DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONSRe:Opposition by Seven Network (Operations) Limited to extension of protection to international registration designating Australia No. 2259985 (International Registration No. 1652677) – – held by ADME (CY) LTD
Delegate: Bianca Irgang Representation: Opponent: Herbert Smith Freehills
Holder: IP Solved (ANZ) Pty Ltd
Decision: 2024 ATMO 117
Trade Mark Regulations 1995 - Opposition under regs 17A.33: sections 44, 58, 60 and 42(b) pressed– section 60 established–protection not to be extended to the IRDA.Background
ADME (CY) LTD (‘the holder’) has applied for extension of protection of International Registration Designating Australia (‘IRDA’) 2259985 in classes 35 and 41 of the International Classification of Goods and Services. Relevant details of the IRDA are set out below.
Trade mark: (the ‘Trade Mark’)
IRDA: 2259985
International Registration: 1652677
Lodgement Date: 1 December 2021
Convention Details: 4 June 2021 (‘Relevant Date’)
Cypress
91752Specification: Class 35: Advertising on the Internet for others; dissemination of advertising for others via an on-line communications network on the internet; promoting the goods and services of others; promoting the sale of the services [on behalf of others] by arranging advertisements; online advertising services; publicity publication services; publication of publicity materials; arranging subscriptions to publications for others; analysis of market research data and statistics; electronic data processing; advertising and marketing services provided via communications channels; advertising and marketing services provided by means of social media.
Class 41: Providing entertainment information via a website; providing entertainment in the nature of film clips via a website; film studios; film editing; film production; entertainment by film; film production, other than advertising films; providing films, not downloadable, via video-on-demand services; multimedia entertainment software publishing services; digital video, audio and multimedia entertainment publishing services; providing user ratings for entertainment or cultural purposes; publication of online reviews in the field of entertainment; entertainment information; entertainment; audio entertainment services; video entertainment services; television entertainment; television and radio entertainment; provision of entertainment facilities; fan club services (entertainment); arranging of visual entertainment; entertainment provided via the internet; provision of on-line entertainment; information services relating to entertainment; provision of entertainment via podcast; entertainment services featuring fictional characters; providing video entertainment via a website; providing video entertainment via the internet; arranging of presentations for entertainment purposes; organizing of shows for entertainment purposes; entertainment services provided by on-line streams; provision of entertainment information via the Internet; preparation of special effects for entertainment purposes; provision of entertainment information via television, broadband, wireless and on-line services; information relating to entertainment, provided on-line from a computer database or the internet; animation production services; production of animation; special effects animation services for film and video; online digital publishing services.
(the ‘holder’s services’)
The IRDA was advertised as accepted for possible protection in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 31 March 2022. Seven Network (Operations) Limited (‘the opponent’) filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose the extension of protection on 12…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Adme (Cy) Ltd v Seven Network (Operations) Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] ATMO 117
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Hearing Officer was whether the opponent had established a ground of opposition under section 60 of the Act. This section allows for opposition if another trade mark had acquired a reputation in Australia before the priority date of the mark sought to be registered, and the use of the latter mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion due to that reputation. The opponent relied on its widespread use of trade marks featuring the word "SEVEN" or the number "7" to establish this reputation.
The Hearing Officer found that the opponent had successfully established the ground of opposition under section 60. This conclusion was based on the opponent demonstrating that its "Seven Marks" had acquired a reputation in Australia amongst a significant number of people before the relevant date. The Hearing Officer noted that reputation is not assumed and must be proven by evidence, such as significant exposure, high sales volume, or substantial advertising expenditure. Having succeeded on the section 60 ground, the Hearing Officer deemed it unnecessary to consider the other grounds of opposition.
Consequently, the Hearing Officer ordered that protection for the International Registration Designating Australia (IRDA) be refused in respect of all the services listed. Costs were awarded against the holder of the IRDA in favour of the opponent, as is usual when a ground of opposition is successfully established.
Background
Background to the litigation
Adme relied on its extensive use of trade marks featuring the word 'SEVEN' or the number '7', known as the 'Seven Marks', to demonstrate the reputation of its trade marks. Adme submitted that these Seven Marks had been used prominently since before the relevant date, thereby establishing a significant recognition among the public. Adme presented evidence, including declarations and exhibits, to support its claim that the Seven Marks had achieved a substantial reputation in Australia, evidenced by extensive advertising, sales, and promotion of goods and services associated with the trade marks.
The Applicant contested Adme's claims, providing counter-evidence and arguments to dispute the reputation of Adme's trade marks and the likelihood of confusion or deception. The Applicant argued that Adme had not sufficiently demonstrated the necessary level of public recognition or reputation required to oppose the registration of its trade mark under section 60. The case hinged on the interpretation and application of section 60, focusing on the extent to which Adme's trade marks had achieved reputation and whether this would lead to confusion or deception if the Applicant's trade mark were registered.
