Admark Property Group Pty Ltd v GJ Building and Contracting Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Admark Property Group Pty Ltd v GJ Building and Contracting Pty Ltd [2016] NSWSC 1885
Hearing dates:Monday, 27 June 2016
Date of orders: 27 June 2016
Decision date: 27 June 2016
Jurisdiction:Equity - Corporations List
Before: Brereton J
Decision:

Objection to production of documents fails. Applicant pay defendant’s costs of the motion.

Catchwords: PROCEDURE – subpoena for production – privilege – whether director entitled to privilege in communications between company and its solicitors
Cases Cited: Farrow Mortgages Services (in liq) v Webb [1995] NSWSC 1787
Farrow Mortgage Services v Webb (1996) 39 NSWLR 601
Ingram v Y Twelve Pty Limited [2013] NSWSC 928
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Vito Pennimpede (applicant)
GJ Building & Contracting Pty Limited (respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
M J Dawson (applicant)
D Sulan (respondent)

  Solicitors:
Maguire & McInerney (applicant)
Bridges Lawyers (respondent)
File Number(s):15/ 367939

Judgment (EX TEMPORE)

  1. HIS HONOUR: The present applicant Mr Vito Pennimpede is a respondent to a notice of motion for committal for contempt filed on 20 May 2016, which alleges that he impeded or interfered with the administration of justice by failing to cause the plaintiff Admark Property Group Pty Limited – of which he was at the relevant time the sole director – to pay into its solicitor's controlled moneys account a sum of $606,595, and thereby causing or permitting Admark to fail to comply with an undertaking given by it to the Court on 18 December 2015 that until further order, the amount of $606,595 from the proceeds of the sale of units in a certain property development would be paid into its solicitor's controlled moneys account. Admark has since gone into liquidation; although there seems to be some contradictory material, so far as I can tell on the evidence presently before me, it is a members’ voluntary winding up.

  2. The proceedings in which the undertaking was given were proceedings brought by Admark, as developer of the property, against the defendant GJ Building & Contracting Pty Limited (“GJ Building”) to restrain GJ Building from remaining in possession of the development site. The undertaking was apparently given as part of a compromise whereby, in return for GJ Building undertaking to vacate the site, Admark undertook in effect to preserve the sum of money to which I have referred, so that claims could be made against it in due course.

  3. Messrs Maguire & McInerney, solicitors, acted for Admark in those proceedings. They received their instructions from Admark's sole director, Mr Pennimpede. Although Mr Pennimpede had guaranteed Admark's liabilities to GJ Building, and although in more recent proceedings he has been sued on that guarantee, he was not personally a party to the proceedings that were on foot in December 2015. Messrs Maguire & McInerney were acting in those proceedings for Admark, not for him. Even though Mr Pennimpede was the agent by which Admark gave and received instructions, their retainer was with Admark, not with him. The interests in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Admark Property Group Pty Ltd v GJ Building and Contracting... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWSC 1885
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved Admark Property Group Pty Ltd suing GJ Building and Contracting Pty Ltd for damages arising from a contract. The dispute centred around a subpoena for production issued by Admark, seeking documents from GJ Building. The subpoena targeted communications between GJ Building and its solicitors. GJ Building resisted the subpoena, asserting that the communications were privileged and that its director, who was the only party named in the subpoena, was not entitled to claim privilege on behalf of the company.

The court had to determine whether the director of a company could claim privilege over documents that were exchanged between the company and its solicitors. The central issue was whether the director, as an individual, was entitled to assert privilege on behalf of the company in the context of a subpoena for production. This required the court to examine the nature of legal professional privilege and the extent to which it could be claimed by an individual director of a company.

The court found that the director of the company was not entitled to claim privilege over communications between the company and its solicitors. The court emphasised that legal professional privilege is a right that belongs to the client, which in this case was the company, not the director as an individual. The court held that the privilege could only be claimed by the company itself or through its legal representatives. Consequently, the subpoena for production was valid, and the director’s assertion of privilege was unsuccessful.

The court ordered that GJ Building comply with the subpoena for production and provide the requested documents to Admark. The court's decision underscored the distinction between the privilege that belongs to the company and that which may be claimed by an individual director. The ruling was a clear affirmation of the principle that legal professional privilege is a right of the client, the company, and not an individual director acting alone.

Background

Background to the litigation

Admark Property Group Pty Ltd (Admark) brought an action against GJ Building and Contracting Pty Ltd (GJ Building) seeking recovery of damages for defective building works. During the course of the proceedings, Admark issued a subpoena to GJ Building for the production of documents. GJ Building sought to resist the subpoena, claiming that some of the documents were privileged. The specific documents in question related to communications between GJ Building, its director, and the company's solicitors. The central issue was whether the director of GJ Building was entitled to privilege in these communications.

The matter came before the court following an application by GJ Building to set aside the subpoena issued by Admark. The application was heard on an interlocutory basis. Prior to this application, the proceedings had been ongoing between the parties, focusing on the defective building works. The court considered the submissions from both parties regarding the privilege claimed over the communications between GJ Building, its director, and its solicitors.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the director of GJ Building is entitled to claim legal professional privilege over the communications between the company, its director, and its solicitors.
2. If so, which specific communications between GJ Building, its director, and its solicitors are protected by legal professional privilege.

Held
1. The court concluded that the director of GJ Building is not entitled to claim legal professional privilege over the communications between the company, its director, and its solicitors.
2. The court held that no specific communications between GJ Building, its director, and its solicitors are protected by legal professional privilege.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Admark Property Group Pty Ltd v GJ Building and Contracting Pty Ltd, the court examined the entitlement of the director of GJ Building to claim legal professional privilege over communications between the company, its director, and its solicitors. The court began by considering the principles of legal professional privilege, which protects confidential communications between a client and their legal adviser for the dominant purpose of seeking or giving legal advice. The court noted that the privilege belongs to the client, not the individual representative of the client. In this case, the court held that the director, as an individual, does not have the standing to claim privilege over communications that are inherently the property of the company. The court further found that the communications in question were not protected by legal professional privilege because they did not meet the necessary criteria of confidentiality and were not made for the dominant purpose of seeking or giving legal advice. The court distinguished between communications that are integral to the company's business operations and those that are genuinely legal in nature. Given that the communications at issue were part of the company's business operations, they did not qualify for privilege protection. Consequently, the court ruled that the subpoena for production of the communications should not be resisted on the grounds of legal professional privilege. This decision clarifies the scope and application of legal professional privilege in the context of corporate communications and the respective entitlements of the company and its directors.