FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| ALLAN & ALLAN AND ORS (NO 4 ) | [2015] FamCA 1081 |
| FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Slip Rule – Where an application has been made to amend an asserted error in an order made 10 November 2015 – Where that asserted error was made by a mistaken or accidental omission or slip by senior counsel and those instructing him – Where the order is amended accordingly. FAMILY LAW – PROPERTY – Declaration as to the validity of appointment of new trustees – Where applications are brought by two companies who purport to replace the trustee of a trust – Where the application is opposed by the 7th to 11th respondents and the wife but supported by the husband – Whether a declaration should be made that the removal of the current trustee was valid where orders were in place restraining the husband and protector of the trust from replacing the trustee –- Where the current trustee had failed to file evidence and did not appear at the final hearing – Where an order was previously made permitting the husband to change the trustee in the event there was compelling evidence that the trustee would not be able to fulfil his role – Whether there was compelling evidence – Where compelling evidence is found to be a legal standard and not self-referential – Where it is argued that the trust would suffer prejudice if it not represented at the hearing – Where it is found that an order was in place precluding the husband from exercising any power of appointment of a new or additional trustee – Where in the alternative the court would not have been prepared to make the declarations as sought. FAMILY LAW – PROPERTY – Where the 13th respondent seeks to be remunerated for work done as trustee of the trust and to be repaid monies disbursed by him in his former position as trustee of a trust – Where the wife consented to the orders sought by the 13th respondent – Where the husband opposed this application and submitted the 13th respondent had inappropriately continued litigation and had inappropriately reached a compromise with receivers and managers without the consent of the beneficiaries of the trust– Where the trustee is entitled to recoup disbursement – Where the trust provides for the 13th respondent to receive remuneration - Where the husband challenges the validity of that provision because of a retainer agreement between the husband and the 13th respondent – Where that agreement was not operative during the time relevant to the claim – Where the court finds that the 13th respondent was at all relevant times following the husband’s instructions and the husband had involvement in the litigation pursued by the 13th respondent – Where the court does not accept the husband’s assertion that the 13th respondent did not fulfil his fiduciary duties as trustee – Order made that the… |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Allan and Allan & Ors (No 4 ) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] FamCA 1081
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine several legal issues. These included whether to declare the removal of a trustee valid, notwithstanding existing orders restraining such a change, and whether there was compelling evidence to justify such a removal. The court also considered the entitlement of a 13th respondent to remuneration and reimbursement for disbursements as a former trustee, and whether the husband's opposition to these claims was valid. Furthermore, the court examined an application by the 13th respondent seeking payment from the wife for a debt owed by a company in liquidation, and the validity of consent orders proposed between the wife and respondents 7 to 11. Finally, the court had to consider and approve a property settlement between the husband and wife.
Watts J applied established legal principles to resolve these matters. Regarding the trustee appointment, the court found that compelling evidence was a legal standard and that an existing order precluded the husband from exercising the power of appointment. The court allowed the 13th respondent to recoup disbursements and receive remuneration, finding that the retainer agreement relied upon by the husband was not operative during the relevant period and that the trustee had acted on the husband's instructions. The application for the wife to personally pay a company's debt was dismissed, as the company was a separate legal entity and the debt was provable in its liquidation. Consent orders between the wife and respondents 7 to 11 were made, as they represented a proper commercial compromise to conclude proceedings, and the husband had no interest in the relevant funds. Ultimately, the court made consent orders for property settlement between the husband and wife, finding it just and equitable to do so, and also made orders regarding the payment of remuneration and disbursements to the 13th respondent from trust funds.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
Within 14 days, the wife and the 13th respondent do all things and sign all necessary documents to pay to the 13th respondent from the monies in the account established pursuant to order 3 dated 14 April 2014 (by a deposit of $600,000) the sum of $575,572 and to pay the trustee of the M Trust, as identified by the notification referred to in order 3, the balance of the funds in that account, within 14 days of receiving that notification.
2.
Order 15.2 made 29 May 2014 be discharged.
3.
The husband, as soon as is practicable, notify the lawyers for the wife and the 13th respondent, of the identity of the appointed Trustee(s) of the M Trust and the bank account details into which the payment referred to in order 1 is to be made.
4.
The applications by the 13th respondent against the wife are dismissed.
Orders made 17.11.15
1.
Pursuant to the slip rule order 1 made 10 November 2015 be deleted and the following order is made
1. The applications in paragraphs [1] to [22] of the Application in a case filed by EE Pty Ltd and FF Nominees Pty Ltd on 23 October 2015 be dismissed
2.
The applications by EE Pty Ltd and FF Nominees Pty Ltd contained in paragraphs 23 to 27 of the Application in a Case filed 23 October 2015 be dismissed.
3.
The applications for declarations and orders by EE Pty Ltd and FF Nominees Pty Ltd set out in Exhibit 42 at paragraphs 1 to 5 are dismissed and accordingly I do not hear the remaining part of those applications for orders that are set out in Exhibit 42.
4.
I note that Order 15.2 made on the 29 May 2014 continues and I will address what is to happen in respect of that order as part of the final resolution of those proceedings.
5.
The time for the 7th – 11th respondents to bring a costs application in respect of the orders made on 10 November 2015 is extended to the date of expiration of the time allowed under the Rules to bring an application for costs in respect of these proceedings.
6.
I reserve my reasons for order 2 to 5.
Orders made 18.11.15
1.
In relation to the applications by the 13th respondent against the wife for orders 6, 9 and 10 contained in Exhibit 40, I grant leave to the wife to make an oral application for summary dismissal pursuant to rule 10.12 Family Law Rules. I reserve my decision in respect of that oral application.
