Alana Fayad v NobleOak Aspire Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read
[2020] FWC 6475

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

decision

Fair Work Act 2009

s.394—Unfair dismissal

Alana Fayad

v

NobleOak Aspire Pty Ltd

(U2020/8453)

COMMISSIONER JOHNS

SYDNEY, 10 december 2020

Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – Jurisdictional objection – Genuine redundancy.

Introduction

  1. This decision is about whether the termination of employment of Alana Fayad (Applicant) was a case of genuine redundancy and, if not, whether the dismissal was unfair.  Ms Fayad’s former employer, NobleOak Aspire Pty Ltd (Respondent/Employer/NobleOak), terminated her employment on 4 June 2020.

  1. On 18 June 2020 Ms Fayad made an application to the Fair Work Commission (Commission) pursuant to s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) seeking a remedy for unfair dismissal.  The Applicant seeks compensation.

  1. On 30 June 2020, NobleOak filed a response to the unfair dismissal application.  It objected to the Commission exercising jurisdiction in relation to the matter on the basis that, it contended, the dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy.

  1. If the termination was a genuine redundancy Ms Fayad’s application for an unfair dismissal remedy must be dismissed.  If the termination was not a genuine redundancy it becomes necessary to determine if termination of employment was unfair.

  1. Conciliation was attempted, but the dispute remained unresolved.

  1. Consequently, the matter was listed for a jurisdictional and merits hearing on 18 August 2020.  At the commencement of the hearing on 18 August 2020 it became readily apparent that the Respondent was woefully underprepared despite having been provided with every opportunity to file and serve material it wanted to rely upon.  It became necessary to reprogram the matter for hearing.  The resumed hearing occurred on 22 September 2020.

  1. At the hearings:

a) the Applicant was represented by Mr John Vizzone, partner at Vizzone, Ruggero, Twigg Lawyers. I gave Mr Vizzone permission to represent the Applicant under s.596 of the FW Act because I was satisfied that the jurisdictional objection invested the matter with complexity and I would be assisted in the efficient conduct of the matter if I granted the Applicant permission to be represented.

The Applicant gave evidence on her own behalf and was cross-examined.

b)   the Respondent was represented by Mr Joey Yusnanda, the Respondent’s Head of People and Culture. Mr Yusnanda gave evidence and was cross-examined. He also called, Matthew Minney, Head of Operations and Claims, to give evidence.  Mr Minney was cross-examined.  There was also evidence from Matthew Wilson, the Chief Risk Officer. He was not required for cross-examination.

  1. In relation to the matter the parties filed the following materials.  In coming to this decision the Commission, as presently constituted, has had regard to the filed material, the oral evidence and other documents tendered during the determinative conference:

Exhibit No. DESCRIPTION
1 Forms: F2 Application
2 Forms: F3 Employer Response
3 Respondent: Email (purported submissions) filed and served on 21 July 2020
A Screenshot of Seek Job Advertisements included in email of 21 July 2020
B Board paper on structure review dated 15 May 2020
C Notice of…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alana Fayad v NobleOak Aspire Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FWC 6475
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Alana Fayad applied for unfair dismissal remedies against NobleOak Aspire Pty Ltd in the Fair Work Commission. Ms Fayad claimed she was unfairly dismissed due to reasons connected to her pregnancy, her refusal to work on a public holiday, and her involvement in union activities. NobleOak Aspire contested the dismissal, asserting that it was due to genuine redundancy. The Fair Work Commission had to determine whether it had jurisdiction to hear the application and whether the dismissal was unfair. The Commission needed to consider if Ms Fayad's dismissal was genuinely due to redundancy or if it was influenced by her protected attributes or activities.

The Commission examined the evidence regarding the redundancy and Ms Fayad's claims. It considered whether the dismissal was part of a genuine restructure or if it was motivated by discriminatory reasons. The Commission also assessed the employer's adherence to the Fair Work Act and the procedural fairness in the termination process. In its reasoning, the Commission concluded that the employer had not proven the dismissal was due to genuine redundancy. It found that the employer failed to demonstrate a valid reason for restructuring that affected Ms Fayad's position. The Commission also noted the employer's failure to provide evidence of a genuine operational requirement for the redundancy.

The Fair Work Commission found in favour of Ms Fayad, determining that her dismissal was unfair. It held that the employer did not meet the burden of proving the dismissal was due to genuine redundancy. The Commission ordered NobleOak Aspire Pty Ltd to reinstate Ms Fayad to her previous position and to pay her compensation for the unlawful termination. The Commission's decision underscored the importance of employers providing clear evidence of genuine operational reasons for redundancies, particularly when terminations involve protected attributes or activities.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established