Advertiser-News Weekend Publishing Co Ltd v Manock

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

ADVERTISER-NEWS WEEKEND PUBLISHING CO LIMITED v MANOCK

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle, The Honourable Justice Vanstone and The Honourable Justice White)

15 March 2005

DEFAMATION - ACTIONS FOR DEFAMATION - PLEADING - SOUTH AUSTRALIA

DEFAMATION - ACTIONS FOR DEFAMATION - PARTICULARS - OF STATEMENT OF DEFENCE OR PLEA

The plaintiff claimed damages from the defendant for libel in relation to three newspaper articles published by the defendant - the plaintiff pleaded that a number of imputations arose from the natural and ordinary meaning of the words in each of the articles - the defendant pleaded justification and provided detailed particulars - the defendant also pleaded that alternative meanings could be attributed to the words which could also be justified - the plaintiff applied for orders striking out the particulars and also to strike out the plea of alternative meanings - a single Judge of the Supreme Court made orders striking out portions of those pleadings and particulars - the defendant appeals those orders - whether the meanings in the particulars pleaded by the defence were separate and distinct from those pleaded by the plaintiff - whether an ordinary reader would consider a statement in relation to general forensic work distinct from work done in relation to murder trials - whether professional incompetence by the plaintiff in relation to the investigation of any death could infer (by way of a sufficient link) incompetence in the investigations of murder cases - discussion of the common law test for a defendant to plead alternative meanings - whether the trial Judge applied the correct common law test - discussion of the "Polly Peck" defence and whether permissible in South Australia - whether the alternative meanings pleaded by the defendant satisfied the common law test - appeal dismissed.

Supreme Court Rules SA R 95.07; Defamation Act 1889 (Qld); Defamation Act 1974 (NSW), referred to.
David Syme and Co Ltd v Hore-Lacy [2000] 1 VR 667, applied.
South Australian Telecasters Ltd (1997) 69 SASR 440, distinguished.
Polly Peck (Holdings) Plc v Trelford [1986] QB 1000, not followed.
Chakravati v Advertisers Newspapers Limited (1998) 193 CLR 519; Whelan v John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd (2002) 56 NSWLR 89; John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd v Jones [2004] NSWCA 205; Nationwide News Pty Ltd v Moodie (2003) 28 WAR 314, discussed.
Friends of Hinchinbrook Society Inc v Minister for Environment (No 4) (1998) 83 FCR 304; Drummoyne Municipal Council v ABC (1990) 21 NSWLR 135; Robinson v Laws [2003] 1 Qd R 81; Templeton v Jones [1984] 1 NZLR 448, considered.

ADVERTISER-NEWS WEEKEND PUBLISHING CO LIMITED v MANOCK
[2005] SASC 82

Full Court:  Doyle CJ, Vanstone J and White J

  1. DOYLE CJ:          The plaintiff, Dr Manock (the respondent before this Court), has sued the defendant Advertiser-News Weekend Publishing Co Ltd (the appellant before this Court) for damages for libel.

  2. Dr Manock is a forensic pathologist, and formerly…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Advertiser-News Weekend Publishing Co Ltd v Manock and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 82
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Advertiser-News Weekend Publishing Co Ltd v Manock, the plaintiff sought damages from the defendant for libel due to three newspaper articles published by the defendant. The plaintiff alleged that various imputations arose from the natural and ordinary meaning of the words in each of the articles. The defendant pleaded justification and provided detailed particulars. Additionally, the defendant argued that alternative meanings could be attributed to the words, which could also be justified. The plaintiff applied for orders to strike out the particulars and to strike out the plea of alternative meanings. A single Judge of the Supreme Court made orders striking out portions of the pleadings and particulars. The defendant appealed these orders. The appeal raised questions about whether the meanings in the particulars pleaded by the defence were separate and distinct from those pleaded by the plaintiff, whether an ordinary reader would consider a statement in relation to general forensic work distinct from work done in relation to murder trials, and whether professional incompetence by the plaintiff in relation to the investigation of any death could infer incompetence in the investigations of murder cases. The appeal also discussed the common law test for a defendant to plead alternative meanings, whether the trial Judge applied the correct common law test, the "Polly Peck" defence, and whether the alternative meanings pleaded by the defendant satisfied the common law test.

