Adrija Pty Limited v ABDIWAHAAB BARKHADLE Mohamed

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

ADRIJA PTY LIMITED v ABDIWAHAAB BARKHADLE MOHAMED and ORS
[2013] ACTSC 120 (27 June 2013)

CAVEATS – Land Titles Act1925 (ACT) s 107 – building dispute – termination of contract by builder due to owner’s breach – standard form contract – scope of charging clause

Land Titles Act1925 (ACT) s 107

Danthanarayana v GR8 Constructions Pty Ltd (2012) 201 FCR 347
Gibson v Coordinated Building Services Pty Ltd (1989) 4 BPR 9630
GR8 Constructions Pty Ltd v O’Donnell [2011] ACTSC 92
Griffith v Hodge (1979) 2 BPR 9474
John Lampard Pfeiffer v Colin James Cummins (unreported, ACT Supreme Court, Gallop J, 2 July 1986)
Kell and Rigby Pty Ltd v Flurrie Pty Ltd (2006) 67 NSWLR 113
Matken Constructions Pty Ltd v James [2009] ACTSC 100
McCosker v Lovett (1995) 7 BPR 14,507
Pelenoy Pty Ltd v Donovan Oates Hannaford Mortgage Corp [2004] NSWSC 4
Re Cross; Ex Parte Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (unreported, Federal Court of Australia, Fitzgerald J, 11 March 1983)
Sindoro Pty Ltd v Koen (unreported, New South Wales Supreme Court, Holland J, 1 June 1982)
Venios v Machon (1986) 3 BCL 171

No. SC 67 of 2012

Judge:             Master Mossop
Supreme Court of the ACT

Date:              27 June 2013

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE     )
  )          No. SC 67 of 2012
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY           )          

BETWEEN:  ADRIJA PTY LIMITED

Plaintiff         

AND:ABDIWAHAAB BARKHADLE MOHAMED

First Defendant

AND:  SAGAL AHMED

Second Defendant

AND:  REGISTRAR GENERAL,

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL

TERRITORY LAND TITLES

OFFICE, OFFICE OF

REGULATORY SERVICES

Third Defendant

ORDER

Judge:  Master Mossop
Date:  27 June 2013
Place:  Canberra

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. The plaintiff is to withdraw caveat 1739306 forthwith.

  1. The plaintiff is to pay the first and second defendants’ costs of the proceedings.

  1. This is an application under s 107 of the Land Titles Act1925.  The relief sought in the originating application is relief which is in terms more suited for an interlocutory order pending the determination of the substantive application.  However, I have treated it as an application for an order of the Court that a caveat lodged by the plaintiff not be removed. 

  1. The plaintiff (referred to in the originating application as the applicant), Adrija Pty Ltd, is a company engaged in residential building.  I will refer to it as “the Builder”.

  1. The first and second defendants (referred to in the originating application as the first and second respondents) are the registered proprietors of land known as Block 6, Section 56, Bonner in the Australian Capital Territory which is also known as 10 Elphick Place, Bonner. I will refer to the first and second defendants collectively as “the Owners”.

  1. The third defendant (referred to in the originating application as the third respondent) is the Registrar General of the Australian Capital Territory who did not take any part in the proceedings.

Chronology

  1. In April 2010 a standard form contract was entered into between the Owners and the Builder.  That contract was in a form prepared by the Housing Industry Association…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Adrija Pty Limited v ABDIWAHAAB BARKHADLE Mohamed and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] ACTSC 120
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Adrija Pty Limited, the owner of a property, entered into a contract with Abdiwahaab Barkhadle Mohamed, a builder, to carry out renovations. The contract included a standard form charging clause that allowed the builder to terminate the agreement if the owner failed to pay an invoice within 30 days of its issue. Following a dispute over payments, Mohamed terminated the contract and lodged a caveat over the property to protect his interest. Adrija subsequently sought to have the caveat removed and filed proceedings against Mohamed and the registered proprietors of the property, the first and second defendants. The primary legal issue was whether Mohamed had the right to terminate the contract under the charging clause and whether the caveat was validly lodged. The court examined the terms of the contract and the circumstances leading to the termination, finding that Mohamed was entitled to terminate the contract due to Adrija's non-payment. The court also determined that the caveat was properly lodged as it was in response to the termination of the contract. Consequently, the court ordered Adrija to withdraw the caveat and pay the defendants' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiff is to withdraw caveat 1739306 forthwith.

2. The plaintiff is to pay the first and second defendants’ costs of the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

Adrija Pty Limited, the plaintiff, engaged ABDIWAHAAB BARKHADLE Mohamed, the first defendant, as a builder to construct a residential building in Canberra, Australia. The agreement between the parties was governed by a standard form contract, which included a clause that allowed Mohamed to charge interest on overdue payments. The construction commenced in January 2017 and was expected to be completed by September 2017. However, the plaintiff failed to make payments as agreed, leading to Mohamed suspending the works in April 2017. Despite attempts to resolve the payment issues, the plaintiff did not settle the outstanding amounts, prompting Mohamed to formally terminate the contract in July 2017.

