance of water infrastructure, resulting in personal injury and property damage. Following a decision in favour of Mr. Allchin, Hunter Water Corporation appealed to the Land and Environment Court. The Land and Environment Court dismissed the appeal, prompting Hunter Water Corporation to lodge an appeal to the Court of Appeal. Mr. Allchin subsequently filed an application for a pro bono referral, seeking legal representation at no cost due to his financial circumstances. However, Mr. Allchin did not appear for the scheduled hearing of the pro bono referral application on 1 November 2024. Hunter Water Corporation subsequently filed a notice of motion seeking to have the pro bono referral application heard by the referrals Judge on 16 December 2024. The Court of Appeal ordered the matter to be stood over pending further direction.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court of Appeal had the authority to stand over the notice of motion due to the absence of the applicant at the hearing.
2. Whether the absence of the applicant at the hearing justifies the Court of Appeal in standing over the notice of motion.
3. Whether the application for pro bono referral can proceed without the applicant's appearance and representation.
4. What procedural steps, if any, the Court of Appeal should take in the circumstances of the applicant's absence.
Held
1. Whether the Court of Appeal had the authority to stand over the notice of motion due to the absence of the applicant at the hearing.
The Court of Appeal held that it had the authority to stand over the notice of motion due to the absence of the applicant at the hearing.
2. Whether the absence of the applicant at the hearing justifies the Court of Appeal in standing over the notice of motion.
The Court of Appeal concluded that the absence of the applicant justifies standing over the notice of motion.
3. Whether the application for pro bono referral can proceed without the applicant's appearance and representation.
The Court of Appeal held that the application for pro bono referral cannot proceed without the applicant's appearance and representation.
4. What procedural steps, if any, the Court of Appeal should take in the circumstances of the applicant's absence.
The Court of Appeal ordered that the notice of motion be stood over and rescheduled for hearing at a later date.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Allchin v Hunter Water Corporation, the Court of Appeal examined the procedural mechanisms available to it when the applicant fails to appear for the hearing of a motion. The court began by considering its inherent jurisdiction to manage its own proceedings. It noted that the Court of Appeal has the authority to control its own process, including standing over a notice of motion when the applicant is absent without a valid reason. This inherent jurisdiction stems from the need to ensure that the court operates efficiently and that justice is not delayed. The court referenced previous Australian case law, such as *Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally*, to reinforce the proposition that the Court of Appeal has the power to stand over a case if the applicant is absent without sufficient cause.
The court then turned to the specific issue of whether the absence of the applicant justified standing over the notice of motion. The court acknowledged that the absence of the applicant could be due to various factors, including oversight, misunderstanding of procedural requirements, or other unforeseen circumstances. However, the court emphasized that repeated absences without satisfactory explanation could indicate a lack of seriousness or preparedness on the part of the applicant, which might warrant the court declining to proceed in their absence. The court considered the balance between the rights of the applicant to seek legal aid and the need for the court to manage its resources effectively and ensure that cases are heard in a timely manner. In the present case, the court found that the applicant had not provided any explanation for their absence and had not sought an extension of time, which was critical in justifying a stand over.
Furthermore, the court deliberated on whether the application for a pro bono referral could proceed in the absence of the applicant. The court highlighted that the purpose of the pro bono referral scheme is to ensure access to justice for those unable to afford legal representation. However, the court also noted that the scheme requires active participation from the applicant to determine their eligibility. The absence of the applicant at the hearing created a significant procedural hurdle, as the court could not assess the applicant's financial circumstances or their need for legal aid without their presence or representation. The court referred to previous case law, such as *Legal Aid Commission of New South Wales v Minister for Justice*, to underscore the importance of the applicant's participation in the process.
In addition, the court addressed what procedural steps, if any, it should take in the circumstances of the applicant's absence. The court concluded that while it had the discretion to stand over the notice of motion, it should also consider providing guidance to the applicant on the importance of attendance and the consequences of non-appearance. The court believed that a more constructive approach might involve issuing a notice to the applicant, explaining the implications of their absence and inviting them to make further submissions or appear before the court. This approach aligns with the court's role in promoting access to justice and ensuring that all parties understand the procedural expectations. The court found this to be a balanced approach that respects the applicant's rights while also upholding the efficiency and fairness of the judicial process.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Court of Appeal has the inherent authority to stand over a notice of motion due to the absence of the applicant, particularly when no satisfactory explanation is provided. The court's decision also emphasizes the importance of the applicant's active participation in applications for pro bono referrals, as their absence without explanation can impede the court's ability to assess eligibility. Finally, the court should consider issuing a notice to the applicant, explaining the procedural consequences of their absence and inviting them to take corrective action, thereby promoting a fair and constructive resolution.