2.
In the event that I dismiss that oral application, I reserve my decision in relation to those applications.
Order made 19.11.2015
1.
Mr J be appointed case guardian for Ms G.
Orders made 19.11.15
1.
That within 7 days of the 7th to 11th Respondents’ Solicitors receiving a sealed copy of these orders, the 7th to 11th Respondents shall pay or cause to be paid to the Applicant Wife the sum of ONE MILLION EIGHT HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS ($1,800,000.00).
2.
The payment referred to in paragraph 1 hereof will be made by the 7th to 11th Respondents into the Trust Account of Mills Oakley, the Wife’s solicitors.
3.
That the funds received by the Wife’s Solicitors pursuant to Paragraphs 1 and 2 hereof are to be held by them on trust pending further Order of the Court.
4.
That subject to Paragraph 5 hereof the 7th to 11th Respondents transfer and assign to the Applicant all and any interest they have in and to the debt owing to them by JJ Pty Ltd (ACN …) being the subject of proceedings in the Supreme Court of Western Australia matter number CIV … of 2011.
5.
That the Applicant prepare and file at her own expense all and any documents necessary to give effect to Paragraph 4 hereof.
6.
That the parties otherwise do all such things and sign all and any documents that are required to give effect to paragraph 4 hereof.
7.
That paragraph 3 of the Orders made by this Honourable Court on 3 November 2008 be and is hereby discharged.
8.
That paragraphs 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 of the Consent Orders made by this Honourable Court on 16 February 2009 be and are hereby discharged.
9.
That Paragraph 8 of the Orders made by this Honourable Court on 29 May 2014 be discharged.
10.
That Paragraph 6 of the Orders made by this Honourable Court on 3 November 2014 be discharged.
11.
That as between the 7th to 11th Respondents and the wife all reserved Costs Orders are discharged.
12.
[Deliberately Blank]
13.
That the 8th and 9th Respondents be at liberty to remove Caveat number L253287 registered against the property at KK Road, LL Town, which property is more particularly described as:
Lot … on Deposited Plan 254022 and being the whole of the land described in Certificate of Title volume … Folio ...
14.
That all applications against the 7th to 11th Respondents are dismissed.
15.
That the Wife’s Application pursuant to s106B of the Act and the Orders sought in paragraphs 4, 5, 6, including 6.1 to 6.16 and 7 of the Wife’s Further Amended Application filed on 25 February 2015 be dismissed.
16.
That paragraph 8 of the Wife’s Further Amended Application filed on 25 February 2015, insofar as it relates to the 7th and 11th Respondents, be dismissed
17.
That the wife shall be and hereby is restrained by injunction from making or facilitating any further application or claim of any nature whatsoever against the 7th to 11th Respondents which in any way relates to GG Pty Ltd, HH Pty Ltd, EE Trust or FF Trust or in any way relating to the property known as MM Valley in NN Town, Western Australia and the Court notes that the wife releases the 7th to 11th Respondents from any claim she may have had in relation to those matters.
18.
That the 7th to 11th Respondents be discharged from all and any other obligations they may have in respect to all and any other Orders that have been made against them in these proceedings.
19.
That there be no Order for costs for the benefit of the 7th to 11th Respondents as against the wife and no Order for costs against them.
20.
[Deliberately Blank]
21.
That Paragraphs 20 and 21 insofar as it relates to the 7th to 11th Respondents’ Further Amended Response filed on 26 March 2015 be dismissed.
22.
That the parties do all such things and sign all and any documents necessary to give effect to these Orders.
Orders made 20.11.15 by consent
1.
The Minute of Consent Orders signed by the husband and wife dated 20 November 2015 be marked as Exhibit 62.
2.
Pursuant to s 79 Family Law Act I make orders in accordance with paragraphs 1,2,3 and 4 of Exhibit 62 and a declaration in the terms of paragraph 5 of the applicant wife’s document pursuant to the orders of 31 July 2015 which is in the following terms:
That it be declared that the wife is the sole, legal and beneficial owner of the General Household Furniture and Effects referred to in the Valuation Inventory General Household Furniture and Effects dated 2 August 2010 prepared by [OO Auctions Pty Limited] held in the storage at [PP Street, Suburb QQ] in the State of Western Australia and that the wife be entitled to take delivery of the same.
3.
I make an order in accordance with paragraph 5 of Exhibit 62.
4.
I discharge to the date to which they stand paid, all arrears owed by the husband to the wife in respect of any spousal maintenance order that has been made
5.
Apart from these orders, I discharge all other orders as between the husband and the wife and dismiss any other outstanding applications by one against the other.
6.
I note that in relation to this final part of the hearing which involves the claims between the husband and wife, these orders then finally conclude that part of the proceedings.
Exhibit 62
1.
That save as is dealt with by these Orders, the wife is sole, legal and beneficial owner of all property in her name and/or possession as at the date of these Orders.
2.
That within 7 days of the receipt by her of the whole of the funds paid to her by the 7th to 11th respondents pursuant to the orders made on 19 November 2015, the wife pay to the children of the marriage equally between them the sum of nine hundred thousand dollars ($900,000).
3.
That within 28 days of the conclusion of the proceedings between Mr L in his personal capacity against the wife the wife pay to the children of the marriage equally between them the sum of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) less the amount of any judgment which L may obtain against the wife.
4.
That the Application of the husband filed in Court on the 19th day of November 2015 be otherwise dismissed.
5.
No order as to costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.