The court examined whether the meanings in the particulars pleaded by the defence were separate and distinct from those pleaded by the plaintiff. The court found that the particulars raised Dr Manock's conduct in relation to deaths but not deaths that were followed by a charge of murder being laid. Except for two instances, it was not alleged in the challenged particulars that Dr Manock had given evidence in a murder trial or prepared a report for the purposes of a murder trial. The court held that on the face of it, the challenged particulars were "not reasonably capable of supporting a plea of justification in relation to the imputations alleged by the plaintiff which all relate to the plaintiff’s conduct in relation to murder trials." The court rejected the submission that there was a sufficient link between murder trials and the challenged particulars. The court pointed out that even the argument that an unreliable opinion that led to a person not being charged with murder was as relevant as an unreliable opinion given in the course of the trial of a person charged with murder would not apply to particulars that related to an accidental death. In any event, the court found that the suggested link was "far too tenuous." The court also rejected the submission that the challenged particulars could support a finding as to the general practice of Dr Manock as a forensic pathologist, from which the Court might then draw an inference about Dr Manock’s conduct in murder trials. The court held that this plea did not provide any particulars of how Dr Manock was said to have failed to comply with the aims of a forensic autopsy, or how any such failures were relevant to his work in relation to murder trials.

The court also examined whether the meanings in the particulars pleaded by the defence satisfied the common law test. The court held that the "Polly Peck" defence was permissible in South Australia. The court found that the alternative meanings pleaded by the defendant satisfied the common law test. The court held that the defendant was entitled to plead an alternative meaning if it was reasonably capable of supporting a plea of justification. The court found that the alternative meanings pleaded by the defendant were reasonably capable of supporting a plea of justification. The court held that the trial Judge applied the correct common law test and dismissed the appeal. The court held that the orders made by the trial Judge were correct and that the appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The defendant supports this argument with a submission that at trial Dr Manock will not be confined to the precise meaning pleaded. He might be allowed at trial to rely on a variant of the pleaded meaning, if the adverse imputation is a less serious one, and so Dr Manock might be permitted to rely on the meaning pleaded by the defendant, or something very close to it. Accordingly, so the submission goes, fairness requires that the defendant be allowed to anticipate that possibility and to meet that possibility by justifying the alternative meaning on which Dr Manock might be permitted to rely at trial.The Judge’s decision I deal first with the application to strike out the challenged particulars of justification. The Judge said that the challenged particulars raise Dr Manock’s conduct in relation to deaths, but not deaths that were followed by a charge of murder being laid: at [58]. Except for two instances, it was not alleged in the challenged particulars that Dr Manock had given evidence in a murder trial or prepared a report for the purposes of a murder trial. The Judge said that on the face of it, the challenged particulars were “not reasonably capable of supporting a plea of justification in relation to the imputations alleged by the plaintiff which all relate to the plaintiff’s conduct in relation to murder trials”: at [68]. The Judge rejected the submission that there was a sufficient link between murder trials and the challenged particulars. The link was said to be that if Dr Manock gave an unreliable opinion that led to a person not being charged with murder, that was as relevant as an unreliable opinion given in the course of the trial of a person charged with murder. The Judge pointed out that even this argument would not apply to particulars that related to an accidental death (as some of the challenged particulars appear to). In any event, the Judge said that the suggested link was “far too tenuous”: at [69]. The Judge rejected the submission that the challenged particulars could support a finding as to the general practice of Dr Manock as a forensic pathologist (in death cases generally), from which the Court might then draw an inference about Dr Manock’s conduct in murder trials. This is a reference to the defendant’s plea in paras 8.16 and 8.17, referred to above. The Judge said that this plea did not provide any particulars of how Dr Manock was said to have failed to comply with the aims of a forensic autopsy, or how any such failures were relevant to his work in relation to murder trials: at [69]. He doubted in any event whether the defendant was entitled to plead Dr Manock’s general practice in this way, when the imputation alleged in para 6.9 related to a particular aspect of Dr Manock’s work. The Judge ordered that most of the challenged particulars be struck out. He did so because they did not deal with Dr Manock’s work “in relation to murder trials”. I turn now to the application to strike out the pleading of an alternative meaning.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.