Alarcon and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

Alarcon and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2015] AATA 475 (2 July 2015)

Division General Division

File Number(s)

2013/4904; 2013/4905 & 2014/0814

Re

Nellie Alarcon

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member J F Toohey
Dr M Couch, Member

Date 2 July 2015  
Place Sydney

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

......................................................

Senior Member J F Toohey

CATCHWORDS – compensation – disease – psychological condition – diagnosis – personality disorder with paranoid ideation – whether events complained of occurred – applicant’s perception – whether employment contributed to a significant degree to exacerbation – Tribunal not satisfied events occurred as applicant claimed – not satisfied condition exacerbated by employment – decisions under review affirmed

Legislation

Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 4, 5A(1), 5B(1), 5B(3), 14

Cases

Comcare v Mooi [1996] FCA 1587

Wiegand v Comcare (2002) 72 ALD 795

Kirkpatrick v Commonwealth (1985) FCA 440

Australian Telecommunications Commission v Tsikas (1985) 5 AAR 173

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member J F Toohey
Dr M Couch, Member

Introduction

  1. Nellie Alarcon has been employed as a postal delivery officer since 2000.  She claims compensation under the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act) for aggravation of a psychological condition as a result of incidents at work in 2012 and 2013.  The respondent denies liability to compensate her.

  2. Over the course of her employment, and in these proceedings, Ms Alarcon has complained of persistent harassment and bullying by managers, supervisors and other staff from around 2003 until the present day.  These proceedings concern three incidents only, and the following reviewable decisions denying liability to compensate her:

    i) a decision dated 18 March 2013 in respect of a claim lodged on 28 March 2012 for    “anxiety/depression” sustained on 28 February 2012;

    ii) a decision dated 5 August 2013 in respect of a claim lodged on 15 December 2012 for “mental breakdown” sustained on 15 December 2012;

    iii) a decision dated 6 August 2013 in respect of a claim lodged on 26 May 2013 for “depression, anxiety and stress” sustained on 9 April 2013.

  3. The first claim appears also to have been the subject of a reviewable decision in the same terms dated 22 January 2014.  The reasons for this are not clear but nothing turns on it.  We have to decide whether the respondent is liable to compensate Ms Alarcon for her claimed injury or injuries.

  4. When these proceedings commenced, Ms Alarcon was represented by a solicitor.  On 16 April 2015, her solicitor advised she had ceased to act for Ms Alarcon.  On 23 April 2013 Mr Ismael Isidto, a former employee of Australia Post who had provided a witness statement for these proceedings, notified the Tribunal that he was assisting Ms Alarcon.  He did so until the start of the second week of the hearing when he advised that he was withdrawing his assistance.  From that point, Ms Alarcon was assisted by her partner, Mr Paul Contessa, also an employee of Australia Post, who gave evidence during the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alarcon and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 475
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ms Alarcon, a former employee of the Australian Postal Corporation, sought compensation for the aggravation of a pre-existing psychological condition she alleged was exacerbated by workplace bullying and harassment. The case was heard by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, which needed to determine whether the events Ms Alarcon claimed occurred actually happened and whether her employment significantly contributed to the exacerbation of her condition.

The primary legal issues the Tribunal had to resolve were the credibility and reliability of Ms Alarcon's accounts of the alleged incidents of bullying and harassment, and whether these events, if they did occur, contributed significantly to the aggravation of her pre-existing psychological condition. The Tribunal also had to consider the diagnoses provided by various medical professionals regarding Ms Alarcon's condition.

The Tribunal found that Ms Alarcon's evidence was not reliable and was often inconsistent and contradictory. The Tribunal preferred the diagnoses of Mr O’Neill and Dr Champion, who identified Ms Alarcon as having a personality disorder with paranoid ideation, over that of Dr Saker. The Tribunal concluded that Ms Alarcon's condition pre-dated her employment with the Australian Postal Corporation and was not significantly exacerbated by any events at work. The Tribunal was not satisfied that the incidents Ms Alarcon complained of actually occurred as she claimed, and even if they did, they did not contribute significantly to the aggravation of her condition.

