AJH Lawyers v Mathieson Nominees Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2015 0021

AJH LAWYERS Applicant
v
MATHIESON NOMINEES PTY LTD First Respondent
IAN MATHIESON Second Respondent

---

JUDGES: HANSEN and McLEISH JJA and ROBSON AJA
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING: 3 August 2015
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 26 August 2015
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2015] VSCA 227
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: AJH Lawyers v Mathieson Nominees Pty Ltd & Anor [2015] VSC 37 (McDonald J)

---

APPEAL – Costs order by Judicial Registrar – Notice of Application to Reconsider Costs Order of Judicial Registrar – Application heard by Costs Judge – Nature of review under s 17HA of Supreme Court Act 1986 – Whether review by way of hearing de novo – Appeal dismissed – Constitution Act 1975 s 75A; Supreme Court Act 1986 s 17HA.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Applicant Mr D G Robertson QC with
Ms A Peek
AJH Lawyers
For the Respondents Mr D J Williams QC Victorian Legal Cost Assessors

HANSEN JA
McLEISH JA:

  1. In February 2012, the respondents to this application for leave to appeal (‘Mathieson’) entered into a written costs agreement with the applicant (‘AJH’) in relation to the provision of legal services by AJH to the liquidator of a company in respect of whom the first respondent was a creditor.  The respondents are ‘third party payers’ within the meaning of the Legal Profession Act 2004 (‘the LP Act’).

  1. AJH rendered three bills of costs in the total amount of $35,709.10 in February and March 2012. Mathieson filed and served a summons for taxation in respect of those bills of costs. After extensive hearings, including the hearing and determination of a matter referred to a judge in the Trial Division pursuant to r 63.51 of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005 (‘the Rules’), Gourlay JR ordered on 17 February 2014 that AJH pay Mathieson the sum of $1,000 in respect of the bills of costs. Gourlay JR then heard submissions as to costs and ordered that AJH pay Mathieson 50 per cent of their costs of the proceeding, save for the costs of the referral to the Trial Division and the costs of 17 February 2014. No order was made as to AJH’s costs.

  1. AJH purported to seek reconsideration of the decision of Gourlay JR by filing a notice of application for reconsideration pursuant to r 63.56.2 of the Rules. The only aspect of the decision which was the subject of challenge was the orders in respect of costs. In their place, AJH sought an order wholly ‘disallowing’ Mathieson’s costs and ‘allowing’ its own costs in full. It is not now in issue that the notice was ineffective as a notice under r 63.56.2 but that it was properly treated in the Costs Court as an application for review by a Costs Judge pursuant to s 17HA of the Supreme Court Act 1986.  The relevant provisions are set out later in these reasons.

  1. Wood AsJ, the Costs Judge constituting the Costs Court,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AJH Lawyers v Mathieson Nominees Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] VSCA 227
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of AJH Lawyers versus Mathieson Nominees Pty Ltd, the dispute involved a costs order by a Judicial Registrar that was subsequently reviewed by a Costs Judge. The applicant, AJH Lawyers, sought to challenge the costs order, arguing that the review process was flawed and did not constitute a hearing de novo. The Supreme Court was the forum for this appeal, and the case was heard by the Trial Division, which ultimately dismissed the appeal.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether a review of a Judicial Registrar's costs order by a Costs Judge under section 17HA of the Supreme Court Act 1986 was required to be conducted as a hearing de novo. AJH Lawyers argued that the review should constitute a fresh hearing, as opposed to a limited review, because of the nature of the power exercised by the Judicial Registrar. The respondents, Mathieson Nominees Pty Ltd, contended that the review could be conducted without a fresh hearing, based on the principles established in House v The King.

The court held that a review under section 17HA of the Supreme Court Act did not necessitate a hearing de novo. The court reasoned that the Supreme Court Act and the relevant rules did not provide for reconsideration or review by a judicial registrar of an order in respect of costs of a review. Instead, the court found that rule 1.15(1)(b) applied, which allowed for a review based on demonstrating 'clear error.' The court further clarified that the nature of the review was not dependent on whether the original decision-maker was a judicial registrar or the Costs Judge. The court found that the Costs Judge had correctly applied the law in conducting the review.

The appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the Trial Division was upheld. The court found no error in the Costs Judge's approach to the review, and the costs order by the Judicial Registrar remained in place.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The application for reconsideration or review After the above ruling, AJH filed a ‘notice of application to reconsider order of judicial registrar’ dated 3 March 2014. That notice sought an order that Mathieson’s costs of the review be ‘disallowed’ and that AJH’s costs be ‘allowed’ in full. The notice stated that AJH applied to the judicial registrar to reconsider the order. However, since AJH was not objecting to an order allowing or disallowing any item in a bill or allowing some amount in respect of any item, r 63.56.2 was not engaged. Since neither the Supreme Court Act nor the Rules provided for reconsideration by a judicial registrar of an order in respect of the costs of a review, the application in the notice was heard and determined instead by Wood AsJ sitting as the Costs Judge. The judge in the Trial Division accepted that Gourlay JR had ordered that the notice stand as a notice of review and had referred it for hearing by Wood AsJ. In any event, the notice was treated as an application for review by the Costs Judge pursuant to s 17HA of the Supreme Court Act. Section 17HA of the Supreme Court Act relevantly provides: Although s 17HA(5) provides for the hearing and determination of a review under the provision to be conducted in accordance with the Rules, the Rules provide only in respect of a review of a decision of a judicial registrar made under r 63.56.2(6) on a reconsideration or review under r 63.56.2. In the present case, there had been no such reconsideration or review, nor could there have been. Accordingly, the Rules were silent as to the procedure on the review before the Costs Judge. In those circumstances, r 1.15(1)(b) governed the situation. It states: As mentioned, Wood AsJ held that the notice seeking reconsideration was in reality an application for review by a Costs Judge under s 17HA. He relied in part on r 1.15(1)(b) to decide that, in order to overturn a costs order in the exercise of that jurisdiction, ‘clear error’ must be demonstrated. In support of that approach he cited a passage from the judgment of Williams J in Owens v Oakley Thompson & Co.[4] In effect, as the judge in the Trial Division held, the Costs Judge conducted the review on the basis that AJH needed to demonstrate error of the type identified by the High Court in House v The King.[5][4][2014] VSC 198, [20].[5](1936) 55 CLR 499, 505. Reduced to its essentials, the first proposed ground of appeal is that the judge erred in holding that a ‘review’ under s 17HA of the Supreme Court Act of a decision of a judicial registrar constituting the Costs Court is not required to be conducted as a hearing de novo. AJH first contends that it is necessary to examine s 17HA by reference to its context. In particular, emphasis is placed on s 75A(5) of the Constitution Act. Section 75A relevantly provides: AJH relies in particular on the words in s 75A(5) contemplating that the Supreme Court Act or the Rules will make provision for the delegation to judicial registrars of the powers of the Court or the Trial Division. The determination of Gourlay JR was not made pursuant to any express delegation of power by the Costs Judge. AJH contended instead that s 75A(5) of the Constitution Act (and perhaps s 17AA of the Supreme Court Act) effect an implied delegation of that kind. It was submitted that the exercise by a judicial registrar of the delegated power to determine costs under s 3.4.45 of the LP Act cannot confine the exercise of the same discretion by the Costs Judge who constituted the Costs Court and in whom the power was primarily reposed. Viewed in that light, it was contended that the review for which s 17HA provides is necessarily in the nature of a fresh hearing.