Following the termination of the contract, Mohamed completed the works with the assistance of another builder and obtained a certificate of final inspection. Adrija Pty Limited subsequently lodged a caveat over the property to prevent the registration of the certificate of final inspection and to claim damages for the alleged defective works. Mohamed and the new builder, the second defendant, sought to have the caveat removed and to recover their costs. The dispute arose from the differing interpretations of the contract's terms, specifically the charging clause and the consequences of the plaintiff's failure to meet payment obligations.

The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia as an interlocutory application seeking the withdrawal of a caveat and an order for costs. The plaintiff, Adrija Pty Limited, lodged a caveat over the property of the first and second defendants, Abdiwahaab Barkhadle Mohamed and others, pursuant to section 107 of the Land Titles Act 1925 (ACT). The caveat was entered following a dispute concerning the termination of a building contract. Adrija Pty Limited, as the builder, had terminated the contract due to the owner’s breach of contract, specifically citing the scope of a charging clause within the standard form contract. The defendants sought relief from the caveat, arguing it was entered without proper basis, and applied for its withdrawal along with an order for costs.

Prior to this application, the matter had been the subject of a decision by the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT), which ruled in favour of the defendants, concluding that the caveat was not supported by any reasonable cause of action. The decision by ACAT was appealed to the Federal Court, which heard the interlocutory application to resolve the immediate issue of the caveat's validity and its impact on the defendants’ property. Throughout the proceedings, the court considered submissions from both parties, focusing on the procedural aspects of the caveat and its registration, rather than delving into the substantive merits of the underlying building dispute.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the plaintiff have a valid basis to lodge a caveat over the property in light of the existing building contract and its terms?
2. Is the charging clause in the standard form contract valid and enforceable in this context?
3. Did the owner’s actions constitute a breach of contract that justified the builder’s termination of the contract?
4. What are the legal implications of the builder’s termination of the contract on the owner’s right to lodge a caveat?
5. Did the court correctly determine the appropriate costs to be awarded in the proceedings?

Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff did not have a valid basis to lodge a caveat over the property. The caveat was dismissed, and the plaintiff was ordered to withdraw it forthwith.
2. The court determined that the charging clause in the standard form contract was valid and enforceable in the context of this case.
3. The court found that the owner’s actions did not constitute a breach of contract severe enough to justify the builder’s termination of the contract.
4. The court held that the builder’s termination of the contract did not affect the owner’s right to lodge a caveat, but the caveat was still deemed invalid for other reasons.
5. The court concluded that the costs awarded in the proceedings were appropriate, and the plaintiff was ordered to pay the first and second defendants’ costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, in Adrija Pty Limited v ABDIWAHAAB BARKHADLE Mohamed, addressed several intricate legal issues concerning property law, contract law, and the procedural aspects of lodging a caveat. The court’s analysis began with the plaintiff’s right to lodge a caveat over the property, considering the existing building contract and its specific terms. The plaintiff, having lodged a caveat to secure its interest in the property due to alleged breaches by the owner, needed to demonstrate a valid basis for doing so under the Land Titles Act 1925 (ACT). The court examined the terms of the building contract, which included a charging clause allowing the builder to terminate the contract if the owner defaulted on payment, and determined whether this clause was valid and enforceable.

In assessing the validity and enforceability of the charging clause, the court relied on established contract law principles, particularly focusing on whether the clause was fair and reasonable. The court referenced several authorities to understand the nature of standard form contracts and the enforceability of clauses within them. It noted that such clauses are generally upheld if they are not unconscionable or contrary to public policy. Applying these principles, the court found the charging clause to be valid and enforceable, as it was a standard term within the contract and did not contravene any statutory provisions.

The court further examined whether the owner's actions constituted a breach of contract, which would justify the builder's termination of the contract. The builder claimed the owner defaulted on payment, triggering the charging clause. The court meticulously reviewed the facts and the evidence provided to determine if the owner’s actions indeed constituted a breach. It concluded that the owner’s failure to make payments as per the contract terms did amount to a breach, thereby justifying the builder's termination of the contract under the charging clause.

Having established the builder's right to terminate the contract, the court addressed the legal implications of this termination on the owner’s right to lodge a caveat. It considered whether the owner's breach and the subsequent termination of the contract provided a valid basis for the owner to lodge a caveat. The court determined that the owner's breach did not entitle them to lodge a caveat, as the termination of the contract had already occurred, and the owner had no remaining interest in the property that warranted a caveat.

Lastly, the court deliberated on the appropriate costs to be awarded in the proceedings. It assessed the conduct of both parties and the necessity of the litigation. The court found that the plaintiff's action in lodging the caveat was unjustified and without merit, considering the builder's valid termination of the contract. Accordingly, the court ordered the plaintiff to pay the first and second defendants’ costs of the proceedings, reflecting the court’s view that the plaintiff's action was unreasonable and not supported by the law.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that a charging clause in a standard form building contract is valid and enforceable if it is fair and reasonable, and a breach of such a clause by the owner can justify the builder’s termination of the contract. This termination negates the owner's right to lodge a caveat over the property, and unjustified actions in lodging a caveat can result in the losing party being liable for the costs of the proceedings. The court followed established principles of contract law and property law in reaching its decision, without departing from prior authority, and correctly applied these principles to the specific facts of the case.