The Tribunal affirmed the decisions under review, dismissing Ms Alarcon's claims for compensation. The Tribunal found that the evidence did not support Ms Alarcon’s claims of bullying and harassment, and that her psychological condition was not significantly affected by her employment.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is common ground that Ms Alarcon’s claims are for the aggravation of a pre-existing psychological condition and are to be determined according to s 5B.Background Ms Alarcon came to Australia from the Philippines in 1991. She has four children. She separated from her husband in 2003. Before joining Australia Post in 2000, she worked for eight to ten years as an assistant nurse in a nursing home. Ms Alarcon claims that, from around 2003 (or, according to another account, 2005) she was bullied and harassed by supervisors, managers and other staff at Australia Post. She maintains there is a conspiracy to “get rid” of her. A persistent theme in her complaints is others’ “jealousy” of her because her efficiency makes them “look bad”. She says she has been accused of “killing overtime” because she works so quickly and efficiently. She denies any difficulties with other workers in previous jobs but agrees that she had some difficulty with another worker at the nursing home who she says was “jealous” of her and made trouble for her. Ms Alarcon also does not dispute that she has had “significant mental problems” for many years. She attributes these to the conspiracy against her by others at Australia Post. The evidence shows consultations with, and treatment by, general practitioners, a psychiatrist and a psychologist, and admission to hospital, over several years. The diagnosis of her condition is in dispute. We consider this further below. The evidence shows that, in September 2006, general practitioner, Dr Noori Abdulla, certified Ms Alarcon unfit for work for two days for work-related stress. In April 2008, a rehabilitation counsellor reported that ”both Clyde and myself” had concerns about Ms Alarcon’s “abnormal” behaviours “possibly indicating some form of emotional/mental stability (sic)”. Among a range of behaviours, the counsellor noted Ms Alarcon’s “seemingly paranoid expressions that everyone is out to get her” and “[r]ecurring statements that numerous people were not doing their job properly”. He suggested a psychological evaluation be conducted. On 29 August 2008, general practitioner, Dr Caroline Davidson, signed a letter for a GP Mental Health Plan and certified Ms Alarcon unfit for work from 27 July 2008 to 5 September 2008 due to depression and anxiety which had its onset in 2006. Further certificates show periods off work due to “depression anxiety and sleeplessness” in October 2009, “severe anxiety and depression” in November 2009, and anxiety and depression in June 2011. Dr Davidson recorded on 3 August 2009 that Ms Alarcon presented for depression when her relationship with her then boyfriend ended. The circumstances are discussed below. Ms Alarcon’s condition appears to have deteriorated after the relationship ended. In October 2009, she presented at the Emergency Department of Mona Vale Hospital with “acute anxiety following an exacerbation of a long running work place harassment issue.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondent submits that we should prefer the diagnoses of Mr O’Neill and Dr Champion. The respondent submits that Ms Alarcon viewed events “through the prism of her condition” and that nothing that happened at work caused or aggravated her condition. In particular, the respondent says, the events complained of did not occur, or did not occur in the manner alleged by Ms Alarcon.The evidence Prior to the hearing, Ms Alarcon submitted a number of statements from fellow workers. One, whose statement appeared to lend some support to her account of the incidents, declined to make himself available to give oral evidence. After discussion with Ms Alarcon at the hearing, it was agreed that several others who had provided written statements could not assist the Tribunal because their statements made clear they had not witnessed the incidents complained of. Those witnesses were not called. Ms Alarcon gave written and oral evidence. Written and oral evidence was also given by Mr Contessa and by Australia Post employees Jake Abeto, Satpal Singh Sethi and Aristona Koukkhanen. For the respondent, oral evidence was given by Bruce Davies, Ms Busby, Steve Charman and Rosalie Harper-Jung, all employees of the respondent, and by Phillip Lewis, the general manager of Telstra security, who gave evidence about CCTV footage of the incident on 9 April 2013. Mr O’Neill, Dr Champion and Dr Saker provided written reports and gave oral evidence.The incident on 28 February 2012 Ms Alarcon asserts that, on 28 February 2012, Bruce Davies, with whom she had had a difficult relationship for some time, called out her name and put out his tongue, “saying ‘fuck you’ and raising his fingers in the fuck you sign.” He was with his supervisor, Steve Charman, at the time; they both laughed and Mr Charman whispered something in Mr Davies’ ear. By reference to the length of the Tribunal hearing room, Ms Alarcon estimated the men were at a distance of more than 12 metres. Ms Alarcon says she complained to her supervisor, Dianne Busby, and repeatedly requested a “P400” form to register a complaint but “none was forthcoming” and Ms Busby yelled at her. She felt that no one was going to help her and she collapsed; an ambulance was called and she was taken to