The Hearing Officer, Bianca Irgang, ultimately found in favour of Adme, determining that Adme had successfully established the ground of opposition under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act. As a result, the Officer refused to extend protection to the Applicant's trade mark in respect of all listed goods and services. The Officer also directed that costs be awarded to Adme in accordance with the Trade Marks Regulations, reflecting Adme's success in establishing the opposition. The decision was made on 28 June 2024, with an option for the Applicant to appeal the decision.
This case before the court concerns an opposition to the registration of a trade mark by Adme (Cy) Ltd against Seven Network (Operations) Limited. Adme (Cy) Ltd filed an opposition to the registration of the trade mark IRDA 2259985 under sections 44, 58, 60, and 42(b) of the relevant Trade Mark Act. The matter was initially heard by the Registrar of Trade Marks, Bianca Irgang, who was responsible for deciding whether to refuse or extend the protection of the trade mark. Adme (Cy) Ltd argued that the registration of the trade mark should be opposed because it had acquired a reputation in Australia, and its use would likely cause deception or confusion under section 60 of the Trade Mark Act. The opponent presented evidence through declarations and exhibits to support its claims. Seven Network (Operations) Limited responded with its own evidence, and the matter proceeded through several stages of filings and counter-filings. Ultimately, the Registrar found that Adme (Cy) Ltd had successfully established the ground of opposition under section 60, leading to the decision to refuse the registration of the trade mark in respect of all listed goods and services. The Registrar also addressed the costs of the proceedings, determining that they should follow the event and awarding costs against the holder, Seven Network (Operations) Limited. This decision can be appealed, and the court directs that any appeal should be disposed of in accordance with its order or discretion.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The opposition proceedings between Adme (Cy) Ltd and Seven Network (Operations) Limited focused on the opponent's claim that the applicant's trade mark infringed on their established marks under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The court's reasoning centered on whether the opponent had sufficiently demonstrated that their marks had acquired a reputation in Australia before the relevant date, which would then lead to a likelihood of deception or confusion if the applicant's trade mark was registered. The court began by examining whether the opponent had established that their 'SEVEN' or '7' marks had acquired a reputation in Australia prior to the relevant date. The opponent relied on extensive use of their marks, supported by evidence of advertising expenditure, sales volume, and public exposure. The court noted that reputation in the context of section 60 requires the recognition of the trade mark by the public generally, which must be established as a factual matter.
The court then assessed whether the use of the opponent's marks was widespread enough to establish the necessary reputation. The evidence presented indicated substantial advertising campaigns and high sales figures, which the court found to be indicative of a significant level of public exposure. The opponent’s reliance on qualitative aspects, such as the esteem and value the public held for their marks, further supported their claim. The court considered these qualitative factors in conjunction with the quantitative evidence to form a comprehensive understanding of the opponent's marks' reputation.
A critical issue was whether the use of the applicant's trade mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion due to the reputation of the opponent's marks. The court found that the similarity between the marks, coupled with the established reputation of the opponent's marks, created a substantial likelihood of confusion. The opponent's marks had a strong recognition in the relevant market, and the applicant's use of similar marks could capitalize on this reputation, misleading consumers.
Further, the court examined if there were qualitative aspects of the opponent's marks' reputation that supported their claim under section 60 of the Act. The opponent presented evidence of the esteem and value associated with their marks, which the court accepted as contributing to the overall reputation. These qualitative aspects, along with the quantitative evidence, established a robust case for the opponent.
The court also considered whether the reputation of the opponent's marks was amongst a significant or substantial number of people in the relevant market. The evidence demonstrated that a large segment of the public was familiar with the opponent's marks, which the court found sufficient to meet the threshold required by the Act.
In terms of the evidence provided by the opponent, the court found it to be comprehensive and persuasive. The combination of advertising evidence, sales data, and public exposure metrics provided a solid basis for establishing the opponent's claim. The court determined that the evidence sufficiently demonstrated the reputation of the opponent's marks in Australia.
Based on the findings regarding section 60, the court concluded that the opponent had successfully established a ground for opposition. The substantial reputation of the opponent's marks and the likelihood of confusion with the applicant's trade mark warranted refusal of protection for the applicant's mark. The court exercised its discretion under regulation 17A.34 to refuse protection in respect of all goods and services listed in the International Registration Designated Australia (IR.DA).
Finally, the court awarded costs to the opponent under section 221 of the Act, as the opponent was successful in establishing a ground of opposition. The court adhered to the principle that costs usually follow the event, and there were no exceptional circumstances to depart from this principle in this case. The decision underscores the importance of establishing a well-founded reputation to successfully oppose a trade mark registration under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995.