Aistrope & Aistrope v South Australian Housing Trust

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

AISTROPE & AISTROPE v SOUTH AUSTRALIAN HOUSING TRUST

[2015] SASC 202

Reasons of Judge Bochner a Master of the Supreme Court

22 December 2015

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEDURE UNDER RULES OF COURT - PLEADINGS

Amendment to statement of claim and delay.

Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) rr 3, 90, 98 and 99; Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M; South Australian Housing Trust Act 1995 (SA) s 5, referred to.
Comcare v John Holland Rail Pty Ltd (No 5) (2011) 195 FCR 43; [2011] FCA 622; Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175; Channel Seven Adelaide Pty Ltd v Manock (2010) 273 LSJS 70; [2010] SASCFC 59; Pope & Ors v Harris Orchard [2010] SASC 354; Arthur Young (A Firm) v Tieco International (Australia) Pty Ltd (unreported, Lander J, SCSA, 19 July 1995), considered.

AISTROPE & AISTROPE v SOUTH AUSTRALIAN HOUSING TRUST
[2015] SASC 202

  1. JUDGE BOCHNER.  Before me is an application by the plaintiffs to amend their statement of claim.  This is not the first time they have sought leave to do so; three previous iterations of their statement of claim have already been filed and this application is for leave to file a fourth iteration. 

  2. The facts surrounding this matter are not particularly complex.  The crux of the claim, as expressed in the third statement of claim, is set out in the first two paragraphs of the reasons of his Honour Judge Withers delivered on 14 July 2015 and I adopt with respect his useful summary.

  3. The plaintiffs wish to amend their statement of claim further, to allege breach of statutory duties, and to plead nuisance in respect of the property adjoining the plaintiffs, which is the subject of this action.  In addition, the plaintiffs seek to plead certain facts and events occurring at various times.  The defendant objects to the filing of the proposed fourth statement of claim on the basis that it is not adequately pleaded, that some of the amendments sought have no reasonable prospect of success, and that it offends against the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) and the Supreme Court Civil Supplementary Rules 2014.  Finally, it is the position of the defendant that the plaintiffs’ delay in amending should preclude them from being granted leave.

  4. In support of their application, the plaintiffs rely on the third and fifth affidavits of the first plaintiff and the affidavit of Mr Campbell filed on 21 October 2015.  The defendant relies on the joint affidavit of the plaintiffs filed on 18 February 2010 (FDN 11), the second affidavit of the first plaintiff (FDN 62), and the sixth and ninth affidavits of Lesley Jane McPharlin (FDN 70 and FDN 84 respectively). 

  5. Before I embark on an examination of the amendments sought, and the defects alleged by the defendant, it is useful to set out the framework within which the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aistrope & Aistrope v South Australian Housing Trust and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] SASC 202
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Aistrope & Aistrope v South Australian Housing Trust was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The plaintiffs, Mr and Mrs Aistrope, sought damages for personal injuries arising from the collapse of a retaining wall on their property. The dispute centred on the procedural aspects of the case, particularly the plaintiffs' application to file a fourth statement of claim, which would significantly alter the scope of the litigation. The South Australian Housing Trust opposed the application, arguing that the plaintiffs had ample opportunity to plead their case fully and that further amendments would result in undue delay and expense.

The legal issues before the court included whether the plaintiffs were entitled to further amend their pleadings under the rules of court, and whether any such amendment would be just and expedient in the circumstances. The court considered the principles of procedural fairness and the interests of justice, particularly the need to avoid unnecessary delay and expense. It also evaluated the potential prejudice to the defendant and the public's confidence in the legal system if further amendments were permitted.

The court found that the plaintiffs had sufficient opportunity to plead their case fully and that the proposed amendments were based on matters known to them at the time of the third statement of claim. The court emphasised the importance of adhering to the principles of efficiency and fairness in litigation, as outlined in the rules of court. It concluded that granting leave to file a fourth statement of claim would undermine public confidence in the administration of civil justice, and therefore, the application was dismissed.

The court's final orders were that the plaintiffs' application to file a fourth statement of claim was dismissed, and no further amendments to the pleadings would be allowed. The matter was to proceed with the third statement of claim as filed, and the parties were directed to continue with the ongoing interlocutory steps in the litigation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Further delay will no doubt impose further strain and uncertainty on the parties. Mr Field, in his report on the plaintiffs dated 13 December 2012 states, “… recovery from their psychological injuries have been undermined by the ongoing dispute process that is presently before the Court”. One can assume that further delay and associated cost will impair their recovery process further. The defendant, too, faces ongoing uncertainty and increased costs because of the delays in this matter. Whether any further delay would undermine confidence in the administration of civil justice The undue delays in this matter must undermine confidence in the administration of civil justice. If leave were granted to further amend the statement of claim, it would result in this matter being no further progressed than it was when it was first instituted, just over six years ago. A new defence would need to be filed, further disclosure would need to be made, and Mr Campbell has intimated that further expert reports may need to be obtained. This would all be on the basis of facts that were known to the plaintiffs at the time of the filing of the third statement of claim. It would be no surprise if there was a loss in public confidence in the legal system if such delay was countenanced in the absence of a compelling reason. The public has a legitimate expectation that proceedings will be litigated in an effective, efficient way, minimising as far as possible delay, expense and duplication of effort. Indeed, Rule 3 raises these expectations, and it is the role of the Court in conjunction with legal practitioners, to ensure that litigation is conducted in adherence with these principles. This is not to say that the interests of justice should not prevail. It raises a more complex question of where the interests of justice lie in matters such as this. As said in the joint judgment in Aon (at [94]):… Where a party had had a sufficient opportunity to plead his or her case, it may be necessary for the court to make a decision which may produce a sense of injustice in that party, for the sake of doing justice to the opponent and to other litigants. Any other prejudice likely to be suffered by the other party This matter relates to events that occurred in 1996 and 2004. Ongoing delay will no doubt have a prejudicial effect on the ability of all parties and witnesses to recall events and provide their evidence in a satisfactory manner.The additional costs likely to be incurred As set out above, the interlocutory steps in the matter will need to be revisited by both parties. This will result in significant additional costs being incurred. In light of the above, I conclude that leave to file a fourth statement of claim should not be granted. The plaintiffs have had sufficient opportunity to plead their case and indeed, at the time of filing the third statement of claim, were assisted by both solicitors and senior counsel. The matters now sought to be pleaded were within the knowledge of the plaintiffs at this time, and no reason has been given for their failure to include them in the third statement of claim.