Royal North Shore Hospital where she was admitted overnight. She was off work for some days after this incident. Mr Davies denies the allegation. He gave evidence that he had returned to work that day after undergoing surgery to two fingers which he injured with a lawnmower at home. Photographs produced to the Tribunal show stitches to both fingers and the bandages Mr Davies was wearing when he returned to work. He says he raised his hand and waved to attract the attention of a fellow employee, showing her his fingers and indicating that he was back at work. He denies seeing Ms Alarcon at the time and denies using the words she alleges. Mr Charman gave evidence supporting Mr Davies’ account. He says he was standing “within about two feet” of Mr Davies and recalled seeing him raise his hands in the air but did not see him raise his fingers and did not hear him say “fuck you”. He recalls there being approximately 14 people in the area at the time; Ms Alarcon was not in the immediate area and was located on the other side of the building.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Merely because Ms Alarcon believes that her work caused her condition does not make it causally related. In Australian Telecommunications Commission v Tsikas (1985) 5 AAR 173, the Court said:There is of course, an important difference between, on the one hand, the sequelae making a sick mind sicker and thus perhaps contributing to incapacity and, on the other hand, a sick mind latching onto the factors described so that, in one sense, they play a part in the illness, but not in such a way as to add to existing incapacity.Conclusion For the reasons we have given above, we prefer the evidence of Mr O’Neill and Dr Champion to that of Dr Saker, and find that Ms Alarcon has a personality disorder with paranoid ideation. We are satisfied that it is long-standing and pre-existed the events of which she complains in these proceedings. We are not satisfied, on the information before us, that any of the incidents of which Ms Alarcon complains in these proceedings actually occurred as she claims. We are not satisfied that her perception of what did occur contributed to a significant degree to an aggravation of her pre-existing condition. We affirm the decisions under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Although Ms Alarcon denies any psychological condition prior to around 2003 when she says bullying and harassment started at work, her evidence about difficulties with a worker in former employment suggests that her condition pre-dated her employment with the respondent. In any event, we accept the opinion of Mr O’Neill and Dr Champion that her condition is long long-standing and was in existence before any of the events complained of. As set out below, we are not satisfied that her employment, in particular the incidents complained of, played any part in causing or aggravating her condition.Consideration The respondent submits that Ms Alarcon’s evidence is unsatisfactory in a number of respects and is unreliable. The respondent refers to the following matters in particular. Ms Alarcon claims she was raped by a fellow employee after he took her home from a work function in 2007. She claims he used repeated threats of violence to force her into a relationship with him for a year after this incident. She claims she was terrified of him throughout the relationship until she could no longer stand it and decided to leave him. In what appears to be at odds with her account of the end of the relationship, Dr Davidson recorded on 3 August 2009 that Ms Alarcon presented for depression. She noted:crying and upest (sic)her boyfriend married someone else while seeing herMSE - teary, crying, distressed Ms Alarcon denies being upset that the man decided to marry someone else. The respondent contends Ms Alarcon’s account is inherently implausible and at odds with Dr Davidson’s records. The respondent also refers to a number of inconsistencies in Ms Alarcon’s accounts to her doctors. Ms Alarcon’s oral evidence was frequently difficult to follow, inconsistent and contradictory. Whether because she was not frank with the Tribunal or whether a manifestation of her illness, or a combination of both, we agree that her evidence about the incidents complained of is not reliable and, except where supported by other evidence, cannot be relied on. As can be seen, there is very little evidence to support her claims; even Mr Singh, the only person to witness the incident on 15 December 2012, gave scant support to her version of events. Turning to the particular incidents complained of, the evidence does not support Ms Alarcon’s account of the first incident. We prefer the evidence of Mr Davies, Mr Charman and Ms Busby. We accept Ms Busby’s evidence that, from where she was, it was not possible for Ms Alarcon to hear Mr Davies say the words alleged. We accept that he waved his fingers in the air but are not satisfied it was directed at Ms Alarcon. The fact that she collapsed soon after is not evidence that Mr Davies behaved as she claims, particularly when she had acted in similar fashion on previous occasions. In relation to the second incident, we do not accept Ms Alarcon’s version. It is not in dispute that Mr Davies hit a ULD near to where she was standing but, despite their apparent history of difficulties, there is no evidence to support the conclusion that he did so deliberately. The evidence is that he was trying to move out of her way. Her claim that he swore and continued banging bins is not supported by her own witness.